Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This book made me nervous for basically every chapter. Yan Hai'an dying, Sun Yan facing some huge enemy, the uncertainty of whether either of them would walk away whole. The external stakes were massive — death, danger, survival. But what kept me turning pages was the internal conflict: could these two guys actually let themselves be vulnerable with each other? That hospital scene where Sun Yan keeps seeing critical illness notices and his anger slowly fades? That's the moment the whole story pivots. He goes from fighting the world to fighting for someone else's life. The stakes stop being about winning and start being about not losing. And yet, the author never lets the tension drop completely. Even in the winery, with Yan Hai'an recovering and their days quiet, there's this undercurrent — what happens when the danger is over? Can they handle normal? Can they handle peace? The final answer, apparently, is yes. But it's earned. Every chapter of near-death, every confrontation, every sleepless night — it all leads to that balcony, where the real victory isn't surviving the enemy but deciding to stay alive together. Brilliant. Just brilliant.
... Read More
I need to talk about the car scene because the seating arrangement alone tells you everything about these three people's dynamics and I am HERE for it. Yan Hai'an literally tells Sun Yan to take the front passenger seat — that is a statement. A declaration. Sun Yan's internal monologue: 'Why should I be treated differently every time I confront Mo Yisheng?' YES. THE RELATIONSHIP GEOMETRY IS PAINFUL AND I LOVE IT. But then — and this is the genius part — Sun Yan says 'I'm going to sit in the back' and somehow ends up in the MIDDLE seat anyway. Three grown men cramming into the back row of a five-seater. The narrator notes 'the scene was terrible.' I needed to sit down. This is Yan Hai'an's priority system made physical. Front seat = guest / someone who needs space. Back seat = family = where Sun Yan belongs even when Sun Yan is mad. But Sun Yan can't help himself — he slides into the middle because of course he can't let Mo Yisheng have the window without a fight. And Mo Yisheng himself — 'I told my mother about this. She supports me very much.' That line hits different when you realize Yan Hai'an immediately thinks 'Of course a brain circuit like Li Weiwei will support you!' There's so much history between all of them compressed into these tiny observations. The mother-son dynamic, the complicated loyalty between Yan Hai'an and Sun Yan, the way Mo Yisheng keeps choosing to keep everyone at arm's length while simultaneously needing them all. Sun Yan promising to handle the media suppression is also wildly telling — he's performing caretaking through power moves, which is literally his love language at this point.
... Read More
The dialogue in this batch is sharp across the board, but Mo Yisheng absolutely stole the show. Let's just look at how he enters the scene: holding a palette, sitting on a wooden bench, tilting his head at Yan Hai'an like a curious bird, and asking with zero filter who he's been texting. His voice is completely distinct from everyone else. Where Sun Yan is all restraint and subtext, Mo Yisheng is curiosity without a shame center. And Yan Hai'an's response — deadpan, deflection, pivoting to gallery business like a man who has successfully avoided seventeen conversations in the last three minutes — is comedy gold. But it's Sun Yan's text messages that really showcase the author's gift for voice. Short. Punchy. Loaded. "You never seem to look back at me before." Every word is doing triple duty. And Yan Hai'an's reply matching that energy exactly — same structure, same accusation, same vulnerability disguised as teasing. That's not just good dialogue. That's two characters who've been writing each other's lines since chapter one.
... Read More
Let me just say this out loud: the first chapter establishes stakes without a single confrontation. That's craft. On the surface, the stakes are modest—a gallery opening, a painting sale, some social maneuvering. But dig deeper and there's a whole ecosystem of power at play. Li Qing has built a network. Xu Ke has found a backdoor through Sun Yan. Sun Yan has influence and he's flexing it casually. Yan Hai‘an is the one who actually understands what's happening and feels the threat before anyone can name it. The conflict here isn't about fists or shouting—it's about who gets to define Mo Yisheng's worth. Is he just the artist behind a pretty painting? Is he Yan Hai‘an's partner who carried him through lean years? Is he Sun Yan's next fascination? Every glance, every word, every silence is a move on a board that only Yan Hai‘an seems to see clearly. And what are they gambling? For Yan Hai‘an, it's his friendship with Yisheng, their hard-won stability. For Yisheng, it might be his art, his innocence, his ability to stay “ignorant of the world”. For Sun Yan—honestly I don't know yet what he's risking, which makes him the most dangerous person in the room. The suspense isn't “will they or won't they”—it's “how much will this cost before it's over?” And I'm already invested enough to not look away.
... Read More
Okay, the dialogue in this chapter is doing SO much heavy lifting, and I need to talk about how distinct each character sounds. Sun Yan's lines are perfection. That opening — "Is this Yi Sheng?" — with the deliberate lowering of voice to create "a little bit of an ambiguous atmosphere"? The author doesn't even need to describe Sun Yan's tone; the dialogue ITSELF carries that creepy, entitled energy. And then the pivot to arrogance: "Who are you?" after Yan Hai'an identifies himself. It's such a power move, and it's delivered in just two words. The man barely says anything but dominates every conversation. Yan Hai'an's voice is equally distinctive — that calculated politeness masking pure irritation. "I don't understand what Mr. Sun is talking about" while internally wanting to rub the bridge of his nose. The gap between what he says and what he feels is where the humor and tension live. And his internal narration about Sun Yan being someone you "can't hide from" reads like genuine exhaustion, which makes him incredibly sympathetic. Mo Yisheng's dialogue is sparse but telling. "I don't want to socialise" — short, blunt, completely unapologetic. His line "People who can't get in touch with me will contact you anyway" is such a perfect character moment because it shows his social ineptitude AND his resigned acceptance of it. He's not trying to be difficult; he genuinely doesn't understand why this is a problem. The narrator's voice also deserves praise — it has this wry, observant quality that occasionally breaks the fourth wall slightly with commentary like "Becoming a nanny..." It's warm without being sentimental, and it gives the whole chapter this very specific tone that I immediately recognized and loved.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is genuinely sharp and I need to talk about how different these two voices are because it's one of the strongest elements of the writing. Mo Yisheng doesn't do subtlety. His lines are direct, often cruel, and always revealing. "I shouldn't have come to this party today. I already know what they're talking about" — that's not just complaint, that's a value judgment delivered casually. And then the real strike: "When you were with them, the way you laughed was too fake." You can't unbark that. It's a sentence that carries the weight of a whole philosophy about authenticity and betrayal. And he says it almost offhandedly, which makes it worse. Yan Hai'an's voice is almost entirely reactive, which is actually his defining characteristic. He explains, deflects, concedes. "Yisheng, you are too extreme. These are just for work." But the most telling line is probably his explanation to Mo Yisheng later: "I don't paint anymore, Yi Sheng. You know, I have no talent in this area. You are in charge of painting, I am in charge of socialising." This reads as practical on the surface but it's devastating when you realize what it means—he's essentially describing his own artistic death as a business arrangement. That's not dialogue, that's a elegy. Li Qing's voice is distinct too, though she operates on a completely different frequency. She's polished, strategic, almost unnervingly composed. Her line about Mo Yisheng—"He's still young in the end and hasn't experienced much"—is both genuinely affectionate and condescending in a way that makes you reconsider her entire character. Then she immediately pivots to holding Yan Hai'an's hand gracefully and saying "Let's go. Let's go up" with that philosophical flourish about paintings. She's the kind of character who delivers profound observations the way other people breathe. The narrator itself has a voice too—brief, literary, occasionally almost poetic in its spareness. Things like "the painter's eyes were still so spotless and clear" or the observation that Yan Hai'an's response carried the weight of someone who had already accepted defeat. These moments of narrative commentary elevate the dialogue without overwhelming it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Sun Yan because something about this chapter broke me open in a way I didn't expect. On the surface, Sun Yan is all casual dominance. He's the general manager, he's smoking in his car, he makes crude jokes about waiting half a month, he offers wine like it's nothing. He's performing this version of himself that doesn't need anyone. And Yan Hai'an plays along — or thinks he does. But then there's this moment. After sex, in the dark, Yan Hai'an wakes up and tries to move quietly so he doesn't wake Sun Yan. And Sun Yan, half-asleep, asks what time it is and then says "If you're exhausted, take a good rest, okay?" He rubs Yan Hai'an's head. Rubs it. Like you'd comfort a kid or a dog or something fragile. That gesture undoes everything Sun Yan built in the first half of this chapter. All that bravado, all that cool detachment, and then this small, unconscious act of tenderness that he probably doesn't even register as significant. And Yan Hai'an's reaction — "What's the matter with you? Do you want me to thank you?" — he deflects. He always deflects. But he doesn't pull away. He lets Sun Yan touch his hair. He stays. The underwear detail too — Sun Yan sitting on his underwear, not even realizing, and Yan Hai'an shoving it at him like "get up, you're sitting on my stuff." It's domestic. It's embarrassingly domestic. These two are pretending this is just physical and casual and improper on purpose, but their bodies are learning a different vocabulary. I keep thinking about who changes first. Who cracks? Because right now it feels like Sun Yan is the one holding the door open, and Yan Hai'an is the one slowly, reluctantly, stepping through.
... Read More
'You don't know how to knock first before you enter the door?' vs 'But strictly speaking, I pay for the room. So this is my territory.' this exchange is the entire relationship in two sentences. yan hai'an demands courtesy (respect, boundaries, social norms) and sun yan subverts it with transactional logic (ownership, money, power). neither of them is wrong, which is why it's so frustrating and so good. and then the whole 'pay me with your body' / 'i might castrate you' bit - that's not even flirting in the traditional sense, it's verbal sparring where the stakes are physical safety. yan hai'an's going for castration as a joke because it's the nuclear option of threats, and sun yan's response 'oh that's not what it looked like last night' turns the entire threat into something intimate and ridiculous. these two speak different languages and somehow that's exactly why they work. sun yan never uses more than three words when one would do, and yan hai'an never says what he actually means. the dialogue is basically two people circle-dancing around the same three truths: i was vulnerable last night, i want you to stay, i don't trust you
... Read More
I need to talk about the atmosphere in this chapter because the author does something really interesting with the setting. This farmhouse isn't just background—it's almost a character itself. The scene opens with Sun Yan and Mo Yisheng at the studio, but the real magic happens when they move to the farmhouse dinner. You can practically smell the food through the prose: "The richness of the farmhouse is placed in a large bowl... chicken meat is fresh... large pieces of local potatoes... shredded cabbage and a plate of kimchi." This isn't restaurant food—this is raw, ecological, unrefined and that's exactly what makes it work. It grounds the entire scene in something tangible and warm, which makes the underlying tension even more striking by contrast. Then there's the hot spring mention—which immediately shifts the atmosphere from cozy family dinner to something far more charged. Wu Ningshu's description of the hot spring as "a little small so at most, only two people can at a time" is doing SO much work here. Two people. At a time. The author doesn't even need to underline it. The hot spring becomes this confined, intimate space where Yan Hai'an's anxiety about Sun Yan "taking advantage" of Mo Yisheng literally boils over. And Sun Yan, lounging on a wooden bench with his legs bent like a hooligan, completely weaponizes the situation by suggesting they ALL go together. The farmhouse at night—with its darkening sky and the practical concern of a three-to-four-hour drive back to the city—adds this layer of forced proximity. They're stuck together. There's no escape. And Sun Yan, who originally planned to leave, decides to stay simply because "when he met Mo Yisheng, he changed his intention." The setting becomes a trap, and everyone knows it except Mo Yisheng, who heads off to the hot spring blissfully unaware.
... Read More
There are so many symbolic layers in this chapter that I could write an essay about them, but let me just highlight the ones that hit me hardest. The flowers are the first thing that comes to mind—not just as a gift, but as a symbol of Sun Yan's approach to connection. He gives them to the studio, not to Mo Yisheng personally. This is the theme of indirect pursuit running throughout the entire chapter. The flowers are beautiful, they suit Mo Yisheng well (as Sun Yan says), but they're also something that Yan Hai'an notes with this quiet bitterness—he remembers "the increasing number of flowers on the counter" and understands that Sun Yan is investing in someone else. Then there's the hot spring, which operates on multiple symbolic levels. It's a place of intimacy and vulnerability—naked, submerged, unable to escape each other's presence. But it's also small, confined, forcing proximity on those who might prefer distance. The hot spring represents everything Yan Hai'an is trying to control and Sun Yan is deliberately destabilizing. And Mo Yisheng, who mentions he's "a little allergic to pollen"—another layer! The very thing Sun Yan brought (flowers) is something Mo Yisheng can't fully enjoy, just as Sun Yan's attention may not fully land where it's aimed. But the image that haunts me most is Yan Hai'an described as a "stray dog guarding his last ration." That single metaphor contains the entire emotional architecture of this chapter. He's not a confident protector—he's a desperate one. He's not elegant in his love—he's feral, exhausted, holding onto something he's afraid will be taken. And Sun Yan, who feels "pity" for this image, is simultaneously the threat and the one being pitied. That paradox is where the story's deepest theme lives: love as both possession and vulnerability, and the terrible risk of making someone your only ration.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter is basically a landmine detonation wrapped in a friendship moment and I am still not over it. Yan Hai'an deciding to come out to Mo Yisheng feels like one of those moments where everything shifts and there's no going back, you know? The whole setup is genius because Mo Yisheng literally guesses 'at least it's a girl' and you can just feel the dramatic irony crushing him from the inside. And then Yan Hai'an drops 'Sun Yan and I are a couple' like it's the most casual thing ever but the narration makes it clear it is NOT casual for either of them. What really got me is Mo Yisheng's reaction arc in real time. He starts confused, thinks about Greek mythology, tries to be rational, then spirals into this little puppy energy where he's actually more hurt that they didn't tell him sooner than anything else. 'Why did you only tell me about this now?' — I literally gasped. He's not mad about the queerness, he's mad about being left out. And then Sun Yan immediately taking the shot saying 'I told him to tell you a long time ago' adds this whole layer of guilt and tension between the two friends that I wasn't expecting. Also the subplot thread with Liang Tian appearing as Sun Yan's new assistant is clearly setting up some kind of workplace friction. Su Yin and Liang Tian not speaking to each other? That's a wound waiting to open. I have so many questions.
... Read More
The way this author uses setting is actually insane and I don't think people give it enough credit. Let's start with the most obvious element: the bed. A double-story house that was originally a single story, rooms added on, furniture old and worn, the closet empty because nobody keeps clothes in the countryside. Every detail tells us about Yan Hai'an's life—his family sent money home before they could save for themselves, he hasn't stayed in this room in years, and now he's bringing his partner into a space that is physically inadequate for what they want to do. The bed squeaks. Not once. Not twice. *Squeak, squeak, squeak, squeak, squeak.* It becomes a running gag that's actually a metaphor for their entire situation—everything about this moment is too much, too loud, too exposed. Then you move outside to the courtyard: dim light, barely visible, a well, a big tree. It's pitch black. There's no privacy, no comfort, just nature being cruel with mosquitoes. And yet—the darkness also protects them. It's the only place they can be alone. The contrast between the claustrophobic interior (parents upstairs, walls thin, bed screaming betrayal) and the hostile exterior (mosquitoes, darkness, trees) creates this incredibly vivid sense of place. You can feel the humidity, hear the creaking wood, taste the blood on Sun Yan's arms. This isn't just backdrop—it's an active force shaping every decision they make.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or