Let me just say — the dialogue in these chapters is EXCEPTIONAL and I need to unpack why.
First, there's Xu Hang's voice and it's SO distinct. When he says "You killed Cong Wei, not because of jealousy, right?" — that's not a question, that's a statement wrapped in a question. He already knows. He's giving Cong Lin an opening to admit it on his own terms. And look how Cong Lin responds:
"If my sister truly loved Duan Zhanzhou, I'd not be willing to go that far. But… she tried to kill him. My foolish sister fell for an old man who saw us as nothing more than tools… she was so naive."
Notice the deflection. He's blaming the sister's naivety, not his own actions. He's framing himself as the victim of circumstance, not the architect of violence. And Xu Hang immediately calls him on it:
"Actually, Duan Zhanzhou didn't sleep with Cong Wei, but you did, right?"
"You did, right?" — three words that carry the weight of an entire investigation. Xu Hang doesn't need evidence. He just needs Cong Lin to admit it out loud.
The dialogue between these two has this incredible rhythm. Xu Hang is methodical, clinical even — talking about pulse-reading, medical conditions, historical texts about sleepwalking. He approaches the truth like a detective. But then when it comes to the emotional truth, he's completely unguarded:
"Cong Lin, Duan Zhanzhou likes you."
Not "I think" or "maybe." Just stated as fact. Like he's delivering news, not offering comfort. Because to him, it's just information. The most important information in the world, but information nonetheless.
And Cong Lin's responses are so beautifully broken. Every time Xu Hang gets close to the truth, Cong Lin pulls back:
"Young Master Xu, even if I'm dying, I won't be this pitiful either, you don't have to coax me…"
"Even if everyone in the world died, he would not be happy…"
He can't accept the possibility of being loved. It's like his emotional vocabulary only has words for betrayal and sacrifice. Love isn't in his dictionary.
The narrative voice is also doing some serious work here. That passage about sleepwalking with the reference to the "Autumn Lantern Collection" is such a specific choice by the author — grounding a modern (well, Republican-era) story in classical Chinese literature. It gives the whole thing this sense of historical weight, like this pattern of restless dreaming and unconscious desire has been repeating itself for centuries.
"In reality, even if Duan Zhanzhou had been awake, Cong Lin knew that if he didn't want to, Duan Zhanzhou couldn't have truly forced him. In the end, with the tacit approval of both sides, one was willing to fight, and the other was willing to be beaten."
That line — "one was willing to fight, and the other was willing to be beaten" — is one of the most erotically charged sentences I've read in this novel and it's describing a sleepwalking encounter. The author's ability to convey desire through implication rather than explicit description is remarkable.
The whispered exchange between siblings is also worth noting:
"Run away, Sister."
"No."
"Can you not kill him?"
"I can't."
Four lines. Four words. A whole relationship compressed into shorthand. This is dialogue at its most economical and most devastating.