Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the way this subplot about the painting unfolded had me softly screaming. Sun Yan goes all the way to Country A specifically to restore Yan Hai'an's painting, treats the 20,000,000 pieces he broke like nothing, comes back, and hangs it in the most conspicuous spot in the living room. And then drops the line: "Better than that Mona Lisa." That's not just a line, that's a plot-level declaration of love disguised as an art opinion. The author didn't need to spell it out with dramatic confessions or anything. Just... that one sentence and we're all on the floor. But here's what really got me — Yan Hai'an's reaction isn't even about the painting. It's about whether he can still pick up the brush again. He's been sitting on this creative impulse for so long, and the moment Sun Yan validates his work, something shifts. "He just… wanted to paint a side view of Sun Yan." A side view! Not a grand portrait, not something monumental — just Sun Yan, seen from the side. That detail made me emotional for some reason. The plot doesn't race here. It breathes. It lets these quiet moments sit with you. And that's what makes it hit so hard.
... Read More
Sun Yan's lines are a masterclass in casual menace. Let me just say that. The man walks into a violent confrontation and his first instinct is to whistle and clap like he's watching a street performance. "Wow. It's amazing." BRO. He's not even phased. He's genuinely entertained. And then the advice—"Baby, don't use your hands too often. Kick with your feet and save effort." That is not a line from a romantic lead. That's a line from someone who has zero moral reservations about watching their boyfriend beat someone half to death and offering constructive criticism on their fighting technique. I'm shook. But here's what makes the dialogue work so well—Yan Hai'an sounds completely different. His speech is punchy, frustrated, raw. "Damn it. Fucking scumbag. I can't control myself when I see that face." That's not performative. That's someone whose hand is literally shaking after hitting someone too hard. The self-awareness in "It's long overdue to beat him so much that he doesn't dare to come out to see anyone"—that's guilt mixed with satisfaction, and the dialogue captures both without needing narration to explain it. Mo Yisheng's voice throughout is softer, more reflective. "I will see the world. I will paint everything." Simple sentences. Clean statements. No hedging. It contrasts perfectly with Sun Yan's elaborate, almost theatrical delivery. The author isn't just writing dialogue—they're using speech patterns to build character architecture.
... Read More
There's this one line that has been living in my head rent-free: 'Mo Yisheng's life has been well protected until now and his life is like a pure white piece of paper.' A white piece of paper. Not blank —白纸 and pure white. There's a difference. It means he hasn't had anything written on it yet, not that he's naive by choice. And Yan Hai'an is terrified of picking up the pen and making a mark he can't erase. The whole chapter is really about protection versus honesty, and whether knowing the truth is ever worth the cost of losing innocence. Yan Hai'an explicitly says he doesn't want to 'open the door to a new world' for Mo Yisheng. He wants to keep him safe. But is that kindness or is it control? The book seems to be asking that question without fully answering it. And then Sun Yan flips the script entirely. 'You can't bend straight things. And you can't straight bend things.' It's almost dismissive, but underneath it there's this whole philosophy about acceptance. Sun Yan's worldview is fundamentally different from Yan Hai'an's — he comes from privilege, from a place where consequences don't land the same way. His carelessness IS his philosophy. The clash between these two approaches to love and risk is honestly the real heart of the story.
... Read More
Let's talk about how this chapter is structured, because it's doing something really clever. It opens intimate and soft—Yan Hai'an leaning on Sun Yan, whispering in his ear, talking about birthdays and gifts. This is warm. This is safe. The reader settles in. Then—bam—we're suddenly in Mo Yisheng's studio, and the tone has completely shifted. The painting description is unsettling. The friendship dynamics are strained. There's a cold war happening. The pacing accelerates from domestic sweetness to emotional turbulence almost overnight. And the author doesn't linger on the transition. We just... arrive at the new scene and the mood is different. That's a bold choice. Most writers would ease you into the shift, but this author just pivots and trusts you to keep up. Then right when you're processing all that interpersonal tension, the author's note drops in with comedic relief about two presidents in one story. It's chaotic, it's meta, it breaks the fourth wall entirely. And then we're back to the studio scene where Yan Hai'an is basically apologizing with his body language while Mo Yisheng acts like a spoiled child on a sofa. The chapter ends on what feels like a cliffhanger—Yan Hai'an telling Sun Yan about the flight, and then... it cuts off mid-sentence. I have to read the next chapter immediately. This is how you maintain engagement. Every shift in tone, every pivot in emotion, every unresolved thread is pulling at me harder than the last.
... Read More
The dialogue in this book is quietly incredible and I want to highlight why. Look at this exchange: Yan Hai'an: "Are you alright?" Sun Yan: doesn't answer, turns away Yan Hai'an: "Hello?" still no answer Yan Hai'an: "I'm uncomfortable not seeing your face." Three lines. Three lines and you understand everything about Sun Yan's inability to be vulnerable, and Yan Hai'an's patient persistence. The dialogue never over-explains. Sun Yan's lines are short, almost clipped — "Is there any discomfort?" "Does it still hurt?" He speaks in care, never in feeling. But Yan Hai'an? He cuts straight through. "It won't hurt if you kiss me." That's not just dialogue, that's a character definition in one sentence. And then the ending of the excerpt where Sun Ling says "this thank you is really hard to say" — that's the narrator's voice doing something different, more grounded, more frustrated, more real. Each character has a distinct register. Sun Yan's voice is physical action disguised as speech. Yan Hai'an's voice is emotional honesty disguised as casual observation. And Sun Ling? He's the only one who says exactly what he means, even when it's awkward. That's three completely different ways of loving and communicating, all in one scene.
... Read More
There are some genuinely cinematic moments in this passage and I want to highlight how the author uses physical space to tell emotional stories. The police station exterior is painted with just two details: 'A bunch of headlights illuminated his feet. Liang Tian woke from his thoughts and walked down the steps.' That's it. No description of the building, no procedural details. Just light on feet and the sound of a car approaching. It's filmmaking-level economy and it works because we already know what a police station FEELS like. The author doesn't waste our time. Inside the car is where the staging really shines. Three large men in the back seat of what the narrator calls 'a big car with five seats' — the physical comedy of it is undeniable but so is the emotional truth. Yan Hai'an sandwiched between Sun Yan and Mo Yisheng, unable to escape either of them, forced to breathe the same air. The car becomes a pressure cooker where proximity forces honesty that neither would risk in a larger space. The burning painting scene — though we only see it through someone else's eyes — is rendered through sound and color. 'Thick black smoke rose from the canvas.' The visual of dark smoke against whatever the gallery walls were is stark and memorable. It's the kind of image that sticks with you because it's violent but controlled, intentional but chaotic. Even the mother's absence is a kind of worldbuilding. We never meet Li Weiwei but the narrator's aside about her 'brain circuit' tells us everything we need to know about Mo Yisheng's family dynamic. A mother who supports radical decisions without question — that's a character drawn in a single brushstroke.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the daisies. They're not just a prop—they're the whole thesis statement of this passage dressed up as a little flower arrangement. Let me trace the symbolism: The daisies arrive at the front desk, 'plain cute little flowers' wrapped in kraft paper. They're compared unfavorably to 'delicate beauty of those bouquets'—which, honestly, sounds a LOT like how the art world treats Mo Yisheng versus the established, polished artists. Daisies are everyday. Accessible. Unpretentious. Exactly the kind of art that gets dismissed in gallery spaces. Yan Hai'an saves them from being thrown away. He chooses the green vase—green, natural, understated. He puts them at the front desk where everyone can see them. This is an act of defiance against the hierarchy of value that the art world represents. Then—a week later—they've withered. 'No matter how well-cared for the flowers, the flowers will still wither away.' Nature doesn't care about your intentions. Care doesn't guarantee permanence. But Yan Hai'an's response isn't grief or frustration; it's practical. 'Let's sort this out. I'll go buy another bunch later.' Because he's 'used to seeing flowers here before.' The ritual matters more than the individual arrangement. Meanwhile, Li Qing is trying to 'preserve' Mo Yisheng by packaging him into an association—essentially putting him in a fancy vase with a price tag. But unlike the daisies, Mo Yisheng isn't a decoration. He's a living, breathing artist who 'rides a bicycle around to ease his mind.' You can't frame him. You can't associate him. You can only protect him by letting him be himself. The crumpled cards thrown in the trash? Those are the labels, the certificates, the provenance documents—the things people use to assign value that have nothing to do with actual worth. I think the book is asking: what do we preserve, and why? And whether preservation through control is really preservation at all.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one passage because it's sitting in my head rent-free: > "They were speeding at high speed, passing through the tunnel that was surrounded by verdant mountains. The sky changed colour at once. A thick layer of grey clouds covered the sky and it looked like it might rain at any time." This is such a small moment in the plot—just travel, getting from point A to point B—but the author turns it into this entire mood piece. You can feel the car moving, the mountains closing in, the sky literally darkening like the story itself is bracing for impact. Three hours of driving replacing what should have been one hour? That's not just geography, that's narrative padding built into the world. The road gets longer because something important is approaching. And contrast that with the jewellery store scene—brash, loud, Sun Yan demanding the heaviest gold bracelet like a cartoon villain who just discovered wealth. The tonal whiplash between those two scenes is kind of masterful. One is quiet tension wrapped in storm clouds, the other is comedic extravagance. Both tell you everything about where this relationship is headed.
... Read More
Sun Ling, bro really said 'I see two people coming out of the same room together, I have questions, but I will watch calmly and wait.' This man is a saint. A literally broken-hearted saint. The scene where he shows up downstairs eating shredded chicken porridge and immediately pivots to 'Ah, isn't this the one from last time?' is peak sibling energy. He's testing the waters, trying to figure out what the actual deal is between his brother and this guy, and both of them immediately bolt. Sun Yan rushes out, Yan Hai'an rushes out. Sun Ling is left there like 'I just wanted to know if someone wanted to eat breakfast with me??' But the real character moment here is Sun Yan's shift regarding Mo Yisheng. Remember how he used to be 'shocked when he saw Mo Yisheng for the first time and wanted to take him to his bed'? Now he thinks about Mo Yisheng's face and it's 'not pleasing to the eye anymore.' This is huge. This isn't just jealousy—this is genuine emotional displacement. Yan Hai'an has replaced someone Sun Yan was physically attracted to, and he did it without even trying. That's the kind of character development that doesn't need a thousand pages of internal monologue. One sentence does the work. And Yan Hai'an himself—rushing back to buy breakfast for Mo Yisheng after spending the night with Sun Yan. The guilt, the division, the fact that he still feels obligated to perform care for someone who clearly doesn't prioritize him equally. 'Mo Yisheng got the inspiration and returned to City B first, leaving Yan Hai'an alone to deal with everything.' Who leaves their partner alone at the end of a five-city tour?? I'm angry on Yan Hai'an's behalf and I don't even know him.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—Yan Jin is such a complicated kid and I literally felt SO bad for him. He shows up looking embarrassed, biting his lip, obviously struggling to even bring himself to ask for help. And then he just... explodes. All those words about how his dad worked extra shifts while Yan Hai'an was studying, how the family went poor because of him—it hit me like a truck. This isn't just a bratty teen being entitled. This is a kid who watched his family suffer and he genuinely believes his brother caused it. And yet. Yan Hai'an just... takes it all. Calmly. Smiles. Offers him fruit. The man is impossibly patient. But then Sun Yan swoops in and quietly solves EVERYTHING without even telling Yan Hai'an first. And Yan Hai'an's reaction when he finds out—just looking at Sun Yan silently—and then Sun Yan acting like a giant golden retriever waiting for praise?! UGH I love them. The way Sun Yan lies and says 'your husband is very powerful' while practically purring... Yan Hai'an tolerates that word which he normally wouldn't, and honestly it makes me realize how much he's grown since the beginning of this whole thing. Also Sun Yan's line about Yan Haijian not having a say in their relationship was surprisingly sharp for such a playful scene. He's soft for Yan Hai'an but don't cross him.
... Read More
This author's dialogue is sharp as hell. I don't think I've ever read a more perfectly calibrated opening line in a romance novel than "I come here to sleep with you." Not seductive, not romantic, just... matter-of-fact. Sun Yan doesn't even bother with small talk. He shows up at midnight and says exactly what he means. And the way Yan Hai'an responds is just as good. His internal monologue — "Yes, who was that person, I would like to know too" — that self-criticism where he calls himself out for being the one who said he missed Sun Yan to death? That's the kind of dry, self-aware humor that makes characters feel three-dimensional. He's too proud to admit it directly but his actions betray him completely. The breakfast exchange is pure comedy gold too: "You waited so long and this is what you're serving me?" — Sun Yan demandingfried noodles because the alternative was potato chips. "Eat less junk food." — the ultimate caretaker line delivered with zero emotion. "So I miss you when I'm full of warmth and lust." — AND HE SAYS THAT OUT LOUD. No filter. Just raw, unapologetic honesty wrapped in absurdity. And Yan Hai'an doesn't even have a response. "..." Yeah, we've all been there. Sun Ling's voice on the phone cuts through everything like a knife. Angry but restrained. "Did you already get on top of that person?" The crudeness of it, the bluntness, shows what kind of family dynamics are happening behind the scenes. Every character has a distinct voice here and that's rare. Also, who needs Su Yin to bring clothes from City B to City S? The absurdity of it made me laugh out loud.
... Read More
Let me just say this — the way this novel handles domestic space is quietly masterful and I don't think enough people are talking about it. The Sun family home. Two brothers. Parents dead. A housekeeper who is young and pretty with light makeup and a sweet voice that Sun Ling immediately has replaced because... why? Because someone stayed overnight? The text says "The two brothers of the Sun family did not like too many people in their home" and this detail about the housekeeper replacement hits differently when you realize it's not just about rules — it's about control. Sun Ling is trying to maintain order in a world that lost its center. And Sun Yan's bedroom. God, the bedroom. "You didn't even open the window to let out the smell." This single line does SO much worldbuilding. It tells us about neglect, about a room that hasn't been lived in properly, about a young man who has stopped performing the basic rituals of self-care. The house opposite — bought specifically as a party house, a place for Sun Yan to "take people home" — this is Sun Ling's way of giving his brother freedom while simultaneously monitoring him. Two villas. Connected but separate. The architecture itself is a metaphor for their relationship. Then there's Yan Hai'an's workplace. The front desk. The little sister who doesn't understand the flowers. The contrast between the sterile, normal office environment and the chaotic emotional undercurrents happening in the private spaces — it creates this beautiful tension between public composure and private unraveling. The author lets the settings breathe and tell stories without needing heavy narration.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or