I need to talk about this scene with Xu Hang and Gu Fangfei because the subtext was absolutely suffocating in the best way possible.
On paper, this is just a polite visit between two people who've known each other for a bit. He brings her cosmetic prescriptions. She offers tea and snacks and even asks the maid to bring out a thin goose-down blanket because it's cold — details like that matter, okay? She's paying attention to him. And then they talk for HOURS. Astronomy, geography, current events, politics. The narrator specifically calls out that she expected him to be conservative given his upbringing, and instead he was "omniscient" and "very open-minded." That's not just worldbuilding — that's the beginning of attraction disguised as intellectual compatibility.
But then the jewelry. The necklace he'd already sent her, and the earrings he "forgot" to include last time. Wait — forgot? Or intentionally withheld so he'd have a reason to come back? Because he definitely had time now. And when the necklace breaks — her fault, her accident, her grief — his reaction is immediate comfort and an almost eager offer to fix it. He doesn't hesitate. He doesn't say "it's fine, don't worry about it" and leave it at that. He says he KNOWS a craftsman, he'll go himself, and he'll bring it back. Two or three hours. In the dark.
The way Gu Fangfei keeps apologizing — "it's all my fault," "wasting your kindness" — versus the way Xu Hang keeps deflecting, minimizing, taking responsibility... it's classic. But it's also genuinely tender. Neither of them is saying what they mean, and that's exactly why it's working. The tension isn't romantic confession; it's in the spaces between everything they're not saying.
And then there's Ruan Xiaodie, entering the scene in full force. Dressed up, perfumed, applying nail polish, putting on her peach-red jacket — she deserves a good day, the text says. But she's walking into a room full of cigarette smoke and a man who's lost enough. Her opening line as she plays the pipa — "The poor servant, panting and heartbroken, coughing and tears welling" — that song choice is not accidental. She's performing sorrow while maintaining a smile that doesn't reach her eyes. I don't know her story yet, but I already feel bad for her.
The emotional landscape of these chapters is devastating and beautiful in equal measure. Three different women, three different kinds of survival, and one man caught somewhere in between. I'm not ready for this book to end and I barely know these people.