Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying—I replayed the daisy scene in my head for like ten minutes after reading it. You know those moments in books where something tiny becomes this huge emotional anchor? That's what happened here. Yan Hai'an looks at this bunch of plain daisies, wrapped in kraft paper, and instead of throwing them out like he probably should have, he says 'No need. Put it in a vase.' He specifically asks for the green one—the thick glass vase. And then he crumples the cards and tosses them. Just like that. The detail that got me: 'It lost to the delicate beauty of those bouquets before, but it had a new kind of lively and lovely look.' He's talking about flowers but... isn't he? There's something so deliberate about him choosing to keep the humble thing over the flashy thing. And then when he returns almost a week later and sees the flowers wilting—that's the part that wrecked me. 'No matter how well-cared for the flowers, the flowers will still wither away.' He says he'll buy another bunch because 'he was used to seeing flowers here before.' Not because the current ones matter. But because the absence would bother him. Also: Li Qing's tea house scene? A small yard, a view of a small bridge and flowing water underneath, beauties in ancient costumes playing the zither among shadowy plants. 'The artistic conception and forceful style are very suitable for Li Qing's needs.' I could literally see this. This feels like a film set. Every frame. The contrast between the daisy vase at the front desk and the opulent tea room with zither players—it's like the book is showing you two different worlds coexisting, and you just have to decide which one Yan Hai'an actually belongs to.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters are terrifying precisely because nothing explosive is happening on the surface. Everyone is just... existing. Eating dinner. Going upstairs. Saying the same lines. And yet the tension is so thick you could cut it with a knife. Sun Yan's internal conflict is the main battlefield here. He knows he's interested in Yan Hai'an — "this interest is from the inside out" — but he also knows that going deeper means risking everything he has left. The cost-effective method. Sex friends. No more, no less. This is a man who has already lost everything once and is now building walls so high that even affection has to be transactional. The stakes aren't about whether he'll sleep with someone — they're about whether he'll let himself WANT someone, and that is infinitely more dangerous for a guy who's already a "dead dog." Sun Ling's conflict runs parallel and is equally agonizing. He's fighting a battle he can't win — trying to save his brother from himself while respecting boundaries he doesn't want to respect. "To actually have someone close to you, it's not such a horrible thing, isn't it?" He's begging. Not demanding. BEGGING. The stakes for Sun Ling are losing the last person he has in this world, and he knows it. Every conversation with Sun Yan is a tightrope walk where one wrong step and his brother retreats completely. And Yan Hai'an? He's the outside force disrupting both of these dynamics. He shows up, Sun Ling dismisses him as straight, Sun Yan tries to reduce him to a convenient arrangement, and yet that flower card at the end proves none of that simplification holds. The real conflict hasn't even started yet. It's just simmering. And I am NOT ready.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the painting. Not just because it's the object that brought these two together, but because it functions as the story's central metaphor for how we let people see us. Yan Hai'an gave up painting because he felt he lacked talent. But the real wound wasn't artistic failure — it was the belief that his work, his expression, his inner self, wouldn't be valued. And Sun Yan, of all people, held onto something Yan Hai'an had already abandoned. That's not just loyalty. That's devotion to the version of someone that even they've stopped believing in. There's a line that keeps echoing in my head: "There has always been a tacit understanding between the two of them that is beyond ordinary relationship." Beyond ordinary. That phrase does a lot of heavy lifting. It suggests their connection exists outside the categories we normally use — friends, lovers, acquaintances — and settles somewhere older and stranger. The painting survived. That matters. Because what it represents — Yan Hai'an's desire to be understood — survived too. And that, honestly, is the whole story.
... Read More
There's this one sequence that I keep coming back to and I can't pinpoint exactly why it works so well. Yan Hai'an is in Sun Yan's bathroom, bent over rinsing his mouth, and he looks up into the mirror and sees Sun Yan standing behind him. Men's skincare products on the shelf. A disposable toothbrush in his own hand. This domestic tableau of two guys who just slept together pretending like it's no big deal. The sensory details are so specific and grounded. The smell of porridge downstairs. The steam from the shower. The visual of Sun Yan smoking at the bathroom door. These aren't cinematic set pieces—the author isn't trying to make you see a movie. They're making you feel like you're accidentally walking in on someone's morning routine. That's harder to pull off and honestly more impressive. Then you cut to the airport waiting room and the world shrinks down to this one small detail: a phone screen, a blue sky at 8 o'clock, a single heart icon. The contrast between the physical space of Sun Yan's house (full of other people, family dynamics, Porridge, siblings) and Yan Hai'an's isolation in that waiting room is devastating. He's surrounded by 'people coming and going' and yet he's completely alone with this realization about Sun Yan. The five-city exhibition tour is mentioned in passing but it paints a whole picture—transient hotels, constant movement, Yan Hai'an carrying the emotional labor of logistics while Mo Yisheng chases inspiration. You understand this relationship dynamic without it ever being stated outright. The author builds worlds through atmosphere and detail rather than exposition. I always appreciate that.
... Read More
I am absolutely obsessed with how each character's voice is so distinctly different in this chapter, and the dialogue carries so much subtext that I keep having to reread lines to unpack them. Let's start with Sun Yan, whose voice is effortlessly provocative. When he says "Isn't it normal for guys to take a hot spring together? If I really want to do something, do you think you will be able to stop me?" — he's being deliberately obtuse, deliberately challenging, and he delivers it with this casual sarcasm that makes Yan Hai'an's teeth grind. And then he caps it off with "But after all, I'm a good person" like he's just made a harmless joke. The tonal whiplash is incredible. Yan Hai'an's voice is the complete opposite—formal, restrained, always using titles like "Mr. Sun" even when he's seething internally. His dialogue is almost painfully polite: "You can wait for a while. I have something to talk about with you later, okay?" and "We already said that we would chat." But the author gives us these brilliant internal asides that shatter the polite facade. Like: "He paused at every word, almost gritted his teeth." Or that gorgeous line I quoted earlier—"Who the hell wants to take a hot spring with this fellow?" — which is Yan Hai'an's internal monologue, and it's so vividly distinct from his external politeness that you feel like you're reading two characters in one body. Mo Yisheng's voice is sweet, natural, completely unguarded. "We talked about some misunderstandings... Is the meal ready? I can smell it. It smells good!" He has this childlike directness that makes him the perfect foil to everyone else's games. And that's what makes the dramatic irony work so well—he genuinely believes Sun Yan is "humorous, approachable, and did not have the bad habit of overwhelming others." The tragedy and comedy of that line is absolutely perfect.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say it—this chapter is a masterclass in indirect courtship and I am HERE for it. Sun Yan basically pulls off the most elaborate workaround in literary history. Instead of pursuing Yan Hai'an directly (which he apparently finds "boring" now that he's had a taste of something new), he strategically befriends Mo Yisheng. The flower-giving scene is pure genius. He doesn't give the flowers TO Mo Yisheng—he gives them to the STUDIO. Brilliant move. It's subtle enough that even Mo Yisheng's own brother can't immediately see the pattern, and yet it's calculated to position himself as a warm, caring figure in Mo Yisheng's orbit. And then the hot spring setup? Chef's kiss. Wu Ningshu mentions the small hot spring that can only fit two people at a time, and immediately you can see Yan Hai'an's eyes widening with panic. He tries to intervene, tries to monopolize Sun Yan, tries to control the narrative—and Sun Yan just sits back and watches him squirm like a cat playing with a very stiff, very upright mouse. The author writes: "Who the hell wants to take a hot spring with this fellow?" — and I literally laughed out loud. That's Yan Hai'an's internal monologue, and it's so painfully accurate. But here's what's really bothering me about the plot trajectory: Sun Yan's interest in Yan Hai'an is clearly waning. The text says his "interest never lasted long" and that he's "reached the limit." Yet somewhere beneath that, he still feels "pity" for Yan Hai'an's "stray dog" energy. That contradiction is WHERE the story lives. This isn't a clean break—it's a messy, complicated tug-of-war where Sun Yan is deliberately creating distance while Yan Hai'an is desperately trying to maintain proximity. And Mo Yisheng, sweet oblivious Mo Yisheng, just thinks they're all getting along beautifully. The dramatic irony is absolutely delicious.
... Read More
The whole sequence revolves around this act of destruction and I keep coming back to it — Mo Yisheng doesn't just ruin the painting, he makes sure it's VISIBLY destroyed. Thick black smoke, people shouting, the police involved. This isn't private grief. This is a man making sure the world WITNESSES his break from something. 'That painting is not pure, it has been stained. I don't want people to know that it is my painting.' This is the key sentence of the entire passage. The painting isn't just an object — it's proof of his existence in a world that he now finds contaminated. Burning it is both liberation and self-erasure. He's saying: if He Ling gets credit for my work, then my work was never mine to begin with. Better ash than compromise. And then the bigger symbol — Mo Yisheng packing to leave, going to find his mother. The journey motif. He's physically moving away from the art world, from Yan Hai'an's orbit, from everything that tied him to this particular version of his life. The story keeps asking: can you unmake yourself? Can you walk away from what made you? Sun Yan's entire arc in this passage is about using money and power to CONTROL the narrative — suppressing the news, trying to buy silence. But the irony is that Mo Yisheng's act of destruction was the one thing money literally cannot contain. Once that paint burned, the story changed regardless of what Sun Ling promises. There's also the recurring image of light and visibility — headlights illuminating Liang Tian's feet, the police station setting, the burning canvas itself. Everything in this passage is about who gets to SEE what, and who gets to decide what becomes public knowledge.
... Read More
The subplot with Yan Jin getting into a City B school is actually the most important plot thread in this entire batch and I'm still processing how elegantly it was handled. Here's what's fascinating: Yan Jin confronts Yan Hai'an directly. Then the scene cuts away. Then Su Yin reports to Sun Yan (not Yan Hai'an!) about what happened. Sun Yan does it himself without Yan Hai'an even knowing. When Yan Hai'an's brother calls to thank him, Yan Hai'an's first instinct is literally 'I didn't do it'—and then he catches Sun Yan on the sofa looking TIMID like a dog who just brought a dead bird to its owner. The reveal that Sun Yan handled it behind the scenes is both sweet and slightly unsettling. It shows how much power Sun Yan has AND how he operates independently of Yan Hai'an's knowledge. But then the scene pivots SO smoothly into domestic fluff on the sofa—playful wrestling, nicknames, the whole 'husband' bit—and you'd never guess there was any tension underneath. That's skilled writing. The plot thread comes in, gets resolved offscreen through Sun Yan's connections, and then we return to the main relationship dynamic without any awkward exposition dumps.
... Read More
I keep coming back to one image from these chapters: the car hurtling along a mountain road with a cliff at every turn, and neither of them slowing down. That's not just a cool scene. That's the entire relationship in miniature. These two are driving toward something they can't name, at full speed, on a road where one mistake means going over the edge. And the terrifying thing is — they're both okay with that. The title 'Improper Relationship' hangs over everything like a joke that isn't really a joke. Nothing about this connection follows the rules. They don't talk about it. They don't define it. They race, they fuck in cars, they wake up confused. It's improper in every sense — socially, emotionally, logistically. And yet it's the most honest thing either of them has experienced. Yan Hai'an's morning-after question — 'Why did I sleep with Sun Yan?' — is the thematic core of the whole book compressed into one line. It's not really about sex. It's about agency. About choice. About whether any of this was real or just adrenaline and circumstance. The fact that he can't answer it is the book's central question, and I'm not sure the author even knows the answer yet.
... Read More
Sun Yan spent a long time looking at the painting. Yan Hai'an wonders if he was looking at Mo Yisheng's ass. But what if he was looking at something else? What if the painting is the whole point — a physical object that carries the weight of desire, obsession, and the commodification of art and artists. The fact that Sun Yan keeps the painting in the guest room instead of the basement, despite it being worth far less than the auction pieces hanging in their actual art space, tells you everything about WHERE this man's attention actually is. It's not about monetary value. And Yan Hai'an's internal monologue about what comes AFTER Sun Yan loses interest in Mo Yisheng — 'they may not need to contact one another anymore' — that's the ghost of the entire theme haunting this chapter. The transactional nature of relationships in this world. Who uses whom. Who gets left holding the painting when the model moves on. Sun Yan asking Yan Hai'an if he has plans later, then immediately regretting the question, then walking him toward the door anyway — that's not just romantic tension. That's someone who has spent his whole life getting what he wants through money and power, discovering for the first time that some things require asking. And having no idea how to do that without making it awkward.
... Read More
"He looked down at Mo Yisheng, whose eyes were shining brightly, as if he was looking at a rare treasure. He couldn't help but gently touch Mo Yisheng's forehead: 'Go to sleep, don't play with your phone.'" I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay. This man — Yan Hai'an — has spent the entire chapter acting like he's just doing chores, being the responsible one, telling everyone when to sleep and what to eat. He calls himself a mother figure half-jokingly and Mo Yisheng calls it outright. But then the narration drops THIS little bomb: "But Yan Hai'an knew that several of Mo Yisheng's paintings were thrown away by his own classmates and he was the one who helped to pick them up but Mo Yisheng still doesn't know about this." ONE SENTENCE. One single sentence and my chest just — you know. He picked up Mo Yisheng's trash. Secretly. For years probably. And Mo Yisheng is over here saying stuff like "I'm still so sad when I think about those paintings" not knowing that someone was already on their knees gathering every last one, without asking for credit, without wanting recognition, without even wanting Mo Yisheng to feel indebted. That's not a friend. That's someone who loves them in the quietest, most self-effacing way possible. And then Yan Hai'an touches his forehead like a parent tucking in a child, and Mo Yisheng twitches in the blanket and says "I can't sleep" and Yan Hai'an just — stays. He doesn't leave. He sets an alarm to call at 9 AM. He turns off the light. He checks on Sun Yan's room like he's tracking the movements of some kind of volatile weather system. This man holds EVERYTHING together with invisible thread and nobody even notices until it's too late.
... Read More
I need to address the dialogue in these chapters because honestly the author has a real gift for making conversations feel lived-in rather than written. Take this exchange: "Don't go to bed too late tonight. Get up for breakfast tomorrow morning." Yan Hai'an asked him to quickly put on his coat, "Adjust your schedule. You can't keep the day and night upside down." "I know." Mo Yisheng muttered. "Why are you like a mother?" Yan Hai'an said helplessly, "Then cut me some slacks!" That last line. "Cut me some slacks" — it's colloquial, it's exasperated, it's the kind of thing a real person says when they're done playing caretaker but will absolutely keep doing it anyway. You can HEAR Yan Hai'an's voice in that sentence. And Mo Yisheng's response — just "I know" and then immediately pivoting to tease him — tells you everything about their dynamic. Mo Yisheng pushes because he knows Yan Hai'an won't actually leave. Then there's the Sun Yan confrontation, which is almost entirely non-verbal: Yan Hai'an: "…" Sun Yan: "…" Just ellipses. Two people sizing each other up across a hot spring, and the author communicates more tension with three dots than most writers do with three paragraphs. The silence between them is LOUD. And then Sun Yan, completely deadpan: "But I want to take a dip now. Should you get up first?" That's such a Sun Yan line — shameless, entitled, and delivered with the casual confidence of someone who genuinely believes the world should accommodate his desires. Meanwhile the narration has Yan Hai'an's internal monologue displayed as actual floating text in different fonts, which is such a creative narrative choice. It's like the author is letting us see Yan Hai'an's thoughts visually, almost like a comic panel, and I absolutely love it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or