Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"Don't lower your standards. This isn't the life you should be living." I need to unpack this because it hit me like a freight train and I've been thinking about it since. On the surface, this is just Shi Yuan being practical. Lin Wangye spent the whole night being all cozy and reluctant to leave, and Shi Yuan is basically saying: hey, this is nice but it's not YOUR life, you shouldn't settle for it. Reasonable. Logical. The voice of adult responsibility. But then I read it again. And I read it a third time. Because what is Shi Yuan actually doing here? He just spent the entire night awake, watching Lin Wangye sleep, letting him cuddle, making sure his clothes were warm, cleaning his shoes, arranging for breakfast — and then the FIRST thing he does when Lin Wangye expresses a desire to stay is shut it down? "Not allowed." Two words. That's it. No explanation. No softening. Just an immediate boundary. Is this because he genuinely believes Lin Wangye deserves better? Or is it because Shi Yuan himself can't handle how much he's starting to want this — the quiet mornings, the shared bed, the domesticity — and needs to protect himself by ending it before it becomes real? The stakes here aren't about plot. They're about emotional survival. Both of these boys are playing with fire and neither of them knows how to put it out.
... Read More
Every character in this chapter has such a DISTINCT voice and I need to talk about it. Lin Shen's dialogue is pure chaotic dad energy. 'Unbelievable! I call you and you don't come — I actually have to come fetch you myself?' That's not just dialogue, that's a personality. You can hear the exasperation, the false outrage, the underlying care disguised as annoyance. And then his pivot from fury to 'ALRIGHT CUT THE DAD TALK YOU'RE DRIVING ME NUTS' is so natural it hurts. These are real people talking. Lu Chengxuan is the straight man archetype and he delivers every line with perfect deadpan efficiency. 'I'm keeping order. Can't skip evening self-study. Are you coming back with me?' No drama, no fuss, just functionally polite and slightly bewildered by the sleepy Lin Wangye. His brief exchange with Shi Yuan—'When did he fall asleep?'—carries this weight of someone who knows exactly what he's walking into but chooses to play it cool. Subtle. Effective. But Lin Wangye? Oh my god. His dialogue is layered in the BEST way. When he says 'Because I want to stay with you' to Shi Yuan—that's the kind of line that hits different because of HOW it's delivered. The text says his voice carried 'a hint of playful sweetness, like honey dripping from a spoon.' It's intentionally disarmingly sweet, and the fact that it WORKS on everyone (including the reader) is a testament to how well-written this character is. Then there's the food scene where he casually tells his own father to leave: 'Did you eat?' 'Just did.' 'Great, then if you've got nothing else to do, you can head back.' This is peak dialogue comedy. It's so matter-of-fact, so ruthlessly efficient in its politeness. Lin Shen's internal screaming is implied through his actions (staring, disbelief, then fleeing) rather than spoken, which makes it funnier. Shi Yuan's dialogue is famously sparse—he says very little in this entire chapter—but every line counts. 'Hungry?' and 'It's fine. Given the situation, I get why you reacted the way you did' are both perfectly calibrated. One shows his quiet way of caring, the other his graceful deflection of conflict. His silence is louder than most people's monologues here. The narrative voice itself deserves mention too. The author has this tendency to describe inner states through physical metaphors—emotions 'sinking, slow and uncontrollable,' voices carrying 'warmth that seemed to go beyond just friendship.' It's poetic without being purple, which is a difficult balance to strike. The tone throughout is this warm, slightly bittersweet observation of people navigating messy relationships with varying degrees of awareness and intention.
... Read More
What makes this chapter terrifying isn't any external threat—there are no villains, no physical danger. The conflict is almost entirely internal, and that's what makes the stakes so high. Lin Wangye isn't fighting for survival or love or freedom; he's fighting for the coherence of his own identity. If his father is gay, and his father is gay, then who is Lin Wangye? The question isn't philosophical—it's visceral. It's the difference between knowing who you are and suddenly not knowing at all. The external stakes are equally compelling but less obvious. Lin Shen risked everything—family rejection, frozen bank accounts, being kicked out of his home—to be honest about who he is. That's massive stakes for a man who could've stayed silent. The conflict isn't just about truth versus lies; it's about the cost of truth. What has Lin Shen lost? What might he still lose? And what does that cost mean for the people around him? Then there's the Wangye-Lin Shen father-son conflict, which is unfolding in real time. Wangye can't look at his father the same way. Lin Shen doesn't know that Wangye knows—or at least, suspects. That dramatic irony creates tension in every shared glance, every casual touch, every moment of proximity. The conflict is barely visible to an outside observer but enormous for everyone inside the scene. And Lu Chengxuan—present in the background, watching, speaking little but meaning everything. The story raises the question: what happens when these conflicts converge? When Wangye finally demands answers? When Lin Shen has to explain not just his sexuality but his entire family structure? The stakes keep rising because every revelation opens new questions, and every question threatens to reshape relationships irreversibly.
... Read More
I want to talk about the glasses because they're doing SO MUCH work in this chapter and I think the author is using them as a symbol without being heavy-handed about it. On the surface, they're just a funny detail - Lin Wangye's internal outrage at those 'ugly, outdated, painfully thick black frames' is genuinely hilarious. But then you realize what they represent: Shi Yuan hiding himself, making himself invisible, disappearing behind something practical and unglamorous. The glasses 'sealed away at least 80% of [his] looks' and suddenly he looked like 'an ordinary bookworm, the kind of guy you'd pass on the street without giving a second look.' This connects to the whole identity theme of the chapter. Shi Yuan was Xu Suinian - the top student on the ranking board - but nobody connected that name to the person sitting in front of Lin Wangye. He changed his name, changed his appearance (with those glasses), and became someone new. The glasses are both literal and metaphorical barriers between how he sees himself and how others see him. There's also the ranking board itself as a symbol. 'That bold, black-inked name had been plastered on the ranking board the whole time — right in front of him this whole time.' It's right there, obvious, but unrecognizable. Success and visibility don't guarantee being seen. You can be at the top of the board and still be invisible to the person standing next to you. The empty kettle in the hospital room is another symbol - absence of care, isolation, being overlooked. Meanwhile Lin Shen's room is filled with people and provisions. The contrast speaks volumes about who gets attention and who doesn't. And the sunset light on Shi Yuan's face? Stars in his eyes? That's the version of him that exists beneath all these layers - the real Shi Yuan that Lin Wangye is only now beginning to see.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's NOT happening in this chapter, because that's where the real tension lives. No one is fighting. No one is shouting. No one is even particularly suspicious of Lin Wangye. And yet—every line reads like footsteps on thin ice. Lin Wangye is inhabiting the body of Lin Shen, the guy whose family destroyed the Lu family's business. He's staying in the Lu mansion. His host's grandfather built wealth by partnering with the Lus, then shifted strategies and became their enemy. The father (presumably Lin Shen) completed the severing. And now Lin Wangye—bearing Lin Shen's face—is curled up in a guest room on the second floor, researching the very history that led to this collision. The stakes are absurdly high and also completely invisible to everyone else. If the Lus find out who is actually inside Lin Shen's body, what happens? If the Lins find out Lin Shen is communicating with the family he betrayed, what happens? Lin Wangye is playing a game where every move could be interpreted as betrayal from either side, and he has no ally who knows the truth. Even the small moments carry weight. When he asks where he's sleeping, he's negotiating his position in a house that belongs to his enemy. When he searches for information, he's armoring himself against a future conflict he understands better than anyone in that building. When Vivian calls him 'Lovely Angel,' she's wrapping kindness around the son of the man who ruined her business partnerships—and she has no idea. The author doesn't need explosions or confrontations to make this tense. The suspense comes from dramatic irony: we know what these characters don't. We know Lin Wangye is a ghost in enemy territory. We know the peace is provisional. And we know—because the text explicitly tells us—that 'not long after, the two families would completely sever ties and become fierce rivals.' So every warm moment is already numbered. Every gesture of hospitality is borrowing time from a war that hasn't started yet. That's how you build stakes. Not by raising the volume, but by making the reader hear the clock ticking underneath every silent room.
... Read More
There's this one detail that obsessed me: Lin Wangye walking into the Lu house and immediately noticing 'Lu Wei wasn't around.' He's been staying there for... how long? And he's never felt pressured by Lu Wei before. But the moment he hears his father is COMING BACK, the entire atmosphere of the space transforms. The author describes the fruit plate—already cut, waiting on the table—like it's a stage set for a family that exists in absence. The villa itself feels vast and slightly cold, a place where people come and go but don't necessarily belong. Lin Wangye grabbing an apple with a toothpick while mentally planning how to AVOID the patriarch of the house? That's such a specific, telling detail. He's a guest in his friend's home, and guests have always known their place. But the most vivid scene is the flashback to elementary school recess. You can SEE it—the kids playing marbles, the heat, the dust, Lin Shen pretending he doesn't care about losing. The author doesn't give us elaborate description, but the images click into place fast. It's like a film playing in your head: wide shot of the playground, close-up of scattered marbles, a quiet boy watching from the edge. And the contrast between these two worlds—the sterile wealth of the Lu villa versus the sun-drenched chaos of childhood recess—says everything about what Lu Chengxuan lost and what he's been trying to hold onto ever since.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is raw, honest, and absolutely perfect for these characters. I want to focus on how Lin Wangye's voice finally breaks through after years of silence. Early on, when he's trying to explain where the necklace was lost, his speech is fragmented, broken by sobs: "I... I already asked... just now... they said the whole hotel... has been cleaned... no one's seen... a necklace." This isn't just emotional distress; it's the sound of someone who has spent their whole life struggling to articulate what they feel. Even something as simple as explaining where an object was lost becomes a stumbling block when your emotions are this raw. But then comes the line that changes everything: "You always run... How long are you gonna keep running away, huh? You coward." This is Lin Wangye at his most vulnerable and his most fierce. The accusation isn't really about running from places or situations—it's about running from feelings, from intimacy, from the possibility of being truly seen. Calling Shi Yuan a coward is the most honest thing he's ever said, and it's delivered with the sharpness of someone who has finally stopped caring about consequences. And then: "I like you. Can't you tell?" Three words. That's it. No elaborate confession, no poetic declaration. Just three words that carry sixteen years of history. The simplicity is everything. Lin Wangye isn't a poet; he's a boy who has loved in secret for too long, and when he finally speaks, he doesn't reach for grand language. He reaches for truth. Shi Yuan's response—or lack thereof—is equally powerful. He doesn't speak at all during the confession. He just asks, barely above a whisper: "Don't cry. Please don't cry." It's the voice of someone who has spent his whole life trying to protect Lin Wangye from pain, only to realize that his own protections have been the source of that pain. The dialogue here works because it's imperfect. Sentences trail off. Thoughts are unfinished. Emotions interrupt logic. And that's exactly how real human conversation sounds when hearts are breaking open.
... Read More
I'm still not over this line. Just—just stop. Lin Wangye says this with such casual confidence after literally just getting his lip cut open, and Shi Yuan's reaction? He doesn't laugh. He doesn't tease him back. He just... gently brushes his thumb along that exact spot and kisses it a few more times. Slowly. Softly. This is the most tender thing I have ever read and I am NOT OKAY. The physical intimacy in this book is woven so carefully with emotional vulnerability. Lin Wangye throws himself into Shi Yuan's arms afterward—not sexually, but desperately—and buries his face in that chest that still smells like body wash and steam. The restlessness in his chest settles. ONE TOUCH. That's all it takes for this person who has been carrying twenty years of loneliness to feel safe. And then immediately after the most emotionally intimate moment of the chapter, Shi Yuan asks about the necklace. Like he's giving Lin Wangye space to breathe before dropping the bomb. THAT'S love. That's actual, real love. The kind where you know when to hold someone and when to ask the hard question. I'm sitting here emotionally compromised and I have no one to blame.
... Read More
The hospital room exists in this weird liminal space — fluorescent lights, looping TV channels, the smell of antiseptic undercut by the sweetness of a shared orange. It's not just a setting; it's a pressure cooker. Confined. Sterile. Yet somehow the most intimate place these two have ever been. Notice how the author uses props to build atmosphere. The pillow book. The TV that loops crappy channels. The internet cafe escape. These aren't decorative details; they're emotional barometers. When Shi Yuan picks up the book to tutor Lin Wangye, the scene shifts from casual visit to structured time. Math problems become a language they speak fluently. Chinese and geography classes are mentioned but skipped — not because they're unimportant, but because the hospital bed has already become the real classroom. The world outside (school, normal life) fades away; what matters is the now, the orange, the formula clicks, the sleepy groan about hospital food. Then the afternoon. Lin Shen discharged. Gone to the internet cafe. Lu Chengxuan follows like a shadow. This routine establishment makes the later rupture hit harder. Because we've seen this pattern — school, hospital, internet cafe, repeat — and then it breaks. The locked door isn't just a plot device; it's a physical manifestation of the sudden absence of routine. The visual contrast between the hospital's sterile calm and the internet cafe's digital hum matters. One is where connection happens face-to-face; the other is where people hide in screens. Lin Wangye rushes from one to the other, phone dead, mind buzzing white noise. The setting itself becomes a character — the hospital promises safety but delivers uncertainty, the cafe promises distraction but offers only waiting. And Shi Yuan's empty room? That's the emptiest space in the entire chapter. Not because it's physically bare, but because it's devoid of the person who filled it. The author doesn't need dramatic scenery shifts. Just an empty bed, a locked door, and a dead phone to make the world feel suddenly, terrifyingly small.
... Read More
I need to talk about Shi Yuan because WOW. This character is absolutely fascinating and I'm obsessed with how he handles this entire situation. Here's Lin Wangye — someone who just met him, essentially — having the most devastating emotional breakdown imaginable, sobbing uncontrollably, blowing snot bubbles, looking like a walrus-eyed disaster. And what does Shi Yuan do? He doesn't flinch. He doesn't get uncomfortable. He doesn't tell him to stop crying or make it about himself. He just… wipes his face. With tissues. Like it's the most natural thing in the world. The line where Shi Yuan calls him "sad little puppy" while still stroking his hair? I almost threw my phone across the room. That contrast between teasing and tenderness is *chef's kiss*. It shows that Shi Yuan isn't just patient — he actually understands what Lin Wangye needs. Not pity, not space, not a lecture. Just presence. And Lin Wangye! Oh man, Lin Wangye. The way he clings to Shi Yuan under that blanket, half-hugging his waist like a security blanket himself. This kid has been through something — the orphanage, living as a guest in someone else's house, carrying this whole weight of feeling like a burden. And somehow, in this one hospital room, he lets someone else hold that weight for a moment. Their dynamic is unlike anything I've read before. There's this instinctive familiarity between them, like they've known each other for years even though they only really just met. Lin Wangye says it himself: "I like being with you." Not "you're nice" or "you're funny." He likes *being* with this person. That's such a specific, profound thing to feel. But what really gets me is the power dynamic. Shi Yuan is the one who's been hurt — his whole family is gone, he's carrying years of grief. And yet he's the one holding space, the one offering comfort. Lin Wangye, who seems like the more emotionally open one, is actually the one who ends up needing to be held. It's beautiful and it completely subverts every expectation I had.
... Read More
'The sunlight streamed through the window, casting a cold, icy light on Lu Chengxuan's side profile. From Lin Wangye's angle, his finely sculpted features almost looked like the perfect piece of art.' I need to just sit with that line for a second. The author has this incredible ability to paint scenes that feel almost cinematic. You're not just reading about a classroom—you're seeing it. The students pounding on desks, the whistling, the homeroom teacher leaning against the podium with that worried expression, shifting his eyes between students who have the worst grades and are tall and not nearsighted like he's doing some kind of brutal optimization problem. And then there's the contrast. You have this warm, golden sunlight hitting Lu Chengxuan's face like he's the protagonist of some artsy film, while simultaneously Lin Wangye is having an internal existential crisis about his entire understanding of reality. The scene works on two levels at once—the external classroom chaos and the internal emotional earthquake. That's skilled writing right there. The classroom as a space also feels very alive. Every detail matters: the desks, the seating chart, the fact that nearly every seat is taken except the back row by the wall. The author isn't just describing a room—they're building a social ecosystem where who sits where carries weight, and the empty seats at the back represent exclusion and hierarchy. Even Jiang Bowen moving to the fifth row instead of the absolute back shows how thoughtfully the physical space is mapped onto the social dynamics.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are MASSIVE and the author delivers them with this almost cruel gentleness. Let me explain. On the surface, it's a paternity test result. Pretty standard dramatic reveal, right? But the author makes it hurt by showing us Lin Wangye's preparation—the way he gathered hair samples, pulling his own out one by one until his eyes watered from pain. He KNEW something was wrong. He'd felt uneasy since Lin Shen came out to the family. The test wasn't just confirmation for Lin Qianqian; it was the end of denial for Lin Wangye himself. And then—nothing. No blood relation. Not even a half-connection. The doctor ran both full-cell and half-cell comparisons, checked for same-father and same-mother relationships, and STILL nothing. This isn't a case of "oh, you're actually adopted from the hospital." This is "you are completely unrelated to the family you've known your entire life." What makes the stakes so high is the timing. Lin Wangye has already found belonging with Lin Shen, with Shi Yuan, with this weird chaotic found family. And now that foundation is gone. The external conflict (who am I?) is devastating because it threatens every internal bond he's built. But here's what really gets me—the scene with Shi Yuan. Lin Wangye comes out of that phone call completely shattered, and Shi Yuan doesn't ask probing questions. He just opens his arms. When Lin Wangye tries to brush off his sadness with "only a tiny bit sad. Not that much," and Shi Yuan replies "my happy little puppy doesn't look very happy right now"—that's the emotional peak of the whole chapter. The external crisis meets the internal need for comfort, and Shi Yuan provides both without demanding answers. Then Lin Shen shows up, making crude jokes about becoming a grandpa, and suddenly the tension dissipates into something warm and funny. The author uses comedy as a release valve after building unbearable emotional pressure. Genius.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or