Fallen Idol Group - Reviews

Fallen Idol Group
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The opening image of these chapters is absolutely cinematic. Rain so heavy the wipers can't keep up, windshield staying blurry the whole drive, Tan Qing alone in the car for nearly five hours. You can FEEL that wet, cold, exhausted atmosphere. The author doesn't need fancy descriptions—just the simple fact that it took five hours in a downpour tells you everything about Tan Qing's determination and his isolation. Then we cut to the hospital. Media cars parked outside, reporters already drafting articles before the critical condition notice even drops. Tan Xiao has to be checked every time she gets off the elevator—even though everyone knows she's the patient's family. It's this brutal bureaucracy of grief, where even your own father's deathbed requires paperwork and verification. The contrast between the intimate (a son wanting privacy) and the institutional (reporters waiting like vultures) is painfully realistic. And then the ward scene—everyone dismissed, just Tan Xiao and her father left. Tan Ruisheng speaking in fragments, reminiscing to himself rather than to anyone in particular. The detail about him playing hide-and-seek with young Tan Qing when he had time... that image of a busy director dropping to the floor to play a game with a quiet boy who never complained... it's so visually specific and so quietly devastating. The author builds whole emotional worlds through single details. No grand speeches, no dramatic music—just a man remembering a child who ate less cake because he cared about his father's health, and now that child is grown and stranges and possibly not even his.
... Read More
There is no bomb threat in this batch. No dramatic confrontation. No one is dying (well, Tan Qing's fictional character dies but that doesn't count). And yet I was somehow more on edge than during most action sequences. The conflict here is entirely internal and relational, which is way harder to write well. Zhu Lianzhen carries guilt about how he treated Tan Qing as a roommate—taking carelessness for granted. He carries the weight of his own emotional clumsiness, evident in how he deflects the intimacy of the bathroom scene by immediately pivoting to a safe topic about Tan Qing's movie. Tan Qing's conflict is more concealed but arguably deeper. He's in a relationship with this person who shares a room with him, who he cooks for and waits up for, and he's communicating through wildlife photography in public comment sections because apparently direct emotional language is off-limits. The stakes aren't about survival or career—they're about whether these two men can ever actually SAY what they mean to each other before the moment passes. The magazine shoot adds external pressure too. Zhu Lianzhen is performing vulnerability on camera while Tan Qing watches from the other side of the lens, both of them using personas as armor. The fans are dissecting every interaction for clues. Nothing is private. Everything is observed. And the snow leopard video that Zhu Lianzhen keeps clicking on? That's him avoiding something. That's the tension in motion.
... Read More
I keep thinking about that animation and what it represents. A boy made of paper falling from the sky into the human world—that's basically Zhu Lianzhen's entire existence as an idol, isn't it? He's this ethereal figure who seems almost otherworldly, then suddenly he's thrust into this gritty reality where fans project everything onto him. The paper bird that knocks him off course? Those are the obstacles, the rivals, the expectations that derail you. The balloon he grabs? That's fame, that's luck, that's something floating by that changes your trajectory. And then this barren land where he lies exhausted, and his dream transforms everything into stardust and roses—that's the artist's inner world, right? Where even in darkness and exhaustion, the imagination creates beauty. The red roses especially, they feel significant. Blood-red, thorny, beautiful but dangerous. And the final line of the video: "You'll always be my boy, always be my favorite." That's the core tension of the whole story. Fans want to preserve him as this eternal boy, but he's literally just celebrated his birthday as a grown man now. The symbolism is everywhere once you start looking. Even Zhu Lianzhen's refusal to admit immaturity—"I'm a man now"—contrasted with the narrator's observation that he still carries a youthful mindset. The author is asking: who gets to define when someone grows up? Is it biology, or is it how the world sees you?
... Read More
This passage made me re-read it five times. Not because it's long or dramatic—because it's devastating in its quietness. Let me go back to the beginning of it all. The tattoo. Zhu Lianzhen has been suspicious, wondering, probably overthinking at 2 AM like the rest of us. When Tan Qing casually offers to prove himself by unbuttoning his belt, the sheer vulnerability of that gesture—offering physical proof, trusting Zhu enough to let him see—versus Zhu's immediate deflection of looking away... that small rejection is so painfully human. He doesn't want to see it? Or he doesn't want Tan Qing to think he cares enough to verify? And then: 'The warmth of his blood surged upward from his fingertips, as if he had just come through a silent battle where neither side had won.' Silent battle. Neither side won. That is the most accurate description of their entire romantic history I've ever encountered. Both of them are standing there with their shields up, neither willing to drop the weapon first, and the result is stalemate wrapped in regret. The crescent bow and arrow—his own symbol, still there on Tan Qing's body, preserved like something sacred. Zhu isn't just relieved the tattoo is intact. He's relieved that some part of him still exists on Tan Qing. That's not subtext anymore, that's text that's yelling at us. Then immediately after this emotional crescendo, they pivot to negotiating fanservice rules like nothing happened. The emotional whiplash is real. It's like the universe itself couldn't let them have one moment of honesty without dragging them back to performance mode. 'What if one of us wants to get back together?' Tan Qing asks, and Zhu can't even answer it directly. He says 'don't flatter yourself' instead. The cowardice! The longing! The absolute ruin!
... Read More
Let me just say this chapter made me feel things I didn't expect. I came in ready to analyze and ended up genuinely moved by a song that doesn't even exist in real life. The performance description alone is enough—'A dagger waits, my throat held tight, one final scream before the bite'—but that's not what wrecked me. It was everything around it. The way Tan Xiao is sitting there holding this QingZhen banner, uncomfortable about it, aware that her brother and Zhu Lianzhen are friends and this shipy stuff might embarrass them. She doesn't fully understand fan culture but she's trying, and it's adorable and heartbreaking. And Xue Chun—oh god, Xue Chun. He's watching Acemon and feels this 'tingling along his spine, as if a surge of new energy had been injected into him.' He wants to be like them. Not just good, not just perfect, but... free. He mentions that on stage he 'had never truly been free to be himself.' That line hit me so hard. He's been practicing to be the perfect idol, the perfect fanservice face, and somewhere along the way he lost whatever made him want to perform in the first place. But then there's Zhu Lianzhen and Tan Qing. The ring touch. The abandoned note. The in-ear monitor coming out. Whatever that was—it wasn't just stagecraft. It was communication. Intimate, wordless, happening in front of twenty thousand people who have no idea what just passed between two performers. That's the kind of emotional beat that stays with you.
... Read More
OK so let's talk about the plot mechanics here because the author has been quietly setting this up for what feels like forever and I am not okay with it. Ji Yunting's confession at dinner — he's choosing love over career, love over the distant dream — is the inciting incident that cracks everything open. Tan Qing immediately redirects it toward Zhu Lianzhen because, well, we all know what Zhu Lianzhen chose. His career. His distance. His careful construction of a life without Tan Qing in it. The parallel is so obvious it aches. Then the car ride: Tan Qing driving, Zhu Lianzhen trapped, the history between them unpacking itself through tiny moments — the earphones memory, the copycat accusation from years ago, the music playlist, the question about why Tan Qing still wants to return to idol work. And Tan Qing's answer: "I just prefer working with you guys." Which is either the most genuine thing he's ever said or the most carefully crafted lie, and the ambiguity IS the point. The climax of the chapter is Tan Qing's final speech — listing every single way Zhu Lianzhen has avoided him, and then the devastating question: "Do you really hate me that much?" This isn't just emotional confrontation, it's a plot pivot. Something has to change now. You can't have this question hanging in the air and then just go back to normal. The narrative is about to shift. And then the cut to Ah-Xu's perspective with "Fans can easily find out when you change flights" — confirming that Zhu Lianzhen's avoidance is public knowledge. This is no longer private. The plot is converging.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this scene from the dance competition because it genuinely gave me chills reading about it. The whole flashback structure is doing heavy lifting here—we're inside Zhu Lianzhen's car watching a fan video, then Tan Qing brings up his past, and suddenly we're transported to this massive live broadcast moment. The way the author handles this isn't just info-dumping backstory; it's layered into a conversation like real memories bubble up organically. What really sold me was the tension during the finals. Everyone expects him to lose—he's a kid dancing against OGs in their thirties. But instead of playing it safe, he stops the music, asks for a blindfold, and says something like, "If it goes wrong, I'll take the blame." That line though—it perfectly captures who he is. He's not arrogant, he's just genuinely confident in a way that frustrates people who expect performers to be humble. And the fact that he memorized his backup dancers' positions before covering his eyes? That's not recklessness, that's preparation disguised as spontaneity. The author keeps this scene deliberately unfinished too, cutting off mid-description of his performance. Makes you want to read the next chapter immediately to find out what happened.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that struck me about this chunk—there's a structural mirroring happening between the two fansign events that I couldn't ignore. In the first one, everything is chaos and closeness. The incident with the stalker guy, the fan confrontation, the whole mess. Tan Qing has his arm around Zhu Lianzhen going backstage. They're physically together, even if the world is falling apart around them. Then you get to the second fansign and the opposite happens—everything is controlled, sanitized, and they're three seats apart. The author is doing something really clever here by using these two events as bookends. The plot isn't just advancing; it's tracing a contraction. The warmth of the first event gives way to the calculated distance of the second. And Tan Qing's justification—avoiding suspicion, considering the fans who spend money—feels surgically rational but emotionally hollow. Zhu Lianzhen literally shoves a pen into his hand and says "I'm in a great mood today, and I want to be with you" before catching himself and correcting to "sit with you." That little stumble? That's the whole relationship in a nutshell, isn't it? Everything gets folded back into safety. I keep thinking about whether this plot choice serves the story or betrays it.
... Read More
Koty is the comedic genius this chapter deserves. ‘Why wouldn't my own kid have my surname?' after comparing Zhu Lianzhen's tooth pain to childbirth—that's not banter, that's a weaponized quip delivered with maximum casual energy. And the way he ‘strutted around proudly in front of Zhu Lianzhen, bragging about being a more evolved human' because he never got wisdom teeth? Koty's voice is pure chaos agent, and I'm here for it. But the real dialogue mastery is in what's NOT said between Zhu Lianzhen and Tan Qing. Zero direct conversation across three hours of proximity. Instead: Zhu Lianzhen ‘pretended to listen attentively' to Ji Yunting's rant while watching Tan Qing's profile. Tan Qing ‘staring out the window, not participating.' Their communication has become entirely performative for others—they're too busy managing external expectations to actually speak to each other. Ji Yunting's ‘going to work feels like heading to a grave' after the Qingming Festival reference is peak self-aware humor from a man who ‘was supposed to join a dating show' but got contract-terminated by his manager. His voice carries the exhaustion of someone who's ‘not the assertive type to begin with' but is forced into leadership anyway. And Zhu Lianzhen's weak ‘I'm basically giving birth in my mouth right now' while Koty immediately responds with ‘is the kid's surname Tan?'—that's trauma bonding through absurdity, and it's hilarious.
... Read More
"I don't want the media reporting on my relationship with him. As long as even one reporter is there, I won't go in. I hope you understand." I have to start here because this line just DESTROYED me. Think about what Tan Qing is actually saying. His father has been absent for twenty years. Now he's dying. And Tan Qing's first concern isn't reconciliation, isn't anger, isn't even grief—it's *privacy*. He doesn't want the public to know about this moment between them. It's this tiny, devastating detail that tells you everything about how he feels. He drove five hours in a storm. Five hours. Through sheets of rain so heavy the wipers couldn't keep up. He didn't even want to park close to the hospital. He sat in his car with the engine off, eyes closed, just breathing through it. And when Tan Xiao asks him to go in, he says no—not out of coldness, but because he needs this to be real, not performed. Then Zhu Lianzhen sends him that message. "Don't force yourself." Four words. No fluff, no pressure. And Tan Qing's response—"But whether I agree or refuse, it still puts me in a difficult spot"—that right there is the heartbreak. There is no right answer. Either he goes and faces twenty years of complicated history, or he doesn't go and carries regret forever. Zhu's reply—"Someone who truly cares about you wouldn't put you in a difficult position"—is the closest thing to absolution Tan Qing was going to get. I'm not crying, you're crying.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is doing such unfair work. Let me start with Tan Qing's very first line: "Maybe some feelings just aren't meant to be spoken aloud, and that's exactly what makes this film compelling." On the surface it's an actor discussing his craft. But come ON. That is literally him describing his relationship with Zhu Lianzhen in code. His manager asks him a loaded question—"Ever been in love?"—and he deflects with corporate rules and then drops a philosophical bomb that's actually a confession. The subtext is so thick you could spread it on toast. Then the food truck exchange. This is literally three messages and it's the most emotionally complex conversation in the book: "Thanks, Leader." — Tan Qing, being polite but clearly knowing exactly who did this. "Didn't I tell you to use the group's name? How did Tan Qing find out?" — Zhu Lianzhen, immediately suspicious of his own assistant. "How's the food from that company's truck?" — Tan Qing, turning the whole thing into a casual check-in disguised as small talk. The fact that Tan Qing knew it was Zhu Lianzhen the entire time and Zhu Lianzhen had no idea is both hilarious and heartbreaking. The banter is perfectly calibrated—two people who know each other way too well pretending they're just being professional colleagues. And the Xu Qing scene! Her dialogue is so distinct from Tan Qing's. She's opinionated, nostalgic, slightly bitter about the industry. "Kids in the industry rise to fame so early now. They get swarmed by fans without any real achievements to show for it." Classic veteran actress energy. But then Tan Qing answers her question about why he studied acting and his response is so quiet and honest it completely recontextualizes everything. "I could completely forget my own worries." Two characters, same scene, completely different frequencies of vulnerability. Xu Qing opens up about the industry and Tan Qing accidentally opens up about himself and neither of them realizes it. That's what good dialogue does.
... Read More
The pacing here is a masterclass in slow-burn dread. It starts almost mundane — Zhu Lianzhen visiting an empty apartment, kicking something on the floor, thinking about whether he left anything behind. The prose is measured, almost observational. Then the glass shard memory hits, and the tempo quickens with his dawning realization. But the real pacing brilliance is how it stretches time around small discoveries: the code still works (one try!), the cup shards are CLEAN, the pomegranate juice has a RECENT production date. Each detail is given room to breathe before the next one drops. The camera reveal is nearly instantaneous — he looks at the painting, notices something, takes it down, and bam, red light. That speed contrast with the earlier slow accumulation of clues makes the horror land harder. Then the phone rings and the entire chapter pivots to the dialogue-heavy confrontation. After that peak, it immediately drops you into the film set — a completely different energy, almost clinical and professional. The abrupt transition from emotional climax to Tan Qing discussing his acting process feels deliberate, like the narrative is saying: this is just another layer, keep paying attention. And the chapter cuts off mid-sentence about the relationship being doomed. No resolution, no wrap-up. Just a hook that forces you forward.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or