Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just talk about how efficiently the author establishes these two voices through dialogue alone? That conversation where Lin Shen flat-out tells Lin Wangye 'I'm a mysterious man. Don't develop feelings for me. It's dangerous' is one of the funniest exchanges I've read in a while and it reveals so much about both characters without a single narrator explanation. Lin Shen's voice is this perfect blend of self-aware absurdity and genuine deflectiveness. He's the type who will say something wild and then watch the other person's face react, half-expecting drama and getting something else entirely. 'Give it up. I have no inappropriate thoughts about you.' The sheer deadpan commitment to this bit, while simultaneously being deeply uncomfortable about it, is comedy gold. And Lin Wangye's responses are equally sharp. 'Smoke less,' he says after crushing the cigarette, and the follow-up argument about regret medicine—'You know what hospitals don't sell? Regret medicine!'—is both genuinely funny and accidentally revealing. He's so earnest about this health advice that it spills over into something tender without him meaning it to. The author doesn't tell us Lin Wangye cares; we hear it in the way he rambling-deflects through a whole lecture about bad habits. What's interesting is that neither character seems to realize the subtext of their own words. Lin Shen thinks he's being humorously dismissive while actually being protective. Lin Wangye thinks he's just being annoying while actually being vulnerable. Their voices are distinct, natural, and layered in a way that makes me want to replay these scenes.
... Read More
The sensory details in this chapter are absolutely *something*. Let me just sit with this image for a second: small flakes of snow turning into goose-feather-like snowflakes, the red oil soup base steaming in the cold air, students from Seventh High School gathering in small groups, and Lin Wangye rolling up his sleeves to help in the freezing weather. The author doesn't just tell us it's cold—they show us through the grandmother's frostbitten hands, through the constant wiping of surfaces to keep everything neat, through the physical effort of pushing a cumbersome trailer through snow. Every detail serves atmosphere AND character development simultaneously. That's the mark of really skilled worldbuilding. And the urban village reveal! A dilapidated door hidden in what was supposedly the city center twenty years ago? The contrast between the bustling food stall scene and then winding through narrow alleys into something so different—it creates this sense that the city has layers, that people live completely different lives just streets apart. The food cart on wheels, the electric tricycle moving at walking speed, someone needed to steady it from behind. These aren't decorative details; they're the texture of a world that feels lived-in. The smell of the red油汤底 drawing people in despite the cold weather? The visual of snowflakes mixing with steam? I could literally see this as a film scene. The author has a real gift for grounding emotional moments in physical space.
... Read More
"This thing's tight and uncomfortable." / "All done. Off you go." Let's talk about the scarf scene because it's basically a textbook case study in how much can happen without a single word being said. Shi Yuan unraveling that haphazard knot, looping it back, smoothing every wrinkle — that's not just practical. That's intimacy coded in fabric. And Lin Wangye? He bends down without resistance. Doesn't question it. Doesn't pull away. Just… lets himself be cared for. Meanwhile, Shi Yuan's sitting there thinking about how this kid has no sense of personal boundaries, never realizing that the kid is actively choosing to cross them with him. The orange theft earlier by Lin Shen? Yeah, that stung Shi Yuan more than he'd admit. But Lin Wangye handing it over so casually? That's the thing — Lin Wangye probably doesn't even register it as crossing a line. His sense of identity is so firmly set that he's not playing games with proximity. He's just… present. Which makes Shi Yuan's overthinking even more tragic, because he's analyzing every micro-gesture for hidden meaning when the truth is probably simpler: Lin Wangye just trusts him. Completely. Unthinkingly. And then the glasses moment. "Your eyes are really pretty." Not romantic confession territory — more like factual observation, the kind you'd say about the sky or a good meal. But placed right before leaving, right after the scarf ritual, it lands like a stone in still water. Shi Yuan freezes. Not because it's dramatic, but because it's unexpected sincerity wrapped in casual delivery. Lin Wangye doesn't linger. Doesn't wait for a response. Just places the glasses and walks out. That's the dynamic in a nutshell: Lin Wangye gives away pieces of himself without fanfare, and Shi Yuan is left collecting them, trying to decode whether they mean what he hopes they mean. The father-son subplot about the sister's treatment is background noise here, but it adds weight — Lin Wangye is carrying private worries while performing this effortless closeness with Shi Yuan. It makes his casual touch feel heavier, like he's anchoring himself to something safe while everything else shifts. And Shi Yuan? He's standing on a minefield of his own making, mistaking comfort for ambiguity, because admitting that these gestures are special means admitting he wants them to be. The relationship isn't moving toward anything dramatic. It's moving toward collapse or clarity, and neither outcome is guaranteed.
... Read More
Okay, I need to unpack the symbolism here because this chapter is basically a treasure chest of it. Let's start with the snowmen. On the surface, it's just a weird habit. But think about it—snow is temporary. It melts. It disappears. And yet Lu Chengxuan, this guy who seems so composed, so put-together, is preserving snowmen in a fridge for a decade. That's not just nostalgia; that's a refusal to let things change. It's about freezing a moment in time, keeping something pure and intact even as the world moves on. He was eight when he made them. That's a pivotal age. Something probably happened, or someone probably left, and those snowmen became a talisman against loss. And then there's the necklace. Platinum, diamonds, crosses. Shi Yuan says it looks expensive, but Lin Wangye doesn't care about the price. He cares about the origin. 'You gave it to me.' It's a symbol of connection, of being chosen. Crosses often symbolize faith or sacrifice, but here? It feels more personal. It's a badge of their bond. Lin Wangye wears it openly, even while visiting a hospital bed. It's visible proof that he's not alone. And the food—the meals he brings—are another symbol. Food is care. Food is labor. By bringing meals, Lin Wangye is saying 'I am here, I am feeding you, I am staying.' It's a ritual of devotion. But the craziest symbol is the generator. Someone modified a fridge to run on backup power just to keep snow from melting. That's extreme commitment to preserving the past. It's almost pathetic, but also beautiful. We all have our snowmen—our frozen moments we refuse to let go of. The chapter is basically asking: what are you keeping in your fridge? What moments are you preserving because letting them melt feels like losing something irreplaceable? And then, right after that deep thought, we get the baby formula joke. Which is the universe reminding us that life goes on, even when we're trying to freeze it.
... Read More
There's something so cinematic about this entire sequence. The hospital room, the hallway footsteps echoing, the bedside cabinet with the fruit knife on it — it all feels like a film set where every detail has been chosen deliberately. And then Lin Wangye bolting to the bathroom on the fifth floor, every head turning as he passes, looking in the mirror and seeing two swollen walnut eyes — I could literally see this in my head like a movie scene. The bathroom moment is particularly vivid. Cold water on his face, standing by the window letting the chill wind hit his puffy skin. There's something almost symbolic about him wanting to dive out that fifth-floor window — not because he's suicidal, but because he's so mortified he wants to disappear. The author captures this perfectly without being heavy-handed about it. What I love most is how the setting becomes a character itself. The hospital room — presumably where Shi Yuan is recovering — is this neutral, almost clinical space. But Lin Wangye buries his face in the blanket like an ostrich, and suddenly it becomes this cozy, private universe just for them. The overturned chair clattering to the floor when he bolts up, the tissues piling up in the trash can — these small details make the scene feel lived-in and real. And the hallway! Those echoing footsteps, the other people's heads turning. It reminds us that this emotional collapse is happening in a public space, surrounded by strangers going about their business. The contrast between the intimate moment between these two boys and the indifferent world outside their door is really poignant. One image that's going to stay with me: Lin Wangye half-hugging Shi Yuan's waist under the blanket, resting his head on his folded arm, peeking out with one red swollen eye. It's such a specific, visual moment — like a painting. I wish I could draw it.
... Read More
"Five thousand! Just say 'Happy New Year' a couple times and do a few bows, and boom—there's our living expenses for a few months, maybe even the whole year!" I literally laughed out loud. Lin Wangye's inner monologue is a whole mood. This kid negotiated his entire social future based on red envelope arithmetic, and he's wearing that transaction like a badge of honor. There's something so honest about it, too—he's not pretending to be above wanting the money. He just states it like, yes, I am a gold digger and I am proud. The text message sequences are also genuinely well-done. The way Lu Chengxuan responds with one-word answers while Wangye floods him with exclamation marks creates this visual rhythm on the page. You can literally hear their voices: Wangye's all caps energy versus Lu Chengxuan's deadpan minimalism. The 888 transfer is peak Lu Chengxuan—affectionate but transactional, romantic but practical. It's the love language of someone who expresses care through numbers on a screen. And then Shi Yuan's dialogue is this warm counterpoint—short, soft, grounding. "Happy New Year's Eve, babe." No flourish, no performance. Just presence. That's the author's voice at its best: switching registers between Wangye's chaotic exterior and the quieter emotional current running underneath. The humor lands because it's earned by character, not slapped on for laughs.
... Read More
I need to talk about Shi Yuan because THIS man is something else. Look at him—gentle, patient, the kind of person who brushes his thumb along someone's lower lip and then notices they have a cut. He says "I'll be more careful next time" like he's apologizing for something and NOT like he was absolutely ravenous five minutes ago. The contrast is killing me. But what really gets me is his observational skills. He notices the expression shift. He catches the hesitation. And instead of pressing aggressively, he just... watches. Quietly. The line "Deep down, he still felt like..." right there at the end—HE STILL SUSPECTS SOMETHING. Shi Yuan is not dumb. He's just choosing to be gentle about it. And Lin Wangye? Oh, Lin Wangye is a mess. Twenty years from the future carrying guilt like a second skin, trying to protect the people he loves from tragedies that haven't happened yet, while simultaneously being completely exposed in bed next to the one person who sees right through him. The power dynamic here is fascinating—Lin Wangye thinks he's the one hiding secrets, but Shi Yuan has been quietly piecing things together this whole time. Who's really in control in this relationship? I'm not sure anymore and I love it.
... Read More
Did anyone else stop and really sit with that author's note? "Yingfu Temple grants every wish. Yingri Peak humbles every smart mouth." This is essentially the thesis statement for the entire chapter. Lin Shen came to this mountain with his usual bravado, his usual running commentary, his usual refusal to show weakness—and the mountain physically forced him to stop. Can't walk. Can't continue. Can't pretend. The peak literally made him small. I think the entire setup of him trying to descend alone mirrors his emotional arc throughout the story: he keeps trying to prove he doesn't need anyone, and every time he does, something literal or figurative makes him fall. And the fact that Yingfu Temple is mentioned as granting wishes but the temple visit never happens? I think that's also on purpose. The story isn't about getting what you want, it's about being shown what you actually need. Lin Shen needed to be carried. He just didn't know it yet.
... Read More
Here's what keeps me up at night: Lin Wangye isn't just making funny assumptions. He's processing real trauma through comedy, and the stakes underneath his wild theories are terrifyingly real. Think about it. Lin Wangye comes from a previous life where he witnessed something terrible happen between Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan. "No wonder the two of them grew up together, only to end up turning on each other like that." That line alone carries so much weight. Whatever happened between them in the original timeline was catastrophic, and Lin Wangye is trying to piece it together from fragments while standing on the outside looking in. His suspicion isn't frivolous. His gut might be wrong about the details, but the core instinct—something significant happened between those two—is probably right. The stakes for Lin Wangye are enormous: if his dad and Lu Chengxuan's relationship is real, then everything Lin Wangye thought he knew about his family, about loyalty, about who to trust, is potentially upended again. He's already lived through one version of events where people he loved were torn apart. The fear of history repeating itself is the real conflict here, and the author wraps it in comedy so effectively that you don't even notice you're crying until later. And then there's the external stake: whatever system or timeline rules are at play here. The author's note about Xiao Lin being an orphan by default, about this timeline being auto-fixed—it raises the question of whether these characters have any real agency, or whether they're just playing out predetermined roles. If Lin Wangye discovers the truth about his dad and Lu Chengxuan, does that change the timeline? Could it break the system? The stakes aren't just emotional, they're existential. Every laugh this chapter generates is earned, but underneath it all there's genuine dread. And that's why it works so well.
... Read More
Let me just say this: every single character in this story is one bad day away from losing everything, and that's what makes it so gripping. Suihe is fighting for her life. Chemotherapy ahead. Transfer to a higher-level hospital. Kids her age should be worried about homework and crushes, not whether they'll see next spring. Lin Wangye is carrying this invisible weight of being the only one who remembers how bad things used to be, and now he's trying to protect everyone from that future while also being a kid who just wants to have fun. Then Lin Pengcheng drops into an ICU bed. Diabetes complications, diet restrictions, the whole family's financial situation hanging in the balance. Remember that demolition compensation detail? The family got money but only Lin Pengcheng actually built something with it. Now if he goes down, what happens to everything they've built? His siblings burned through their shares. This man was the pillar. And the hiking trip—Yingtian Mountain, 1500 meters, no cable car, snow in winter—sits as this almost ironic backdrop to all of it. A voluntary hardship they're choosing while others are fighting involuntary hardships. Lin Shen calling it "amazing views" and "spectacular stuff" while the reader knows full well what suffering actually looks like in this story. The contrast is brutal and I'm here for it.
... Read More
The imagery in these chapters is so specific and it builds this whole world without ever stopping to explain it. You have the announcement board where Lin Wangye checks the rankings — that's such a great detail because it grounds the whole academic pressure system in a physical object you can picture. Then the classroom in Class 7 where Lin Wangye is 'banging the table enthusiastically' and the classroom in Class A that he peers into and finds Shi Yuan's seat empty — those two shots side by side tell you everything about the hierarchy. Class A is the temple, Class 7 is the rest of the world, and Fu Xuexue is crossing a threshold. But the real masterpiece is the teacher's office. Large space, cubicles, the door that opens for just a few seconds, Lin Wangye leaning over trying to sneak a peek. You can SEE this. The metal railing he leans against. The closed door. His phone in his hand. It's cinematic and restrained and the author never once slows down to describe it like it's important — which is exactly why it's important. The school itself feels like a character with its rankings, its announcement boards, its class divisions that are treated like social strata.
... Read More
Let me just lay this out: Lin Shen is protecting Lin Wangye from relationship harm. Lu Chengxuan is protecting Lin Shen from his own impulsiveness. Lin Wangye is apparently protecting his secret relationship with... someone? Xu Suinian? The text doesn't confirm but the clues are everywhere. And underneath all of this, Lu Chengxuan is facing some kind of external threat — he mentions being surrounded by three people, the forces he needs to face, things under control. The stakes are operating on at least three different levels simultaneously and the author never lets you forget any of them. What's interesting is how the conflict shifts from external to internal and back again. Lin Shen's conflict starts as external — he wants answers, he wants to confront someone — but it quickly becomes internal, about his own inability to accept that the kid he's been watching over has a secret life. Meanwhile Lu Chengxuan's conflict is almost entirely internal, a battle between his love for Lin Shen and his fear of failing to protect him. And Lin Wangye? His conflict is the oldest in the book — two lifetimes of experience but still just a kid trying to navigate everything. The college entrance exam adds another layer of stakes on top of all this. One wrong move and years of effort are gone. The author is piling on tension from every direction and I'm genuinely worried for everyone. Not in a frustrating way, but in that good way where you can't stop reading because you need to know if anyone survives this intact.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or