Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this excerpt is perfectly calibrated to reveal character through what is said and, more importantly, what is missed. Lu Suju's voice is pure, unadulterated anxiety masked as hospitality. Her rapid-fire questions ('Only him? Where's the others?') and her swift pivot to 'He didn't even eat?' show a woman desperately trying to control a narrative that is slipping through her fingers. Then there's Sun Yan. His voice is the highlight. He switches from formal ('Uncle, auntie') to playful ('I will take good care of Hai'an') to shamelessly flirtatious ('I got hard...') with terrifying ease. He's code-switching for survival. But the funniest part is the dialect barrier. Sun Yan doesn't understand half of what Yan Jiali is saying, yet he responds with perfect nonchalance. The author uses this to hilarious effect—Yan Jiali is probably pouring his heart out in rough rural dialect, and Sun Yan is just nodding along, thinking he's making friends. Meanwhile, Yan Hai'an is suffering, translating nothing, trapped between two worlds. The banter between the brothers, especially Yan Haijian's deadpan '...Well then' when he realizes they're sharing a bed, is comedy gold. It's understated, dry, and perfectly human.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is absolutely phenomenal and I need to discuss why. Look at how Sun Yan speaks - terse, practical, occasionally sharp but undercut by actions that betray his care. 'Forget it. Just save it for the next fight.' That's not dismissive; that's him processing that Yan Hai'an was hurt and he doesn't know how to say it directly. Yan Hai'an's voice is different - more analytical, more willing to tease but also more guarded. His 'shoot guns' explanation about mouth cannon is brilliant characterization; it shows he uses humor and deflection as armor. The real dialogue gold is in what they DON'T say. That entire hand-holding scene? Zero dialogue but it communicates more than any confession could. And the ending exchange - 'Why haven't you left?' / 'Then why don't you leave?' - is perfect. It's not about the words; it's about the pattern. Two people who can't admit they don't want the other to go, so they weaponize politeness instead. The narrator's voice is equally distinctive - wry, observant, never judgmental, occasionally letting us in on Yan Hai'an's internal monologue ('hey, why is this guy so clingy?') while maintaining objective distance. Even Su Yin's phone voice shifts appropriately - professional polish with underlying warmth. Every character sounds like themselves, and the author never lets dialogue become exposition dumps.
... Read More
There's this one scene that I can't get out of my head. Yan Hai'an tugs off his bow tie, sits on the sofa, drinks a lot, and just... stares at the city. The floor-to-ceiling windows on the 17th floor, the busy traffic below, the quiet of the hotel room. He's been through social events all day, dealing with people who look down on him, pretending he's fine. And then he's alone. The contrast between the noisy daytime world and this silent hotel room at night is so cinematic. Earlier, we see the domestic space of Mo Yisheng's apartment — messy, lived-in, Yan Hai'an picking up scattered belongings. Then we cut to Su Yin's elaborate hotel arrangements, first-class upgrades, car pickups. The contrast between these two worlds says everything about where Yan Hai'an's heart is. He could live anywhere — the text literally says 'He just needs a place to rest.' But he chooses to be near Mo Yisheng. And now he's in a fancy hotel room with a view, and it feels hollow.
... Read More
I can't stop thinking about that word the author chose — "corruption." Yan Hai'an looks at the 2000 yuan bill and the word just lands on the page by itself: This is corruption. Corruption. It's almost comedic but also deeply revealing about his self-image and his values. He's a man who sends most of his money home, who eats chicken breast at fancy restaurants because he has no feelings for Western food, who feels guilt over spending money he doesn't really have. Sun Yan, on the other hand, represents everything Yan Hai'an isn't — wealth without shame, desire without apology, living entirely for himself. And the whole premise of this novel seems to orbit around this clash of worlds. There's also the recurring image of Yi Sheng being watched. First Yan Hai'an is the one watching over him, checking his health, managing his life. Then Sun Yan appears and immediately starts observing him too — from across the room at first, then through Yan Hai'an's descriptions. Two men circling the same person, each claiming to know what's best for him. And Yi Sheng himself? Still sleeping, still painting, still unaware that his life is about to get dramatically more complicated. The title of the novel — "不正经关系" (Improper Relationship) — keeps echoing in my head. What's improper about it? The class difference? The romantic pursuit? Or the fact that the people around Yi Sheng are more entangled with each other than with him? I have so many questions and I need to keep reading.
... Read More
The author has this really interesting relationship with space and time in these opening chapters. The entire first chapter takes place in roughly one afternoon at a gallery opening—but it covers SO MUCH ground emotionally. That's the skill here. The external action is minimal: people walk in, look at art, exchange a few words, make a sale. But the internal action is running a marathon. What I appreciate is how the author uses environmental details as pacing tools. The weather description at the very beginning—“there is no fixed weather. The temperature fluctuates arbitrarily”—isn't just setting the scene, it's establishing the emotional temperature of the story. Things will shift. People will be uncomfortable. No one will know exactly how to dress for what's coming. The AC being poorly adjusted in the gallery is such a small detail but it mirrors the social dynamics perfectly—everyone's slightly uncomfortable, people are performing composure (“unwilling to lose their dignity”), and underneath it all something is about to change. The thick carpet absorbing footsteps is another layered detail: everyone's moving quietly, carefully, not making waves, but the waves are already coming. The transition from Yisheng's anxiety to calm as he looks at his paintings, then the jolt when Sun Yan appears—that rhythm feels very intentional. The author lets us breathe, then tightens the screw. I want to read more immediately but I also want to sit with this chapter for a while. That's a good sign.
... Read More
I need to talk about this absolutely devastating line: "He is his future. He is also his hope. And what's more… He is his reason to live." I read that and just sat there staring at my phone like what is wrong with me why is this character so deeply in love it physically hurts. Sun Yan sitting by Yan Hai'an's hospital bed for who knows how many sleepless nights, writing a will saying if you die I die — and he says it almost casually like it's just a fact of life. The way he holds Yan Hai'an's hand from under the covers like he's afraid to break him, the way he smiles when his eyes are red from crying but doesn't want to be seen crying… this man loves so loudly in silence it's obscene. And then Yan Hai'an wakes up and his first real thought isn't about his own pain, it's "how long have you not had a good rest?" That's the most dangerous kind of love — when two people are this consumed by each other and neither can admit it out loud but also neither can stop. The whole dynamic where Yan Hai'an saved Sun Yan's life and now Sun Yan won't let him out of his sight… it's obsessive and beautiful and I am here for it. Sun Ling saying "I regret that I encouraged him to pursue you" hit me like a truck. Of course he does. Because his brother isn't just in love, he's all in, completely and irreversibly, and his family knows it.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter opens with what should be a mundane village visit and somehow becomes the single most revealing sequence in the entire book. Let me explain why. Sun Yan tells Yan Hai'an to take it slow — and immediately after, chaos erupts. A goose attacks Yan Hai'an, Sun Yan physically shields him, kicks the goose, gets his trousers mauled. And then Yan Hai'an picks up broken sunglasses and says thank you. The plot doesn't just move forward here; it reorients. What struck me is how the author uses the goose as both literal obstacle and structural pivot. Before the goose: Sun Yan and Yan Hai'an are at odds, exchanging barbed comments. After the goose: Sun Yan has positioned himself as protector, Yan Hai'an is indebted, and the power dynamic has shifted without anyone acknowledging it. This is brilliant plotting — the same event that creates conflict also creates dependency. Then the chapter fractures into three simultaneous threads: Yan Hai'an in the kitchen with Wu Ningshu, Mo Yisheng chatting with Sun Yan about trousers, and Yan Hai'an's internal monologue about the flowers. Each thread advances a different aspect of the central relationship. The kitchen scene establishes Yan Hai'an's rural roots as both vulnerability and pride. The courtyard scene shows Mo Yisheng softening toward Sun Yan — which worries Yan Hai'an. The flower thread connects back to their unresolved tension. The goose gets its comeuppance when Wu Ningshu corrals it back to the pen. But the human conflict? That stays wide open. Which is exactly how a good chapter should end — resolved on the surface, simmering underneath.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is deceptively simple. On the surface these people are just talking about being trapped, but if you actually listen to HOW they talk, it's a whole other layer. Sun Yan's voice is chaos — fragmented, repetitive, spiraling. 'You're bleeding!' repeated like a broken record. 'How are you feeling? Where is the injury? Huh?' The 'huh' is everything. It's not a question, it's a panic attack in punctuation form. And then the crescendo: 'Who the hell made you jump to protect me?! You are sick, Yan Hai'an?!' That second sentence especially — 'You are sick' is such an odd thing to say to someone saving your life, but it's PERFECT for someone whose emotional vocabulary at this point is just rage and terror. Yan Hai'an's voice is the opposite — compressed, practical, barely there. 'It's okay, I'm not dead yet!' is almost funny if the situation weren't so dire. And his internal monologue is where the real voice lives: 'I didn't know why either. I did it without thinking.' That's the Yan Hai'an who says what he means without elaboration. Even his final words — 'I love you' — are delivered without flourish, because that's how he operates. Understated to the last.
... Read More
The author has this incredible ability to make a chapter feel like three different experiences stitched together, and each one serves the whole. Act One: The Goose War. Fast, physical, almost slapstick. Sun Yan kicks a goose. His trousers get destroyed. His assistant loses his mind. This section moves at the speed of panic and comedy, and it's exactly the right temperature for opening the chapter. You're laughing, you're紧张, you're not sure which emotion to trust. Act Two: The Aftermath. Yan Hai'an picks up broken sunglasses. Offers to pay. Sun Yan deflects. The assistant gets shut down. Wu Ningshu apologizes profusely. The pace drops suddenly — from physical chaos to social negotiation. This is where the author makes you feel the weight of what just happened without saying a word about it. The silence after noise is where tension lives. Act Three: The Kitchen and the Courtyard. Two parallel scenes that cut between each other. Yan Hai'an washing dishes with Wu Ningshu, revealing his rural past. Mo Yisheng feeding geese with Sun Yan, bonding over destroyed trousers. These scenes breathe. They don't push the plot forward aggressively — they deepen it. And then Yan Hai'an's internal monologue about the flowers, about the deal, about everything unsaid, brings it all back to the emotional center. The transitions are seamless. You go from a goose pecking Sun Yan's legs to quiet dishwashing without jarring. The author trusts you to follow the emotional thread even when the physical action stops. And that closing image — Sun Yan asking about Mo Yisheng still sleeping, Yan Hai'an deflecting, heading to the kitchen — it's not a cliffhanger. It's a breathing space. The chapter ends the way a conversation ends when something important has been said without being spoken. This is how you pace a chapter. Not by adding more conflict, but by letting existing conflict breathe.
... Read More
Let's talk about the flower delivery because this is where the stakes become painfully clear. Sun Yan sends a bouquet of blue hydrangeas in a long gift box — expensive, celebrity brand, but the card has ONLY the recipient's name and absolutely nothing else. No message. No warmth. Just a name. Yan Hai'an notices this immediately and describes it perfectly: 'Expensive, but there's no heart to it.' He's right. This is Sun Yan being performative — grand gesture on the surface, emotionally distant underneath. It's control disguised as generosity. And Yan Hai'an's reaction? He takes care of Mo Yisheng during dinner, then packs up and leaves, goes to a bar, and smokes half a pack of cigarettes because he's too irritable to sit with his own thoughts. Half a pack. This man is holding onto so much anger and he has nowhere to direct it because Sun Yan keeps wrapping his cruelty in kindness. Meanwhile Mo Yisheng just accepts the flowers and says Sun Yan is 'an interesting person.' An INTERESTING PERSON. Like he hasn't just been psychologically maneuvered into gratitude for a loveless gesture. The tension between these three is suffocating and I can't look away. What are they all standing to lose if this dynamic breaks?
... Read More
The gift-shopping scene is apparently about gold bracelets but it's actually about something much bigger and I'm not okay. Yan Hai'an explicitly tells Sun Yan his parents are simple people. He rejects the jade (too expensive, too fancy for a mom who works on a farm). He warns against anything too pricey. And Sun Yan—who is genuinely trying, I think—goes and buys two of everything because apparently "paying enough attention" has a price tag in his vocabulary. This isn't comedy, readers. This is a class collision happening in real time inside a jewellery store. But then there's Su Yin, carrying bags in both hands and on his back and pushing two suitcases, and Sun Yan's like "Don't worry about him. It's his job." Yan Hai'an watching all this with that resigned, slightly horrified expression—you can feel him calculating what it would be like to introduce this entire chaotic ecosystem to his father. The dad's birthday isn't just a plot device. It's the threshold. Once Sun Yan walks through those doors, there's no going back to this comfortable in-between space where nothing is real except the art and the schemes. "Take a short leave. Will you be free to go with me?"—the most vulnerable sentence this book has ever given Yan Hai'an, delivered with zero fanfare.
... Read More
The author knows how to pace this. We start in media res - already at the villa, already comfortable, already settling in. The first half is all leisure: bed, wine, dinner, swimming pool, lazy conversation. It's slow because it's supposed to be. This is Yan Hai'an finally resting. Then the birthday mention - “Sun Yan's birthday came during this kind of idleness.” No fanfare. Just a quiet acknowledgment that time has passed. And then the tour through France - a whole paragraph summarizing a month of traveling, efficient but warm. And then - “After more than a month, the results should come out. Yan Hai'an first randomly checked the Internet and was shocked of the news.” Boom. Everything shifts. The pacing goes from lazy afternoon to frantic phone calls in one beat. The transition from “Young Chinese Painter He Ling Won the Excellence Award” to Yan Hai'an's face turning pale is so abrupt it feels like a punch. One paragraph he's reading the news, the next he's muttering “What's going on” and cursing. And the chapter ends with “Mr. Sun, I can't find him.” That's not a resolution. That's a cliffhanger wrapped in a single line.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or