Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this one scene because it's been living in my head rent-free. Lin Wangye tells Lu Chengxuan he likes someone else — and Lu Chengxuan's reaction is just... silence. He doesn't agree or disagree. He just stays quiet. But then the narrator drops this line: "deep down, hearing Lin Wangye liked someone else… it lifted something off his chest he didn't even realize was weighing him down." I literally gasped. That is such a devastatingly beautiful way to write unrequited love. It's not the dramatic tear-jerker moment you expect. It's quieter than that. It's the relief of someone who finally has an excuse to stop hoping. Lu Chengxuan has been carrying this weight silently, and now that it's confirmed Lin Wangye's heart belongs to someone else, he can finally put it down. And yet — he says nothing. He just hugs Lu Wei, goes home, and pretends everything is fine. Meanwhile, Lin Wangye is over here absolutely glowing from his chat with Shi Yuan, completely oblivious to the fact that the person sitting across from him just lost something irreplaceable. The dramatic irony is killing me. Every sweet exchange between Lin Wangye and Shi Yuan hurts more because we know what Lu Chengxuan is feeling. That little dog holding a rose emoji? I laughed and then immediately felt guilty because Lu Chengxuan isn't getting any of that warmth.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan because honestly, this chapter was a masterclass in unspoken tension. Like, the board game isn't just a board game, okay? It's a metaphor and I am HERE for it. Every time Lu Chengxuan deliberately dodges his green planes instead of engaging Lin Shen — that's not strategy, that's restraint. That's a man who could crush his rival at every turn but chooses not to, not out of weakness but because he's holding back something far more complicated. And Lin Shen? He's so furious he can't even name what he's angry about. He just knows it's personal. Meanwhile, Lin Wangye and Shi Yuan are out there being disgustingly sweet, holding hands, walking around Mount Yingtian like a rom-com extra, and I respect the energy but also — I'm over here having an emotional crisis watching two men communicate entirely through a board game while some people are already married in spirit. The line that wrecked me though: Lin Shen could have won Lu Chengxuan over with 'just one soft word.' ONE WORD. He's been so proud, so stubborn, that he'd rather lose badly than admit he wants something. That's not just character flavor — that's the whole tragedy of their dynamic packed into a single sentence. And then Lin Wangye tearing up the DNA report in the hallway. Calmly. Politely. No tears, no breakdown. Just… acceptance. The way he handled that moment said everything about what he's carrying inside. Some wounds don't bleed, they just quietly close.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that got me—Lin Wangye sneaking that money under the mouse. Five hundred yuan. For a part-time worker, that's not pocket change. The way the author sets it up is genius: Lin Shen first notices the mouse feeling 'off,' lifts it, and there's the cash. Crisp bills. No note, no drama, just this quiet act of 'don't fight with your family, have good food.' It's the kind of plot detail that hits different because it's so specific. The author doesn't tell us Lin Wangye's motivation outright—we figure it out from context. He knows Lin Shen tends to spiral during holidays, gets into family fights, ends up depressed in the internet cafe. So he gives him money. Period. And then there's the whole Lin Shen-Lin Wangye dynamic with the 'dad energy' bit. Lin Wangye tries to give advice about spending New Year together, all fatherly and worried, and Lin Shen panics like 'no no no I get it, go away.' The humor in that is sharp, but it also reveals something real: these two care about each other, but they don't know how to be soft with each other. Meanwhile, Lin Wangye's internal monologue about his own dad—how in his last life they barely had time together, how this one day a year was sacred—hits completely different when you realize he's thinking about forgiving his father while simultaneously being the one person Lin Shen can't forgive... or won't let himself. The subplot with Shi Yuan's pottery shop is a nice contrast. It's quiet, domestic, warm. All the action with Lin Shen's family tension gets cut against this calm slice-of-life moment. Good structural choice by the author. It keeps the narrative from becoming one long depression spiral.
... Read More
I have to talk about how masterfully this section shifts tones. We start with what seems like a quiet domestic scene—eating porridge, wiping condensation off a window—and somehow the author squeezes an entire life trajectory into a few pages. The rent reveal is brutal in its casualness. Two thousand a year for a former warehouse? That single number does so much heavy lifting. It tells us about Shi Yuan's priorities, his sister's illness, his sacrifice—all without a single melodramatic sentence. Then comes the pivot to Lin Wangye's internal monologue, and oh boy. "Fate doesn't give anyone a chance to start over; once a choice is made, all you can do is grit your teeth and continue forward." That line hit me like a truck. Because suddenly we understand why he regrets not going to the competitions. It's not just about money—it's about the weight of alternatives, the ghost-path of the life he didn't choose. And then the story BOWLS us over by cutting to the school scene, all playful energy and gaming complaints, as if to say: yes, life is terrible, but also look, they're still sixteen and joking about who gets abandoned first. The structural whiplash is intentional and it works so well.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author builds atmosphere in this tiny hospital room because it genuinely feels like a character itself. We start with sensory details immediately — the bags of chips tumbling to the floor, the kettle being set down first (priorities!), the messy pile on the bedside table. This is a small, cramped space but it never feels sterile or cold. It feels lived-in. The bedside table becomes a stage. The bed becomes somewhere intimate enough for confessionals and dramatic monologues about joy. The lighting and physical proximity matter a lot here. Lin Wangye is sitting on the bed, propping his chin on his hands, looking up. Shi Yuan is at the edge of the bed, looking down. That vertical positioning — the height difference, the angle of their gaze — creates this visual composition that's almost cinematic. You can SEE this scene. The stray tufts of hair sticking out from the sweater friction. The rabbit fur sweater itself, which adds texture and warmth to the whole image. There's also this moment where Lin Wangye's posture is described as "like a cat curled up beside its owner, purring in its sleep." That comparison transforms the entire room. It's no longer a hospital room or a temporary space — it's somewhere safe. Something domestic. Something tender. The author doesn't need to describe decorations or views out the window. The emotional atmosphere does all the worldbuilding. And that metal railing on the side of the bed — Shi Yuan uses it as a tool for the static electricity trick. A hospital bed railing becomes a prop in a comedy routine. The mundane becomes magical. That's the whole aesthetic of this story in a nutshell: finding warmth and wonder in the most ordinary, confined spaces.
... Read More
Let's talk about the dialogue in this chapter because it's giving me life. The way characters speak here is so distinctly coded—it's like you could cover their names and still know who's talking. Lu Chengxuan is the king of minimal. Three words: 'Don't move.' That's it. He says almost nothing else throughout the whole scene, but every syllable carries weight. When Lin Wangye asks him why he stopped him from giving up the seat, Lu Chengxuan's response is this beautifully dismissive 'You?' like, really, are you worried about your grades? His voice is cold, clipped, authoritative—and somehow that makes him infinitely more interesting than any character who monologues. Then you have Lin Wangye's voice, which is totally different—energetic, sarcastic, constantly narrating his own reactions. 'Tsk…' 'Aha~' He's performing even when he's just talking to his best friend. And the physical comedy of him leaning in close, blocking his mouth with a book to whisper—he's literally playing a spy in his own father's classroom, which is both funny and slightly devastating. Shi Shi's dialogue is sparse but telling. She speaks softly, politely, answers everyone's questions with warmth—but her eyes 'revealed no signs of familiarity or closeness with anyone.' The narration does the heavy lifting here, but it's the contrast between her warm words and cold eyes that makes her feel like a real person with layers, not just a beautiful face in a story. The teacher's lines are utilitarian—practical, efficient, slightly stressed—which perfectly captures that authority figure who just wants to get through the day without anyone causing trouble.
... Read More
I want to appreciate the craft here because this scene takes place over roughly twenty minutes of real time and the author makes every second count. It opens with maximum energy — Lin Shen already losing it, pillow on the floor, yelling. That's an immediate hook. Then the mahjong detour serves as a brief comedic beat before pivoting to flying chess, which becomes the main engine. The pacing of the game itself is well-controlled: we see Lin Wangye's terrible start, his slow climb back, the escalation of conflict, the alliance drama, and then the cliffhanger. There are no filler moments. Even the exposition about Yingtian Mountain and why they're stuck in that hotel is woven in naturally as background rather than dropped as info-dump. The three-act structure within the scene is clean — setup (boredom), confrontation (the game), resolution withheld (cliffhanger). And the dialogue beats land because each character has a distinct rhythm. Lin Shen's lines are explosive and immediate. Lu Chengxuan's are clipped and loaded. Lin Wangye's are performative. Shi Yuan's are barely there and that's the point. The author knows when to speed up (the back-and-forth between Lin Shen and Lin Wangye) and when to slow down (the quiet moments with Shi Yuan).
... Read More
There are so many symbols packed into this chapter that I need to sit with them. The snow melting on the windowsill—that's not just atmosphere, it's the central image of the entire story. Things that were frozen are beginning to thaw. The window itself is a barrier and a threshold. Lin Shen has to peek through glass before knocking, physically separated from the people he wants to reach. And Lin Wangye keeps referencing being cursed, being broken since the start, paying for sins he hasn't named. The curse is a metaphor for inherited trauma, for the damage passed down through families who don't know how to love properly. Lin Shen himself was rejected by his own family in the previous life, and now he's repeating patterns of distance and failed connection. The old post mentioned earlier—the one about year after year messages and shattered defenses—that's about fate refusing to let certain connections dissolve. Shi Yuan thought he could protect himself, but the text says he never even tried to guard himself, not once. That's the tragedy and the beauty of it. He's already surrendered. And Lin Wangye, the boy with sharp intent behind soft edges, he's charging straight at people with a smile because he's learned that vulnerability is the only weapon he has. The composite logarithmic function Lin Wangye throws at his dad as a test—math as a barrier, a way to prove who deserves closeness and who doesn't. Everything in this chapter is about thresholds: doors, windows, the edge of relationships, the line between friendship and something more dangerous.
... Read More
OK so the plot mechanism here is absolutely brilliant and I need to discuss it because the author set this up like a chess grandmaster. On the surface, this is a slice-of-life New Year's Eve chapter. Cute, warm, low-stakes. But underneath, the author is setting up a massive coming-soon confrontation. Lu Chengxuan invites Wangye to meet his family, provides financial incentive (red envelopes—let's be real, this is basically bribery), and simultaneously removes the father from the immediate scene. Why? Because he knows his family would eat Wangye alive, and he needs time to prepare the ground. The narrative arc here moves in three beats: the invitation (setup), the New Year's Eve preparation (rising action through domestic normalcy), and then the looming family dinner (the cliffhanger). What's clever is that the author deliberately delays the actual drama. We get the market trip, the tender couple moments, the butler interaction—all of this makes the upcoming family scene feel more inevitable because we've seen what Wangye stands to lose. The quieter the happiness, the sharper the potential fall. Also worth noting: the author uses the red envelope as a plot device AND a thematic device. It's literally the mechanism that brings Wangye into the Lu family orbit, and it's also commentary on how love and transaction blur in relationships where power imbalances exist. Wangye jokes about it, but he also can't refuse. That tension between agency and necessity is the engine driving the next arc.
... Read More
I need to talk about the Lin Wangye × Shi Yuan energy because WOW. When Lin Wangye gets completely wrecked by Lin Shen's yellow planes and his only remaining red plane gets sent back to base AGAIN, what does he do? He doesn't cry. He doesn't sulk. He turns around, grabs Shi Yuan's hand, and pouts. Like a literal child. And Shi Yuan — sweet, calm Shi Yuan — just laughs and squeezes his fingers back, then rolls a five and saves the day. This is the kind of moment that makes me put the book down and just sit with it. It's not dramatic romance, it's not even really romantic, it's just two people who clearly care about each other existing in a shared moment of playful desperation. The hand-holding during a board game. That's the stuff. Meanwhile Lin Shen is over here screaming about bros and alliances and Lu Chengxuan is running cold calculations like a chess master (ironic, given they're playing a board game). The contrast between Lin Wangye's openness and everyone else's guardedness is so sharp. I'm here for the soft boy energy.
... Read More
"I used to think you were nothing like an Aries. But now I get it. You're pure Aries. Textbook Aries." This line alone is worth the price of admission. Lin Wangye, having just switched gears from gushing about how cute Xu Suihe is to randomly launching into a zodiac sign lecture, drops this on Lin Shen with absolute conviction. And Lin Shen's response—"I'm really not—"—gets cut off mid-sentence like it always does when Lin Wangye gets on a roll. This is their dynamic in a single exchange. The dialogue in this chapter is ridiculously natural. Every character has a distinguishable voice. Lin Wangye chatters, jumps between topics (paper stars → horoscopes → birthdays), and backs his opinions with the confidence of someone who's never been told he's wrong. Lin Shen is laid-back but dry—"Not like being born on Singles' Day is something to brag about anyway." That line had me wheezing. Shi Yuan speaks sparingly and when he does, it's heavy with meaning: "It's not safe with me. If he gets his hands on it, we're screwed." Three sentences, and you feel the weight of his entire backstory. And Lu Chengxuan? Not a single line of exposition. He says "No problem" and goes back to his ice jelly. His silence IS his voice. It tells you everything about who he is compared to the others. The author doesn't need to explain that Lu Chengxuan is the most grounded of the four—you learn it through what he DOESN'T say.
... Read More
Let's be real about what's at stake here because this chapter quietly raises the stakes to a level that should feel unbearable and it actually does. Shi Yuan isn't just some kid who fell in a ditch and got a concussion — he's carrying the weight of a gambling-addicted father who destroyed his family, a mother who died in a fire, a sister whose leukemia treatment costs more than most people will earn in a lifetime, and a scholarship that might be the only thing keeping him in school. And the conflict isn't even over yet. His dad is currently arrested, sure, but the sister still needs treatment, the financial damage is done, and the psychological damage — the fact that this kid is sitting in a classroom doing math problems while his entire world collapsed around him — that's the kind of thing that doesn't resolve in a single chapter. The author is setting up a long-burn conflict here, not a quick drama. But what really grips me is Lin Wangye's internal conflict. He knows what's coming. He lived this life before. And now he's standing here with the knowledge that he could've prevented so much of it, or at least stood closer to Shi Yuan during it. The grandfather's death was the first crack, but the father's gambling is the earthquake. Lin Wangye's fists unclenching at the end — that small physical detail says everything about a boy who wants to act but doesn't yet know how. The stakes here aren't about winning a competition or passing an exam. They're about whether these kids survive each other. And I am invested to the point of obsession.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or