Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What strikes me first is how the author weaves together multiple subtle plot threads without ever feeling rushed or cluttered. On the surface, this chapter is just daily school life—seat switching, winter break assignments, class rep duties—but beneath that lies a carefully constructed narrative of personal stakes and relational shifts. Lin Wangye's realization about early romance testing self-control is a brilliant plot device that connects his past-life regret to present behavior. His decision to actually study isn't born from sudden heroism but from a concrete fear: failing to get into Ningchang University again. That's a relatable, human motivator, not a dramatic trope. The subplot about Lin Shen's fury over being exploited as labor while Lu Chengxuan gets credit is funny but also reveals a shifting power dynamic in their friendship. When Lu Chengxuan effortlessly negotiates Lin Shen's new title (“Deal”) just by offering the study monitor position, it shows how quietly authoritative he is—and how much Lin Shen values recognition over fairness. That's a sharp little character beat disguised as comedy. Even Shi Shi's appearance functions as plot engine: her invitation to the Kalamay Islands trip isn't random; it's a narrative pressure point that tests Lu Chengxuan's boundaries and reminds us that the adult world is always circling these kids, offering escapes they're not ready for. The chapter ends with Lin Shen proposing a trip and Lin Wangye eagerly agreeing, which sets up the next phase: the winter break adventure. So yes, the plot may be quiet, but it's precisely engineered—every conversation, every grievance, every offer of a title moves the characters closer to either connection or conflict.
... Read More
I need a minute. Lin Shen lying half-reclined on that sofa, eyes closed, not actually sleeping, just... orbiting this thought he can't voice. He asks Lu Chengxuan if he's ever thought about resisting. Not about fighting for love. Not about running away together. But about resistance. Power. Capability. Because he knows — he absolutely knows — that love without power is just suffering with a prettier name. And then he changes the subject so fast it hurts. "I'm starting to envy Xiao Lin." "He doesn't have a father." Just like that. The entire emotional architecture of his pain collapses into four words. His father is the wall. The obstacle. The reason he can't have what he wants. And Lin Wangye, this kid who never had a father to begin with, is suddenly the most envied person alive. What broke me most was that Lin Shen already took the first step. He already acted. He already crossed some invisible line. But he STILL doesn't feel entitled to ask Lu Chengxuan to choose him. That's not love — that's someone who has been conditioned to believe they don't deserve to be chosen. And Lu Chengxuan, who wouldn't give an answer even if he wanted to, who wouldn't make promises because promises require a future he's not sure he'll have... They are both so desperately trying to protect each other by protecting themselves first.
... Read More
The way the author opens the school scene with "the winter in Ningchang was so cold that even water froze instantly" — it's such a small detail but it immediately sets the temperature of the entire story. Not just weather. Emotional temperature. Everything here is sharp, brittle, preserves nothing. Then you get this incredibly specific, almost cinematic description of Lin Wangye stepping into that classroom. "A fluffy head peeked in, glancing around with curiosity before jogging up to the podium, grinning widely." I literally saw this as a film shot. Wide angle on the door, slow push in on that face, the whole room going quiet. The author writes space like a director — the central seating position of the class monitor, the damp mold spots on the ceiling above the back corner, the way girls whisper and compete over who gets to claim him. And that ceiling detail! It's not just set dressing. It's narrative determinism disguised as environmental description. That seat looks fine from a distance, but look closer and it's damaged. Just like the situation these three are in. The teacher points to Lu Chengxuan and assigns Lin Wangye right next to him — no choice, no alternative, the only available seat happens to be the one that forces proximity. The world of this story keeps conspiring to push them together while every internal barrier pushes them apart. The contrast between the frozen Ningchang winter and that burst of spring-like energy Lin Wangye brings into the classroom is honestly one of the most vivid image clashes I've read all year.
... Read More
The way Lin Shen speaks is an absolute art form. 'Fifty-three, round it up to fifty-five.' That is the calmest, most audacious sentence I have ever read. He's looking an elderly street vendor in the eye and saying 'I will round my debt UP and still not pay it' and somehow it comes out like he's doing everyone a favor. And then 'my number one buddy is on his way' delivered with total nonchalance while holding an unlit cigarette between his lips because he noticed his son is uncomfortable — this man is performing emotional intelligence while simultaneously being a financial predator. The dialogue between Lin Wangye and his dad is where the real comedy lives though. The back-and-forth about paying, the moment of shared burps, the sudden silence when the truth lands. And Lin Wangye's internal voice? Pure chaotic energy. 'What the hell, Lu Chengxuan!?' followed immediately by 'If there wasn't some deep tangled emotional history between them, where did all that bitterness come from?!' This kid is mentally spiraling in real time and the narration captures that perfectly. The author lets Lin Wangye's thoughts run wild while Lin Shen stays almost eerily calm. The contrast IS the voice.
... Read More
I keep thinking about that board game and what it represents, and honestly, the symbolism is so thick I can barely breathe. Lu Chengxuan's four green planes vs Lin Shen's four planes vs Lin Wangye and Shi Yuan's combined eight. The math is deliberate. Four versus eight. One versus two pairs. The image of someone standing alone against a united front is the entire emotional architecture of this chapter. But here's what really gets me — those green planes. They're positioned 'six spaces away, not too close, not too far. Close enough to taunt him, but never close enough to strike.' This is the physical manifestation of emotional availability. Lu Chengxuan is right there, within reach, but strategically positioned to never actually engage. It's proximity without connection. Safety without warmth. He could destroy Lin Shen at any moment but chooses the torture of nearness instead. And Lin Shen throwing himself into the game, rolling sixes, sending his planes back out with relentless determination — that's pride as coping mechanism. Every time he gets knocked back to base, he launches himself forward again. Not because he's winning (he's clearly not), but because stopping means acknowledging he wanted something from Lu Chengxuan all along. The snow-covered Mount Yingtian operates as another symbol. It's beautiful, dreamlike, isolated — and Lin Wangye walks through it hand-in-hand with Shi Yuan while his own identity crumbles behind him. The contrast between external beauty and internal devastation is almost cruel. And the DNA report itself — those cold tables, those clinical codes, that bold black conclusion. It's the ultimate symbol of how biology defines and divides us. Two sheets of paper that reduce years of assumed kinship to 'no biological relationship.' The paper is thin, the ink is permanent.
... Read More
Everything in this chapter is vibrating with unspoken tension about family. Lin Shen's brother is in the hospital. Lin Wangye's dad is sick—"his health was starting to go downhill." Lin Wangye knows this but doesn't say it outright. He just calculates: "Out of 365 days, there was only one like this." New Year's Eve. The one day that matters. The stakes aren't world-ending—they're something worse. They're personal. They're about whether these characters can face the people who hurt them, or whether they'll run away to internet cafes and pottery shops instead. Lin Shen wants to avoid his family. Lin Wangye wants to patch things up with his dad but knows it might not work. Both are scared. Both are trying. What's brilliant is how the author uses the New Year setting as pressure. It's not just a backdrop—it's a deadline. You feel the clock ticking. If they don't resolve this now, when? Next year? And what if next year is too late? Meanwhile, the subplot with Shi Yuan and the pottery shop is the emotional counterweight. That relationship has no conflict—just warmth, mutual care, tiny gestures. It's what the characters are fighting toward, not away from. Lin Wangye runs to Shi Yuan. He buries his face in his neck. He says "I missed you" like it's the most natural thing in the world. That's the stake: building something stable and sweet when everything else feels fragile. The five hundred yuan? That's Lin Wangye saying "I'm scared you'll end up alone and miserable during the holidays, so here—eat something good." The ceramic dog? Shi Yuan saying "I made this for you because I was thinking about you when you weren't here." Both are acts of love dressed as casual gestures. And that's where the real tension lives—in what people can't bring themselves to say directly.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate the visual storytelling here? The author doesn't need paragraphs of description — a few precise details do the entire job. Take the morning scene: "Couch cushions tossed everywhere, the rug halfway flipped, decorations scattered around like someone just tossed them in the air." That's it. That's the set design. You immediately understand: someone had an emotional breakdown or a very animated conversation in here overnight, and it mirrors exactly what happened between Wangye and Shi Yuan in their room. Then the contrast — cutting from that chaotic living room to the quiet image inside the bedroom: "the two people wrapped up in the same bed, cuddled up fast asleep." The parallel is delicious. Outside = chaos, noise, panic. Inside = peace, warmth, intimacy. The physical space tells you everything about where these characters stand emotionally. And the lighting! The night light glow, the dim room, the morning light flooding in — the author uses light as a mood instrument throughout. When Shi Yuan turns off the bedside lamp, the scene shifts from private to protected. When the morning comes, everything is exposed, which is why Lu Chengxuan has to literally close the door. The hotel itself is almost a character. These two-bedroom suites, the shared spaces, the thin walls where you can hear your neighbors crying at 2am — it's this forced intimacy that pushes everyone's relationships to the surface. They're not just staying somewhere. They're being tested by the space they're in.
... Read More
There's a recurring motif in this chapter that I can't shake: the symbolism of titles, positions, and the invisible labor behind them. Lin Shen isn't just mad about handing out test papers; he's furious about the imbalance of credit and reward. “Why the hell is it everyone else doing the work, and you're the one getting all the credit? You're a damn capitalist vampire!” That's not just a joke—it's a sharp observation about how merit and recognition are distributed in systems we pretend are equal. Lu Chengxuan, the class rep, doesn't do the grunt work; he delegates. Lin Wangye handles the stack but dumps half on Lin Shen. Xu Suinian collects homework but struggles with basics. The teacher assigns Lin Wangye as secretary because he's convenient, not because he's skilled. So what is the class system really teaching them? That visibility doesn't equal value. That titles are just wrappers. And then Lu Chengxuan offers Lin Shen the study monitor title, and Lin Shen accepts instantly. Not because he wants to work, but because he wants the label—the proof that he matters. That's a profound commentary on adolescent identity formation. We chase titles because we haven't yet learned to value internal growth. Meanwhile, Lin Wangye's reflection on his past-life laziness ties into another theme: the illusion of comfort. He didn't fail because he was unintelligent; he failed because he never learned to push through discomfort. “He was a spoiled kid, raised to be pampered, and even the slightest discomfort made him feel like he was being wronged.” That's a cycle. But now, with Shi Yuan as deskmate, he's forced to sit with discomfort—his own urges, his own fear of falling behind again. The Kalamay Islands trip offered by Shi Shi is another symbol: escape, indulgence, a world where problems are temporarily suspended. Lu Chengxuan refuses it flatly. He chooses presence over escape. Every character in this chapter is navigating between comfort and growth, between being seen and being real. The author doesn't preach this; he lets it simmer in dialogue and silence.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying this whole love letter sequence is genuinely brilliant plot work, and I need to talk about why. Here's the setup: Lin Wangye has been heroically delivering love letters to Lu Chengxuan all day. We've established this as a running gag/subplot that's been simmering since earlier chapters, and the reader starts to wonder: is Lu Chengxuan going to break out of his cold shell? Is there going to be some emotional moment where he finally acknowledges these feelings? The tension has been building toward something, right? Then. Boom. The letter was never for him. It was for Lin Wangye himself. The reveal hits like a physical slap. Lu Chengxuan unfolds it, reads the first line, and the entire classroom — including us, the readers — are blindsided. 'Dear Lin Wangye, Hello. The first time I saw you was at…' What makes this twist actually work instead of feeling cheap is the setup. The author spent earlier chapters showing us Lin Wangye's softness, his instinct to help people, his emotional nature. That's WHY all those love letters ended up in his hands. Everyone trusted him with their secrets. The author had already laid the groundwork for Lin Wangye to be the unexpected recipient. And then watching Lin Wangye's reaction — the pure, unfiltered humiliation as he yanks the letter back and storms out of the classroom only to immediately walk into the math teacher — is peak comedic misfortune. The universe really said 'you wanted embarrassment? I'll give you double.' I also want to highlight how Lu Chengxuan's reaction during the reveal was so perfectly calibrated. He didn't gloat. He didn't laugh. The text says 'the corner of his lips curving up in a barely noticeable smirk' while he returned to his homework. That restraint is what makes him such a compelling character. He found this deeply funny but had the self-control not to show it outright. The plot here is doing triple duty: it advances the romantic tension between characters, it deepens our understanding of Lin Wangye's personality, and it delivers an genuinely surprising twist. That's efficient storytelling. I haven't stopped thinking about Lin Wangye's face when he realized what happened. The man just stood there, letter in hand, completely destroyed by a mistake he made while trying to be a good person. Irony really is the author's favorite tool.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say - the Xu Suinian thing? I screamed. Like actual screaming into my pillow. Because up until this moment, I genuinely did NOT connect Shi Yuan with the name on the ranking board. The author had me SO right where they wanted me. Think about it - we keep seeing Lin Wangye trying to find information about Shi Yuan's past, digging through No. 7 High's history, completely baffled. And the answer was staring us in the face this whole time. The ranking board name "Xu Suinian" belonging to the top student in Class A, and now we learn Shi Yuan was using a different name back then. Even his dad's research came up empty because obviously you can't find someone under a completely different identity. What's brilliant about this plot twist is how it reframes everything. When Lin Wangye kept asking about Shi Yuan's background, it wasn't just curiosity - it was partly because he was drawn to him and wanted to know more. And now we understand why Lin Wangye was so devastated when he realized he'd never noticed him. He literally sat there looking like he was about to cry. But here's what really got me - the author doesn't just reveal this and move on. They use it to build tension between characters. Lin Wangye's frustration about Zhao Youyou not mentioning Xu Suinian when listing handsome guys, his determination to make Lin Shen apologize... it all connects back to this revelation driving the plot forward. And the pacing? Chef's kiss. We get the reveal, then immediately pivot to Lin Wangye going to confront Lin Shen. No dwelling, no info-dump explanation. The story just keeps moving. That's how you handle a major plot twist - make it matter to what comes next, not just sit around reacting to it.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one moment where Lin Wangye just blurts out "He's my dad!" like his life depends on it, and honestly it is the most revealing character beat in these chapters. Think about it. He and his father have always been close — glued together, natural, comfortable. But he never considered how that would look from the outside. From Shi Yuan's perspective, someone who doesn't share their history, their context, their inside jokes. So when Shi Yuan gently asks, "What exactly is going on between you and Lin Shen?" — that question hits Lin Wangye like a truck because suddenly he realizes his own blindness. And then the desperation. The full explanation. The way he sounds "way more serious and sincere now" compared to earlier. This is a guy who usually operates on playful energy, teasing, leaning into people's shoulders — but here he is, sweating through an explanation because the idea of Shi Yuan misunderstanding anything about him terrifies him. Meanwhile, Lin Shen is doing what dads do best: caring so much it becomes comedy. "That's my precious Xiao Lin we're talking about—my baby, my pride and joy!" Bro, you're standing in a wrecked living room at 8am and your first thought is your son's love life. Classic. But the real gold is Lu Chengxuan. He hears Lin Wangye crying last night and decides NOT to intervene. Not because he doesn't care — because he respects the moment. That's the difference between a good friend and a great one.
... Read More
There's a lot going on beneath the surface of this chapter, and I want to unpack the symbolism because the author is doing real work here. The love letter itself — scented with lily perfume — is such a deliberate choice. Lilies carry heavy cultural weight in Chinese literature: purity, devotion, but also funeral connotations. This girl poured her hopes into this letter, and the scent is her emotional investment made physical. Lin Wangye can literally smell her vulnerability. But the deeper theme here is about the burden of being the person everyone trusts with their feelings. The narration explicitly tells us: 'The reason so many love letters ended up in his hands was because everyone knew that any letter he handled would eventually make its way to Lu Chengxuan. Whether or not it was ever opened, at least Lin Wangye wouldn't let the expectation go to waste.' Lin Wangye is the emotional landfill of his classroom. Everyone deposits their hopes, their crushes, their confessions into his hands because he's the only one who promises to carry them forward. He becomes the middleman of other people's emotions, and in this chapter, we see the cost of that role. Then there's the contrast with Lu Chengxuan, whose coldness is described as 'inherited from his father, practically etched into his bones.' His refusal to engage with these letters isn't just personality — it's familial programming. The father's indifference is reproduced in the son. But Lu Chengxuan's rationality also has its own morality: he won't give false hope because that would be cruel. His indifference is a form of respect, twisted as it may be. And Lin Shen! His entire arc in this scene is fascinating from a thematic angle. He positions himself as Lin Wangye's protector — 'you little scumbag' directed at the girl who wrote the letter, defending Lin Wangye's honor even as he mocks him. But the text also notes he was 'heartbroken' while doing it. Is he jealous? Is he performing masculinity for an audience? Or is he genuinely hurt that Lin Wangye might be drifting toward romance? The math teacher appearing at the end ties everything together thematically. Lin Wangye wants to flee his emotional crisis and runs straight into the figure of academic authority who represents another kind of crushing expectation. Every adult figure in this chapter is there to discipline, judge, or expose him. The world is not gentle to soft boys. Also the meta-layer: the author breaking character to ask readers for coffee and engagement, then immediately dropping us back into the drama. The boundary between narrator and audience is porous, which feels intentional — we're meant to feel complicit in watching these kids suffer.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or