Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'Has no one taught you not to point fingers at others? It's better to have some manners as a person.' Yu Cheng's voice became deeper, with a coldness to it. This boy is eighteen and he looks like a vicious wolf staring at its prey. The stakes in this story keep rising and I love it. First there's the disciplinary review threat — Qin He could get punished for reporting Yu Cheng, or Yu Cheng could get in serious trouble. Then there's the physical fight they both got into climbing that wall. Then there's Yang Man, this English teacher who just lost her mind and started insulting an entire class of teenagers, calling them useless and making personal attacks about their families. Yu Cheng kicked that door open with so much force it scraped off plaster. That's not just anger, that's years of being looked down on exploding at once. The question is — what happens next? Yang Man said she'd tell the principal. Yu Cheng threatened her career. And somewhere in the middle of all this, Qin He is just trying to survive, work his part-time job, and not get involved with rich kids who complicate his life. But he's already involved. He gave his name. He's in Class 1 of Grade 2. And Yu Cheng is now looking for him. The tension between all these threads is what makes this story addictive.
... Read More
Let me ask you something: what does Yu Cheng have to LOSE in this confrontation? On the surface, it's his grades. His reputation. His scholarship. But dig deeper and you'll find he's fighting for something much more fundamental—his RIGHT to exist as himself rather than as a comparison to someone else. Every time Yang Man brings up his brother, she's attacking the one wound that never heals. And when she says 'if I were your father, I wouldn't choose you as my successor,' she's not just insulting him—she's threatening his entire sense of belonging. Is he worthy of his family name? Is he worthy of taking his father's place? The stakes escalate dramatically throughout this sequence. It starts as a teacher-student disciplinary conversation. Then it becomes a personal attack. Then it becomes a physical altercation. Then it becomes a legal/professional crisis when Yang Man claims he tried to kill her. Each level raises the stakes higher and higher. But here's what makes the conflict so compelling: Yu Cheng WINS this round, but he doesn't win cleanly. He had to resort to violence. He hurt someone. He left marks on Qin He. The recording saved him from expulsion, but it didn't save him from becoming what everyone already thought he was—a violent, unstable kid. And the ending? 'Do you also think I'm a manic monster? Not as good as my brother?'—that question carries the weight of EVERY failure, EVERY comparison, EVERY expectation he's ever faced. He's not just asking Qin He. He's asking himself. And that's where the real conflict lives. Qin He's advice at the end—'not everything has to be solved through violence. You can try using your brain'—is both genuinely helpful and subtly heartbreaking. Because the reader knows: using his brain is exactly what got Yu Cheng here. His intellect didn't save him from being the 'lesser' child. His intelligence didn't prevent the comparisons. So of course his body became his last resort.
... Read More
'In Yu Cheng's camera, Qin He is always vivid and happy.' I literally had to stop reading for a second. That sentence — that's it. That's the entire romance right there. Because think about what it means: Qin He's camera captures sunsets and rivers and pedestrians and trees, all these beautiful things that exist outside of himself. He sees the world as something worth documenting but never includes himself in the frame. He's always the observer, never the observed. And Yu Cheng — Yu Cheng's entire photographic project is just Qin He. Every other subject in his viewfinder is secondary. Qin He becomes the only landscape that matters. And this connects to everything else in the chapter, doesn't it? The way Yu Cheng plans their future — "planning how to make their parents accept it, and planning how to protect Qin He" — it's the same instinct. He sees something precious and he wants to preserve it. Capture it. Keep it safe. But here's what made me actually feel things: the amusement park scene. Qin He says "I almost forgot what it's like to have fun" and Yu Cheng says he wants to go to make up for his broken childhood. Two broken kids showing up at an amusement park together, both using the other as an excuse to feel something normal for once. And then Yu Cheng grabs Qin He's wrist and writes on it because apparently holding hands in public isn't safe but invisible words on skin are. That's the most romantic gesture I've read in a long time. It's not grand or dramatic — it's barely anything — but it carries so much weight. "No one is watching" becomes this secret promise, this tiny act of defiance that says: we can still touch each other even when the world won't let us.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is minimalist to the point of violence. Almost nothing is said directly, and that's precisely what makes it hit so hard. Look at the exchange with the doctor. The woman in the white coat says something like "just take a look at how much effort your mother has put into you" and underneath it is all this rot. The doctor FEELS disgusted—he wants to vomit—but he says nothing. He performs gratitude alongside Qin Wanqing because he's complicit. This single moment tells you everything about an entire industry that preys on vulnerable families. Then there's Qin He's response to his mother: he smiles, but "there was no genuine smile in his eyes, only a slight twitch of his muscles." This is narration doing the work of dialogue. We don't need him to say "I hate you" or "stop lying to me." The physical description carries the subtext like a live wire. Yu Cheng's line "I won't touch you. If you don't want to see me, I'll leave first. Can you please get up from the ground? It's hot" is devastating because it's so ordinary. He's not making grand declarations. He's negotiating for basic human contact in the smallest possible increments. Get up from the ground. That's all he's asking. Just sit up. Stay alive. The rest can wait. The person on the phone at the end barely speaks either. Just a sigh and "...alright." Two words that carry an entire world of resignation.
... Read More
I need to talk about the single most devastating character choice in this entire section. When Yu Cheng returns to the Yu family after everything, he doesn't just grieve—he transforms. He empties his wardrobe of colorful clothes. Grows out his hair. Changes his perfume to something light 'that Qin He might like.' He literally becomes another version of Qin He. That moment hit me like a truck because it's not just mourning—it's identity dissolution. And then there's Qin Wanqing. This woman wrote 'I hate you' in a letter to her own son, and the narrative frames it as 'an insignificant act of revenge.' INCONSEQUENTIAL. SHE KILLED HIM THROUGH HER CHOICES AND NOW SHE'S REGRETING IT FROM HER DEATHBED. But the story doesn't let her off the hook or give her a redemption arc either. She dies alone, illness-wracked, having lost both people she should have protected. That's not forgiveness—that's consequence. The relationship between Yu Cheng and Qin He is the core, obviously, but what struck me most was Yu Cheng's relationship with his own family. He cuts them off. He returns only when he has no choice. The comparison the narrator makes—'From a certain perspective, isn't he very much like Qin He?'—this is the author sliding in a line that reframes everything. Yu Cheng was always running from his father, and now he's become the ghost himself. The mementos collection is the real mic drop for their relationship though. Every photo annotated, every candy wrapper preserved, every petal from flowers Yu Cheng gave him. Qin He was hoarding pieces of him the way people hoard love letters. That changes how you read their entire history.
... Read More
The structure of these chapters is a masterclass in controlled devastation. It starts with the cold open—the doctor's voice, the solitary confinement sentence, the door closing. Immediate dread. Then we cut to Yu Cheng's parallel storyline, which acts as both relief and knife-twist because we KNOW what's happening to Qin He while Yu Cheng sits at his desk staring at a photo. The pacing between these two threads is almost cinematic in how it builds unbearable tension. And then back to the treatment room—the scene where they show him Yu Cheng's photo and shock him. The repetition in the prose mirrors the repetition of the torture itself. "You can't like him. You can't like men." Over and over, like a corrupted record. Then the final paragraph drops us into that long montage of ongoing abuse without any transition, like we're just swept into the conveyor belt of Qin He's destruction alongside him. And then—"No matter how long the night, the day will come." The chapter ends on something that could be hope or could be bitterness, and I sat there for a full minute just staring at the screen.
... Read More
I want to focus on how their relationship actually shifted between these chapters because it's subtle but massive. Remember when Qin He first met Yu Cheng? Aggressive, hostile, barely tolerating him. Now? He's looking at him sleeping and his furrowed brow is loosening. The physical description alone tells the story — 'without the strong aggressiveness he had displayed while awake, Yu Cheng seemed much more gentle and harmless.' Qin He notices this. He's allowed himself to notice. The dorm scene is where it really clicks. Qin He goes to Yu Cheng's room — a single, spacious room with a potted plant, looks like a vacation spot — and finds zero study materials. Nine test papers, thirty minutes, multiple choice randomly filled, big questions untouched. And Qin He's sitting there furrowing his brows, biting his cheek, wondering how this boy even survived school. But he doesn't give up. He creates a study plan. He invests his own time and energy. That's the core of their relationship: Qin He sees potential where everyone else sees waste, and Yu Cheng, for once, isn't fighting it. He's obedient. He follows the schedule. He listens. "You should make some progress during the final exams; don't ruin my reputation." On the surface it sounds like Qin He is only doing this for himself. But the subtext? He cares about Yu Cheng's outcomes enough to tie his own reputation to them. That's commitment wrapped in sarcasm. And then Yu Cheng exceeds his expectation — ranking in the top 600 instead of the top 800 his dad wanted — and Qin He's like 'it's not that I'm confident in you; it's that I'm confident in myself.' NO. You're confident in him. Don't lie to yourself.
... Read More
The setting of this story is so specifically drawn — 13th Middle School, where most students come from wealthy families except for a few like Yu Cheng who are still willing to learn. The experimental classes, Classes 1 and 2, are where the 'good seedlings' end up, which basically means the poor kids who earned their way in through merit. That's a whole social hierarchy built into the school system. And then there's the wall. The wall they climb over at night — it's not just a physical barrier, it's this symbol of the whole restricted world Qin He lives in. He's never left his hometown and Yao'an City. His world is three points: home, school, work. The wall represents everything outside that triangle. I also love the description of the sunset scene — 'the setting sun cast a gentle glow, the rustling sound of leaves was carried by the gentle breeze.' It's such a quiet, almost melancholic image that contrasts with all the tension in the rest of the story. And the classroom scene with Yang Man is visceral — she throws chalk at Yu Cheng, makes him stand outside, then sits with her legs crossed mocking them. You can feel the humiliation in that room. The students glare but don't move. They're used to it. That's worldbuilding without explaining the world — showing us a place where kids just accept abuse because that's what they've learned to expect.
... Read More
The villain says it so casually. "You can't like him." Said with that clinical, almost gentle tone, like he's correcting a child's arithmetic. And then the electric shocks hit. This is peak horror writing because the conflict isn't just physical—it's an assault on identity itself. Qin He is being FORCE-REWIRED. The stakes escalated from "stay alive" to "don't feel" to eventually "be someone else entirely." And the cruelest part? "Qin Wanqing might never know in this lifetime that Qin He was naturally homosexual. They would have sent him here anyway." So even if he wasn't into Yu Cheng specifically, his very existence was a problem. The external conflict (guards, machines, solitary confinement) mirrors the internal one (am I still me? will I stop feeling?). Every scar on his body is a trace of his brokenness—the narrator literally says that. And yet. And yet. He still clings to that photo. He still thinks about Yu Cheng in the dark. The tension between what they're trying to erase and what won't die is what makes this chapter unputdownable.
... Read More
'Qin He, let's go to the amusement park.' 'Want to go?' 'Of course, I almost forgot what it's like to have fun,' Qin He replies. Qin He doesn't care where to go, as long as he's with Yu Cheng, it's all good. I love the minimalism here. The author doesn't give us inner monologue or elaborate descriptions — just four lines of almost-too-casual dialogue and somehow it conveys more than pages of prose could. Qin He saying he doesn't care where they go as long as he's with Yu Cheng — said with the casualness of someone discussing the weather — is peak romantic writing because it's true love disguised as nonchalance. And then the wrist scene. Yu Cheng writing 'No one is watching' on Qin He's wrist with a gentle movement that causes a tingling sensation, as if being lightly electrified and flowing into his heart. The dialogue doesn't even appear here — it's all action, all sensation — but the words on the skin say more than any conversation could. It's private, it's urgent, it's dangerous, and it's the most intimate moment in the entire chapter. What strikes me is how the author uses silence as a dialogue tool. So much of what these two communicate isn't spoken. The ear-pulling. The pen tapping. The failed leaning-in attempts. All of it says: I want to be close to you. I'm afraid you'll pull away. Please don't pull away. And Qin He's responses — dismissing the hedgehog comment, slapping the forehead, telling him to study — they're not rejections. They're a language too. A language of someone who's used to keeping distance and is learning, slowly, that closeness doesn't have to hurt.
... Read More
I genuinely reread this section five times and I still can't get over how much it hurts. This is the part where they both get dragged apart by forces bigger than them, and the worst part is how quiet everything is after the storm. The principal's office scene—everyone's shouting, crying, insults flying—but then it cuts to silence. Just two boys sitting in separate rooms, being broken down by the people who were supposed to protect them. Qin Wanqing asking "What sins have I committed?" while beating her own son? How is that even real? She's grieving the image of the son she thought she had, not the actual person standing in front of her. And Qin He—he knew it couldn't last. He knew from the beginning. But he stayed anyway, living on edge every single day, hoping maybe today would be the day it could be different. "Every day he spent with Yu Cheng afterwards, he was always on edge, thinking that maybe it could last a little longer..." I literally cannot handle this. And Yu Cheng kneeling in that study, learning to submit instead of fighting, because the only way to keep Qin He safe was to pretend he didn't love him. The fact that both of them are carrying this guilt separately, thinking they're the problem, when really the whole world is the problem—that's the kind of pain that sticks with you long after you finish reading.
... Read More
There's something about the way this text describes Yu Cheng that makes my heart ache a little. "Yu Cheng brought Qin He into his territory a long time ago, like a wolf guarding a treasure. Anyone who dares to touch or covet this treasure will be bitten by him and left with no escape..." I'm not okay with this. This man is so fiercely loyal, so protective, and yet he's also so dangerously possessive. The metaphor of the chain around his neck - if something happens to Qin He, what will he do? That question hangs in the air like a storm cloud. And then you have the father-son relationship, which is just... God. Li Zhuang is the worst parent in the history of fiction and I need a moment. He didn't just abandon Qin He emotionally - he literally offered him as payment. The casual way he says "You little brat, you're still somewhat useful" after securing his own safety tells you everything you need to know about this man's soul. It's empty. Completely hollow. What's fascinating is how Qin He and Yu Cheng navigate this crisis differently. Yu Cheng immediately wants to solve it with force - "What about that person? Do you want me to teach him a lesson?" - and Qin He gently pushes back, hoping Yu Cheng can learn a softer approach. But then Qin He faces his own father alone, completely on his own, without Yu Cheng there to protect him. There's a painful symmetry to that. The trust between Qin He and Yu Cheng is the emotional anchor of all this chaos. Yu Cheng checking his phone obsessively, the eyelid twitching, the urgency of running out into the rain - every detail screams that he cares deeply. And Qin He, even while blindfolded and terrified, still calls the police rather than panicking. They're both holding it together differently, and that's what makes their bond feel so real.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or