Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'Why do we need to go? Do I even agree?' - Yan Hai'an's voice in this chapter is pure exhaustion masked as sarcasm, and I am here for it. The author has developed these two characters to the point where their dialogue sounds like real people who have known each other forever, even though they just started dating. Sun Yan speaks in declarations and commands, but there's always something underneath - when he says 'Let yourself be obedient first,' it's not just control, it's desperation. He's afraid of losing this, so he's grabbing harder. The dialogue rhythms are perfect. Sun Yan's lines come fast and furious, often trailing off into increasingly unreasonable demands ('I'll buy an SUV and it's okay if the car hits and smashes things or people'). This is comedy gold - the author knows exactly how to make Sun Yan's controlling nature feel funny instead of abusive. But then it pivots. 'I'm not joking about this kind of thing' - and suddenly the humor drains away and we see the fear underneath. That's when the dialogue stops being funny and starts being devastating. Yan Hai'an's responses are shorter, more measured, which creates this beautiful push-pull dynamic. He's the anchor to Sun Yan's storm. When he says 'Food and shelter is not equivalent to falling in love. That was just giving others support,' there's this entire history in five words. He's drawing a line between transactional care and genuine love, and Sun Yan doesn't understand why that line matters. The most brilliant exchange has to be the rent discussion. Sun Yan: 'Why don't I send you some money?' Yan Hai'an: tries to explain the difference between employment and romance. Sun Yan: completely misunderstands and gets offended. This isn't just witty dialogue - it's two people speaking completely different emotional languages, and the author makes us feel every miscommunication.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I respect it. We start with something almost cozy — Yan Hai'an making breakfast, Sun Yan making a brief dramatic appearance, a quiet village where artists paint and chat. It lulls you into this warm, slow rhythm. Over half a month passes in just a few paragraphs. Mo Yisheng's painting is completed. Sun Yan disappears. Life is... normal. Then Chapter 42 hits like a truck. One minute Yan Hai'an is having a relatively calm conversation with Li Xi about their 'affairs' (his word, not mine — they're supposed to be friends apparently), and the next Li Xi is pouring white powder into his vodka while the bartender makes jokes about it like this is a Tuesday. The transition is so jarring on purpose. The author lets you breathe with the village interlude, makes you think everything is okay, and then slams the trap shut. The scene where Li Xi asks 'Hai'an, what do you think about our affairs then?' — that's the calm before the storm. Yan Hai'an is starting to say something important, and his phone rings. Mo Yisheng. Of course it's Mo Yisheng. Everything always revolves around that guy. And then the final line: 'After only three glasses of wine, ...' Three. Glasses. He's already feeling off and Li Xi is watching him. The chapter cuts before we know what happens. This is peak manipulation — both from Li Xi in the story and from the author with the reader. I immediately wanted to click to the next chapter.
... Read More
This whole subplot about Mo Yisheng is giving me so many feelings and I don't know whether to root for it or just give up on the whole thing. Yan Hai'an's explanation about how he met Yi Sheng was actually really raw. 'Because he finally set foot on this path that I liked so I am very fond of him. I am thankful to him.' That's not romantic love — at least Yan Hai'an doesn't think it is. But Sun Yan still has to hear it, right after finding out Yan Hai'an has a whole family he didn't know about (big brother, nephew). The timing is brutal. What kills me is Sun Yan trying to be cool about it. He says 'Forget it, forget it' like he's brushing off something huge, but then he's gloomy the whole dinner and can't even enjoy the food. Yan Hai'an notices and just watches him. There's this moment where Sun Yan says 'I'll listen to you' about not moving in together yet, and it sounds so unfamiliar coming from him. That line hit me harder than I expected. Meanwhile Mo Yisheng is just... out there riding bikes and being tired, completely unaware that his presence is causing all this tension. I feel for him a little but also kind of don't? The author is building this emotional triangle that makes you want to scream at the characters. Every time Sun Yan asks about Yi Sheng, Yan Hai'an shuts it down, and every time Yan Hai'an tries to explain, it sounds more like he's convincing himself. Is Yan Hai'an truly over his feelings for Yi Sheng, or is he just convinced he should be? That question is going to haunt me through the rest of this arc.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in controlled pacing. Let me break down why it works so well. The chapter opens with what feels like a minor scene — Yan Hai'an leaving Li Qing's gallery with a cake. There's this brief philosophical aside about how "the brighter the industry is, the filthier it gets" which sets up the central tension without announcing it. Then we transition smoothly into the studio, where we spend time establishing the domestic rhythm between Yan Hai'an and Mo Yisheng. This isn't filler — it's essential character work that makes everything that follows hit harder. The middle section is where the pacing really shines. The phone call happens organically — the music plays, the phone falls behind the cushion, and suddenly we're in completely different territory. The transition from cake-sharing to threat-receiving takes maybe two paragraphs, and it's jarring in the best possible way. That's the narrative equivalent of someone handing you a pastry and then dropping a bomb in your lap. After the call, there's a brief cooling-off period where Mo Yisheng eats his cake and Yan Hai'an processes what just happened. This breathing room is crucial — it gives the reader time to absorb the tension before the chapter ends with Sun Yan's physical arrival. The final image of Sun Yan leaning on the front desk, sunglasses lowering, looking around the studio? That's a textbook cliffhanger that doesn't feel manufactured because everything leading to it has been earned. What I appreciate most is that the author never rushes. Even the exposition about the studio's operations and the characters' backgrounds is woven naturally into action rather than dumped in infodumps. The result is a chapter that moves at exactly the right speed — intimate enough to care about the characters, tense enough to keep turning pages.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is masterfully uncomfortable. The author lets the scene with Sun Yan sitting in Mo Yisheng's studio breathe for what feels like forever — over two hours of silence, just the sound of a paintbrush, Yan Hai'an gradually relaxing his vigilance only to have it snapped back the moment Sun Yan touches his phone. That's when the rhythm shifts. Sun Yan makes that call with an impatient but intimate tone, and suddenly everything changes. He's done observing. Time to leave. And then the flower delivery sequence hits like a second wave — same tension, different room, same三个人 navigating unspoken stuff. But then Yan Hai'an leaves and goes to the bar and the whole pacing drops for a beat, like the reader gets to exhale, right? Wrong. Because Li Xi appears. One finger snap. 'Long time no see, I thought I won't be seeing you anymore.' And then the chapter cuts off mid-sentence: 'His temper is not as good as how he usua' — cut. Just cut. I had to scroll to the next chapter immediately. The author knows exactly what they're doing with this structure — they build pressure slowly, release it briefly, then yank the rug out right when you think you're safe. No cliffhanger exposition, no dramatic declaration, just a cut mid-word and a reader who can't sleep.
... Read More
This place - the winery, the villa, the swimming pool behind it - it feels like a character itself. “The bedroom is completely European aristocratic style, with a King sized four-poster bed, a gorgeous hand-embroidered bed curtain, and a cashmere carpet.” That's not just decoration; it's atmosphere. It says: you're somewhere important, somewhere earned. And the food, the wine - “Dom Pérignon” for appetizer, “noble rot sweet wine of Lucullus Wine Castle” after dinner. Yan Hai'an doesn't know how old the bottle is, but he knows the taste is better than any white wine he's had before. “It's a little sweet. Looking at the wall of the glass, it makes the whole wine glass sparkle with a wonderful golden colour.” That sentence - it's so specific, so sensory. You can see the light through the glass. You can taste the sweetness. Then the pool at night - “The air at night was still a little cold. But the two of them were messing around inside and rubbing against each other, so they didn't get cold.” Cold water, warm bodies. That contrast is everything. And the trip through France - Bordeaux, Alps, Côte d'Azur, Atlantic coast, Loire Valley. A whole month of traveling without rushing. The scenery isn't the point; it's the atmosphere. “Yan Hai'an saw that it was so beautiful. It is not due to the scenery, but it is the atmosphere.” He wasn't relaxed for years. Now he could sit and rest.
... Read More
Let me just say — the tension in this section is UNRELEASEABLE. Yan Hai'an is literally sitting across from the man who also wants Mo Yisheng, and they're having the most vulnerable conversation of their lives. But the real stakes here aren't just romantic. It's about identity, acceptance, and whether love is even survivable in a world that won't protect it. Sun Yan puts it bluntly: "The kind of relationship which is neither protected by law and was also rejected by morality?" This isn't subtext anymore, folks. This is TEXT. The legal and moral rejection hanging over everything like a storm cloud. And Yan Hai'an's answer — that Mo Yisheng "only likes pure things," that there's no gender difference in Yi Sheng's heart — that's Yan Hai'an trying to convince himself as much as anyone. Meanwhile, Mo Yisheng is out there painting "Triumph" with dark circles under his eyes, refusing to join any association, being stubborn AF. He's sacrificing his comfort and his health for his art AND his independence. What does HE stand to lose? His autonomy? His connection to Yan Hai'an? The fact that he fell asleep with his back turned in ten seconds while Yan Hai'an was watching him — that's not just tiredness, that's trust. And trust is the most dangerous thing to have when you can't guarantee tomorrow. The empty flower vase at the front desk is also NOT an accident detail. Someone stopped sending flowers. The absence speaks louder than the presence ever could.
... Read More
What makes the conflict in these chapters so effectively unsettling is that nobody is fighting about anything concrete. There's no betrayal, no revelation, no external threat. The entire conflict is philosophical, internal, and it eats away at everyone involved. On the surface, the stakes seem small: an art exhibition, a trip to an ancient village, a disagreement about whether painting is sacred or a commodity. But underneath all of that is the real question that the book keeps circling around—can you sell your soul and still recognize yourself in the mirror? Yan Hai'an knows the answer is complicated, which is why he can't defend his position to Mo Yisheng. He doesn't believe his own logic. Mo Yisheng's conflict is cleaner because he actually believes his side. Painting is sacred. Business is contamination. People like Li Qing and her circle are destroying something pure. But here's what makes it dangerous—he's right, and Yan Hai'an knows it. That knowledge is what turns this from a simple disagreement into something that permanently alters their relationship. The Yan Hai'an and Li Xi tension adds another layer of stakes. Yan Hai'an is emotionally available enough to consider a relationship with Li Xi—he acknowledges Li Xi is nice, patient, worthy of consideration—but he can't act. The author describes it as a "too long window period" that makes Yan Hai'an overthink to the point of paralysis. So the stakes here are different: it's not about losing someone to betrayal, it's about losing the possibility of connection through sheer inability to commit. And the road trip section raises the stakes in a physical way that mirrors the emotional ones. Bad roads, wrong turns, arriving late and starving—the journey itself becomes another kind of trial. They're heading somewhere undeveloped, somewhere "disappearing," and they're stuck in a car together after days of unresolved tension. You can feel the pressure building toward something inevitable. The question isn't whether they'll reconcile. It's what will break first.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how absolutely chaotic and perfect the Li Xi confrontation was? On the surface it's a simple 'villain shows up to cause trouble' moment, but the author ramps up the stakes so quickly it's dizzying. Li Xi sees Sun Yan with Yan Hai'an and his whole demeanor changes. He's jealous, bitter, and immediately goes for the jugular: 'When there is no more Mo Yisheng, here comes another one, who was at odds with me since the beginning.' He knows exactly which buttons to push. And Sun Yan's response is either the most impulsive or the most calculated thing I've seen him do. He doesn't warn anyone. He just SLAPS Li Xi on the head from behind. No warning, no words, just sudden violence. The description of Li Xi rolling down the steps is almost cartoonish in its physicality, and then Sun Yan KICKS him. 'This kind of scum who dares to drug people,' he says, as if this is basic justice and everyone should agree. But here's what keeps me up at night — what are the actual stakes here? Sun Yan just assaulted someone in public. Yan Hai'an is watching. Li Xi threatens to call the police. And the chapter cuts off right as Yan Hai'an smiles this almost arrogant smile and says 'Him being...' WHAT WAS HE GOING TO SAY?! I need to know what happens next. The tension between Yan Hai'an and Sun Yan is still unresolved (the moving-in question, the Yi Sheng issue), and now this new conflict with Li Xi adds another layer of danger. What if things actually go badly? What if Li Xi really does press charges? The author is stacking conflicts on top of each other and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I need to talk about this painting Mo Yisheng made. Because honestly? It gave me actual chills. "One person is sitting at the dining table and eating. The light is coming in from outside. It is almost night time. The light is dim, making the tone of the whole painting heavy. The protagonist in the painting is He Ling. Compared with the real him, there is a hint of indifference and arrogance between his brows. He thoughtfully put his hand on the knife, but did not pick it up. It makes people feel nervous about what he'll do." Read that again. This isn't a portrait. This is a threat wrapped in oil paint. Mo Yisheng captured He Ling at the exact moment before violence—hand on the knife but not yet gripping it. The dim light, the heavy atmosphere, the indifference between the brows. This painting doesn't just depict a person. It depicts a mood, a promise of something dark about to happen. And the fact that it's "quite different from Mo Yisheng's previous style" but "full of disturbing hints" and "even more intense" tells me everything I need to know about where his head is at. This man is not painting pretty pictures anymore. He's channeling something unsettling into his art, and Yan Hai'an is the only one who seems to notice how off-kilter everything has become. The studio itself feels like a character here. The drying varnish, the canvas, the easel at the other end—it's all so quiet and heavy, like the air before a storm.
... Read More
Let me just say — the car contrast in this chapter is SO deliberate. Yan Hai'an driving his ¥100,000 old Buick into a villa area where even the underground garage costs a fortune to build, with liftable mechanical elevators that look like a famous car showroom. The author just drops these details casually, but every one of them is a tiny knife twist. Yan Hai'an sighs internally at the wealth gap while Sun Yan's housekeeper Aunt Hong and Ling Li help carry in the painting that probably cost less than Sun Yan's parking space. And then there's this moment where Sun Yan says "This brother will show you something different" and Yan Hai'an's resistance crumbles because... well, because he's tired and lonely and someone is finally reaching out. The dark road outside the city after midnight, no radio playing, just the modified engine hum and two guys who don't quite know what they're doing with each other. It's cinematic. It's moody. It's giving me main character energy for a thriller that never actually becomes a thriller.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage escalate in layers and it's actually really well done. On the surface level: Mo Yisheng is in police custody for arson. That's dramatic but contained — a lawyer shows up, the Sun family name opens doors, problem solved in two paragraphs. So the author immediately pivots to a different kind of danger. The real threat isn't legal — it's existential. 'Even if the media doesn't report it, the public doesn't know about it. Can people in their circle still know about it?' That line from Sun Ling is the pivot point of the entire passage. It reframes everything. The police station was the EASY problem. The hard problem is: what happens when your private destruction becomes public knowledge in a world that demands your art? And Yan Hai'an's conflict here is so quietly devastating. He's torn between protecting Mo Yisheng and... what? Following him? Losing him? The text never says it but the subtext is screaming. 'I shouldn't have left' — that apology to Mo Yisheng isn't about the painting. It's about every moment of absence that led to THIS moment. Sun Yan's stakes are different but no less real. He's performing confidence ('I'll handle it') while his brother calls him out on his naivety. 'You never thought that much about anything.' The irony is sharp — Sun Yan only realizes the complexity of the situation when he connects it to whether Yan Hai'an will worry. His empathy runs through Yan Hai'an, not directly. The passage ends on an unfinished question about whether Mo Yisheng will visit his mother, and honestly that hanging note is what makes the stakes feel ongoing. Nothing is resolved. The fire is out but the damage is spreading.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or