Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in this excerpt is interesting because it moves in waves. It starts chaotic — the mother-in-law-style interrogation scene with Lin Ying, Yu Cheng eating fruit like nothing happened, Qin He stuck between being polite and being suffocated. Then there's a complete tonal shift when they go upstairs and it's just them again, and the pacing slows down dramatically. That's where the real content lives. The transition from the loud, crowded family scene into the private bedroom scene is where the author really controls the reader's attention. It goes from external conflict (social awkwardness) to internal conflict (Qin He's memories of his childhood). The pacing decision to insert all that backstory about Qin He's father right when Yu Cheng wipes grape juice from his face is deliberate — the tenderness of the moment triggers the memory of never being allowed to be messy or childish. Then it pulls back out again to a lighter pace with the photography ticket subplot, and by the end we're already moving toward the visit to Qin He's actual home, which sets up the next wave of tension. The chapter ends on that description of the suburb — haphazard lanes, lingering smells, men with bare arms — and it stops right where you'd expect a chapter break to hit. The author knows exactly when to land the plane and when to let you float.
... Read More
This chapter is surprisingly visual for a character-driven text. Let me just say—the sweat scene is doing so much work. Yu Cheng carrying a bottle of ice water in hot weather, the water sweating onto his hands, beads hanging from his chin. That's not just atmosphere, that's literally the temperature of his desperation. He's out here in civilian clothes during what seems like a rare afternoon off, buying secondhand-ish but decent pants for a boy he barely knows, and the heat is making everything visceral. Then there's the classroom scene where Yu Cheng is examining Qin He's school uniform like he's seeing it for the first time. 'The blue and white school uniform looked particularly good on Qin He.' This image stays with me. There's something almost painful about how well-fitting the uniform is on him—disciplined, clean, appropriate—and yet it creates this 'sense of alienation around the person.' The uniform makes him look like 'a TV star with rosy lips and white teeth' but also untouchable. Yu Cheng is right there and still can't reach him. The author also builds this whole ecosystem of wealth subtly: no strict uniforms at Thirteen School, rich kids flexing brands, students discussing watches and new clothing lines while Qin He is calculating whether he can afford magazines. The world feels lived-in because we're not told about poverty or wealth directly—we see it through what people can and cannot discuss at lunch. That's craft.
... Read More
There's this one moment that just hit me—when Qin He realizes that because Yu Cheng sits next to him, the classroom goes completely dead silent. Like a vacuum. Other kids are scared off, and suddenly there's this eerie quiet that actually helps Qin He catch up on sleep. I love how the author uses silence as a physical space here. It's not just absence of noise; it's something you can feel pressing down. And then there's the scene with the medical room—so mundane but so loaded. Yu Cheng applying ointment, turning his head away, not being able to look at Qin He directly because those scars are his own fault. The whole energy shifts from chaotic to this awkward tenderness, and you can practically feel the temperature in that room change. No fancy descriptions needed, just body language doing all the work. The bus stop scene at rush hour is another one that stuck with me. Qin He watching Yu Cheng from afar, calculating whether he'll even be able to get on the bus in that crowd. The contrast between Yu Cheng's sheltered life and the real world grinding around him—it paints such a vivid picture of two people who literally occupy different worlds, even when they're standing five feet apart.
... Read More
"I didn't just lose to you; I even gave myself to you. No regrets, no regrets." God, Yu Cheng. This man. I kept coming back to this line because it captures literally everything about how he loves Qin He — it's not subtle, it's not measured, and honestly I love that about him. He goes all-in from the start and never second-guesses it. Even when Qin He lists off all the reasons he's difficult (stubborn, unreasonable, quick-tempered, annoying), Yu Cheng doesn't flinch. He just agrees and says "if I can pursue you, then I must be quite outstanding." Classic deflection, but also kind of brilliant self-preservation. What really got me though is that moment when Qin He asks if Yu Cheng ever gets tired, and Yu Cheng immediately knows it's not about the tutoring — it's about him being a burden. And Yu Cheng's answer, "He just did what he could. He knew that Qin He could handle things on his own, but he wanted Qin He to rely on him" — that's the whole relationship in one sentence. Yu Cheng doesn't want to be needed because Qin He needs him; he wants to be needed because it means Qin He will choose to let him in. That's so specific and so tender. And then the hedgehog thing — the nickname, the prickly hair, the repeated attempts to get close and the repeated gentle rejections — it all adds up to this portrait of someone who is completely, devastatingly in love and perfectly okay with the pace being whoever's slower. That's Yu Cheng's entire romantic energy if you ask me. I'm not even mad about it. Actually, I'm a little bit mad but in the best way.
... Read More
'Are you stupid or something?' came out of Qin He's mouth before he even processed it. This guy just got hit, has a scraped elbow and torn pants, and his first instinct is to clap back? That's not just defiance — that's a survival mechanism so deeply wired into him that even in a weak position he refuses to be small. I love it. And then Yu Cheng's response — the earring, the skull shirt, the chain that clangs, the whole performance of being unbothered — it's almost sad how hard he's trying to maintain that image. His internal monologue reveals everything: he got scolded by his dad, skipped class, was already frustrated before bumping into Qin He. He wasn't angry at the right person. But here's what got me — the mother-son flashback. 'Don't cry; it doesn't hurt.' A child comforting his abused mother while getting stitches himself. That line rewired everything I thought I knew about Qin He. His sharpness isn't arrogance. It's the armor of someone who learned early that showing vulnerability gets you nothing. And yet he chose this school on a full scholarship, worked a part-time job he never told his mom about, just so she wouldn't have to worry. That kid is built different. Also Yu Cheng called himself handsome and honestly? Fair. But that confidence felt more like a shield than a fact.
... Read More
Let me just say this — the pacing in these first four chapters is genuinely impressive. The author doesn't waste a single moment. We open with gossip, drop a character legend, pivot to the actual protagonist's backstory, then return to the present timeline where two boys collide over a physical bump. Eight paragraphs of setup, one paragraph of impact, and then it cuts off mid-threat. That cliffhanger? Chef's kiss. What's clever is how the author controls the tempo through information withholding. We know Qin He is poor and resilient, but we don't fully understand his emotional complexity until the flashback hits. We hear about Yu Cheng as a notorious figure, but his interiority only emerges when he's standing face-to-face with someone who actually talks back. The rhythm of exposition and scene is tight — there's no filler, no unnecessary description. Even the part-time job detail serves dual purpose: it establishes Qin He's financial situation AND creates the reason he's climbing over the wall at night, which directly causes the collision. Everything is connected. The only question is whether the romance angle (and I'm already sensing it from how charged this first meeting is) will develop fast enough to satisfy readers or drag into that uncomfortable slow-burn territory. Either way, chapter one ended with a threat and chapter two better deliver. I'm invested.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the structure of this section because holy crap. The opening hits us with a birthday scene at a grave and I'm already devastated—then we learn this is Qin He's grave. Not just any grave, but the person who's been central to everything. The reveal that Qin He is dead comes relatively early in this batch, and instead of being a cliffhanger, it becomes the gravitational center that every subsequent scene orbits around. That's bold storytelling. Most authors would drip-feed this information, but the author just… drops it and never lets up. What's really interesting is how the plot then branches into two parallel threads: Yu Cheng's descent into grief and the reader's growing understanding of what Qin He was actually going through. The letter to Qin Wanqing, the letter to Yu Cheng—they serve as exposition but feel like intimate confessions rather than info-dumps. And the timeline jump to 'four years later' at the end? That's a massive structural leap that lands perfectly because the emotional weight has been accumulating since page one. The subplot with Qin Wanqing dying too—within months, not even surviving the Lunar New Year—adds another layer. It's not just one death; it's a chain of losses that strips away every anchor Yu Cheng had. And then the ending where he burns the last photo and takes a pill… the plot essentially circles back to the beginning. The birthday that wasn't celebrated together becomes the birthday he chose to join Qin He. I don't know if that's meant to be tragic or romantic or both, but it's undeniably coherent.
... Read More
I need to talk about the sheer tension in this section because my heart was pounding the entire time. Let me set the scene for you: inside, Qin He is blindfolded and bound to a chair, surrounded by seven or eight armed men. Outside, Yu Cheng is running through rain-soaked streets, checking his phone every thirty seconds, his eyelid twitching with dread. Two parallel dramas playing out simultaneously, and the reader is trapped in the space between them. The stakes here are impossibly high. Physically, Qin He is in immediate danger - he's outnumbered, bound, and facing people whose livelihood depends on intimidation and violence. But the emotional stakes are even higher. This is his FATHER who sold him. The man who beat him as a child, who continues to poison his life from the shadows, has just traded his son for debt relief. There's no deeper betrayal than that. What makes this scene work so well is the dual perspective. We cut between Yu Cheng's growing panic and Qin He's forced calm, creating a tension that's almost unbearable. Yu Cheng has no idea what's happening. He's furious, scared, helpless. And Qin He - we know exactly what he's experiencing, and we're screaming at him through the page to stay strong. The question that keeps me up at night: what happens when Yu Cheng finds out? When he discovers that Qin He was taken because of his father's gambling debts? The wolf guarding his treasure is about to discover that the threat isn't external - it's family, and it's personal. I cannot wait to see how this resolves.
... Read More
'Class 1 of Grade 2, Qin He.' That's it. He says his name and walks away. And Yu Cheng just watches him go like... what? I keep coming back to this moment because it tells you everything about both of them. Qin He doesn't want anything to do with Yu Cheng. He can tell the guy is rich, he can tell this is going to complicate his life, and he just wants to disappear. But Yu Cheng? He won't let it go. 'What's your name and class? I said I'm responsible; I'll pay however I need to.' This kid doesn't understand why he's so invested. He literally asks himself 'why was he making such a fuss over finding comfortable and cheap clothing?' And he still goes through with it anyway. That's character development right there — someone doing something they can't explain because something inside them won't let them stop. Then there's Gao Yu, Qin He's roommate, who covers for him during roll call. Small detail but it shows Qin He has at least one person in his corner. Meanwhile Yu Cheng has this older brother who tutors to make his own money and seems to be the only normal person in the Yu family. Two different kinds of support systems. Two different kinds of loneliness.
... Read More
Okay so the pacing here is honestly wild. You start with this full-on kidnapping scene — Qin He getting tossed around, kicked, head hitting a car door, all that. Super tense. Then BAM, cut to the police station, Li Zhuang already caught, everything resolved within, what, two pages? It's almost too fast. Like, where were the authorities this whole time? But then the author slaps you with the wet-rain, hospital-wounds, emotional fallout, and suddenly you're sitting with these characters in this quiet, heavy silence. The chapter structure is interesting though because it doesn't linger on the action the way you'd expect from a thriller. The kidnapping itself feels almost skipped over — we get snippets, not a sustained scene. The real weight lands in the aftermath: the hospital visit, the umbrella walk home, Qin He finally talking about his childhood. That's where the story breathes. And then — and this is the part that got me — after all that emotional buildup, the very next scene is Yu Cheng following Qin He to the bathroom. Just... the bathroom. For twenty minutes. What. The tonal whiplash is insane. One moment they're sharing vulnerability under a tiny yellow duck umbrella, the next Qin He is literally asking if Yu Cheng has urinary frequency. It's such a deliberate choice to deflate tension like that, and honestly? It works. It's human. Not every moment needs to be a movie scene. The school gossip section at the end — where everyone is surprised Yu Cheng is actually paying attention in class — is another pacing masterstroke. It gives us a time jump without any exposition. We just know something shifted. The story trusts us to figure it out. Some people might complain the first half moves too fast and the second half meanders, but I think that's the point. Trauma doesn't hit all at once; it crashes in later, in quiet moments. And the author nails that rhythm.
... Read More
Okay so this scene. This whole bathroom confrontation. I need to talk about it because it's honestly the kind of moment that makes you go wow, the author really knew what they were doing here. The setup is brilliant — those two boys gossiping about Yu Cheng behind his back, calling him names, making homophobichints about Qin He too. And then Qin He just... appears. Like a ghost. They don't even flinch when they see him, which tells you everything about the social dynamics at play. These kids are used to getting away with shit behind people's backs. "You think so too, don't you, Qin He?" — that line hits different because it shows how pathetic they are. They WANT validation for their cruelty. Then the actual fight. I love how the author doesn't make Qin He some invincible badass. He specifically notes that he's thin but strong, and his fighting style is born from years of being bullied himself. That backstory detail about learning not to get beaten up, learning where to hit, when to run — it turns what could've been a generic fight scene into something layered. And the fact that he mentions there are no cameras and no injuries on them? That's cold calculation. He's not just protecting Yu Cheng emotionally, he's protecting him legally too. This kid thinks three steps ahead. But what got me the most was the aftermath. Back in the classroom, Yu Cheng immediately tries to flip the script and act casual about it. He's all pouty and deflective, asking about Qin He's red hands while clearly trying NOT to ask what actually happened. That tension between wanting to know and pretending not to care — THAT is character writing done right. The teacher's fake smile in the background while they whisper is the perfect chaotic energy. It's like the whole world is performing normalcy while something huge just happened underneath it.
... Read More
There's this Shakespeare quote at the top: "No matter how long the night, the day will always come." And then the story immediately undercuts it. Because for Qin He, daylight doesn't come. He's trapped in an eternal abyss. The irony is almost cruel. The imagery throughout is relentlessly physical. Long sleeves in early summer heat—not because he's cold, but because he can't bear for anyone to see the scars. The cicadas breathing hot air. The hot pavement burning his skin as he sits on the ground. Everything is felt through his body, because his body is where the trauma lives. It's branded onto him. He literally cannot escape it. But the most powerful symbol is probably that moment when Qin Wanqing reaches for his hand and he instinctively pulls away, rubbing the spot afterward. A mother's touch—something that should be safe—has become something his body registers as threat. The conditioning has gone so deep that even genuine affection triggers his survival response. And then there's the white shirt. He used to like crisp white shirts. Now he wears loose coats. White represents purity, innocence, the person he was before all of this. He can't wear it anymore because it's a reminder of who he lost. The author doesn't need to say any of this explicitly. The clothes do the work.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or