Give Me Back My First Love! - Reviews

Give Me Back My First Love!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so here is the thing about this batch of chapters and why I cannot stop thinking about how the author constructs tension like a tightening noose. Chapter 11 opens with Hazel already in distress — the grotesque object returned to her bedside table, impossible and inexplicable. She rationalizes it away like a tired adult pretending nothing is wrong, throws it out again, goes to work. The Academy is bright and lively, almost mocking in its normalcy. And then Enoch appears. Not dramatically bursting through the door, but simply there, leaning against her podium, borrowing paper and a pen like a normal person. The horror is in how casually he invades her space. The lecture scene itself is where the pacing becomes exquisite. The author forces us to stay in Hazel's limited perspective the entire time. We see what she sees. We notice what she notices — that suspicious hand movement under the desk — and then she looks away because the alternative is too much to process. The bell ringing and her fleeing to the faculty office feels like the first exhale after holding your breath for twenty pages. But it is immediately undercut by Philip walking in and dumping his workload on her. Because of course it is. Then Chapter 12 escalates everything. The door bursts open. She screams. Enoch is there, and the “bad luck banishing stick” on her bookshelf becomes the pivot point for his entire power play over her. The pacing shifts from psychological unease to near-violent confrontation, and the chapter ends mid-struggle with Hazel pinned, defenseless, and Enoch saying something that clearly means something far worse than “leaving her alone.” What is remarkable here is that the author never lets us rest. Every scene contains a nested threat. The object returns home. Enoch attends her lecture. Philip exploits her. Hazel watches Enoch train and gets caught. Enoch finds the object. He locks the door. And the chapter cuts before we know what happens next. This is serial narrative craft at its most effective — each cliffhanger compounds the anxiety from the last one rather than resetting it. By the end of Chapter 12, I needed air. I genuinely needed to stop and walk around.
... Read More
This is the part where Hazel tries to justify not having feelings for Enoch and I was RIGHT THERE WITH HER doing the mental gymnastics. She goes through this whole internal speech about class differences — Hoover Earldom vs Meyer Marquisate, political alliances, the Crown Prince connection, all of it. She's building this logical wall. And then she admits: 'His face alone was enough to cancel out all his flaws, including being a deviant.' DEVIAN. T. And the physical compatibility she casually references? She literally spent paragraphs describing how good that night was. She wanted to wait. She opened the door. She KNEW. And yet here she is, still liking him. The fortune teller scene hits even harder in retrospect — the woman says 'It's fate' and Hazel almost believes it. The bad luck banishing stick? The most aggressively symbolic moment in the entire book. Hazel is literally being given a phallic talisman to ward off bad luck while her worst nightmare and best dream are the same person. When she shouts 'Why does he have to be a deviant!' at nobody on the street — that's not just frustration, that's grief. She's grieving the fact that the man she liked years ago just got reincarnated as the man she wants now. And she hates that growing up means admitting your romantic ideals were naive.
... Read More
Okay so the office scene where Enoch shows up uninvited? Hazel tries to hand him the key and pretend nothing happened, but he literally blocks her path. And then he closes that drawer she forgot to shut properly — creaky hinges, which the narration immediately calls out as foreshadowing. That is NOT a subtle author move but honestly? It worked. The power dynamic here is so juicy. He hears her gossiping about him, makes this soft smile that doesn't reach his eyes, and she's sitting there trying to play it cool while internally screaming. Then the contraceptive sigil reveal — she asks the boldest question of her life and he basically says oh that's cute you're worried. The fact that he casually mentions having this sigil engraved when he joined the Imperial Knights shows how routine this all is for him. One night for Hazel was devastating. For him? Probably Tuesday. And then he offers to show her the sigil and immediately starts unbuttoning his pants like it's the most normal thing in the world. Hazel's silent scream? I felt that. The whole thing just highlights how differently they process intimacy — his casual physicality versus her flustered vulnerability. She's trapped in this position where she has to endure him for a year, and he knows it.
... Read More
"Please, give me back my beautiful first love!" Hazel's silent prayer to the heavens broke me. This woman spent an entire night (and more) with the person she once adored, and her immediate thought isn't anger or confusion—it's grief for the version of him she fell for as a girl. The noble face. The one she held onto through years of longing. And Enoch just... sits there. Flush but composed. Serious. Like she's a masterpiece he's studying. "His face was strangely flushed, his expression serious as though he were admiring a masterpiece." That line hit me like a truck. He's looking at her with this intense, almost reverent expression during something so violating, and the disconnect between how he sees her and how she experiences him is devastating. She wants her first love back but the man before her is someone entirely different—calm, deliberate, and utterly unaware that his touch destroys whatever innocence she had left. Then we cut to cherry pie. Vanessa asking if she has someone. Hazel lying. The whole scene is drenched in this melancholy where Hazel is surrounded by family and warmth but carrying this secret so heavy she can barely sit still. "A lot of things had piled up indeed. Not only had she reunited with her first love, but she had also discovered a deeply private secret." The contrast between that domestic sweetness and her internal turmoil is chef's kiss. I literally felt her exhaustion.
... Read More
Okay, I need to process what just happened with these two characters because my brain is still reeling. Hazel is such a fascinating wreck. On one level, she's doing everything a 'normal' person would do—she's angry, she's hurt, she's trying to resist. She literally thinks about slapping him multiple times. But here's where it gets complicated: every time she tries to pull away, her own body betrays her. And that's not played for cheap thrills, it's played as genuine psychological terror. She's watching herself lose control in real-time, and the horror on her face isn't just about the act—it's about losing agency over her own reactions. And Enoch? God, Enoch is terrifying AND fascinating. This isn't just some generic dom character. The text gives us this moment—this tiny, almost gentle moment—where he says "I'll go as slowly as I can. If you don't like it, hit me." Like... what? You just raped her memory of him five minutes ago and now you're asking for consent like a good boy? But here's the thing that keeps me up at night: does he actually mean it? Is he genuinely afraid of hurting her, or is this part of the performance? The power dynamic between them is absolutely poisonous in the best way. He knows exactly what buttons to push because he literally wrote the manual on her desires years ago. Every touch is informed by their history—even if that history was built on lies or misunderstandings. When he asks her to look at him, to witness what he's doing to her body, it's almost intimate in a way that makes me uncomfortable just writing about it. But the most disturbing part? Her willingness to keep going. Not because she's been convinced it's okay—it's because somewhere beneath all that outrage, there's a part of her that recognizes this as something real. Something raw. The first love fantasy dies, but something else is born in its place, and it's far more honest and far more dangerous.
... Read More
"That man's status is guaranteed, so you don't need to worry. He's the man Hazel likes." Okay, I NEED to talk about Vanessa because this woman is playing some absolutely diabolical chess and I am HERE for it. She literally sets up the entire encounter with Enoch like it's some kind of elaborate match-making operation. The fact that she PRE-INSTRUCTED Emily before they even left the mansion — 'find a way to slip away discreetly' — means this wasn't spontaneous at all. Vanessa had been planning this. Planning for Hazel and Enoch to end up alone together. And the chilling part? Hazel has ZERO idea what's happening. The scene where Emily gets handed that golden badge and then just... leaves? Chef's kiss. The badge as a tool to buy off the only witness who could stop this from happening? That's manipulative brilliance. Hazel is standing there losing her mind internally while Emily walks away with a smile, and Enoch is over there acting all innocent like 'I'm just asking you to show me around.' Meanwhile the reader is screaming because we KNOW Vanessa orchestrated this. The dramatic irony is THICK. And don't even get me started on the list of items Enoch needs. The Crown Prince sent an Imperial Knight to a remote countryside to find... what exactly? Some fruit? This has 'plot device' written all over it. What is he really looking for? The narrative is clearly setting something bigger in motion and I am hooked.
... Read More
Can we just talk about the dialogue in this for a second because I am obsessed? Like, I know this is an erotic romance and the primary function of dialogue might seem secondary, but the author clearly put serious thought into how these characters speak—and more importantly, how they SILENCE each other. Enoch's dialogue is this terrifying mix of command and vulnerability that never quite lands on solid ground. "Look at me. You need to see who made me like this, don't you?" That line has to be one of the most beautiful and horrifying things I've read all year. It's possessive, yes—but it's also almost... pleading? Like he wants her to witness this transformation, to be complicit in it, to acknowledge that he became this because of something between them. And Hazel? Her dialogue is fragmented, broken, barely coherent. She goes from full sentences of moral outrage to single syllables of pleasure to complete wordless noise. That progression IS the character arc. The author shows us her breakdown through speech patterns alone, and it's masterful. But what really struck me is the silences. The author uses pauses, incomplete thoughts, interrupted sentences so frequently that the gaps between words become almost as important as the words themselves. When Enoch whispers "Hazel, breathe"—that's not just instruction, it's this moment of genuine care cutting through the depravity. And when Hazel tries to say "wait" but it comes out as "ngh" instead? That single shift tells you everything you need to know about where she is emotionally. The internal monologues are where the voice really shines though. Hazel's thoughts are this chaotic mess of contradiction and self-reproach that feels so authentically female—in the best way. "Surely I wasn't about to forgive him simply because he was handsome, right?" That line made me laugh out loud because it's so petty and so human and so true. Every character has a distinct voice, even when they're barely speaking. Enoch is measured, deliberate, always three steps ahead. Hazel is reactive, emotional, drowning in sensation. And the narration? It's this lush, breathless thing that matches the physical intensity perfectly.
... Read More
"Something flickered in his eyes." That's it. That's the line that contains every conflict in this entire story. On the surface the stakes are tiny. Two adults walking around a countryside, getting lost, buying juice, drinking at a pub. Nothing life-or-death happening. But the author makes every small moment feel monumental because we know what's at risk. Not their lives. Their hearts. Their carefully constructed distance. Hazel's conflict is internal and it's exhausting to watch. She wants him. She's wanted him for years apparently. But she's also terrified that wanting him means weakness, means losing control, means becoming the girl at the Academy who got caught looking at him across a crowded room. So she performs competence. She leads him through town even though she's lost. She claims the errand is critical when it's not. She pretends the sunset spot is just polite hospitality. Enoch's conflict is quieter but just as dangerous. He's the one who held her waist十四 years ago and whispered about running away. He's the one who sent the maid away because he wanted solitude. He's the one watching her drink herself into honesty while he stays perfectly composed. His stake is the same - if he reaches for her now, he loses the careful equilibrium they've maintained. But if he doesn't reach, he loses her to someone else or to time itself. The pub scene raises the stakes to something almost violent. Hazel gets drunk and her walls crack. She's not performing anymore. She's just... raw. About students, about struggle, about everything she's swallowed for years. And Enoch has to decide: does he let her fall apart alone or does he step into that mess with her? His hand on her wrist is the answer before he speaks it.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Enoch because this man is a puzzle wrapped in a riddle dipped in chaos. He's pinned Hazel against the wall, doing things that would make anyone question their life choices, and his face? Completely calm. Not a single blink. He looks like he's admiring a painting, not tormenting someone with his hands. "I'm doing it because I'm turned on." SAYING THAT LIKE IT'S JUSTICE. Like it's a perfectly reasonable justification for assaulting someone against a wall during school hours. And Hazel's internal scream—"Please, give me back my beautiful first love!"—is honestly the most relatable reaction I've ever read. But here's what gets me: he brought that dildo to the professor's office WHERE STUDENTS COME AND GO. That is not a private stash. That is a statement. And then he leaves it because "there wasn't enough time" so she doesn't miss class? That's... that's some next-level twisted care. He's controlling her entire experience down to the minute while acting like nothing unusual is happening. The way Vanessa sees right through Hazel though—"You're bad at hiding things, so stop trying"—that's sister energy I respect. Vanessa is the only one in this entire text who operates on plain truth, and it makes every interaction with her feel like a breath of fresh air after the suffocating tension with Enoch.
... Read More
The white motif in these chapters is doing a lot of heavy lifting and I think most readers will gloss right over it. Enoch notices Hazel wears white. He assumes it's her favorite color because that's all he's seen. White throughout this narrative seems connected to purity, to the image Hazel projects—the composed professor, the dutiful daughter, the woman who never caused a scandal. But underneath that white exterior, her body betrays her. It responds. It trembles. It cries. "You like white, don't you?" / "It's not like that! I have other colors too!" This exchange is so much bigger than fashion preferences. Hazel is literally saying: I am not just what you see on the surface. I have complexity. I have depths you haven't mapped. And Enoch's response—"Ah, so you do have other colors"—is almost mocking in its gentleness. He's found something real beneath her performance. Then the dress Vanessa gives her, different from Hazel's usual modest outfits, becomes another layer of this theme. She's being dressed for a new version of herself, one that might actually step outside and live. The cherry pie—sweet, familiar, something no bakery in the capital can replicate—represents the homeland she runs back to when the world becomes too much. And Hazel swallowing the truth about what happened with Enoch every time someone asks if she's okay—that's the real symbolism. The things we can't say become the weight that makes us physically sick. Her silence isn't strength; it's a cage she built herself.
... Read More
I finished this chapter sequence and immediately needed to sit down because the pacing is absolutely BRUTAL—in the best possible way. The author starts with Hazel's internal monologue, and that first paragraph alone establishes the emotional stakes before we even get to the physical stuff. "Wasn't he essentially asking her to destroy her cherished memories of her first love with her own hands?" That line came early, and it set the entire tone. This isn't just smut with a plot—that philosophical weight hangs over every single scene. What's brilliant is how the physical escalation mirrors the emotional destruction. It starts with him just... existing in public like this. Then it moves to touching. Then to her touching him. Then to full-blown sexual contact. Each step feels inevitable but also like a door closing that can't be reopened. The author never rushes these transitions—they linger on Hazel's hesitation, on her confused breathing, on those tiny moments where she could stop this but chooses not to. The chapter breaks are perfectly placed too. Chapter 4 ends with this devastating realization—she's had an orgasm and now has to face what that means about herself. Chapter 5 opens with her breathlessly kissing him back, and the shift is so sharp it feels like whiplash. You go from horror to surrender in two paragraphs, and that whiplash IS the point. The climax itself is handled with this incredible tension/release cycle. Enoch deliberately denies her deepest stimulation, pulls back, teases—and each denial builds the pressure higher. When he finally does what she needs, it's not gentle. It's violent and desperate and perfect. The structure of the scene itself becomes a metaphor for everything wrong and right about their relationship. And that final image—her vision white, her mind blank, losing herself completely—that's not just a satisfying ending to the scene. It's the death of the girl she used to be, and honestly? I couldn't look away.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is SO distinctively THEM and I need to talk about why it works so well. Enoch's voice is this incredible mix of command and vulnerability. He goes from 'Step on me' (two words, devastating impact) to 'You don't know what to do, do you?' (teasing, dominant) to 'It was amazing' (barely a whisper, completely exposed). One guy, three completely different energies, and ALL feel true to the same person. Hazel's internal monologue is the real star though. Her thoughts are chaotic, reactive, funny: '...What?', 'Are you seriously asking me to step on you right now?', 'You said I could sleep…!', 'How could he possibly say such nonsense in a situation like this?', 'You said I could sleep!' She interrupts herself, repeats things, talks to herself. This is how an actual person thinks during sex. Not poetry. Just pure, unfiltered brain noise. The external dialogue is sparser but hits harder: "Why?" — her exact words when he enters without warning. Two syllables of pure betrayal. "You like this, don't you? Hot and firm." — him turning her pain into something she's supposed to enjoy. The audacity. "I don't want to open my eyes..." — her final thought, the most honest line in the entire passage. She doesn't want to face reality because reality is: she's falling for this man and her body is destroyed and she's never going to recover from this. The author's narrative voice is observant but never preachy. It stays in Hazel's head without trapping us there. We get her body AND her thoughts, and the alternation creates this rhythm that mirrors the scene itself—building, peaking, collapsing.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or