Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I keep coming back to the jacket. Not just as a plot device, but as a symbol that holds the entire thematic weight of this passage. It's warmth offered and refused. It's protection granted and ignored. It's the physical manifestation of the choices these characters are making about who they align with and who they leave out in the cold. And then there's the wind—the relentless, cutting force that no amount of shared body heat can fully defend against. It's a perfect metaphor for the external pressures closing in on Lin Wangye, the “wheels of fate” grinding toward that inevitable arrest. But what really got me was the idea of recognition. The officer says, “We'd recognize you even if you were turned to ashes.” That line isn't just about police work; it's about identity, lineage, destiny. You can burn someone down, change their clothes, hide their face, but they'll still know who you are. The system knows. The past knows. And Lin Wangye, caught between his father's world and Lu Chengxuan's indifference, is already being read like an open book. The whole scene feels like an elegy for choice—a quiet acknowledgment that some threads are already woven, no matter how desperately you try to pull them apart.
... Read More
Okay can we talk about how perfectly this scene carves out the four dynamic personalities without a single exposition dump? Lin Shen is chaos incarnate — throwing pillows, yelling at people, crushing soda cans like his life depends on it. Lu Chengxuan? Silent stares and eyebrow raises that hit harder than any shouting match. That moment when he says "I'm not feeling the sincerity" is absolutely devastating in its casualness. And Lin Wangye being the little puppy who immediately goes to Shi Yuan for comfort — "Help the poor puppy!" — I literally laughed out loud. Meanwhile Shi Yuan just sits there being all cute and helpful like a golden retriever in human form, rolling a five and accidentally taking down Lin Shen's entire strategy. The hierarchy shift when Lin Shen tries to recruit Lu Chengxuan and gets cold-shouldered is everything. These four have such distinct energy and the author never lets them blur together.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are layered like an onion and I'm crying from the fumes. On the surface: Lin Wangye is trying out for a competitive gaming team. Simple enough. But then you have Yang Qingsen—the boss figure, the one who built this operation—who needs to verify Lin Wangye's skills before committing. The 1v1 match isn't just a game, it's a trial that could determine whether this kid gets his shot or gets sent home. Under that: Lin Shen's past with Yang Qingsen is clearly not clean. The whole "who's the dad" bit isn't just comedy—it's a power play, a way of asserting familiarity and territory. Yang Qingsen testing Lin Wangye's skills while subtly reminding Lin Shen who's in charge? That's chess, not checkers. And then LU CHENGXUAN walks in. The man who Lin Wangye lives with. The man who shows up unannounced at an internet cafe. His presence changes the entire gravity of the room. Lin Shen goes quiet. Lin Wangye tries to play it cool. The air freezes. What are the stakes here? Lin Wangye's gaming future is on the line, sure. But so is whatever fragile peace exists between these three men. And if Lin Wangye finds out what's actually going on between Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan—well, that's the real cliffhanger, isn't it?
... Read More
There's something really cinematic about this whole scene. A street-side hotpot stall, late evening, probably after school hours, and you've got these two guys hunched over bamboo skewers and a boiling pot. The author doesn't go overboard with descriptions but the few details that ARE there land perfectly. The old man busy cooking meatballs in another small pot, the old woman with hearing loss sitting across from them smiling with her eyes crinkled into lines — this is a whole family unit just existing in their little corner of the world, and suddenly our protagonists are part of it for thirty minutes. It's warm and ordinary and it contrasts so sharply with whatever elite power struggles are waiting for Lin Shen back at whatever mansion they're really from. The golden hair of Lu Chengxuan appearing under a streetlamp, blocking the light — that image alone is a whole mood. Winter evening, biting wind, and the visual of this intimidating figure casting shadow over someone smaller. I could literally see this as a film scene.
... Read More
The night market scene is one of those passages where the author just lets the world breathe. Lanterns going up, stalls appearing like magic, the whole place transforming into something out of an old-time lantern festival. I love how casually it's established—‘This was also one of the highlights of Yingtian Mountain'—as if we're supposed to know this already, as if the mountain has its own rhythm and schedule independent of the characters. And then there's the hotel suite dinner. The manager clearly knows hosting Lu Chengxuan is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, so every plate is arranged ‘like art,' some even carved with radish flowers, ‘on par with a full imperial banquet.' The absurdity of it all—the overpriced tourist traps, the extravagant hotel response, the five-yuan whistle that costs more in suffering than it should—creates this perfect bubble of warmth and humor. The pavilion scene where they stand and look at the night view before heading back is probably the most cinematic moment in the chapter. Four people, no dialogue needed, just taking in the mountain darkness together. It's the kind of silence that says everything.
... Read More
So here's the thing about these chapters that I genuinely love — the author splits the narrative right down the middle. One half follows Lin Shen stuck in the hotel, the other follows Lin Wangye and Shi Yuan on the mountain. Two completely different vibes, two completely different energy levels, and they complement each other like yin and yang. The Lin Shen half is comedic chaos. Bananas, TV remote throwing, muttering complaints about being watched like a hawk, then this bizarre pivot into a full-on rant about why hotels should invest in esports. It's fast, it's silly, it's letting the reader breathe. And then — BAM — 'After hiking up Mount Yingri at dawn, Lin Wangye thought nothing could wear him out anymore.' The tonal shift is so sharp it practically hits you. What's brilliant is how both halves feed each other. Lin Shen's boredom mirrors Lin Wangye's exhaustion. Lin Shen worries about being caught gaming while Lin Wangye is slowly dying on a mountain. They're parallel tracks of suffering, and the chapter structure makes you feel both at once. No dragging, no rushing. Just two stories that need each other.
... Read More
There's this one moment — just three sentences, really — that I kept coming back to like it was a film frame I couldn't skip: "Lin Shen had pale skin, made even fairer from staying indoors so much. In the sunlight, the tiny blue veins beneath his eyelids were faintly visible. He blinked at the brightness, eyes stinging, then stretched with a lazy groan." The author is doing something really interesting here with light. Lu Chengxuan moves to BLOCK the sunlight — not because he cares about Lin Shen's comfort, but because it's blocking his own view. Or maybe it IS because he cares, and he's just not capable of admitting it. The sunlight is this constant presence in the room: glaring, exposing, impossible to ignore. It illuminates the paper fibers on the scrap paper like "dried-up riverbeds" — cracks and grooves, nothing smooth about it. Everything in this room is textured, rough, full of fissures. Just like their relationship. Meanwhile, the other thread takes us to Room 520, where Lin Wangye is standing in a kitchen surrounded by failed seasoning experiments. The contrast is almost comical — one character is bathing in silent, devastating light while another is swearing at a recipe website about MSG quantities. But the domus feels equally alive in both spaces. The Lu estate has this oppressive, controlled atmosphere where every emotion is measured and suppressed. Room 520 is chaotic and warm and smells like burnt garlic. Both worlds tell you exactly who lives in them. And that crumpled paper airplane floating to the floor like a feather? Perfect. The most violent emotional moment in the chapter is accompanied by the softest visual.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Wangye's position in this family because it is COMPLICATED and I love it. He's technically Lin Qianqian's nephew but they have history — she raised him basically — and now he's sitting in her car having the most intense internal crisis of his young life while outwardly just nodding and saying 'okay!' like nothing is wrong. The duality here is EVERYTHING. And then Lin Shen — oh Lin Shen. He goes from being the protective older cousin in the past life to now being broke, scrambling through his aunt's bag for cash, and accidentally destroying a half-million yuan bag. The role reversal is delicious. He's so flustered and desperate trying to cover it up, asking 'what happened? WHO did this?' like his sister doesn't know literally everything about him. Classic Lin Shen being chaotic. The silence between Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan when the bag gets scratched — that single beat where Lu just looks out the window and Lin Shen is internally dying — that tells you SO much about their dynamic. Lu Chengxuan isn't even surprised, just resigned. They've been through worse. But the real moment for me is Lin Qianqian's treatment of Lin Wangye. She immediately shifts him to the front seat 'to avoid motion sickness' — that's the kind of specific, caring detail that shows how deeply she's wired into his well-being. Despite everything happening in her life, she still notices these things about him. And he feels regret for her despite not even fully understanding her past yet. That bond is the emotional anchor of this whole section.
... Read More
Let's talk about Lu Chengxuan because this man is quietly the most interesting person in every scene. You've got this otherworldly reborn protagonist who should be center stage, but honestly? Lu Chengxuan is the one doing the actual work here. He notices the surveillance gap before anyone else. He knows how long each meat should grill for. He's carrying bags of stuffed animals like he just rolled out of bed but also somehow manages the entire situation with a quiet competence that makes you respect him immediately. The dynamic with Lin Shen is what really gets me though. Lin Shen walks in acting like a spoiled brat — ordering Lu Chengxuan around at the barbecue place like he's personal staff, completely ungrateful. And Lu Chengxuan just... does it. No resentment, no dramatic speech about standing up for himself. He's comfortable enough with the role that Lin Shen assigns him that it doesn't even register as beneath him. That's either genuine emotional maturity or something deeper and more complicated that the text is teasing out slowly. Then there's Lin Qianqian, who oscillates between being warm toward Lin Wangye and completely ignoring Lu Chengxuan at dinner. She clearly knows about the Lu family's reputation and the awkward history between their families, but she also seems to have formed her own judgment. The line where she decides not to bother asking Lu Chengxuan what he thinks — that's not hostility, that's something more nuanced. She's read the room and decided where he fits in her hierarchy of people worth engaging with. And Lin Wangye himself — orphan status triggering everyone's mothering instincts, accepting money awkwardly, falling back into sibling dynamics with Lin Shen like they never separated. The text keeps reminding us this is a second chance at relationships, and that weight hangs over everything.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this exchange and I think it might be the single most important dialogue moment across all four chapters. Lin Wangye builds this whole setup — talking about his own overwhelming feelings, his secrets, his insomnia — and all of it is steering toward one question: "Are you happy?" He's trying to share his joy with Shi Yuan. That's what he says explicitly: "I'll give you some of mine — hold onto it, okay?" He's offering happiness like it's a gift he can hand over. It's so earnest and so young and so beautifully naive. And Shi Yuan's response? "Is happiness really necessary for survival?" JUST ONE WORD different. Lin Wangye is talking about life. Shi Yuan is talking about survival. That gap between them — that chasm — tells you everything about where each of them has been. Lin Wangye gets to ask about happiness because he hasn't had to fight just to stay alive. Shi Yuan hasn't thought about happiness in years because he's been in survival mode since he was a kid. But what I love is that Shi Yuan doesn't shut him down. He doesn't say "no" or walk away. He answers. He engages. He stays in the conversation even when it hits something painful. And the dialogue throughout this chapter is just so natural. Lin Wangye's voice is loud and playful — the God of Joy monologue, the puppy comment, the dramatic gasps. Shi Yuan's voice is quieter, drier, but there's warmth underneath every line. When he says "It's just static electricity," that's not dismissal — that's him playing along in his own restrained way. His humor is deadpan but present. And the line "I'd really love to waste my time on you" from earlier is perfectly Lin Wangye — forward, sweet, slightly silly, impossible to resist.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the pacing in chapters 107-110 is absolutely masterful and I don't say that lightly. Chapter 107 opens with chaos — Lin Wangye bursting into Room 520 with snacks everywhere, bags tumbling, kettle placed down first like his priorities are immediately clear even in his clumsiness. It's energetic, almost comedic. We get the setup of why he's there (he scolded someone for bothering Shi Yuan), and then we settle in. Chapter 108 is where it slows down. The pacing shifts from physical comedy to emotional intimacy. Lin Wangye sits on the bed. The conversation starts casually but gets heavier fast. The whisper moment, the question about happiness — all of it builds without rushing. The author doesn't hurry any of these beats. You can feel every second stretching between them. Chapter 109 is the emotional peak. The survival question hits like a truck. And then chapter 110 releases ALL that tension with the static electricity scene — pure playfulness, physical comedy, vulnerability disguised as a joke. It's such a smart structural choice to follow the heaviest moment with something light, because the lightness actually makes the heaviness feel more earned. If the chapter had ended on "is happiness necessary for survival?" alone, it would have been devastating but one-note. Instead, we get the snap, the spark, the puppy comment, and the hair ruffle. The tension dissolves into something warm, and that warmth hits harder than any drama could have. The transitions are seamless. No jarring jumps, no dragging sections. Every paragraph earns its place. I read this in one sitting and I blame nobody.
... Read More
I need to talk about the blackboard. Not just because it's funny — though Lin Shen's 'modern medical marvel' joke absolutely deserves its own footnote — but because that single detail contains the entire thesis of this chapter, maybe this whole section of the novel. Shi Shi claims a dust allergy so severe she can't participate in cleaning duties. The teacher believes her. The school accommodates her. She sits out an entire year of manual labor while others sweep floors for her class's mobile flag. This is a girl who has built an entire infrastructure of exceptions around her. And then — she wipes the blackboard. For Lu Chengxuan. No allergy. No certificate. Just... suddenly dust-free when it matters. The symbol here is so layered. The blackboard represents effort, labor, participation in the mundane reality of school life. Shi Shi rejects all of it EXCEPT when it serves her relationship to someone powerful. She doesn't clean for herself or her classmates. She cleans for Lu Chengxuan. The allergy isn't real — it's selective. It activates only when she wants to avoid work and deactivates when she wants to appear helpful to the right person. This connects to everything else in the chapter about performance. Shi Shi's life is described as 'one big performance.' Her beauty is 'untouchable.' Every gesture is 'like a perfect scene from a script.' She's constructing an identity the way an actor constructs a role — carefully, strategically, always aware of the audience. Lu Chengxuan, by contrast, refuses to perform. His 'No' to the love letter question isn't cruel — it's honest. He doesn't understand why anyone would ask him to play a game he's not interested in. The four people at his table share something rare: they've seen behind the performance and chosen to stay anyway. The recurring motif of vocal lessons with Aunt Lu also feels significant. Art as performance. Voice as projection. Shi Shi is literally training to perform, to perfect her craft of being seen. And yet Lu Chengxuan won't watch.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or