Give Me Back My First Love! - Reviews

Give Me Back My First Love!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing here is deceptively casual. On the surface it reads like a lighthearted chapter—Hazel venting, some comedic misunderstandings about titles and uniforms, the odd student gossip moment. But underneath, the tension is building like a pressure cooker, and the author knows exactly when to add fuel. The opening is deliberately fast-paced and almost chaotic. Hazel talks over Enoch, clamps her hand over his mouth, rants about students. It's breathless and energetic, which makes you think you're reading something light. Then she collapses. Shoulders trembling, crying into the table. That's the first beat drop. The energy goes from frantic to heavy, and suddenly the scene has weight. But the real pacing masterstroke is what happens next. Enoch doesn't immediately escalate things. He gives her water. He touches her cheek gently. He asks about the students like he's genuinely trying to understand her world. The author lets the quiet moments breathe—which makes the moment when Hazel says "I remember everything I did with you" hit even harder because you're caught off guard after all that gentle pacing. From there, the pace accelerates naturally but never feels rushed. Each action flows from the last: the drink, the hand squeeze, the carrying, the door, the water, the touch, the dress, the undressing, the kiss. There are no sudden jumps or time skips that make you feel lost. The chapter moves from public to private, from words to actions, from restraint to surrender—and each transition feels earned. Chapter 21 continues this momentum without resetting. Hazel initiates. She doesn't hesitate. The pacing here is almost breathless again, but it's a different kind of breathless—not the frantic energy of the beginning, but the breathless intensity of someone who's finally stopped fighting themselves.
... Read More
"You should wear them more often. Aren't there lots of handsome men in the capital?" — Vanessa saying this felt less like advice and more like a prophecy. Let me unpack the dress itself for a second. Hazel hasn't worn something like this since her Academy graduation. That's not arbitrary. A graduation marks a transition — from student to professional, from one chapter to the next. Vanessa essentially dressed Hazel in the clothes of someone ready to begin something new. And what happens next? She runs into the person she used to like. Coincidence? I don't think so. The dress becomes a symbol of vulnerability and openness, both emotional and physical. Hazel feels exposed in it, yes, but also... hopeful? Even if she won't admit it to herself. Then there's the badge. Gold, shiny, authoritative. Enoch offering it to Emily like currency rather than a symbol of rank is interesting — he's essentially saying 'my status guarantees this interaction is safe.' It's transactional trust, which is kind of bleak when you think about it. Money and position buying human connection. But also... the badge represents the world Enoch came from, the institutional power that separates him from Hazel's quiet, modest life. When he wears casual clothes instead of his knight uniform, he's deliberately stepping out of that framework. The visual contrast says everything. And the hometown itself — changed, developed, barely recognizable yet deeply familiar. Growth without loss of identity. Hazel leaning back on that bench feeling peace despite all the chaos... it's a moment of stillness before the storm.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is doing SO MUCH work. Enoch's line delivery is peak manipulative charm — 'Professor Hoover, you're very kind, even to people you're not close with.' He's absolutely mocking her but she can't prove it because on the surface it sounds like genuine praise. His voice shifts so naturally from cold to warm in one breath: 'What's wrong all of a sudden?' the concern sounding real but making her want to retreat further. The contraceptive sigil conversation is comedic gold though. Hazel asking 'Did you use contraception last night?' with the gravitas of someone asking about nuclear codes, and Enoch responding like she just asked if the sky is blue. 'Well, since it halts certain bodily functions, it's effective.' Bro. She didn't ask for a biology lecture. And then 'If you want, I can show you' delivered with zero humor while immediately dropping his pants. The contrast between Hazel's frantic internal monologue and her outward composure is where the humor lives. Her inner voice is chaos — 'I asked to see the sigil, not for you to take off your pants!' while externally she's just forcing awkward laughs and trying to shoo him out. The fortune teller scene has such a distinct voice too — 'It's a bad luck banishing stick' said with such earnest salesperson energy. The narrator's voice itself is dry and self-aware, which makes Hazel's dramatic moments land perfectly.
... Read More
"Wouldn't it be a waste to throw it away?" He drank from the same spot her lips had touched. I'm still not over this. The author just casually drops this detail like it's nothing, but Hazel's entire internal monologue immediately spirals. She tells herself not to overthink it. She tells herself he probably didn't even think about it. But the fact that she has to tell herself that means she's absolutely thinking about it. And thinking about it HARD. This whole chapter is a masterclass in romantic tension built through tiny moments. Not grand declarations or dramatic confessions. Just... juice. A handkerchief wiping sticky fingers. Eyes locking across a sunset. The way Enoch's Adam's apple moves dramatically as he gulps down lukewarm juice like it's the most precious thing he's ever tasted. The absurdity of it! This is a man who could buy every fruit orchard in the region and he's treating expired juice like vintage wine. But here's what wrecked me - the pub scene. Hazel gets drunk and instead of confessing feelings or breaking down emotionally, she complains about students. She orders three more drinks like a teenager throwing a temper tantr üm. And Enoch just watches. Patient. Amused. Concerned all tangled together. When she suddenly leans in close and he coughs and leans back - that flinch! That's not rejection, that's panic. He's been holding onto something for years and now she's close enough to breathe and he's terrified. I swear the author wrote this scene knowing exactly what they were doing. Every touch, every glance, every awkward silence is loaded with fourteen years of unsaid words. And Hazel pretending she only invited him because it's proper etiquette while her heart is doing gymnastics... I couldn't breathe through half of this.
... Read More
The setting transitions in this section are really well done, almost invisibly. We start in what feels like a pub or tavern—servers passing by, coins changing hands, the kind of place where professors and aides would grab a drink after hours. The atmosphere is warm but slightly noisy, which explains why Hazel feels comfortable enough to lower her voice to "like the hum of an ant" when revealing the student scandal gossip. Then Enoch literally picks her up and carries her somewhere else. The destination is described as "feeling like a dormitory" but smaller. Hazel notes it's her place since her sister lent her the dress—this world has boarding arrangements, family support networks, a sense of community that makes the setting feel lived-in rather than just a backdrop. The fact that this feels like an Academy-adjacent environment ties back to Hazel's role as a professor, grounding the romantic scene in the story's institutional context. Inside the room, the sensory details do a lot of heavy lifting. Cool water on a flushed face. The rustle of silk. The sound of breath becoming audible because the room is small and quiet. Enoch's fingers fumbling with intricate dress knots—this is where the worldbuilding gets intimate, literally. The dress matters because it belongs to someone else (Vanessa), which means this isn't just a random encounter; Hazel has a life, relationships, responsibilities outside this bedroom. The lighting isn't explicitly described, but the atmosphere shifts from the public warmth of the tavern to something more enclosed and charged. There's a difference between being watched in a public space and being alone in a private one, and the author understands that. The bed, the bedside table, the closed door—these domestic details make the scene feel grounded rather than fantasy-escapist. It's a real room where real people are having a real moment. That's what makes it work.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this sequence is PLOT PERFECT. Like, the way the scene builds from slow, almost comedic teasing into something raw and unfiltered is chef's kiss. It starts with Enoch being all 'you need to relax more' while clearly NOT relaxing at all, which is already funny AND hot. Then Hazel kisses him, things escalate, clothes come off, and BAM—he asks her to step on him. That's a PLOT TWIST in a bedroom scene and I am HERE FOR IT. What I love is how it doesn't feel like filler. Every beat serves the relationship arc. The stepping-on thing isn't just shock value—it's Enoch revealing a vulnerability, a hidden desire he's never shown before. It changes the dynamic COMPLETELY. Hazel goes from reactive to dominant in that moment, and it flips everything we thought we knew about their power balance. And then after? He says 'I'll wake you up' while literally going wild on her. That contradiction IS the plot. He's trying to be sweet but can't help himself, which makes him so human. Waking up sore and alone, then seeing him fresh from the shower—that's the emotional payoff. The aftercare moment. It tells us everything about where they are in this relationship.
... Read More
'But Enoch Meyer was a pervert who masturbated in his office. Not only that, but he was also a pervert who dragged an innocent person into his act.' I literally screamed at my phone reading this. The emotional whiplash in this passage is insane. Hazel is simultaneously furious, embarrassed, traumatized, and also—let's be real—completely turned on just thinking about it again. The author writes this gorgeous little moment where Hazel is cataloging all the reasons she should despise him and then immediately undercuts it with 'But really, it was… incredible.' She's fighting herself and losing and she KNOWS she's losing. What killed me was the line: 'She never thought, even for a moment, that she would become someone special to him after just one night.' That's not just self-deprecation, that's genuine emotional wounds showing through. Meanwhile Enoch is over there being unexpectedly gentle—helping her stand, fixing her clothes, escorting her home—and Hazel is over here building this entire narrative of him as this irredeemable pervert when clearly she's the one whose heart is doing gymnastics. The CP chemistry is off the charts because neither of them are acting rationally and the reader is sitting there like 'JUST TALK TO EACH OTHER.'
... Read More
The dress isn't just clothing—it's a symbol of everything Hazel is trying to hold together. Her sister lent it to her. She took it seriously enough to protect it with her life when Enoch wanted to tear it off. And yet, in the end, it comes off anyway. The knot-by-knot undoing mirrors the knot-by-knot undoing of her composure. Each button, each tied string represents something she's been holding onto: professionalism, propriety, the careful distance she's maintained. There's a parallel between the dress's complicated design and Hazel's complicated emotions. Both require patience to unravel. Both resist force—that's why Enoch sighs and decides to take it slow instead of just pulling. The dress slips down "effortlessly" once the knots are loosened, just like Hazel's resistance melts away once she stops fighting her own feelings. Then there's the water. Cool water on a flushed, wine-warm face. It's a literal and figurative moment of clarity. Hazel's mind is foggy from alcohol, and the water clears it just enough for her to realize what she wants. It's a small detail but it's doing thematic work—the tension between intoxication and sobriety, between impulse and intention. The title confusion at the beginning—Hazel calling Enoch "Commander" when he's actually the aide—isn't just comic relief. It's about perception versus reality, about how we see people and how they see themselves. Hazel sees the grandeur of the Imperial Knight Order and projects that authority onto Enoch. But Enoch corrects her quietly, firmly. He doesn't want the title; he wants her to see him clearly. And when she finally does—when she remembers everything they shared—that's the moment the projection falls away and they're just two people, no titles, no ranks. The recurring theme of memory versus forgetting runs throughout. Hazel wants to forget the student incidents but can't. Enoch remembers everything Hazel has done. Memory becomes a form of intimacy—in what you hold onto, in what you refuse to let go.
... Read More
There's something genuinely funny about Hazel trying to maintain her composure around Enoch while simultaneously being completely unable to help herself. She's this professor who's supposed to be all dignified, talking about students and propriety, but she's also just a girl who gets flustered by a man's touch. And Enoch? He's playing a different game entirely. The way Enoch handles this situation is fascinating. He's all controlled movements—removing her hand gently from his mouth, taking her glass and drinking it in one gulp, commanding her to "get up" like he's done this a hundred times. But then you see the internal monologue: the part where he's consciously trying to suppress his attraction, telling himself he needs to put in extra effort because their start was rocky. That tells me he's been thinking about her for a while. What really got me though was Hazel's admission: "I remember everything I did with you, too." That line landed like a physical blow. It's the moment where her professional facade completely cracks. She's been rambling about student scandals to fill the silence, and then she just drops this bomb. You can feel the shift in the room. Enoch's restraint snaps right there. Their dynamic is one part comedic bickering, one part genuine tenderness. When he scoops her up because she's stumbling, that's not just practical—it's almost protective. And Hazel? She lets him. She pulls him toward her instead of pushing away. The fact that she initiated the kiss in Chapter 21 tells me something important: underneath all this hesitation, she wants this just as much as he does. They're not perfect for each other, but they're honest. That's worth something.
... Read More
The sunset scene at the viewpoint is one of those passages that just... glows on the page. Red light pouring over Enoch's face, highlighting features that are already striking enough without assistance. Hazel moving the handkerchief slightly further away before sitting down - five words that tell us everything about her boundaries and her fears. But what struck me most was the pub. How does a secluded pub exist in the middle of nowhere? The text says Hazel glanced around "as if wondering how such a secluded pub could exist" and I love that the narrator doesn't explain it either. Some worlds just have magic in their margins. A road upstream from a marketplace, a river leading to a hidden drinking hole where old classmates can disappear together. The walk there matters too. Gentle breeze. Humming unconsciously. Nostalgia for happier times. These aren't set pieces the author built for description's sake. They're emotional weather. The breeze brushes Hazel's cheeks the same way Enoch's words brush her defenses. The chirping birds fill silence that would otherwise be unbearable. And that moment when Enoch spreads his handkerchief on the ground like a gentleman from another century while Hazel moves it away like she's creating a demilitarized zone - the visual comedy of it paired with the romantic tension is perfection. Two people who want the same thing but are playing by completely different rulebooks. The text also keeps returning to eyes. His gaze following hers. Her eyes demanding explanations. His lowered eyes making her flinch. Eyes as weapons, as promises, as landmines. Every look between them is a scene within the scene.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or