Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The core conflict here isn't just “He Ling stole Mo Yisheng's painting.” It's about trust, ownership, and who gets credit. He Ling told Mo Yisheng: “You must help me.” Then offered him money. Then said “Give your painting to me. But the prize money belongs to you.” That's not partnership - that's exploitation dressed up as collaboration. And the stakes? For Mo Yisheng, it's his art, his voice, his career. For Yan Hai'an, it's guilt - “I should have looked after him.” For Sun Yan, it's watching someone he loves fall apart and having to be the steady hand. But what really terrifies me is Yan Hai'an's realization: “I doted on him so much that he doesn't know that people's hearts are sinister.” He protected Mo Yisheng from the world, and in doing so, made him vulnerable. That's a different kind of betrayal - not from He Ling, but from love itself. And the ending - “Mr. Sun, I can't find him.” Who is “him”? Mo Yisheng? Where is he? Is he safe? The stakes just went from “art theft” to “where is the person who created the art?” That's escalation you can't ignore.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are deceptively low-key until they suddenly aren't. On the surface, it's just one friend telling another friend he's gay. No explosions, no threats, no dramatic confrontations. But read between the lines and the tension is absolutely suffocating. Yan Hai'an isn't just coming out — he's risking his friendship with Mo Yisheng, and more importantly, he's risking the carefully constructed bubble around Mo Yisheng's life. 'Who knows what ghosts will come to grab him?' — this line hit me like a truck. Yan Hai'an has seen the darkness in this world and he's desperately trying to keep his best friend from encountering it. But by keeping secrets, is he actually the one creating the danger? Meanwhile, the Sun Yan subplot adds another layer of conflict. His family dynamics are clearly complicated (the mention of 'family affairs' at the very beginning), and Yan Hai'an is caught between loyalty to his friend and loyalty to his partner. When Sun Yan says 'I told him to tell you a long time ago,' there's guilt there — but also frustration. He's been waiting to be chosen, and this moment is his proof that Yan Hai'an finally chose him. But the real ticking bomb? Su Yin and Liang Tian. They don't speak to each other. They're assistants to the two central couples, and their silence screams. What happened between them? And what happens when that silence finally breaks?
... Read More
Okay, this scene. THIS scene. The author absolutely knows how to paint with words when it comes to atmosphere. Let me just quote this because it deserves to be preserved: 'Light grey smoke mixed with a soft mist of water curled up into the air.' That single sentence does so much. You can feel the heat, see the smoke, sense the humidity clinging to everything. The hot spring setting isn't just backdrop — it becomes a character itself. The warm water surrounding their bodies, the low stars, the silence, the dim light softening every outline into something hazy and dreamlike. Everything feels deliberate here. Sun Yan occupying most of the pool, stretching out like he owns the space. Yan Hai'an floating quietly, 'as if he was about to merge with the dark surrounding.' That image stayed with me for hours. It's cinematic in the best way — you can literally see this as a film scene, the way the camera would linger on water droplets sliding down a collarbone, the steam rising between two men who are circling each other carefully. The cold air meeting wet skin and creating goose bumps — these sensory details make the world feel alive and tactile. I felt the temperature shift just reading it.
... Read More
I need to talk about the flowers for a moment because this detail is destroying me. Mo Yisheng keeps the flowers Sun Yan sent him. Why? Because he's allergic to them. He can't put them in his studio. But he also can't bear to ruin their beauty, so he stores them somewhere. This is the most Yan Hai'an thing I have ever heard — hoarding beauty you can't touch, preserving something precisely because you're denied it. And Sun Yan sent them. Just flowers. With a perfunctory note bearing only the recipient's name. No sentiment, no elaboration — just the bare minimum of acknowledgment. Is this Sun Yan's love language? Show up, cause chaos, destroy your sunglasses protecting someone, and send them flowers you don't even bother to personalize? Yan Hai'an wanted to throw those flowers away. Wanted to. But the deal between them — that thin thread holding everything together — kept him from doing it. He keeps the flowers the same way he keeps his composure: barely, resentfully, and with enormous effort. Then there's the goose scene. Sun Yan shielding Yan Hai'an. Physical, instinctive, immediate. Not calculated. Not performed. Just body moving before mind catches up. And Yan Hai'an sees this — he notices Sun Yan's sunglasses fall and get stepped on, he sees the frustration carefully buried, he watches someone fight a goose for him and then act like it was nothing. "Now you know I'm a good person, right?" Sun Yan asks. And Yan Hai'an doesn't answer. He can't. Because Sun Yan IS both things at once — the good person who shielding him from a furious bird, and the person who would ruin him without hesitation if Yan Hai'an crosses him. That contradiction is the emotional core of everything between them. I keep thinking about what Yan Hai'an feels when Sun Yan says that line. Does he believe him? Does he want to? Does it matter?
... Read More
I have never wanted to punch someone through a screen so badly in my entire life. Li Xi. Let me just say it: LI XI IS A MONSTER and the worst part is that he KNOWS it and he doesn't even care. Let's break this down, because what he did is absolutely despicable. He's been playing this long con — being thoughtful, considerate, charming — all while secretly preparing to drug Yan Hai'an. And the reason?! Because Yan Hai'an keeps bringing up MO YISHENG. Every single conversation circles back to that artist. Li Xi can't compete, so he decides to just... take Yan Hai'an by force. 'I originally wanted to have a real relationship this time.' REAL. He wanted a REAL relationship. As if drugging someone gives you a relationship. The scene where he watches Yan Hai'an rush out to answer Mo Yisheng's call is devastating in its own way. His face darkens. He pulls at Yan Hai'an's arm. And Yan Hai'an just looks at him confused and goes. That's the cruelty of it — Yan Hai'an still trusts him enough to leave the phone call. He still thinks Li Xi is just being jealous, not plotting. And what about Yan Hai'an? Half of him knows Li Xi will eventually change his mind. 'A nail was nailed to the wall. And even if it was pulled out, it would always leave a dark hole there.' But the other half keeps telling himself to just let it go. Why?! Why keep going back to someone who makes you feel safe but isn't actually safe? I'm furious for him and frustrated with him simultaneously.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how Sun Yan completely flips the script in this batch? This guy has been nothing but domineering and aggressive from chapter one—grabbing people, shouting in dialect, treating everyone like they owe him something. And then here he is, asking 'Would you like to try it with me?' in this barely-whispered tone that's basically the emotional equivalent of him rolling over and showing his belly. I almost choked on my coffee. The wrist thing? That's not just physical contact, that's Sun Yan doing something genuinely vulnerable. He's not commanding, he's not ordering, he's literally pressing his face into someone's palm like a supplicant. And Yan Hai'an—brilliant writing how the narrator frames this realization: 'The fact that this person likes him.' Not 'loves,' not 'adores,' just this quiet, almost inconvenient truth landing on him like afternoon sunlight through a dirty window. Meanwhile Mo Yisheng exists in this story like a ghost of everything Yan Hai'an thought he wanted, and the author doesn't even need to put him in the scene to make his absence heavy. Just the mention of his name and the description of that spare bedroom—military-folded quilt, no art, no personality—tells you everything about what Yan Hai'an was settling for versus what he's getting now.
... Read More
I keep coming back to one image from these chapters: the mosquitoes feeding on Sun Yan's blood. On the surface it's comic relief—a wealthy city boy getting wrecked by country insects. But zoom out and it's loaded with meaning. Sun Yan is described as a 'rich man' whose blood the mosquitoes haven't tasted before. He's entering Yan Hai'an's world, literally being consumed by it, and he doesn't flinch. The mosquitoes represent everything about this environment that's hostile to him—the poverty, the discomfort, the lack of privilege—and yet he lies there and takes it. Meanwhile, Yan Hai'an's empty closet, the renovated-but-still-cramped house, the family eating early and sleeping early like country folk... all of it marks the distance between these two men's backgrounds. And what bridges that distance? Not grand gestures. Just a hand on a shoulder, a whispered 'let's go over there,' and waking up tangled together the next morning with mosquito bites all over your arms. The deeper theme here is about belonging. Yan Hai'an hasn't lived in this room in years. He sends money home. He's built a new life. But bringing Sun Yan here—into this squeaky, mosquito-filled, parent-supervised space—is an act of trust so radical it barely needs words. The story isn't asking us to romanticize poverty. It's asking us to see what love looks like when it refuses to wait for perfect conditions. The bed squeaks. The mosquitoes bite. They stay anyway.
... Read More
The opening image of this whole sequence is just *chef's kiss*. Yan Hai'an standing under the street light, that warm yellow glow outside the window reflecting something grim in his silhouette — it's such a small detail but it tells you everything about his headspace. He's literally caught between light and shadow, which is basically the entire metaphor of his situation compressed into one visual. And then you've got the car scenes. The first one is heavy, loaded with unsaid things, the kind of silence that screams. But then later, after the whole comeout conversation, there's this almost domestic shift where Sun Yan is touching Yan Hai'an's ear, teasing him, and the SUV becomes this weird liminal space — not quite public, not quite private. 'Facts have proved that SUVs are indeed more suitable for certain sports than ordinary sedans' — I literally laughed out loud at this line. It's so casually blunt and it completely breaks the tension after everything that just happened. The author knows exactly when to let the reader exhale. The office worldbuilding is subtler but I love how Yan Hai'an observes Su Yin and Liang Tian from a distance. Different vibes, different energies, clearly unresolved history between them. You don't need a thousand words of description — a few glances and the absence of speech tells you the whole story. The author trusts the reader.
... Read More
I have to talk about how this chapter handles plot progression because honestly, it's doing something really interesting. On the surface, nothing huge happens - they argue, there's a kiss, Sun Yan goes abroad, Yan Hai'an stalks his WeChat. But that's the point, isn't it? This story isn't about dramatic plot twists; it's about the space between moments. The way Sun Yan pulls Yan Hai'an back by the hand when he tries to leave - that's a plot beat that says everything without dialogue. And then the whole Su Yin thing? Genius. This assistant who knows exactly how to walk the line between professional and personal, who can read the room and adjust his tone accordingly. He's basically the Greek chorus of this relationship, observing from the sidelines while subtly enabling whatever mess these two are making. The S city trip setup is interesting too - sending them apart physically while the emotional connection intensifies. Classic move. Yan Hai'an reading those three weather posts from years ago and overthinking them? That's not filler, that's character-driven plot. The author understands that sometimes the most important story beats are the quiet ones where we see what people do when they think no one's watching.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is so casually perfect I almost didn't notice it until I went back and re-read everything. Let's start with the simplest exchange: Yan Hai'an says 'Just hold it back' and Sun Yan responds 'Aren't you unreasonable?' This is two people who have been together long enough that their bickering has the texture of affection. There's no performative romance here—just frustration and familiarity. Then there's Yan Hai'an's line 'You look like a pervert, you know?' said while Sun Yan is literally just looking around his childhood bedroom. It's sharp, it's teasing, it's exactly the kind of thing you say to someone you're comfortable with. But the dialogue gem of the chapter has to be: 'Who the hell are you calling a dog?' after Sun Yan mutters 'They're really like dogs' about the mosquitoes. Yan Hai'an catches it in his half-asleep state and throws it back like a knife. And Sun Yan just... stops. 'Sun Yan: ...' That ellipsis says everything. He can't even defend himself because he knows he's been got. The narrative voice also deserves mention—it's dry, observant, occasionally wry. The translator's note about 'cumming' being a smut chapter is peak internet romance fandom energy, and it matches the tone of the book perfectly. This isn't literary fiction trying to be profound; it's a story that knows what it is and doesn't apologize for it. The humor lands because it's earned through character, not inserted for Comic Relief.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the dialogue because honestly the narrator's interjections are giving me life. There's this one moment where Mo Yisheng says thank you and apologizes for the trouble, and Sun Yan blurts out 'It was for my boyfriend. You're welcome.' and the narrator just straight-up says 'Yan Hai'an wanted to grab a stick and beat him up. Is it funny to make such a middle school joke at such a time?!' I literally chugged water trying not to laugh out loud. That's not just narration — that's the author sitting right beside you like 'can you believe this clown?' And then later when Mo Yisheng says something genuinely vulnerable — 'I'm lucky that I met you first' — Yan Hai'an chokes on air. The narrator doesn't even try to dress it up, just says Yan Hai'an was 'not prepared for his sudden sensationalism.' Short, punchy, captures the exact energy of someone whose heart just did a backflip. The contrast between Sun Yan's chaotic loud energy and Mo Yisheng's quiet devastating one-liners is what makes the dialogue sing. Sun Yan says 'What's wrong?! This car is big and has five seats' with zero awareness that he's being dramatic. Meanwhile Mo Yisheng just drops 'That painting is not pure, it has been stained. I don't want people to know that it is my painting' like he's commenting on the weather. Different frequencies, same conversation. And Yan Hai'an in the middle, trying to translate between them both. Also can we appreciate how natural the Su Yin interactions feel? He's basically a prop for Sun Yan's anger at this point — 'Su Yin didn't dare to ask what to eat and started the car tremblingly.' You can feel the guy's entire soul leaving his body. No drama, just observational perfection.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Sun Yan because this character is fascinating. Here's this guy who just got into a physical fight, gets beaten up, and his first instinct is to worry about whether HE hurt someone else's hand. That's not just care - that's a fundamental way of relating to the world. And Yan Hai'an? He's all表面 tough with his mouth cannon threats, but then he Initiates a kiss - literally the first time he's ever taken the initiative with Sun Yan. The text says it was 'without a trace of lust' but honestly? That made it hit harder. It wasn't about sex or physical desire in that moment; it was about connection. And Sun Yan's response - biting his palm half annoyed half fond? That's so them. Two thirty-something men who've seen through life, sitting in a car holding hands like high schoolers, neither willing to be the first to let go. The power dynamic here is constantly shifting. Sun Yan drives the car but Yan Hai'an drives the emotional conversation. They bicker about who leaves first, who sees whom off, and it's the most painfully relatable couple behavior ever. I love how the narrator has Yan Hai'an think Sun Yan is 'clingy' while simultaneously being the one who initiated physical contact. These men don't know how to want each other directly and it's absolutely killing me.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or