Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay can we talk about Yan Hai'an for a sec because this guy is doing SO MUCH emotional labor and nobody is acknowledging it. He's literally carrying Sun Yan's lunch box off the floor, offering him water like a damn butler, then standing around awkwardly on the edge of the sofa like he's afraid of touching anything. Meanwhile Sun Yan is just… there. Existing. Being infuriatingly comfortable in someone else's space like he owns it. And the worst part? Yan Hai'an is genuinely concerned about Mo Yisheng throughout all of this. He's worried Sun Yan is going to bother him while he's painting. He makes up excuses for Sun Yan's weird behavior ('probably feels sorry for disturbing you'). He goes to a bar alone afterward because he has 'no one to talk to' about how unsettled he feels. That's not just a friend. That's someone deeply entangled and refusing to admit it. Then Li Xi shows up at the bar and immediately knows Yan Hai'an is unhappy. Of course he does. These guys have history and it's written all over Yan Hai'an's face. I just want to shake him and say 'you're allowed to be angry at him'
... Read More
Okay so this chapter starts with Yan Hai'an at a bar with Li Xi and honestly the whole setup is basically the author trolling us. Li Xi is out here laying it on thick trying to flirt, saying things like 'we both have the same preference' like it's some big bonding moment, and Yan Hai'an is just... sitting there. The fact that the narrative explicitly tells us Yan Hai'an 'wanted to go through with it many times' but then immediately undercuts it with 'Sometimes it's just too hard to be alone' — that's not a character making a choice, that's a character whose loneliness is louder than his pride. And then the kicker: he leaves because he needs to get back to Mo Yisheng. Not because he's morally opposed to Li Xi, not because he's disgusted, but because he literally doesn't want to leave Mo Yisheng alone. The plot doesn't even need a big dramatic moment here. One sentence — 'Yan Hai'an didn't dare to leave Mo Yisheng alone for too long' — and suddenly all the tension in every previous chapter clicks into place. Also the bit where he's standing outside looking up at all those lit windows and thinking 'In the lights of ten thousand houses, which one is lit for me?' is such a beautifully awkward moment of vulnerability that he immediately dismisses as 'hypocritical.' He knows exactly which house matters to him. The structure of this chapter basically takes us from external social maneuvering (the gallery dinner) to internal reckoning, and it works.
... Read More
'I am sorry.' Three words. That's all it took. Sun Yan, the man who walked in here yelling and shoving and treating Yan Hai'an like a piece of furniture he could drag around, just... apologized. And not in some grand dramatic way either. He just stops massaging the wrist, looks at the person he's been tormenting and yearning for simultaneously, and says it like his voice cracked on the way out. Then he kisses the wound. Like, literally kisses the place where his own animalistic behavior left marks. I am not okay. The scene with Mo Yisheng haunts me in this context—Yan Hai'an taking care of someone 'like a child,' appreciating them 'like a masterpiece,' building a love entirely free of desire because he was terrified of being hurt. And then Sun Yan comes along and destroys that entire architecture with a single gesture. The way the narration describes it—'the frequency of his heart beating' against his palm—that's the most physically intimate sentence I've read in months and I'm shook. This CP chemistry isn't built on banter or sexual tension alone; it's built on the terrifying realization that someone sees you, really sees you, and chooses to be gentle anyway.
... Read More
I need to talk about the atmosphere in these chapters because wow. The author doesn't just describe a street race — they make you feel the heat of the engine, the thickness of the darkness beyond the headlights, the way your hair stands up on your neck when tires screech. There's a line that literally gave me chills: 'The darkness beyond that was too thick to disperse at every turn. It seems as if they are about to be thrown out beyond the horizon off the cliff.' That's not set dressing. That's a mood. The underground racing scene is painted with enough sensory detail to exist on its own. The fork in the road. People standing and sitting around. Cars parked haphazardly. Engine noises replacing birds. The girl in high heels walking between two idling sports cars like she's on a runway. It feels lived-in, not researched. You can tell the author either knows this world or has spent serious time imagining it convincingly. And then the car interior after — 'The dimly lit car was filled with the two men's deep breathing and occasional panting. Even if the seat was put down, the space was still cramped.' Same setting, completely transformed. The car goes from a death machine to an intimate cocoon in one paragraph. That kind of spatial recontextualization is exactly what good atmosphere does. It doesn't just surround the characters; it reacts to them.
... Read More
This chapter made me feel things I didn't expect. Not the sex scene — don't get me wrong, the frequency shift from once a week to four or five times had me taking notes — but something quieter and somehow more devastating. Yan Hai'an looking back at Sun Yan's car and texting him: "You never seem to look back at me before." And Sun Yan's reply: "You never seem to have waited for me before." That exchange alone could be a thesis statement for their entire relationship. They're both watching each other leave. They've always been watching each other leave. And yet here they are, building something real in the space between departures. The most emotional moment though? When Yan Hai'an thinks about how even if he'd given that painting to the person he originally wanted, they probably wouldn't have cherished it the way Sun Yan did. That's not jealousy. That's grief dressed up as gratitude. He's thanking Sun Yan for something that was never meant for him, and loving him for it anyway. I'm not crying, you're crying.
... Read More
This batch of chapters operates on two different frequencies and honestly the author knows exactly when to push each one. The first section—the exhibition dinner planning—has this slow-burn social energy where nothing explosive happens but you feel the pressure building under every polite exchange. Li Qing is all grand visions and carefully managed relationships, Mo Yisheng is sitting there visibly deteriorating from the artificiality, and Yan Hai'an is translating everything in real time. The chapter ends on that quiet cliffhanger of Mo Yisheng storming out, which is perfectly calibrated. Not a dramatic exit, just a frustrated dismissal, but it lands because we've been watching the tension accumulate all along. Then the author does something really smart by cutting to the bar scene. It's a complete tonal shift—small, intimate, nocturnal. Yan Hai'an alone with his wine, observing Li Xi's patience. This section moves slower, almost deliberately meandering, giving the reader room to breathe after the dinner scene's social claustrophobia. It's not filler. It's essential character work that reframes everything we just saw. And then—bam—the road trip. The jarring transition from an indoor social event to a bumpy country drive is almost funny in how physical it becomes. The author wastes no time here. Wrong turns, ditches, ducks on the road, starvation-level hunger. It's kinetic energy after the simmering tension. When Li Qing appears at the end in her grey sports suit and minty green sunglasses, waving at them from a residential doorway, it feels like a scene transition that opens a completely new chapter of the relationship between these three. I also want to call out the translator's note as part of the reading experience itself. The aside about Sun Yan not appearing and the translator hating business talk—it's oddly effective at making you feel like you're being guided through the text by someone who actually cares about the emotional beats over the plot mechanics. It's a weird structural choice but it works.
... Read More
The opening of this passage is essentially a cold splash of water — someone lights a painting on fire and the chapter starts mid-crisis. No context, no setup, just thick black smoke and someone yelling. Then we pull back to learn that Yan Hai'an 'heard that Mo Yisheng was in trouble before his jet lag was even down.' That single line does so much work — it tells us the distance between them, the urgency, the fact that Yan Hai'an's life is structured around being available for Mo Yisheng. The pacing then shifts gears completely. We go from emergency mode to the bureaucratic calm of the police station — lawyers, phone calls, the Sun family name doing its thing. This deliberate slowdown gives the reader a breath before the emotional beat drops: Mo Yisheng smiling calmly while Yan Hai'an is internally spiraling. Then in the car, the pace slows even more into something almost meditative. Mo Yisheng's confession about burning the painting comes almost casually, like he's sharing something small. But it carries the weight of the entire preceding chaos. The author trusts the reader to connect the dots between the dramatic fire and the quiet justification. The final section picks up speed again with the packing, the mother reveal, and Sun Yan's call to his brother. Each beat propels us forward but never lets us settle. The transition from 'let's go eat' to 'he's leaving' to 'the circle will know' creates a staircase of escalating tension that never plateaus. And that ending — Sun Yan asking 'Have you made up your mind' about finding his mother, cut off mid-thought. Perfect. No resolution, just the sound of someone about to walk away.
... Read More
This chapter is thick with symbolism, mostly revolving around the idea of the 'unpresent presence.' The entire family prepares for a daughter-in-law who never arrives. The table is set for five, six, maybe seven people, but one chair remains symbolically empty. This empty chair represents every secret Yan Hai'an has kept, every version of himself he has hidden to fit into this family's expectations. The food itself is symbolic—traditional, abundant, overwhelming. It's the love language of his mother, but it's also a trap. To accept it is to accept the lie. Sun Yan's role evolves throughout the scene from 'friend' to 'godson,' which is a profound symbolic shift. He is being integrated into the family structure, but on Yan Hai'an's terms, safely tucked away in a category that doesn't threaten the heteronormative narrative the family clings to. And the wine—brought by Sun Yan from his collection, praised by the father—represents the blending of their worlds. It's sophisticated, expensive, yet it flows freely at a rustic country table. The ultimate symbol, though, is the bed. The double bed in the tiny room forces a physical intimacy that contradicts the social distance they must maintain upstairs. It's a cage and a sanctuary all at once.
... Read More
There's this one detail that I cannot stop thinking about: 'the heat was like a substance that pressed against his face with a kind of heavy pressure.' The author doesn't just describe the light—they make it weight, texture, an almost suffocating presence in that tiny room. And it works because the room itself is so aggressively ordinary. No paintings. No personality. A desk facing the window, a notebook, some sundries, a bookshelf that says 'minimalist by circumstance not by choice.' This is someone's temporary life, not a curated space. But then Sun Yan moves through it like he owns the air in it, criticizing the layout one second and then performing this tender ritual with ointment the next. The contrast between the bleakness of the setting and the intensity of what's happening inside it is chef's kiss. Even Wu Fang's voice muffled behind the door—a peripheral character providing background noise—makes the scene feel lived-in, like we're eavesdropping on a private moment that could be happening in any apartment in any city. It's not a palace or a dramatic landscape; it's somewhere real, which makes everything hit harder.
... Read More
I need to talk about Yan Hai‘an because THIS character. He's the one holding the umbrella while everyone else is getting wet and he's just... aware. From the very first page he's reading the room, assessing people, making mental notes. When Sun Yan's gaze sweeps past him like he's an object, Yan Hai‘an feels it immediately. The text says he felt “upset for a moment” and I bet that understates it by a mile. His relationship with Mo Yisheng is the anchor of everything so far. Two guys who survived the grind together, opened a studio, kept each other afloat. Yan Hai‘an handles the business side while Yisheng paints. There's this deep loyalty in how he protects Yisheng—when he sees Sun Yan approaching, his immediate thought isn't “oh cool, a fan” it's “this person will only bring trouble and I won't let him near Yisheng.” That's not just friendship, that's something deeper that the book hasn't named yet but is clearly building toward. And Sun Yan! The man who's supposedly a playboy, casually drops “I want this painting” like he owns the place, calls Mo Yisheng “beautiful” without a hint of irony, and completely disregards everyone else in the room. But here's the thing—he's also self-aware enough to call himself an “unemployed vagabond” when introduced. That's either deflection or genuine humility masked as self-deprecation, and I can't tell which yet. The triangle (or whatever this is becoming) is already electric just from glances and silence. Yan Hai‘an watching Sun Yan look at Mo Yisheng—that image is going to haunt me.
... Read More
the sensory shift in this chapter is honestly remarkable. you go from the violent crack of a phone hitting a wall - full of adrenaline, sweat, confusion - to an almost meditative silence as yan hai'an sits in a private restaurant eating spicy fish. that transition IS the chapter. and the restaurant detail? only four tables per night, no menu, owner decides the price. this isn't just setting, it's character revelation. sun yan doesn't take someone to a normal place. he takes them to a place where the rules don't apply, where you sit in silence and eat whatever the chef feels like making. it mirrors their whole relationship - unstructured, unpredictable, dominated by someone else's whims until they negotiate their way to something real. the boiling fish pot is such a perfect image too. hot, bubbling, dangerous if you lean in too close, but comforting in its own way. yan hai'an staring into it like it might give him answers about last night while sun yan watches him watch it? chef's kiss
... Read More
The setting in these chapters feels incredibly tactile and alive. We start on a slope—that immediate physical ascent mirrors Yan Hai'an's emotional journey back into his past. The welcome is a sensory overload: the sound of the car, the swarm of family members (men, women, children), the heat of Lu Suju clinging to the window. It's vibrant, noisy, and deeply rural. Then we move to the dining table, which the author paints with lavish, almost grotesque detail: 'full of chicken, duck, fish, pigs, wild fish, and pheasants.' This isn't just a meal; it's a display of parental love and desperation, a feast prepared for a ghost (the nonexistent girlfriend). The lighting shifts too—from the bright, exposed daytime arrival to the dark, intimate dinner, and finally to the small, cramped bedroom upstairs. That bedroom description is key: 'the bed is a double bed and it takes up more than half of the space.' It's claustrophobic, forcing proximity. The world-building here isn't about magic systems or tech; it's about the geography of shame and desire. Every location acts as a pressure cooker, literally and figuratively squeezing the characters closer together until something has to give.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or