Give Me Back My First Love! - Reviews

Give Me Back My First Love!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What I love about the conflict here is how layered it is. On the surface, it's simple: Hazel just slept with her first love and now she has to see him every day at work and pretend nothing happened. But the stakes keep escalating with every paragraph. First it's the internal conflict—her body betrayed her, her mind is confused, she's attracted to a man she's decided is a pervert. Then it's the external conflict—Vivian is circling like a shark, clearly suspicious, clearly protective, clearly about to make things worse. And then the biggest conflict of all: the one-year deadline. Enoch is going back to the Imperial Family in a year. A year of this tension, this pretending, this unbearable proximity. But here's the thing that makes the stakes so high—Hazel thinks she's just going to endure it. She thinks she can survive a year of avoiding him and then it's over. But the reader can see what she can't: that she's already completely entangled. The stakes aren't just about surviving the next year. The stakes are about what happens when she realizes she doesn't WANT to survive it—she wants more. And what happens when Enoch Meyer, the man who seemed so casually destructive, starts showing signs of actually caring? That's the real suspense. That's the thread pulling at me.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes, because this text makes you CARE about outcomes in ways I didn't expect. On the surface, the conflict is straightforward: Hazel vs. Enoch, victim vs. predator, morality vs. desire. But the brilliance is in how the author complicates every single layer of that binary. Hazel is NOT a passive victim here, even when she's being physically dominated. She's making choices—tiny, terrified choices, but choices nonetheless. And that changes everything about the stakes. The internal conflict is where the real tension lives. Every time Hazel says she wants to stop, her body says something else. Every time she surrenders to pleasure, a voice in her head screams betrayal. That war between mind and body isn't resolved—it's amplified. And the author makes us feel every single volt of that voltage. But here's what I found most compelling: the stakes aren't just about whether Hazel will "win" or "lose." They're about who she becomes in the process. Will she remain the girl who clings to idealized memories? Or will she accept that desire is messier and more complicated than any first love fantasy ever promised? The answer to that question matters more to me than any traditional plot outcome. The external stakes are present too—the risk of discovery, the public nature of their act, the violation of social norms. But honestly? Those feel secondary to the internal stakes. The real danger isn't getting caught by other students. It's getting caught by HERSELF. Seeing yourself clearly for the first time, even when that clarity is devastating. What keeps me gripped throughout is the uncertainty of Hazel's agency. Is she choosing this? Is she being chosen FOR? The text refuses to give us a straight answer, and that refusal IS the conflict. Every reader will land somewhere different on that spectrum, and I respect that deeply. The tension never drops because the fundamental question never resolves: can something be simultaneously violating and liberating? The text doesn't answer—it makes you feel the impossibility of answering.
... Read More
Vanessa's dialogue alone is worth the price of admission. This woman walks into her sister's home and within three lines has already seen through every lie Hazel tells. "You're bad at hiding things, so stop trying." And Hazel's response—pretending she's just tired from overtime at work, the Academy excuse that's so transparent Vanessa doesn't even push further. Their dynamic is effortless. You can tell these two have known each other since birth and there's a whole language built between them that needs no translation. "Anyone would think you raised me." / "I practically did." I screeched. That exchange is so casual but it carries decades of history. Vanessa isn't just Hazel's sister; she's a co-conspirator in her upbringing, someone who shaped her and still checks on her despite pretending not to care. And the Enoch mention—Vanessa brings him up casually through her husband's gossip network. "I heard from my husband that Lord Meyer is working as a professor at the Academy." That's how she operates. Information flows through her like water. She tests Hazel with a simple "Is there anyone you're seeing?" and when Hazel shuts her down, Vanessa drops it without missing a beat. Meanwhile Enoch's dialogue is this cold, flat monotone that contrasts perfectly. "I'm doing it because I want to." / "I'm doing it because I'm turned on." He speaks like he's stating facts about the weather, not confessing sexual aggression. The voice distinction between these characters is razor-sharp and it makes every interaction crackle.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author controls time in these chapters because it's genuinely brilliant. Chapter 17 starts with physical comedy - Hazel spilling juice everywhere, getting lost in her own hometown, the whole absurd sequence of pride keeping her from admitting she doesn't know where she's going. Fast pace. Snappy dialogue. Then Chapter 18 slows to a crawl at the sunset spot. Minutes stretch into what feels like hours. The author makes us sit in that silence with them. Lets the ordinary conversation about the view carry the weight of everything unsaid. Then BAM - Chapter 19 drops us into a pub and the pacing shifts again. Drinking scene. Emotional unraveling. Hazel's breakdown about students that's really about something else entirely. The author knows we're hungry for more so they give us... more drinking. More frustration. More inability to communicate directly. What keeps me hooked isn't plot movement. It's the micro-tensions. That moment when Enoch looks at Hazel's lips without her noticing. The server placing drinks and both of them missing the clink. The three-finger order that Enoch immediately shuts down. Each beat is a small explosion of almost. The chapter break at the end of 19 with Hazel suddenly leaning in and Enoch leaning back is a cliffhanger that doesn't need drama. It's just two people hovering at the edge of something and the reader screaming at them to just do it already. The author trusts us to sit with that ache. Doesn't rush to resolve it. Just ends on the moment before everything changes.
... Read More
What happened to Enoch between the Academy and now?? Okay first of all, the man walked in wearing casual clothes with his shirt slightly open and UNKEPT HAIR and somehow that made Hazel's heart beat faster??? Like hello, she's falling for him AGAIN and I am witnessing it in real time. The contrast between his usual sharp, composed knight demeanor and this softer, almost vulnerable version he's showing here is fascinating. He's still the same flirtatious guy who enjoys flustering Hazel, but there's something gentler underneath now. His line 'Maybe spend some time together while we're at it' with that sly smile is giving MAJOR 'I know exactly what I'm doing and I'm enjoying this' energy. The man is shameless and I love it. But here's what got me — when Emily glared at him suspiciously, he didn't flinch. He just calmly pulled out his golden badge like it was nothing. Not defensive, not aggressive. Just... confident. The kind of confidence that comes from knowing your worth. But honestly? The most revealing moment was Hazel realizing her own heart was racing and immediately attributing it to his looks. '...It seemed his looks were indeed the main reason.' Liar. We all know it's not just his face. It's the history. The unspoken tension between them that's been building since the Academy. And Vanessa, bless her chaotic soul, has been patiently waiting for this moment to finally snap.
... Read More
“First loves are only beautiful when they remain as good memories.” I need to sit with this line for a moment because it completely destroyed me. Hazel says it to herself like a mantra, like if she repeats it enough times she will actually believe it. But the novel does not let her — and more importantly, it does not let me — off the hook that easily. The fact that she still watches him train with the sword makes my chest ache in a way I did not expect. She tells herself he is just her former love, but the novel shows us a woman who cannot look away. Her instinct and her reason are at war every single time he appears, and losing feels like the default state. When she sees him in the training yard, she forgets about work. She steps closer to the window. She lets herself remember the girl she used to be, the one who found quiet corners just to watch him without being seen. And then he turns his head. And smiles. The way she ducks, bangs her knee, curls into herself — that is not just fear. That is the violent collision between the girl who adored him and the woman he has become capable of harming. The physical pain of the knee slam is almost secondary to the emotional whiplash. She wanted to be seen by him as something tender, and instead he saw her watching him like a pervert — which of course ties back to the object on her shelf, which of course he uses to further mock and destabilize her. What haunts me most is the tenderness hiding underneath all of this. Enoch is abusive and manipulative, absolutely. But Hazel's love for him has not simply vanished. It has been corrupted, twisted into something painful, and yet it persists. That is what makes this emotional arc so devastating to read. It is not a clean story of victim and villain. It is a story about how love lingers long after it should leave, how memory and trauma braids together so tightly you cannot tell them apart anymore. The scene in the office — him locking the door, telling her no one will come, saying he'll “let her go” before her next lecture with that predatory smile — that is the kind of moment that stays with you. It made me physically uncomfortable in the best and worst way. I wanted to shake her. I wanted to hug her. I wanted to throw the book across the room.
... Read More
Oh my god, let's talk about this plot because it had me SCREAMING into my pillow. We start with Hazel completely devastated—her first love, this guy she's treasured for years, turns out to be some shameless creep who's exposing himself in a school? And he's dragging HER into it? That opening hit so hard, right? Like the betrayal alone would be enough to make anyone quit reading, but then the author just... escalates? What I love about how this unfolds is the deliberate destruction of Hazel's romantic fantasy. She's clinging to these beautiful, idealized memories of Enoch Meyer, and the entire first half of this chapter sequence is basically watching those memories die in real-time. Every touch, every word he says—it's this perversion of everything she thought she knew about him. But here's the thing that caught me off guard: the plot doesn't just stay in the horror zone. It pivots into this uncomfortable exploration of how desire and disgust can literally occupy the same body at the same time. The classroom setting itself is such a bold choice. A sacred space of education becoming this... den of sin? The author keeps reminding us of where they are—the desks, the silence, the absurdity of doing this in public. And Enoch's awareness of it makes everything seventeen times more intense. When he says "How does it feel to be an accomplice?" that line stuck with me like glue. It's not just about what's happening physically—it's about how complicity rewires your entire sense of self. By the end, Hazel has experienced something so overwhelming it shatters her understanding of who she even is. She thought she had low libido, she thought she knew what she wanted—and yet here she is, completely undone by the one person she should be running from. The plot doesn't give us easy answers or clean resolution. It leaves us with this terrifying question: what happens when the monster under your bed is also the only thing that makes you feel alive?
... Read More
'Living an ordinary life was her goal. Sure, living ordinarily might be the hardest thing to achieve, but wasn't that the life everyone wanted?' This line hit me like a truck. It's not just a throwaway character thought—it's the thematic core of the entire passage. Hazel wants to be ordinary. She wants the simple, boring, unremarkable life. But then she sleeps with the most extraordinary man in this world (heir to a marquisate, Imperial Knight, perfect in every way) and everything ordinary has gone out the window. The irony is suffocating. There's also this recurring motif of eyes throughout the text—Hazel's 'tear-filled crimson eyes,' Enoch's eyes that 'sparkled with a suspicious intensity,' his eyes that 'gleamed knowingly.' Eyes as windows to desire and power and the things we can't hide. And then there's the body itself as a traitor—her body responds even when her mind wants to resist, her body aches as permanent proof of what happened, her body drenching his clothes in ways she can't control. The body knows truths the mind refuses to accept. And the word 'accomplice' keeps echoing—she was coerced into complicity, dragged into his world. But complicity implies shared guilt, and the question becomes: who's really the accomplice here?
... Read More
Can we talk about this moment? Hazel is absolutely losing it—body wrecked, mind spinning—and Enoch looks down at her and says: "You can sleep. I'll handle everything." I genuinely gasped. Because on the surface it sounds absurd (she's literally unable to close her eyes), but underneath it's the most INTIMATE thing he could possibly say. He's not just talking about sex anymore. He's saying: I've got you. Rest. I won't hurt you. I'll take care of you even when you can't take care of yourself. The contrast is everything. He's being this rough, relentless lover but his words are GENTLE. And then—plot twist—he falls asleep too. Of course he does. Even in surrender, he's human. He's not some immortal powerhouse, he's just a guy who got carried away. But the REAL emotional gut-punch is waking up. Hazel's body aching, disoriented, thinking he abandoned her ('Did he leave me behind and go first?'). Her heart sinks. And there he is—clean, towel around his neck, teasing her about being hungover. He didn't leave. He CLEANED UP. He waited. He just... took care of her. "You said you'd wake me." "I was going to, but I fell asleep too. I couldn't help it." His playful smile makes it impossible to be mad. That's the CP chemistry I'm SCREAMING about. He knows exactly how to wound and heal her in the same breath.
... Read More
The tonal whiplash between these chapters is absolutely intentional and I am HERE for it. Chapter 13 opens with Hazel backed against a cold wall, nowhere to run, heart pounding between fear and anticipation. The spatial claustrophobia is palpable—she's pinned, pressed, trapped. Every detail zooms in: his gaze fixed on one spot, the firm grip on her jaw, the warm breath, the slick moisture. The camera stays tight on bodies and sensations until it's almost suffocating. Then Chapter 14 opens like... a vacation. Home. Family. Cherry pie that nobody in the capital can replicate. The space opens up enormously—from a corner of a room to an entire estate, from her body to her niece, from panic to the gentle rhythm of tea and conversation. "The family home, which she hadn't visited in a long time, was quiet and peaceful. Spending her holiday with Mrs. McFinn's expertly baked cherry pie was the perfect way to relieve stress." The contrast isn't accidental. This is the author showing us two worlds Hazel lives between: the oppressive, intoxicating reality with Enoch, and this sunlit refuge where life actually makes sense. Even small details ground us—the swing her father fixed himself, hammering every nail, the way he glares at his family because he doesn't know how to be soft. These aren't set dressing; they're emotional geography. And the dress Vanessa hands her, different from Hazel's usual modest outfits—that's a visual metaphor wrapped in fabric. She's being pushed out of hiding, into light, into a world where she might actually get to live instead of just survive.
... Read More
The pacing here is genuinely masterful and I need to talk about it. We go from an intense, extended intimate scene directly into the morning aftermath with zero breath. No cute fluffy morning-after breakfast, no soft focus montage. Just HARD CUT to Hazel waking up in pain, panicking, and shuffling to work. That structural choice is so deliberate—it mirrors exactly what Hazel is experiencing. There's no soft landing, no transition period, just the brutal collision of private desire with public life. And then the office scene? Perfect. Vivian's entrance gives us a breather, a moment of comic relief and social tension, and then Enoch appears and the pacing SLAMS back into high gear. The chapter ends on that cliffhanger of him standing in the doorway and Hazel frozen, and it's executed so smoothly I barely noticed the gears turning. The author trusts the reader to connect the dots between the intimate scene and the workplace confrontation without spelling out every emotional beat. Some writers would have added a whole scene of Hazel preparing mentally or rehearsing what to say. Instead we get her just... sitting there, thighs sore, pretending to review lecture materials, while her entire world has tilted on its axis. Tight as a drum.
... Read More
What makes this scene work on a CONFLICT level is that there are constant micro-resistances that never actually stop anything. They CREATE tension instead. Hazel says 'That's enough' while pulling him closer. She says 'It's my body—I know it better than anyone!' while letting him guide her hands. She hesitates before stepping on him, questioning everything, then says 'Fine. After everything we've done, what's there I can't do?' She's in pain during penetration but her body betrays her pleasure. She protests 'You said I could sleep!' while clearly not wanting it to stop. Every 'no' is actually a negotiation, and every negotiation DEEPENS the intimacy. That's the conflict engine here—not two people fighting against each other, but two people fighting against their own restraint, and losing beautifully. The stakes? They're not in danger of dying or losing money or anything externally dramatic. The stakes are EMOTIONAL. If she gives in, she can't pretend this is just physical anymore. If he lets go, he's admitting he needs her. Both of them are risking something real by letting the scene go this far. And the moment Hazel wakes up alone and thinks 'Did he leave me behind?'—that's the STAKES made VISIBLE. The worst fear isn't pain, it's abandonment. And the author answers it immediately: he didn't leave. He cleaned up. He's right there. The tension holds because neither character fully surrenders until they've already crossed every line. By the time Enoch says 'I'll handle everything,' we're already emotionally committed to both of them. There's no going back—and that's the point.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or