Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how brilliantly mundane this chapter is and also how it completely wrecked me? I know, I know, it's a smut chapter and yet somehow the most emotionally devastating thing in it isn't even the sex—it's the fucking bed squeaking. Like, you've got these two guys trying to have a moment, and the universe just goes *squeak* every single time. It's almost comedic at first, but then it hits you: this is Yan Hai'an's childhood home, renovated but still cramped, still poor, still not the life either of them probably imagined. The plot here isn't moving forward in any traditional sense—there's no big reveal, no antagonist showing up—but the tension is still absolutely suffocating because every obstacle is tiny and real. They can't do it in the room. Can't do it outside because of mosquitoes. Can barely breathe without someone overhearing. And then the morning after, Sun Yan just pulls him back into bed like nothing happened, like last night was normal. Which is the plot point that actually broke me. Because it shows everything about their dynamic: Sun Yan doesn't treat Yan Hai'an like something fragile. He treats him like his person. Period.
... Read More
This chapter had me sitting with a weird ache in my chest. Yan Hai'an and Mo Yisheng used to be close—I mean, really close. Like inseparable. But somewhere along the way, everything changed, and it wasn't even dramatic. It was just... gradual. The kind of drifting that happens when one person falls in love and the other is left standing still. What gets me is Mo Yisheng's reaction when Yan Hai'an mentions wanting to take time off for Sun Yan's birthday. He doesn't throw a tantrum. He doesn't even really complain. He just says, "Oh... No wonder," and then pivots to asking if he should give Sun Yan a painting. The disappointment is there, but it's buried under layers of practiced casualness. And then there's the whole He Ling situation. Yan Hai'an explicitly says he has a bad impression of He Ling, calls him "greasy," says he doesn't have the temperament of a painter. And Mo Yisheng's response? Getting angrier and angrier about it, to the point of snapping "You can go take care of Sun Yan! Just leave me alone." That's not just anger—that's childish grievance. That's someone who feels abandoned and doesn't know how to say it without lashing out. The cold war between them is silent but devastating. Yan Hai'an even admits: "they have lost a close relationship." Not broken. Not ended. Lost. Like something alive that quietly died rather than had a dramatic end.
... Read More
So this chunk starts with Sun Yan's text messages and honestly, I just lost it. The guy is literally saying "It is annoying!" and "Seeing you is annoying. Not seeing you is even more annoying." Yan Hai'an reads this and thinks... it's cute?! CUTE?! This old man is acting like a scolded teenager and Yan Hai'an finds that adorable. The fact that he literally has to figure out how to reply to someone who can't stop messaging him while he falls asleep holding his phone — that's the plot twist we didn't know we needed. Meanwhile, back home, Mo Yisheng is casually asking when Yan Hai'an is moving out like his whole world isn't shifting. The dual timeline between Yan Hai'an in S City and Mo Yisheng at home creates this nice push-pull structure. Yan Hai'an going to social events alone where Mo Yisheng would've been despised is such a small detail but it tells us everything about why he's protecting that boundary. And then the ending — Yan Hai'an on the sofa, drunk, looking at unanswered messages, wondering how deep his feelings really are. The narrative doesn't tie things up neatly, which I actually appreciate. It just... stops, like real life.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one image that stayed with me way longer than it should have. Yan Hai'an walks away, gets to the stairwell, turns around, and Sun Yan's sports car is still there. Still parked. Still waiting. The narrator doesn't even describe it dramatically — just states it as fact. But the visual of a man idling in his car across the street after dropping someone home, watching him walk away, then waving when he catches him looking back? That's a scene that belongs in a film. The light, the positioning, the silence between them — you can literally see it. And the terrace scene Yan Hai'an回忆s — sweating under the night wind, catching a cold because Sun Yan couldn't keep his hands to himself — there's something almost tender about how casually brutal it is. These two don't do gentle romance. They do reckless intimacy wrapped in rain-slicked cityscapes and awkward car rides. The world of this story feels lived-in in a way that matches its characters: messy, warm, and full of things unsaid.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how little Sun Yan says and how much it carries? The guy speaks in bullets. 'Soon.' 'Racing?' 'It's just for fun.' 'Why would I be afraid?' 'Hurry the fuck up!' 'Let's go back and continue.' Every line is a knife cut — no fat, no decoration. And yet you know exactly who this man is after three sentences. Yan Hai'an is the opposite. He asks questions. 'Have you died before?' 'Why did I sleep with Sun Yan?' He processes through language; Sun Yan processes through action. That asymmetry in their voices is what makes their dialogue sing. They're not having conversations — they're having collisions. The girl's dialogue is perfectly sketched too — all bubbly and performative, full of suggestions and flirty propositions. It immediately establishes her as someone playing a role, which makes Sun Yan's brutal 'Hurry the fuck up!' cut through her entire performance like a sword. One line destroys a whole scene's energy. And that translator note joke at the end — 'Sun Yan: Come on, don't be pretentious. Yan Hai'an: I don't know you.' — it's silly but it captures something real about their dynamic. Sun Yan calls out nonsense. Yan Hai'an can't even recognize himself sometimes.
... Read More
There's a scene in here that I keep replaying and it's not even the sex scene, it's the car scene. So understated and I think that's why it lives in my head. Sun Yan waiting in Parking Lot 3. The text says he waited 'an unknown amount of time' — we don't know how long. Did he show up early? Did he hover? We don't get that. What we get is the cigarette smell hitting Yan Hai'an the moment he exits the terminal. That's the first sensory detail, and it's already intimate. Sun Yan's presence is announced through scent before we even see him. Then the car interior. The arm resting on the window frame, the cigarette being pressed into the ashtray, the casual flick of it toward Yan Hai'an. These small movements carry so much weight because they're unforced. Sun Yan isn't performing affection — he's just existing in a space that now belongs to both of them. The dinner scene at Sun Yan's place. Xu Hong smiling, the red wine from France (a bottle with no label, no logo, just presence), the casual act of sharing a meal like this is normal. Like Yan Hai'an coming back and ending up at Sun Yan's house eating dinner is just... the default. And then the bedroom. The air conditioner running, skin still damp from the shower, the curtains not fully drawn, light still in the room. There's this vulnerability in the brightness — they're not even hiding in darkness, which is usually where intimacy happens in these stories. They're doing this in the open, almost recklessly. And then later, morning light, the blanket slipping, the awkward search for underwear. The physical world of this story is never decorative. Every detail exists to make the emotional texture legible. I live in this world. I would happily get lost in it.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this one moment because it absolutely wrecked me. Yan Hai'an is sitting in an airport waiting room, exhausted after this whole five-city art tour with Mo Yisheng, and he just starts scrolling through his phone. He sees that one like on his random 8 o'clock sky photo—and then he realizes something that changes everything. Sun Yan has liked EVERY SINGLE POST in his WeChat moments. Not just the important ones, not just the ones worth responding to. Every. Single. One. Yan Hai'an tries to rationalize it. He tells himself it's just a habit, that Sun Yan probably likes everyone's posts, that it means nothing. But the narrative doesn't let him off that easy. We get this line: 'Suppressing the throbbing heart, Yan Hai'an carefully analysed the matter in his heart.' Throbbing heart. The guy is actively fighting his own feelings in real time. And what's devastating is that Sun Yan, this guy who just spent the night being genuinely attentive—'He seemed to be particularly concerned about Yan Hai'an's feelings'—this same guy is showing up in the quietest, most persistent way possible. Leaving digital breadcrumbs of attention that Yan Hai'an only notices when he finally has a quiet moment to himself. The contrast between the physical intimacy they just shared and this slow-burn emotional revelation is everything. Sun Yan doesn't announce anything. He doesn't say 'I care about you.' He just... likes every post. I'm literally sitting here like what does Yan Hai'an do now, because he can't unsee this. The fact that the text cuts off right when he's about to send that message? Unforgivable. Absolutely unforgivable writing choice. This is the kind of moment that makes you put the book down and just stare at the ceiling.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about what just happened because my hands are literally shaking. For the entire arc with Li Xi, I've been sitting on the edge of my seat wondering whether he was actually going to pull the trigger or just keep dancing around it. And then BAM. He drugs his own drink and feeds it to Yan Hai'an. Not a dramatic confession, not a confrontation — just cold, calculated poisoning disguised as friendship. The most chilling part? The bartender didn't even flinch. Just laughed and called him a scumbag like this was routine. Like Li Xi is some kind of seasoned predator who's been doing this for years. 'Oil and salt can't mix well' — what a casual line to drop while mixing powder into vodka! But here's what's messing with me: when Yan Hai'an answers Mo Yisheng's call and rushes out, does he suspect anything? He comes back apologizing for Yi Sheng needing a paintbrush. Meanwhile Li Xi is sitting there smiling that lonely smile, watching him drink. The tension in that moment is absolutely suffocating. And the ending — 'After only three glasses of wine, ...' — the chapter just stops mid-sentence. Three glasses. That's it. He was already feeling something was wrong. But he drank them anyway. I can't breathe. What happens next? Is he going to wake up somewhere? With Li Xi? With no memory? God, I need the next chapter like yesterday.
... Read More
There's one line in these chapters that has been living in my head rent-free: 'A nail was nailed to the wall. And even if it was pulled out, it would always leave a dark hole there.' This is Yan Hai'an's internal philosophy on Li Xi. On relationships. On trust. He believes that every connection leaves permanent damage, so why resist the inevitable? Why fight when everything ends in holes anyway? This is the logic of someone who's been hurt so many times they've decided to stop protecting themselves. It's self-sabotage dressed up as wisdom. And look what it gets him. He stops running from Li Xi. He drinks the poisoned vodka. He lets himself be vulnerable with someone whose 'charm' is just a more sophisticated form of violence. Then there's the paintbrush motif. Yan Hai'an rushing out because Mo Yisheng 'couldn't find a paintbrush.' A tool for creation, for expression, for making something beautiful — and it's what pulls Yan Hai'an away from danger at that exact moment. Meanwhile, Li Xi holds the powder that destroys. One creates, one destroys. And Yan Hai'an keeps choosing the destroyer because the creator is too far away. The ancient village, the oil paintings, the creative process — all of it represents something pure and untouched. And Li Xi exists to contaminate it. The contrast between Mo Yisheng's sunlight-filled studio and Li Xi's dim bar is the entire thematic battle of this story.
... Read More
What keeps me hooked here is the layered conflict running through every exchange between Sun Yan and Yan Hai'an. On the surface, they're discussing Mo Yisheng — or rather, Sun Yan is prodding about him while Yan Hai'an deftly sidesteps. But the real conflict is internal, and it's razor sharp. Sun Yan wants Yan Hai'an but refuses to admit it because Yan Hai'an's feelings are directed elsewhere. His philosophy that 'everything in this world is gone if you don't grab it' reads like he's trying to convince himself, not the other person. And Yan Hai'an? He's playing a longer game. He knows exactly how to keep Sun Yan engaged without ever giving him what he actually wants. 'Mr. Sun, Yi Sheng is really a very simple person. He is not suitable for playing love games.' Polite, deflective, and devastating. The stakes here aren't life or death — they're something more dangerous for this genre. Emotional exposure. The risk of being seen wanting something you can't have. Every line of dialogue is a minor skirmish, and the chapter ends with Sun Yan alone in the water muttering 'How boring' after Yan Hai'an escapes. That's not boredom. That's rejection. And I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Everyone talks about the goose. But the goose is the least dangerous thing in this chapter. Let's look at the actual stakes. Sun Yan is a developer coming to transform this village. He has money, power, and assistants who yell at peasant women. Yan Hai'an is caught between being a guest in someone else's land and being someone who understands both worlds — the rural one he came from and the urban one he now occupies. Every interaction between them is a negotiation of this asymmetry. The goose attack raises the stakes literally — someone could get hurt. But the real threat is structural. Sun Yan protects Yan Hai'an from the goose, then immediately reminds him: "Don't get in my way or I won't take it slow." Translation: I can be your protector or your predator, and you won't know which until it's too late. Yan Hai'an's broken sunglasses symbolize his own fragility in this situation. Expensive, curated, now shattered by circumstances he didn't choose. He offers to pay — not because he thinks Sun Yan will accept, but because he needs to reassert some agency. Any agency. Even a meaningless one. Mo Yisheng's alliance with Sun Yan raises the stakes emotionally. Yan Hai'an watches his friend warm up to the very person he's trying to manage, and there's nothing he can do about it. Sun Yan doesn't need to threaten Mo Yisheng — he just needs to be charming, and Mo Yisheng hands over his loyalty freely. The assistant's anger at Wu Ningshu introduces a class conflict that hasn't been explicitly addressed yet. This man represents Sun Yan's world — demanding, entitled, unable to comprehend why a village woman would let a goose attack a distinguished guest. But Sun Yan shuts him down. Protects Yan Hai'an from his own assistant. Who is actually protecting whom here? Every conflict in this chapter is layered. The goose is physical. The sunglasses are material. The flowers are emotional. The power dynamic is systemic. And none of them are resolved. Which means the real story is just beginning.
... Read More
Okay so the way Yan Hai'an loves Mo Yisheng is the whole emotional core here and it's giving me mixed feelings. On one hand, it's really sweet — he brings her cakes because she mentioned them once in passing, he arranges everything so Yi Sheng can focus on his art, he lies to protect him from Sun Yan. "He can only look out for him right now" — that line hit me. But then you realize this isn't a normal relationship and you start worrying for both of them. Yan Hai'an is essentially isolating Mo Yisheng from the world "for his own good." He doesn't even let him know about Sun Yan's family problems. And the author drops this bomb about Sun Yan's parents dying in a plane crash and his brother surviving only because he couldn't travel at that moment. This family is messy. The sexual tension between Yan Hai'an and Sun Yan is practically radiating off the pages though. Yan Hai'an has to put on a polite smile and apologize to Sun Yan after fabricating an excuse to leave. Sun Yan just stares at him like he's trying to solve a puzzle. And Xu Ke is apparently already targeting Sun Yan? The love triangle plus the complicated family history plus the secret protective arrangements — it's a lot emotionally and I'm here for it. What I find most touching is how Mo Yisheng has absolutely no idea how deep Yan Hai'an's worry goes. He just nods and follows, comfortable in his ignorance. Is that peace or is that tragedy?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or