Give Me Back My First Love! - Reviews

Give Me Back My First Love!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The stakes here are quietly enormous and nobody except the reader seems to notice. Hazel is trapped in the most delicious way. She wants to leave. She's already mentally preparing to leave the mansion in a few days. She's practical, careful with money, sending earnings to her father — this woman is living with constraints and making do. And then Enoch appears in HER hometown, the one place where she should feel safest and most in control, and suddenly she's being guided around by a man who just bought off her maid with a piece of gold. Her internal conflict is screaming. Part of her wants to run. Another part — the part that still has feelings from years ago — is beating a path to his door. And the worst part? She can't even be mad at Vanessa because deep down, Hazel probably wants this too. That's the real tragedy here. She's not conflicted between two options; she's conflicted because she's afraid of wanting the wrong thing, or wanting the right thing at the wrong time. Meanwhile, Vanessa is operating with complete confidence that everything will work out. Emily is complicit, if reluctantly. Enoch is playing the long game. And Hazel? Hazel is just trying to find the shop on that list so she can go home and pretend this never happened. But we all know she won't.
... Read More
There are three symbols in these chapters that keep echoing each other and I can't stop thinking about them. First: the contraceptive magic sigil. It's described as something that halts 'certain bodily functions' but 'doesn't mean those functions disappear entirely. Once the magic sigil is removed, everything returns to normal.' This is literally the thesis of Hazel and Enoch's entire dynamic — restraint, suppression, the promise that everything will return to normal once a condition is lifted. Hazel's emotional state mirrors this sigil exactly: she's kept herself controlled, composed, professional, but underneath there's a whole lot of stuff that hasn't disappeared. Second: the fortune teller's 'bad luck banishing stick' — a blunt long pillar with two small round shapes at the bottom. The author couldn't even pretend this was metaphorical. It's a talisman shaped like a penis given to a woman haunted by a man's penis. The cosmic irony is staggering. Third: that drawer hinge. Hazel keeps it well-oiled but forgot to close it properly, and Enoch closes it with a creaking sound that the narration explicitly frames as foreshadowing. Everything in this story is about things left open that should be closed, and things that need oiling but aren't getting it. The class disparity theme runs through all of this too — the Meyer Marquisate's gold mine, the Imperial Knights' laws, the entire system that keeps people like Hazel in their place. Fate, sigils, and poorly closed drawers — what a triad.
... Read More
There's this one line that wrecked me—Hazel notices his scars and instinctively reaches out to touch them, and instead of pulling away, he catches her wrist and says: 'Weren't you curious to touch?' She thinks she hurt him. He INVITES her in. That's the entire relationship in one sentence. Enoch is this guy who's supposed to be this untouchable, pampered young master—everyone's perception of him—but here he is, completely bare physically AND emotionally. The scars tell a story we haven't fully read yet, and the fact that Hazel notices them mid-passion means SHE sees him. Not the mask. The real thing. And then he ASKS her to step on him. This is a man who's used to being in control voluntarily handing over power. His submissive moment isn't weakness—it's TRUST. Maximum trust. He's exposing himself literally and figuratively, and he lets her decide what to do with that access. Afterward when he says 'It was amazing'—and I mean just mutters it while leaning against her like a satisfied cat—that's Enoch at his most unguarded. No grand declaration, no dramatic confession. Just raw honesty from a guy who's never let anyone see this version of himself before. Their dynamic has shifted permanently. He trusted her with something dark inside him and she didn't run. That's the moment this relationship became something real.
... Read More
"It's not actually that important." Okay but can we just talk about how Enoch literally used the Crown Prince's orders as a cover for a leisure trip and Hazel bought it?? I almost laughed out loud. Here's this whole buildup about some super critical items that could only be obtained in this region, right? My brain was already going full conspiracy theorist. What is the Crown Prince really after? Is this a political maneuver? And then Enoch just... deflates the entire tension like a popped balloon. He needed fresh air. That's it. No grand scheme, no hidden agenda. Just a rich guy who's been working too hard. But here's the thing that made me sit up straight - the fact that Hazel immediately assumed it was critical says so much about how she operates. She carries every responsibility like it's the weight of the world on her shoulders. Meanwhile Enoch has this whole other rhythm to him. When he says "you could've just said so from the beginning" about her being lost, it's not cruel. It's genuinely baffling to him that pride would override practicality. The plot twist I didn't see coming wasn't some major revelation though. It was smaller. When Hazel asks why he sent her maid away and he just says "I just felt like it" - that line hit me like a truck. On the surface it's flirtation. But what if it's something deeper? What if he wanted her all to himself without distractions? The author didn't spell it out, didn't make Enoch explain his own motivations. And that silence between them? The text says "a delicate silence lingered" and honestly that's when I knew the real plot was happening underneath all the walking and talking. The surface story is two people running errands. The actual story is something else entirely unwinding.
... Read More
"I remember everything I did with you, too." I need to talk about this line because it completely rearranged the emotional temperature of the entire scene. One second Hazel is venting about students like a stressed academic, and the next she's confessing something so intimate it could only come from a place of genuine vulnerability. And Enoch's reaction? His entire being shifts. The text says his fragile thread of rationality snapped—and I mean that literally. You can watch it happen in real time. What struck me most was how the author built toward this moment without making it feel forced. Hazel starts off all energetic and loud, complaining about these incidents with her hands in her hair, getting progressively more dramatic. Then she just... deflates. Her shoulders tremble as she cries. And in that quiet, exhausted space, the confession comes out almost accidentally. Like she couldn't hold it in anymore. And Enoch—he doesn't rush her. He listens. He takes her trembling hand gently. He says "You've been through a lot" like he actually means it. That's the man she's fallen for, or maybe that's the man he's always been but she's only now seeing clearly. Then the power dynamic flips so perfectly. She tries to play it cool, tries to maintain some sense of propriety, but her body betrays her every step of the way. She's the one who initiates the kiss in Chapter 21. She's the one wrapping her leg around his waist. She's the one who can't stop following him with her tongue when he pulls away. This isn't some passive romantic interest—she's hungry for this connection, and she's done pretending otherwise. The sexual tension between them isn't just physical—it's emotional. Every touch carries weight because these two have history. They've seen each other at their worst, and they keep choosing each other anyway. That's the good stuff. That's what makes you re-read a passage five times.
... Read More
I just want to say that Enoch Meyer is one of the most unsettling antagonists I have encountered in recent reading. Not because he is loud or overtly threatening, but because his cruelty is intimate, calculated, and deeply personal. He does not just want to control Hazel — he wants to weaponize her past, her secrets, her deepest humiliations, and force her to smile through it all. The moment that sealed it for me was when he found the grotesque object on her bookshelf and said: “If you had such tastes, you should've said so. I would've been considerate.” This is not a joke. It is a threat wrapped in mockery, designed to make her feel exposed and insane in her own office, with him kneeling beside her, clearly aroused, locking the door behind him. And Hazel? She could barely form a coherent sentence. She tried to resist. She thought about students walking by. She thought about dignity. But Enoch had already mapped every exit, every fear, every weakness. He knows she cannot report him because “there's no one who would believe her.” He knows her professional standing is fragile. He knows exactly how to break her without leaving a mark anyone else can see. What makes their dynamic so unbearable to watch is that Hazel still catches herself looking at him when she thinks no one is watching. Still remembers him training in the swordsmanship field. Still feels the pull of that old affection even as he systematically dismantles her sense of safety. That's the real tragedy here — it's not just that he is dangerous, it's that her heart has not fully caught up to the fact that he is hers no more, but rather something far worse: her tormentor. And Philip? Don't get me started on Philip. The man dumps his workload on Hazel, uses his performance review as leverage, pats her shoulder like a benevolent senior while clearly treating her as his personal assistant. “Last year's wasn't great, was it?” he says, as if that is helpful feedback. Hazel's already drowning under Enoch's shadow, and now this? She has no allies. No protection. Just a mountain of paperwork and a man with a bulge in his pants walking toward her with a cursed object in hand. Is there anything left that can save her? Or is that the entire point?
... Read More
I keep coming back to the symbolism in this text because it's layered in ways that went way deeper than I expected. Let's start with the setting itself—a school, a place of learning, a sacred space of education. The author keeps emphasizing this, and it's not accidental. This is where identities are formed, where children become adults, where first loves are conceived and later mourned. And here, in this temple of innocence, something primal and filthy is happening. The classroom becomes this dark cathedral where Hazel's childhood beliefs are being systematically dismantled. Every act of transgression against social norms is also an act of transgression against her personal mythology of Enoch. When she touches him, she's not just touching his body—she's touching the corpse of her first love and feeling it move. There's this recurring motif of witnessing and being witnessed that I find absolutely fascinating. Enoch repeatedly demands that Hazel look at him, that she witness what he's doing. But it goes deeper than that—he wants her to witness HIM witnessing HER. The double gaze, the reciprocal observation, it creates this hall of mirrors where identity dissolves. Who is she when he's watching? Who is he when she's watching? The text seems to suggest that neither of them fully knows, and that's part of the terror. The physical setting matters too—the desks, the silence, the risk of discovery. There's something profoundly symbolic about committing this act in a place associated with rules and consequences. It's rebellion as ritual, sin as sacrament. Hazel isn't just having sex—she's being initiated into a version of adulthood that she wasn't prepared for. And the fluidity throughout—sweat, tears, lubrication, cum—all of these bodily fluids serve as markers of boundary dissolution. The walls between self and other, between pleasure and pain, between love and violation—all of them become permeable. By the end, Hazel can't tell which side she's on anymore, and that uncertainty IS the theme. This is ultimately a story about the death of innocence—not the naive kind, but the necessary kind. The kind you have to lose before you can actually know yourself.
... Read More
I keep coming back to that object. The “bad luck banishing stick.” On the surface, it is grotesque comedy — a phallic wooden carving that Hazel throws into the trash and then wakes up to find on her nightstand. But the longer I sat with it, the more I realized this is one of the most layered symbolic objects I have encountered in contemporary fiction, and the novel is using it to explore power, violation, and the impossibility of escape. First, the object represents Hazel's violated privacy and autonomy. She discards it with her own hands. She confirms with her own eyes it is gone. And yet it returns. This is not supernatural — it is a metaphor for how trauma and abuse follow you home. No matter how decisively you try to dispose of something poisonous, it finds its way back. The object moves from her trash to her bedside table to her office bookshelf, escalating each time, mirroring how Enoch's control over her expands from her private life into her professional one. Second, the object functions as a perversion of intimacy. It is shaped like a male genital organ, yes, but it also represents Enoch's sexual dominance over Hazel. He gives it to her. She tries to reject it. He uses it to humiliate her in front of herself — “If you had such tastes, you should've said so.” He turns her attempted rejection into a tool of further entrapment. The object is literally a weapon disguised as a curiosity. There is also the motif of watching and being watched. Hazel watches Enoch train from afar, and he watches her watching him. Enoch watches her reaction to the object. The students watch Enoch teach swordsmanship. There is a whole architecture of surveillance in these chapters that reflects Hazel's loss of agency — she is always the observed, never the observer in control. And beneath all of this sits the novel's deeper inquiry into complicity. Hazel is called an “accomplice,” a word that echoes through these chapters like a curse. Accomplice to what? To what happened between them? To her silence? To her continued presence in his orbit despite knowing better? The novel refuses to give her the clean victimhood she might deserve. She is trapped, yes, but she also still looks. Still remembers. Still feels. And that complexity — that refusal to simplify her into either saint or sinner — is what makes this novel genuinely devastating.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about this chapter sequence because the plot twist here isn't some big reveal—it's the sheer audacity of Enoch's character. The scene starts in media res, which is bold as hell, and then we get the morning after which is where the real narrative machinery kicks in. Hazel wakes up with body horror-level muscle pain and her whole internal monologue is basically 'I need to avoid him at all costs' while simultaneously being unable to stop mentally replaying everything. That's not just a trope, that's a plot engine. She's already planning her escape strategy—endure for a year until he returns to the Imperial Family, avoid him at the Spring Banquet, survive normalcy. And then BOOM, her coworker Vivian walks in and immediately starts probing. The chapter ends with Enoch literally appearing at the door asking about reference materials while Hazel is sitting there trying to act normal. The tension between what happened and what they have to pretend about going forward is absolutely delicious. Also can we appreciate that the author didn't even give us the full scene of how they got together? We're thrown into the aftermath and have to piece it together. That's either really confident writing or deeply selfish writing and honestly I respect it.
... Read More
The way this scene is WRITTEN—I keep going back to the sensory details because they're NOT accidental. Let me list the ones that stuck: 1. 'The faint scent of alcohol from his slightly parted lips didn't bother her in the least.' — That detail grounds the whole thing in a specific moment. They were drinking. This happened AFTER something. It's messy, not cinematic-perfect, which makes it MORE real. 2. 'His silky hair tickled her cheek' — a tiny, domestic detail in the middle of something primal. That juxtaposition is genius. 3. The floor scene. Enoch kneeling. Hazel's foot hovering. 'Even the light weight of her small foot seemed to send a thrill through Enoch.' The spatial choreography here is so clear I could've drawn it. You can SEE this. 4. 'his face flushed as if it were on fire, and his lower abdomen and organ covered in white, sticky fluids—it was a sight to behold' — yes. The author does NOT shy away from the visceral. This isn't romance-novel pasteurized intimacy. This is sweat, fluids, aching muscles, tears. 5. The post-coital clean-up contrast—Hazel sticky and wrecked vs. Enoch freshly out of the bath with a white towel. That visual separation says SO MUCH about their dynamic. He takes care of himself, takes care of her, and somehow still looks perfect. Annoyingly perfect. The room feels like a character. It's dark, they're half-drunk, the air is thick. Every surface matters—the bed, the floor, the bathroom. This isn't a generic bedroom; it's THEIR space, and the environment reflects the intensity of what's happening between them.
... Read More
Can we talk about Enoch for a second because this man is a whole mood and I need to unpack it. The kid at the Academy was calm, composed, distant. The man standing in front of Hazel now is... different. Playful. Smiling. Teasing her about being lost like it's the funniest thing ever. But beneath that warmth there's steel. Watch what he does when she starts drinking. He doesn't lecture her. He doesn't grab her wrist aggressively. He just... stops her. One hand on her wrist, one firm sentence: "Wait, Hazel, slow down. You're going to get yourself into trouble." And Hazel? Oh my god. She's this competent professor, this woman who built her life on control and discipline, and the second alcohol loosens her tongue she's throwing tantrums about rebellious students. Enoch's confusion is so genuine - to him having a hard time means unfair treatment, stolen credit, impossible tasks. To Hazel it's children who won't follow rules. That gap between them is huge and the author lets it sit there uncomfortably. But the waist grab. The one where she stumbles and he catches her. That memory flashback is everything. "Are you trying to run away now?" he'd whispered back then. Same grip. Same intensity. He hasn't changed at all, has he? The playful exterior is still protecting someone who holds on desperately when he thinks someone might leave. What I love is how neither of them addresses the history. They circle around it like two animals sniffing each other. Hazel tells herself she invited him because it's polite. Because he's a guest. But her own narration betrays her: "She wanted to spend a little more time with him..." Stop lying to yourself girl. The maid situation wasn't random. The sunset spot wasn't random. None of this is random.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author structures this transition because it's dangerously good. We go from Hazel having what can only be described as a full physical breakdown against a wall—tears, trembling, orgasm—to Enoch pulling out a handkerchief, thoroughly wiping between her legs, and lifting her up like she weighs nothing. Like a man finishing chores. Then BAM. Bell rings. Class starts. She has to pretend nothing happened. "If he had used it, she wouldn't have been able to attend class, that much was certain." THE COURSE CORRECTION. The author drops this detail casually mid-reflection and I nearly fell out of my chair. The pacing here is like a rollercoaster that refuses to slow down. Then Chapter 14 drops us into what feels like a completely different genre—domestic slice-of-life, family visit, eating pie. But the tension doesn't vanish; it just changes shape. Vanessa pressing about whether Hazel has a boyfriend, Hazel deflecting, the underlying current of "I slept with my first love and he's a menace" running under every line of polite conversation. The chapter ends with Hazel reluctantly agreeing to go out, Vanessa essentially saying "meet a decent man and don't come back." And Hazel's thought—"Though she had done something unimaginable back then... Feeling a pang of guilt, Hazel swallowed the truth"—is the perfect button. The pacing doesn't let you breathe but it also doesn't rush. It knows exactly when to linger and when to pivot.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or