Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This passage is VISUAL. Like, I could absolutely see this as a film. The empty teaching corridor — everyone's at the celebration outside, so the hallways are deserted, and Feng Yiqing's door is closed. Yan Hai'an knocking on nothing. The silence before the storm. Then there's this one line that I keep coming back to: "The trees in summer are always green and vibrant and the way the sun falls on them will make people think that they're full of hope." And then immediately after — "Was the sky also so blue back then?" THE AUDACITY of the author to juxtapose eternal, vibrant nature against the fact that Yan Hai'an's world was completely shattered ten years ago, and now the sun is STILL shining and the trees are STILL green and nothing in the physical world cares about your trauma. It's beautiful and kind of cruel, honestly. The school itself feels like a character — "There is only one high school time in one's life. It sounds strange. At that time, he had a love-hate relationship with this school. Maybe he hated it more than he liked it." But now, standing there in the present, looking at students in the same uniforms he used to wear, they look different than he did. Time moves, people change, the building stays the same. I also love the detail about Feng Yiqing's appearance — "his clothes looked a bit old-fashioned. There are no wrinkles on his face. But his body has gained a little weight although he is not fat." This man has been preserved in amber, stuck in the same pattern, same routine, same cowardice. While Yan Hai'an walked away and lived. The ending image of Sun Yan smoking with the car window open, watching Yan Hai'an approach — framed like a movie still. Window down, smoke curling, the friend who knows without asking. Pure cinema. And then: "He walked all the way forward, leaving the noisy crowd and the past behind him. He walked along the avenue of tree line to the school gate. He walked through his high school's past, walked through the pain, and walked towards his present self." THREE WALKS. Past, pain, present. The geography of emotional healing mapped onto a physical path.
... Read More
Can we just talk about this exchange for a second: Sun Yan muttered indignantly, "With one less birthday being celebrated, who knows how many more birthdays could be celebrated?" And Yan Hai'an responds by pressing his cheek against Sun Yan's shoulder and saying, "You will definitely like the birthday present I'm going to give you." The way Sun Yan immediately softens—"So confident?"—and then turns around and holds Yan Hai'an so he can sit on his waist. This is love. This is just... everyday, domestic, unglamorous love. And it's beautiful. Then Sun Yan says: "Then I'll wait. Let's just say that it won't count as a gift. You've already been mine. It's already a gift." I'm not okay. I said it would be fine but this hit me right in the chest. That line isn't dramatic. It's not poetic in an obvious way. It's just... true. And it comes from someone who was genuinely upset moments before but chose to let it go because he felt wanted, not neglected. Yan Hai'an's line about not wanting to be a model is also hilarious because it reveals so much. He refused, they had a long cold war, and Mo Yisheng was so sad he ignored Yan Hai'an more than ever. And Yan Hai'an admits he didn't know how to coax him because "this time, he was not thinking about Mo Yisheng. He was thinking of Sun Yan." The author's voice in the author's note was also fantastic—pure chaos energy with Mr. Sun threatening to bankrupt President Wang. I love the tonal whiplash.
... Read More
This chapter reads like a film. I don't mean that as empty praise — I mean the author constructs every scene with such visual precision that I can see it in my head frame by frame. The opening kitchen scene. Wu Ningshu in her home, ingredients laid out neatly, the kind of organized chaos that comes from hosting people you can't quite read. A big white goose that somehow senses tension between two humans and decides to intervene. Sun Yan's sunglasses hitting the ground — lenses cracking, frames snapping — this detail alone tells you everything about the collision between Sun Yan's world and this village. But the courtyard scene is where the worldbuilding truly shines. Mo Yisheng in wrinkled pajamas, standing at the edge of the goose pen, tossing vegetables like a child at a zoo. Sun Yan showing off the hole in his trousers like a battle scar. These two men — one a city boy who's never seen a live goose, one a powerful developer who got pecked by one — standing together in muddy boots, and somehow it feels intimate. Not romantic intimacy, but the kind that comes from sharing something ridiculous. The village itself is a character. Wu Ningshu's awkward hospitality, the empty rooms she's prepared, her genuine confusion about the value of limited edition sunglasses — every detail grounds us in a place where money means something different, where status is visible but not always respected, where a goose can humble a man in a suit. And Mo Yisheng's studio — filled with flowers he can't display because of allergies, beauty he has to store away. The contrast between this rural suffocation and his artistic sensibility says everything about who he is without the author having to tell us directly. The world feels lived in. Not picturesque. Not romanticized. Just real, with mud on trousers and geese with axes to grind.
... Read More
I need to talk about the subtext between Sun Yan and Yan Hai'an because oh my god the tension is UNREAL. These two are sitting across from each other having a meal and it's basically a war fought with manners and passive aggression. Let me just quote the most devastating exchange: "Do you like Yi Sheng?" — and Yan Hai'an answering too quickly "I'm just friends with him" and Sun Yan immediately calling him out: "Hmm. Answering too quickly." I literally gasped. That is such a sharp, precise strike and Yan Hai'an knew it. But then what makes this scene absolutely gut-wrenching is Yan Hai'an's internal contradiction. He's trying to protect Yi Sheng, yeah, but I couldn't help noticing how protective he already is. Like, he's the one who tells Yi Sheng to sleep, who manages his schedule, who worries about his health. And when Sun Yan says "That's because he hasn't met me before" in response to the whole "he may prefer women" thing, Yan Hai'an's silence speaks louder than any words could. I swear my heart rate went up. The fact that Yan Hai'an ends up lowering himself and literally saying "please take your time" — that broke me a little. He's not naive, he knows exactly what kind of man Sun Yan is, but he's also trapped because he can't afford to offend him. This whole dynamic is so painful and I'm already obsessed.
... Read More
The contrast in settings throughout this section is doing SO much heavy lifting. You've got the studio first — cheap rent, bad location, Mo Yisheng huddled on a sofa eating takeout while staring at his easel. There's something almost sacred about that image, right? A man completely lost in his art, exhausted, surrounded by the physical evidence of his obsession. And then Sun Yan waltzes in with his sports car and says let's go to a Western restaurant in the city center. The transition is jarring and that's intentionally uncomfortable. I loved how the author described Sun Yan ordering without even looking at the menu — he's obviously a regular at these places, he lives in this world of expensive dinners and fine wine. Meanwhile Yan Hai'an is watching the wine get poured and feeling absolutely out of place. And then the bill comes to over 2000 yuan and the narration just goes into Yan Hai'an's head about how most of his money goes back to his hometown, how he's not used to extravagance. That single detail about his salary and where it goes — that's worldbuilding disguised as mundane observation. It tells us everything about who he is without the author having to write a single paragraph of exposition. The whole scene reads like a movie, honestly. The sunglasses coming off, the slow shaking of the wine glass, the silence while they eat. Every beat is carefully staged.
... Read More
Okay so the title is “Improper Relationship” and honestly the vibes are already matching that energy without anyone saying it out loud. The whole first chapter has this undercurrent of tension that's not about drama—it's about proximity, about people standing close to each other and what that means. The most devastating moment for me wasn't even a dramatic one. It was just Yan Hai‘an standing there looking at Mo Yisheng's painting of himself—the one where Yisheng painted his own youthful, Greek-mythology sort of beauty with “curiosity in his deep but clean eyes.” Yan Hai‘an watched the whole creation process, from sketch to finished piece, and he's the one standing in front of it while Yisheng walks away. He's looking at a portrait of his friend that someone else (Yisheng himself) captured, and he can't look away. The text says “Yan Hai‘an had watched the whole process…so Mo Yisheng really can't figure out what else to see.” That sentence hit me like a truck. Yan Hai‘an isn't studying the brushstrokes. He's studying the person. Then Sun Yan comes in and says something almost tender to Mo Yisheng—“They are both very beautiful”—and Mo Yisheng, this pure guy who's “addicted to painting and a bit ignorant of the world,” just accepts it. He doesn't read the room. But Yan Hai‘an does. Of course he does. The emotional geography of this book is already mapping itself out and I am NOT okay with how much I care about three men in a gallery.
... Read More
I need to talk about the molecular restaurant scene because it is genuinely one of the most vivid and uncomfortable moments in this entire chapter. The author describes it perfectly — 'the decoration was very exquisite, the dishes looked very classy, and of course the prices were very expensive.' And then Yan Hai'an has absolutely no interest in this kind of food. He's just sitting there eating boredly while Sun Yan watches him the whole time. This is such a specific kind of awkwardness that I feel like everyone has experienced at some point. You take your partner somewhere fancy because you think it'll impress them, and they just sit there looking miserable. What makes it work is the detail about Sun Yan being 'good at many things but pleasing others is definitely not one of them.' That single line tells us so much about his character and his relationship with Yan Hai'an. He's wealthy, he's capable, but this particular skill — reading what someone else needs and giving it to them — is completely foreign to him. And he knows it. The contrast between this fancy restaurant and the street scene outside where Li Xi confronts them is also interesting. You go from this sterile, expensive, uncomfortable atmosphere to raw physical violence on the steps. The transition feels almost deliberate, like the author is saying 'okay now we're leaving the pretend world and entering the real one.' Li Xi blocking their path, Sun Yan's impulsive violence, Yan Hai'an's unexpected smile — it all happens in this transition zone between the restaurant's polish and the street's grit. That visual shift stayed with me.
... Read More
The conflict in this chapter is deceptively quiet on the surface but absolutely explosive underneath, and I need to talk about the stakes because they're layered in ways that make every interaction feel dangerous. On one level, the obvious conflict is between Sun Yan and Yan Hai'an over Mo Yisheng. Yan Hai'an explicitly told Mo Yisheng that "Sun Yan was not allowed to associate with him"—and now Sun Yan is systematically dismantling that boundary by befriending Mo Yisheng directly. But the REAL stakes go much deeper than a simple love triangle. For Yan Hai'an, the stakes are about control and fear. He's terrified that Sun Yan will hurt Mo Yisheng, and his defensive posture—sitting upright like he could "hold a board meeting at any time," guarding Sun Yan "like a stray dog guarding his last ration"—shows how personally invested he is. He's not just protecting Mo Yisheng; he's protecting something he values enormously from someone he finds fundamentally threatening. The text says Yan Hai'an "became angry when he thought of the scene where Sun Yan will look at Mo Yisheng's body slyly"—and that single sentence reveals how much Yan Hai'an's own desire is entangled with his protective instincts. For Sun Yan, the stakes are about freedom and consequence. He's no longer chasing Yan Hai'an with the same intensity—his interest has faded, he's reached his limit—but he still enjoys watching Yan Hai'an squirm. The stakes for him are different: can he pursue Mo Yisheng without consequence? Can he walk away from Yan Hai'an without facing resistance? And perhaps most importantly, does he actually care about what happens if he loses Yan Hai'an entirely? That last question is the one the chapter leaves unanswered, and it's doing a lot of heavy lifting for the tension ahead.
... Read More
I'm genuinely amazed at how distinct the voices are here. Sun Yan's dialogue is fearless and almost playful, but every sentence has an edge. Remember when Yan Hai'an tries to set a boundary and Sun Yan responds with "Although I don't know why you said this to me, but I have always been a gentleman... Okay, I'll try to take it slow." The polite words masking absolute arrogance is chef's kiss. And then there's Yan Hai'an who is so careful and measured, choosing every word like he's walking on thin ice. His line "You really 'opened' my eyes" — the quotes around the phrase, the deadpan delivery, the barely contained rage — it's one of my favorite moments in the entire text. The author gives each character a completely different rhythm and it makes reading their exchanges feel like watching a fencing match. Sun Yan attacks fast and openly. Yan Hai'an parries slowly and strategically. And the humor! The translator's note about "you really opened my eyes" being this realization that the world is bigger than you thought — and then Sun Yan literally weaponizing that expression later with "you have too little knowledge, you should come out and see the world more." That callback had me wheezing. The author's voice is also doing a lot of work — it's close third person locked firmly in Yan Hai'an's head, so we feel every awkward silence and every uncomfortable swallow. It never drifts away from his experience, which makes the whole thing incredibly immersive.
... Read More
The Sun Ling backstory drop in chapter 187-190 is basically the author feeding us exposition through violence, and honestly? I'm here for it. We learn that Sun Ling tricked some guy into gambling in Macau, lost over 10 million, and then hired debt collectors to come after him. This isn't just worldbuilding—it's character assassination as a weapon. Sun Yan watches He Ling's public confession and calls it "so fucking disgusting," which means he's been watching this whole time, analyzing every move. But here's the thing that keeps me up at night: Sun Yan says, "When he's done talking, he'll be stared at by others and his life will be over." Translation—they're not just winning. They're erasing him. This is a war of reputations, and Yan Hai'an is right in the middle of it, watching the footage with that detached "I don't want to pay attention to him anymore" energy. Meanwhile, his personal life is getting complicated—art museums, boyfriend meetings, dad's birthday. The plot threads are tightening from every angle and I cannot wait to see what snaps first.
... Read More
There's something really interesting happening with all these material objects in this chapter — the car, the gifts, the restaurant — and I think they're doing more work than you'd expect. Sun Yan gives Yan Hai'an a car, which is this huge gesture that immediately sets off alarms. Not because it's bad, but because it represents this whole mismatch in how they express care. Sun Yan thinks buying things = showing love. Yan Hai'an thinks that's not how it works. The author literally has Sun Yan say 'It's just for you' like that should be the end of the argument, and Yan Hai'an just responds with silence. That silence says everything. Then there's the molecular restaurant — food so expensive you can't even see the ingredients. It's literally inedible pretension. Yan Hai'an has no interest in it. Again, this mismatch. Sun Yan is throwing money at problems and Yan Hai'an just wants normalcy. But the most powerful symbol might be Mo Yisheng himself. He's this ghost that haunts every conversation, every decision, every moment between Yan Hai'an and Sun Yan. Even when he's not in the scene, his presence is felt. Sun Yan compares himself to Yan Hai'an's past with Yi Sheng and finds himself lacking. Yan Hai'an tries to explain but the explanation keeps circling back to gratitude rather than desire. The title of this novel is 'Improper Relationship' and I think that's the theme running underneath everything. What makes a relationship proper? Is it the gifts, the grand gestures, the fancy dinners? Or is it knowing what the other person actually wants and giving them that instead?
... Read More
'I just like to buy things for the people I like! No one should give a shit about it!' - this line from Sun Yan is simultaneously the most romantic and most terrifying thing he's ever said. And that's the entire problem with these two, isn't it? Sun Yan loves in grand gestures that somehow always feel like chains. He's genuinely trying to be good to Yan Hai'an, but his idea of goodness involves buying houses, cars, and expecting obedience in return. Yan Hai'an's resistance is what makes him so compelling. When he says 'Maybe in the eyes of outsiders, they will think that you and I are in the kind of relationship between a sugar baby and a sugar daddy?' - that's not just pride talking. That's a man who has spent his whole life being careful, being responsible, being the one who takes care of others, suddenly finding himself in a position where someone wants to take care of HIM. And it terrifies him because it means becoming dependent, becoming obligated, becoming someone who can never fully reciprocate. The most revealing moment for me is when Sun Yan gets serious about the car safety statistics. He's not being controlling - he's genuinely scared. 'Do you know how many car accidents happen in a year?' This is the Sun Yan nobody sees: the man who can buy anything but can't guarantee the person he loves will stay safe. His wealth is both his superpower and his limitation. He can provide everything except the one thing Yan Hai'an actually needs: equality. And Yan Hai'an's silence at the end when he admits he doesn't want money - that's the real heartbreak. He's not refusing because he's proud. He's refusing because he knows he can't pay it back. There's something heartbreaking about a man who would rather remain independent than owe someone his whole heart.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or