Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
OK so Sun Yan's text messages are genuinely the highlight of this section. 'Isn't it rare for you to miss me? How often does it matter when I come back?' and then later: 'I can't help thinking about you all the time. Don't you think you're annoying me?!' The energy here is unhinged and I love it. He's an older man, presumably sophisticated, running a bank acquisition, and yet his texts read like someone who just turned twelve. There's this weird vulnerability underneath the annoyance — he's basically saying 'I miss you' through five layers of defensiveness. And Yan Hai'an's responses? Almost nothing. He sends one message and waits. The silence between his words is louder than Sun Yan's entire message chain. Then there's Su Yin, who calls over ten times in a few days. 'I can arrange the flight ticket and pick-up for you.' What a sweet, anxious person. And Li Qing 'cooling down' on them — these background characters add texture without taking focus. The dialogue overall feels unforced, especially the Yan Hai'an and Mo Yisheng interactions which have this comfortable shorthand of people who've lived together for years.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened in this chapter because my heart is actually hurting. That moment when Yan Hai'an leans over and kisses Sun Yan - the text describes it as 'a sudden fall from the sky' and 'the high you get when you reach the top.' But what got me wasn't the romance; it was the vulnerability. Two men in their thirties who carry themselves like they've survived everything, sitting in silence holding hands, trying to feel comfort through tension. The author writes: 'They were not speaking. They were trying desperately to feel the comfort wrapped in the tension from their clasped hands.' That right there - that's the emotional core of this entire relationship. It's not about grand declarations or dramatic confessions. It's about two damaged people finding safe harbor in each other's proximity. And then the goodbye scene! Neither moves. Five seconds of silence. Sun Yan coughing twice like a nervous teenager. The whole 'I'll see you off' back-and-forth that's really just code for 'I don't want you to leave.' Yan Hai'an cursing himself afterward that his IQ dropped by half? That's not anger - that's someone realizing they've been completely disarmed by the person they're arguing with. The emotional intelligence in this text is staggering. Every gesture, every pause, every unspoken thing carries more weight than actual dialogue would.
... Read More
This entire chapter is saturated with symbols of ownership and dependency, and I'm not sure the author realizes how heavy-handed she's being - which makes it all the more effective. The house represents commitment, domesticity, belonging. But it's also Sun Yan's brother's house, which adds this layer of trespassing - Yan Hai'an is already living in someone else's space, and now Sun Yan wants to move them into ANOTHER person's property? The symbolism of nesting is almost suffocating. The car is the bigger symbol, and it's brilliant in its complexity. A car represents freedom, movement, the ability to go wherever you choose. But Sun Yan is buying Yan Hai'an a car that he doesn't want, for reasons Sun Yan decided for him. It's a gift that functions as a leash. 'I'll buy an SUV and it's okay if the car hits and smashes things or people' - this line is dark comedy, but underneath it's Sun Yan's philosophy: if I give you something valuable enough, you won't leave. The car becomes a metaphor for the relationship itself: luxurious, powerful, but ultimately owned by the person with more money. The clothing and watches Sun Yan wants to buy add another layer - they're about presentation, about how the couple looks to the world. Sun Yan wants to dress Yan Hai'an in his wealth, to make him visible as his property. And Yan Hai'an's refusal? That's about invisibility, about not wanting to be paraded as someone's trophy. The cigarette moment when Sun Yan leans against the car door, smoking in silence - that's the chapter's most powerful image. It's vulnerability disguised as casualness, a moment where the mask slips and we see the man underneath who's willing to buy anything except the one thing he actually needs: genuine partnership.
... Read More
Oh my god. The description of Sun Yan's heart was like a match streaking across the box. The flashing light didn't even have time to illuminate anything, leaving only a little bit of hard-to-find and extremely uncertain revelation. That line hit me like a truck. Because that's exactly what this whole dynamic between Sun Yan and Yan Hai'an feels like — these tiny, almost accidental flashes of something real that barely register before they're gone. And then the cigarette scene. Yan Hai'an blocking the wind with his hand, making sure the cigarette wouldn't go out, handing it directly to Sun Yan's mouth. It's such a small gesture, but the intimacy of it? Chef's kiss. Yan Hai'an isn't even fully aware of what he's doing, right? He's just being practical. But Sun Yan notices. Sun Yan always notices. And the fact that Yan Hai'an had to consciously decide to come along — "how can he just go with him?" — shows how much internal work he's done. He used to be vigilant and disgusted. Now he's... unsure, but willing. That evolution is everything.
... Read More
This entire section is about healing, but not the kind that comes from dramatic justice or public apologies. It's about the quieter, messier kind — the kind where you walk into a room and realize the person who hurt you is just... small. Pathetic, even. And that realization is more healing than any revenge could ever be. The poem quote at the end is the thesis statement for everything: "At the end of the day, I stand in front of you. You will see my wounds and know that I have been wounded and healed." Yan Hai'an shows up at Feng Yiqing's door not as the wounded teenager but as someone who has already begun the process of healing — and in doing so, forces Feng Yiqing to see the wound he caused. The power dynamic flips not through force but through presence. The school itself is a powerful symbol. "There is only one high school time in one's life." It's a liminal space — not quite childhood, not quite adulthood, where identity is formed and sometimes shattered. Yan Hai'an returns to it as an adult, and the realization hits him: "Those intense emotions were just some teenagers' melancholy. There was nothing special to them." This isn't him dismissing his pain — it's him recognizing that his teenage self projected enormous significance onto a relationship that was never what he thought it was. The school was just a building. The teacher was just a flawed man. The trauma was real but the mythology around it was his own. Another recurring motif: walking. Yan Hai'an walks through the empty corridors, walks past Feng Yiqing without stopping, walks down the avenue of trees, walks toward the school gate, walks back to the car. Each step is a deliberate movement away from the past. The act of walking itself becomes the ritual of release. And Sun Yan waiting in the car — that's the symbol of the present. While Yan Hai'an walks through the past, Sun Yan represents the life he's built, the relationship that doesn't ask for explanations, the person who shows up without being asked. The driver who becomes the destination. "I'm going to go and be myself again." — self as something that was lost and needs to be reclaimed. Not invented, not discovered, but RECLAIMED. Something that existed before the betrayal and deserves to exist after it.
... Read More
Every time I think about these chapters, I keep coming back to three images: the hot spring, the collapsing fence, and the discarded paintings. They feel connected to me, like they're all talking about the same thing without saying it out loud. The hot spring itself is interesting — it's shallow, only reaches to the chest normally, and Yan Hai'an has to sit further back to submerge his shoulders. It's a natural pool, dug by whoever lives here, covered partially by a fence that's already falling apart. This is a space that's meant for warmth and relaxation but is already structurally unsound. And then Sun Yan walks in and DESTROYS the remaining barrier. The fence collapses. The water ripples. Everything Yan Hai'an had carefully arranged shifts. The paintings throw away by classmates — these represent everything Mo Yisheng values that other people don't see. His art, his sensitivity, his worth. Yan Hai'an picks them up. He preserves what the world discards. That's basically his entire role in this story, isn't it? And there's this line about Yan Hai'an: "He has to find something to think over and over in order to occupy his mind. Only by supervising himself all the time can he be who he is now." This is the thematic key, I think. Yan Hai'an's entire existence is built on constant vigilance — monitoring Mo Yisheng's schedule, watching Sun Yan's room, calculating risks, preventing disasters before they happen. He's holding himself together through self-surveillance, and the hot spring is the one place where he allows himself to stop. Of course that's exactly when everything falls apart.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how Sun Yan's personality shifts when he gets serious? Because this chapter had me screaming internally. One second he's this effortlessly cool guy cracking jokes about checking schedules, and the next he's leaning his forehead against the steering wheel and asking Yan Hai'an to see him more than twice a week. That right there is a man who doesn't know how to ask for what he wants but also can't hide it anymore. And Yan Hai'an — oh, Yan Hai'an. The way he thanks Sun Yan for keeping that painting all this time, like it's this monumental revelation. I actually had to pause because it hit so hard. He's admitted to giving up painting, admitted he has no talent, and yet the fact that someone *kept* his work matters more to him than any gallery ever could. That's character depth right there. Their dynamic is everything. Two people who understand each other beyond words, but neither will say what they actually mean. When Sun Yan says he wants to thank Yan Hai'an too and then just… doesn't explain why, but Yan Hai'an knows? That's not just romance. That's a whole other level of intimacy built on years of history neither of them is ready to name out loud.
... Read More
so Yan Hai'an is basically a feral cat in this chapter and i am HERE for it. he gets drugged, wakes up next to sun yan, and his immediate response is to threaten violence and smash his phone against the wall. no soft morning after, just pure hostility. but here's the thing - sun yan doesn't even flinch. he just watches this angry little thing throw a tantrum and thinks it's cute. the power dynamic is so interesting because on paper yan hai'an is the one who should be in control (he's the one being harassed), but sun yan physically blocks the door and yan hai'an literally can't leave until he negotiates. that's not dominance, that's patience. sun yan is playing the long game and yan hai'an doesn't even realize it yet. the moment where sun yan admits he feels like touching yan hai'an's face but can't stop himself? that's the part that got me. it's not even sexual in a crude way - it's this hungry, almost desperate need to be close to someone who actively hates him. and yan hai'an calling sun yan out on li qing's manipulation while simultaneously being grateful that li qing set them up? that's such a messy, human contradiction. who is he actually mad at right now, li xi or sun yan or himself
... Read More
The stakes here are SO simple and SO enormous at the same time. Two guys trapped under a collapsed building, one bleeding out, and the tension isn't about whether the plot will resolve — it's about whether one of them breathes again. That's it. And yet the author makes every second feel like an eternity. What's brilliant about the conflict layering is how it works on three levels simultaneously. External: the building could collapse further, rescuers haven't arrived, Yan Hai'an is losing blood. Internal: Sun Yan's terror masquerading as anger, his fear of losing someone he already lost his parents to. Interpersonal: the raw, ugly, desperate conversation between two people who clearly care deeply but might not have said the right things until now. And the aftershock! Just when you think they're stable, another rumble, another panel pressing down harder. Yan Hai'an's chest pain — 'the strike was probably at the position of the lungs.' He's having trouble breathing and still thinks about leaning to the side so he doesn't crush Sun Yan. The stakes keep escalating with every paragraph, and the author never lets you breathe either.
... Read More
"Those who have no temper are only the dead." Yan Hai'an says this line with a forced smile and I swear to god I laughed out loud because it is SO him. This man walks around with a permanent mask and every word he speaks is calibrated two inches below the surface. But Sun Yan? Sun Yan operates on a different frequency entirely. Watch how Sun Yan handles the goose incident. He doesn't just protect Yan Hai'an — he does it while simultaneously humiliating the situation. Kicks the goose. Gets his expensive trousers destroyed. Loses his sunglasses. And then asks Wu Ningshu if she has anything to eat, completely refusing to acknowledge the destruction he just endured. This isn't kindness. This is performance. Sun Yan is curating his own image in real time, and Yan Hai'an is watching every frame of it. The sunglasses detail haunted me. Yan Hai'an bends down to pick them up — lenses broken, frames snapped. Who does that? Who physically shields someone and still ends up with destroyed property? And Sun Yan's response? "Go and get me a new set of clothes." Like it's nothing. Like Yan Hai'an's gratitude is a transaction he's already settled. But here's what gets me: Yan Hai'an still says thank you. Not because he's grateful — I think he says it because he doesn't know what else to say when someone protects him in public but threatens him in private. "Don't get in my way or I won't take it slow." Said leisurely. Said with indifference. The threat wrapped in a yawn is the most dangerous kind. And then Mo Yisheng. Sweet naive Mo Yisheng, who suns up to Sun Yan like a flower chasing light, while Yan Hai'an watches from the kitchen wondering why his friend is so easily charmed. Mo Yisheng's allergy to flowers is literally mentioned in the same breath as Sun Yan's gift of flowers. Symbolism so厚 it hurts.
... Read More
Okay so here's what's actually happening in this chunk and I'm gonna try not to spiral. Yan Hai'an calls Sun Yan after building up "psychological construction" — like, actual prep. This isn't just a casual call. He has to steel himself before picking up the phone. And Sun Yan's first line? "Hello? Finally, remember to call me?" Not needy, not desperate — casual, almost teasing, but underneath it there's this undercurrent of "I was waiting." The power dynamic is already weird because on paper Sun Yan is the busy GM and Yan Hai'an is the one reaching out, but we already know that's a performance. Then Yan Hai'an says he's going back to City B and Sun Yan immediately offers to pick him up. Not "okay cool" but "what time, I'll come." That's the thing about this plot — it keeps giving us moments where the characters act like they have full control, and then one sentence dismantles all of it. The airport scene is perfect. Sun Yan waiting with cigarettes, lying about how long he's been there. The smell of smoke, the car, the casual toss of a cigarette toward Yan Hai'an like he's offering a peace treaty. And then Yan Hai'an falls asleep in the car and wakes up in Sun Yan's garage. Forty minutes. Forty minutes of sleeping beside someone who clearly wanted him close enough to drive him home instead of just texting. And then the dinner, the wine from France, the unspoken agreement about physical intimacy — and then the morning after, ending on this suspended note. Sun Yan asking if he's feeling better, the blanket slipping, the underwear incident. It ends mid-thought, mid-action. Sun Yan gets out of bed and... what? The chapter cuts off right when something shifts. This plot doesn't explode. It accumulates. Every scene adds weight to things that haven't been said yet. And that ending? It's not a cliffhanger in the traditional sense — it's more like holding your breath.
... Read More
Let me just say — picking Shelley's 'Love's Philosophy' for the final chapter is not an accident. The poem is literally about how everything in nature connects, how it's natural law that things mingle and kiss and clasp each other. 'The sunlight clasps the earth, and the moonbeams kiss the sea. What is all this sweet work worth, if thou kiss not me?' Yan Hai'an recites this to Sun Yan on their balcony, under the moon, with wine in hand. Of course he does. The whole novel has been building toward this acknowledgment — that their connection isn't accidental, isn't something to be ashamed of or overthought. It's inevitable. Natural law. The moon itself is a recurring presence. 'Blessed by the moon for thousands of miles together.' The moon watches, the moon witnesses, the moon is gentle and complete — just like their resolution. It's not perfect, but it's whole. I also can't ignore how the author frames their beginning as lust and their ending as something deeper without ever dismissing the physical. Their bodies brought them together, yes, but their souls decided to stay. That duality — that the physical and the emotional aren't separate but intertwined — runs through the entire book. The poem isn't just decoration. It's the thesis statement.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or