Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so the pacing in these chapters is genuinely masterful and I need to unpack why. We open with the aftermath of the painting restoration — a quiet, almost meditative moment between Yan Hai'an and Sun Yan. No urgency. Just two guys sitting in a car, figuring out what the hell they're doing. Then it cuts to the terrace sex recollection, which gives us the physical escalation, the heat, the comedy of Yan Hai'an wondering if Sun Yan is secretly taking performance drugs. Very funny, very tonally balanced. And then — bam — we pivot into Mo Yisheng's storyline with the competition and Li Qing and gallery politics. In a regular novel, this would feel jarring. But here it works because Yan Hai'an's voice carries it. He goes from flustered lover to protective manager in half a paragraph, and that shift itself tells us everything about who he is. The chapter ends on an almost comedic note with Yan Hai'an worrying Mo Yisheng will be damaged by lesser artists. It's a deflation after all that emotional weight, but it's the right kind. The story knows when to breathe.
... Read More
The author really understands how to paint a room with words, honestly. That studio description on the second floor is one of my favorite set pieces I've read in a while. Semi-industrial design, exposed ceiling, white walls, floor-to-ceiling windows on the south side — it's got this specific light quality that feels almost photographically precise. And the three-seater sofa placed in what the narrator explicitly calls a "strange position" but admits works perfectly when you sit there? That's such a small detail but it makes the whole space feel *lived in*, not just described. I also love the contrast between the bright, empty studio space and the darker undertones of what's happening. The piano music playing softly, the sunlight moving across the floor indicating the passage of time, the large square table covered in scratch paper — all of these create this very specific atmosphere of creative work happening in real time. You can practically smell the turpentine and see the dust motes in the light. The downstairs front desk area with the young girls working there adds another layer to the worldbuilding. This isn't just a fancy art gallery — it's a working studio, a crash course type place where fine arts students come for part-time work. The social hierarchy is clear: the little sisters downstairs handling visitors, Yan Hai'an managing operations, Mo Yisheng upstairs in his own world. Every character has their spatial place in this environment, and it just feels so grounded and real. Every time I read these descriptions, I think about how film productions would kill for this kind of clear visual worldbuilding.
... Read More
Okay can we talk about how devastating yet beautiful it is to watch Mo Yisheng finally choose himself? Like. He packs his suitcase. He says he already bought the plane ticket. That's not impulse—that's someone who has been mentally preparing for this moment for chapters, maybe arcs. And his line about not caring what other people think and not mixing in the circles anymore? Oof. That's him cutting the cord. That's him saying I am done letting this world redefine who I am. And the way Yan Hai'an reacts—frowning, asking if he'll still paint—it's so casual but it carries so much weight. Of course he's worried about the painting. But underneath that, isn't he really worried about losing the person who shared that world with him? The fact that he's relieved just because Mo Yisheng isn't giving up oil painting? That's love language, coded. Then Sun Yan slides in—"It's your first time traveling alone. I'll find someone to assist you." Protectiveness dripping off every word. But then Mo Yisheng says "I want to go alone" and BOTH of them just... pause? Yan Hai'an can't even define what he feels. That silence between them says everything. And don't get me started on Sun Yan asking "Do you think the child has grown up?" with that interesting smile. He knows. He absolutely knows what's happening and he's letting Yan Hai'an sit with it. This triad dynamic is cooked. Absolutely cooked.
... Read More
Okay, this scene hits different when you really sit with it. On the surface it's just two guys who had sex one night and then do breakfast banter the next morning, right? But read between the lines and there's so much depth here. Sun Yan literally shows up at Yan Hai'an's door in the middle of the night after being up all day with his brother dealing with work craziness, and his reason isn't vague or flimsy — it's just "I missed you to death" and he came. That's the kind of directness that doesn't come easy for most people. And Yan Hai'an knows it. He can't even argue with it because the truth is right there. What killed me though is Yan Hai'an taking care of him afterwards. Covering him with the blanket. Ordering breakfast. Cleaning up the messes. He's frustrated — genuinely frustrated at Sun Yan's shamelessness — but the actions keep showing up anyway. There's this moment where he thinks about Sun Yan being spoiled by his family, never had to deal with hard stuff, and still he's the one quietly managing everything. That tension between "you idiot" and "I'm not going anywhere" is everything. And don't even get me started on Sun Yan's phone call with his brother at the end. The way Sun Ling asks "Did you already get on top of that person?" and Sun Yan answers with disgust — but he's still on the phone, still engaging — it shows how messy and complicated their world is. These two aren't just living in a bubble. There are expectations, family pressure, and boundaries being tested. My heart hurts for them. Like, they want simple things but everything around them keeps making it complicated.
... Read More
Okay so the pacing in these chapters is a masterclass in tension without relying on action. Let me explain. We've had a rescue, survival, the aftermath — and instead of rushing to resolve anything, the author just… makes us sit in the hospital room. For days. Yan Hai'an waking up confused, Sun Yan barely functioning, the slow return to consciousness, the two-day gap where Sun Yan is finally coerced into sleeping — each beat is deliberate. The author knows exactly when to linger and when to cut forward. The biggest structural choice here is probably the Sun Ling reveal about the will. It comes at the end like a punch to the gut, right when you've settled into this warm domestic snoring scene. Boom. Now you understand everything. Sun Yan wasn't just being devoted, he was already planning his own death if Yan Hai'an died. That's a structural grenade and it works because the chapter lulls you into comfort first. The chapter ends on Sun Ling's regret — another emotional pivot that propels you forward without any cliffhanger action. Just emotional stakes escalating. Which is honestly more effective than any explosion.
... Read More
I need to talk about the structural transition in this batch because the author just SLAYED it. You go from a domestic kitchen scene — Sun Yan hanging a painting, Yan Hai'an blushing and touching his fingers subconsciously — and then it cuts to Li Weiwei's phone call which is fast, bright, slightly chaotic, and then... cemetery. New Year's Eve. Three people at a tombstone. Absolute silence except for water being poured and incense being lit. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works so well. It forces you to slow down, to actually feel the weight of what's happening. The pacing here is masterful because it doesn't rush the grief or the tenderness. Sun Ling pours the water. Sun Yan fetches it. Yan Hai'an watches from the corner of his eye. No dialogue needed. Then the next scene — the old house, the winery wine, Sun Ling raising a glass — the warmth returns but it's earned. It's not forced cheerfulness. It's quiet gratitude. The chapter structure moves from intimacy → chaos → stillness → warmth, and each section gets exactly as much space as it needs. No rushed endings, no filler. Just... moments that breathe.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the elevator scene. Yan Hai'an blocking the door with his hand, signaling Mo Yisheng to go in first, then winking and calling his decision a 'secret.' The elevator itself is such a loaded symbol here — it goes up and down, it opens and closes, and right at that moment, their relationship is in transition. Mo Yisheng asks 'What will you do if you live alone in the future?' and the question hangs there. Living alone is this abstract concept for Yan Hai'an (he says he can live anywhere), but it's an existential crisis for Mo Yisheng. There's also the repeated imagery of waiting — Yan Hai'an waiting for Sun Yan's reply, Mo Yisheng waiting for answers, Su Yin waiting to be useful. Even the international art exhibition that Yan Hai'an decides to stay for is about waiting, about observing, about not rushing. And that final line about his mind being 'full of thoughts' when it's quiet at night — silence as the condition where truth becomes unavoidable. The story keeps circling around this idea that love and loneliness share the same space.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author uses FOOD and DINING SETTINGS to ground this entire emotional earthquake of a scene. We start in bed—intimate, warm, the kind of morning-after glow where someone is accidentally touching another person and neither wants to acknowledge it. Then we CUT to a restaurant. A fancy one, obviously, because this is Sun Yan's world. The Babao Duck arrives 'one layer on top of another' and the narrator takes time to describe how 'the strength implements the teaching of the ancestors that they should never get tired of eating finesse and be careful. It is quite time-consuming and laborious.' Let that sink in. This dish takes FOREVER to eat properly. And Yan Hai'an is starving himself during this entire conversation because he's too worked up to eat. The food becomes a metronome for the tension—every course that arrives and goes untouched mirrors the emotional distance growing between them despite them sitting inches apart. The teacup detail is everything. Sun Yan reaches for his teacup to 'moisten his mouth and ease the atmosphere' and finds it EMPTY. He's so flustered he doesn't even notice he finished it. And then Yan Hai'an, who literally a moment before was delivering an emotionalnuke, pours him more tea. That small gesture—so casual, so tender—says everything the dialogue refuses to say. The public setting matters too. They can't fully fall apart here. They have to keep their voices down, can't make a scene. It adds this layer of performance to their interaction, like they're both acting out a version of themselves while something real is happening underneath. The whole thing reads like a film scene—close-ups on hands, on teacups, on eyes avoiding each other. I could literally see this on screen.
... Read More
Okay, I need to just sit with this ending for a minute. The way the author wraps everything up is... surprisingly gentle. After all that tension, all those near-death moments and emotional confrontations, the last chapter just... breathes. Yan Hai'an recovering, Sun Yan taking him to the winery, six months of almost domestic normalcy. It's not flashy. It's not dramatic. And honestly? That's what makes it hit so hard. What struck me most is how the narrative treats their relationship like it was always moving toward this moment, even when it felt like they were colliding. The car race, the drugged confusion, the hospital bed — all of it circles back to that balcony scene with the moon and the wine. The author basically says: forget about where it started. Where it ends matters more. I also loved the side characters getting their little beats. Sun Ling telling Yan Hai'an to teach Sun Yan how to love — that's everything. And Mo Yisheng sending postcards from Iceland like nothing happened. Small touches that make the world feel complete. It's a soft landing for a story that spent most of its time making me hold my breath. And I respect that.
... Read More
Mo Yisheng and Yan Hai'an are honestly one of the most quietly devastating duos I've read in a while. Their whole dynamic just sits there underneath every scene, humming like a live wire. On the surface they're friends, business partners, whatever label you want to slap on them—but the real story is in how differently they see the world, and how much it actually hurts them. The scene where Mo Yisheng confronts Yan Hai'an after that exhibition dinner is genuinely gutting. Not because of any dramatic outburst, but because of how understated it all is. He says Yan Hai'an's laugh was "too fake" and that he warned him not to mix with people like that. These are quiet, precise observations that cut deeper than any yelling could. And Yan Hai'an doesn't even defend himself properly. He just sits there, chest heaving, thinking about how do you buy painting tools if painting isn't real work? That thought alone tells us everything about how much he sacrificed internally. What kills me most is the narration's observation about Mo Yisheng's eyes: "It's heartwarming and also heart-wrenchingly clear." Yan Hai'an can see this person who hasn't been corrupted, hasn't learned to play the game, and instead of feeling inspired, Yan Hai'an looks defeated. He tells Mo Yisheng to go home and says he'll join later—like surrendering. And then the aftermath is even worse in its own way. Mo Yisheng sulks for days, keeps repeating that Yan Hai'an doesn't need to flatter people who don't know how to paint. And Yan Hai'an just... treats him like a child. Still takes care of him meticulously, ignores the provocations, keeps showing up. That's not weakness, I think. That's a different kind of devotion. He's choosing to stay anyway, even though every conversation between them confirms they're living in different moral universes. The Li Xi subplot is interesting too. Yan Hai'an actually catches himself thinking, "What if you give this nice guy a try?" But the "too long window period" keeps him paralyzed. He controls the distance, chats over wine, lets Li Xi wait. It's a different flavor of compromise than what he's making with Mo Yisheng, but it's the same pattern: Yan Hai'an never quite lets himself want anything fully. He manages everything instead.
... Read More
I have to take a moment for the very first scene of this batch. The way Yan Hai'an helps Mo Yisheng eat — cutting up the egg bun into small pieces, feeding him like a child — and then Sun Yan just walks in and watches all of it with that cool, almost amused expression. The image is so domestic, so weirdly tender, and then Sun Yan just takes a bun from Su Yin's plate and waves goodbye without even looking back. That's it. That's all he does. Just a hand wave and he's gone. 'The engine of the Land Rover sounded and the explosive force disappeared from Yan Hai'an's field of vision.' That line. That is a perfectly crafted cinematic moment. You can SEE it. The car pulling away, Yan Hai'an standing in the doorway watching it disappear, and then he just goes back to his breakfast like nothing happened. The contrast between that explosive entrance/exit and the mundane return to normal life is chef's kiss. Then we cut to the ancient painting village — 'only Mo Yisheng was like a loner, isolated from all of them without realizing it.' This place feels so different from the bar scenes. Quiet, sunlit, almost peaceful. The other painters greeting each other, He Ling being universally liked. It's a stark contrast to the toxicity of the city scenes. When Mo Yisheng's painting is finally completed and Sun Yan has disappeared, it feels like a chapter closing. But then we're shoved back into the bar, the drinking, the manipulation, and the warmth of that village feels like a distant memory. The author really knows how to use setting to shift mood. One moment you're basking in golden-hour painting vibes, the next you're watching someone get drugged.
... Read More
There is one image in these chapters that I cannot stop thinking about. Yan Hai'an finishes his drink, takes a taxi back, looks up at the building, and sees 'many rooms with lights on' — including Mo Yisheng's studio light — and behind each window 'there is a family.' The text says: 'And behind each window, there is a family. In the lights of ten thousand houses, which one is lit for me?' This is the most cinematic moment in the entire book so far. I swear I can see it like a film shot — night, the city sprawled out, individual rectangles of warm light in dark windows, and this one guy standing at the bottom looking up like he's trying to read a message written in electricity. It's devastating because we know the answer. We've known the answer since chapter one. Mo Yisheng's light is the one that matters. But the narrator still calls this thought 'hypocritical' and has Yan Hai'an shake his head and walk inside anyway, as if denying it out loud makes it less true. The gallery scene itself is also richly drawn — Li Qing's clubhouse with its platform garden, the contrast between the glamorous exterior of the art world and the brutal economic reality ('sales tax is much higher... many galleries cannot maintain their operation'), Wang Yuhu's dyed hair and refined bearing, the whole setup of a world that runs on relationships and title-chasing rather than actual artistic merit. Mo Yisheng's discomfort in this environment isn't just personality; it's philosophical. He hates the machine, and everyone around him is either feeding it or being fed by it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or