Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This entire sequence takes place in one room—the teacher's office—and somehow it feels like a pressure chamber. Let me break down why the setting works so well. First, the physical space: Yang Man is seated, Yu Cheng is standing, Qin He leans against a desk. When Yu Cheng kicks over her chair, that's not just action—it's a literal destabilization of the power structure in the room. The teacher who was comfortably seated and delivering her lecture suddenly has to scramble for survival. The lighting detail when Qin He first enters: 'With a click, the door lock was opened, and the light from outside shone in.' This is such a small detail but it's so cinematic. You can picture it—the darkness of the office interrupted by that sudden beam of hallway light, marking the moment Qin He becomes an unwilling witness to violence. And the physicality of the confrontation: 'His hand gripped her collar and slowly tightened it, as if just touching her was dirty.' That 'as if just touching her was dirty'—that's the kind of prose that gives me chills. It tells you everything about Yu Cheng's mindset. He's not enraged in a hot way; he's enraged in a cold, controlled, disgusted way. That's scarier. The office setting also matters because it's supposed to be a PLACE OF TRUST. This is where students go to be disciplined, where teachers are supposed to be authorities. But what we see here is the complete inversion of that—Yu Cheng is the one wielding power now, Yang Man is the one cowering, and the 'authorities' (the principal, the leaders) arrive too late to prevent the damage. The final image of just the two of them in the silent office, with only panting sounds? That's one of those moments in fiction where the setting becomes almost a character itself. The walls closing in. The isolation. The weight of everything unsaid hanging in the air between them.
... Read More
There's a recurring motif in this text that I can't stop thinking about: the word 'monster.' Yang Man calls Yu Cheng a 'manic monster.' Later, he asks Qin He 'Do you also think I'm a manic monster?' And when he's holding Yang Man's collar, he literally says 'I'm a crazy monster? Then maybe you should see what a crazy monster looks like when it goes berserk!' This word—'monster'—is weaponized again and again, and it's not just an insult. It's a label that gets STUCK to him like tar. And then there's 'stain on the Yu family.' That's another label, another way of being defined by others in the most negative way possible. These labels accumulate throughout the text, and they reveal something profound: the danger of letting other people's opinions become your identity. The contrast between Yu Cheng and his unnamed brother is also deeply symbolic. The brother represents everything Yu Cheng is told he should be—successful, disciplined, worthy. But we never meet him. He exists only as an abstract standard, a ghost that haunts every interaction Yu Cheng has. That's a powerful metaphor for sibling rivalry and parental expectation. And the recording itself? That's symbolic too. It's truth captured in digital form—a weapon against lies. In a world where Yang Man can twist reality (showing bruises that came from her own tight collar, claiming he tried to kill her), the recording is the one thing that can't be spun. It's objective reality. It's proof that sometimes the truth doesn't need to be shouted—it just needs to be played. The Yu family's sponsorship of the school is another layer of symbolism. Money buys influence. Money buys silence. Money can make a 'stain' untouchable. But it can't buy respect. Yu Cheng has all that family money behind him, and he's still told he's worthless. That's the cruel irony the text keeps circling around.
... Read More
Okay so the final scene hits like a freight train. The way it just starts mid-action — 'been longing for day and night, as a smile played on his lips' — no warning, no buildup within the chapter itself, just pure momentum carrying forward from everything that came before. And then that line: 'Qin He, you know, I won't let go of what I have set my heart on.' CHILLS. Absolute chills. The possessiveness, the vulnerability wrapped in threat — it's the culmination of every tension thread the author has been pulling since chapter one. The story structure here is brutal in the best way. Instead of giving us a tidy bow, we get this raw moment of commitment that feels both earned and terrifying. And then the author immediately follows it with 'End of story' — no fanfare, no epilogue tease, just finality. That confidence is something else. The journal entries between chapters 87-90 serve as emotional counterweight to that explosive ending, showing us the long, aching space between what was promised and what was delivered. The parallel timeline structure — the elderly neighbor's observations woven with the letters to Qin He — creates this delicious dramatic irony where we're seeing the origin of everything while simultaneously witnessing the resolution. Brilliant structural choice.
... Read More
So let me just process the structure of what the author did here. They DON'T dump all the backstory at once. Instead, we get these fragmented revelations: first the clinic visit where Qin Wanqing is practically glowing with joy over her son's 'correction,' then the encounter where Qin He's clearly traumatized, then finally Yu Cheng receiving that document with the full history. Campus violence, verbal bullying, isolation, then the forced treatment. Each piece lands like a hammer blow. The narrative arc here is devastating because it reframes everything we thought we knew. Qin He wasn't always like this. He used to joke about being in 'no man's land' wherever he went. He wore crisp white shirts. He had light in his eyes. The author slowly peels back these layers and each one makes you want to scream. And that ending—it's not a cliffhanger in the traditional sense, it's more like a emotional freefall. The sentence literally breaks off. It's as if the story itself can't bring itself to finish that thought. What also works is how Qin Wanqing is positioned. She's not a cartoon villain. She's a mother who genuinely believes she's helping her son, who wants a commemorative plaque made for the doctor. The banality of her evil makes it so much worse.
... Read More
The last line of this section—"In Yao'an City, a continuous drizzle began to fall; the sky was dark and gloomy, without a trace of light." It's such a simple description but it perfectly captures the mood after everything that just happened. Everything gets pulled away from these boys and then suddenly it's just... gray. No sun. No hope. Just rain. What's interesting is how the author uses weather as emotional punctuation. The drizzle isn't dramatic, it's not a thunderstorm or anything cinematic. It's just persistent and dreary, which somehow fits the story better than any big weather event could. The story has been building toward this kind of suffocating atmosphere since the photo got posted. The school forum, the whispers in the hallway, the principal's pitying looks—all of it creates this claustrophobic world where these two boys have nowhere to hide. I also appreciate how the home scenes contrast with the school scenes. The school is full of noise and people and judgment, but home is worse in its own way. Qin He's mother smashing his phone, Yu Cheng's father sitting in a leather chair discussing how to ruin someone's life like it's a business decision. Both spaces feel like traps, and that's a really deliberate choice by the author. There's no safe place in this story yet.
... Read More
I need to sit down. I just read the scene with Qin He's mother and I am genuinely not okay. "Your grandma is coming, and it's better for her to stay with me so I can take care of her." She's crying, wiping her tears, immediately pivoting to cooking for her son because that's all she knows how to do — take care of everyone else while falling apart herself. The author didn't even go hard on the pathos. No dramatic music, no tearful confession. Just... hands worn out beyond recognition, scars all over, white hair at forty-plus, fine wrinkles. These are the details that wreck you because they're so matter-of-fact. Qin He notices all of this. He sees his mother aging in real time and his first thought isn't "how unfair" — it's "how do I earn more money?" And then there's Yucheng, who has everything materially but is emotionally starved, throwing a tantrum because Qin He didn't react to him on the bus. Two kids, opposite worlds, both lonely in completely different ways. That's the thing that sticks with me — the parallel suffering. Qin He can't afford to be emotional because his family needs him. Yucheng can't stop being emotional because he has no other outlet. One suppresses, the other explodes. The tutoring arrangement is supposed to be transactional, but isn't it kind of romantic in its own twisted way? Qin He agreeing to spend his limited free time with Yucheng, setting boundaries, making it work — it's the most attentive he's been to anyone in these chapters. And Yucheng, for all his brattiness, actually found someone he wants to impress. Don't tell me that's not the seed of something.
... Read More
The way this author writes about places is something else entirely. Mount Lushan in the September entry isn't just scenery — it's a ghost landscape. 'The fallen leaves in the mountains cover the ground, and the view from above is truly beautiful, like a sea of clouds.' But the beauty is hollow because the beloved isn't there. The narrator went specifically to the place their partner 'always wanted to visit' and experienced it as a museum of absence. Every couple walking hand in hand becomes a mirror of what's missing. Then Yao'an City in February — 'cloudy skies all day and occasional rain or snow. It's gloomy and dreadful without you, as if the weather is always bad.' The author doesn't just describe atmosphere; they make the environment itself complicit in the emotional state. And the villa neighborhood in the final section — high-end, curated, sterile — contrasts sharply with the raw emotional exposure of the letters. The elderly narrator's perspective adds this layer of physical space that exists outside the romance but quietly observes it: 'In our neighbourhood, we all live in high-end villa communities.' It's a world where wealth can't buy connection, where the Yu family is too busy to notice their mascot-grandmother-figure wandering alone. These settings aren't decoration; they're emotional architecture.
... Read More
"That bitch changed your last name, huh? Good for her?" - this opening line from Li Zhuang is just... what? It's brutal, it's crude, and it tells us everything we need to know about this man in six words. He doesn't even greet his son. He attacks the one change that represents Qin He's independence from him. The last name. The identity he tried to erase. And then Qin He's response, or rather the lack of one, speaks volumes. He doesn't engage with the verbal abuse. He punches. "Didn't he tell you? Keep your mouth shut." Cold. Surgical. These two voices couldn't be more different - Li Zhuang is all hot, drunk, spitting anger, while Qin He is ice. And that contrast is the entire conflict in microcosm. But the most interesting dialogue comes from the creditor. Listen to this: "It's really hard to find you and your dad. We went to your house, but you're living in the dormitory. We've been waiting for you for several days." The casualness is terrifying. These people aren't screaming or threatening - they're almost conversational about kidnapping. "Little brother, your dad owed us money, and he gave you to us as compensation. You know you have to pay your debts, right?" The normalcy of the threat is worse than any violence. And Qin He's response: "I have nothing to do with him. Do you really believe him if he just made up a son out of thin air?" The calm defiance! The witty comeback under pressure! This is the kind of line that lives in your head for days. The author has crafted dialogue that doesn't just advance the plot but reveals character in every single exchange. The narrative voice itself is worth noting too - it's observational, almost detached, letting the dialogue carry the emotional weight rather than drowning us in internal monologue.
... Read More
This one passage hit me harder than it should have. Yu Cheng wipes grape juice from Qin He's chin, treats him almost like a child, and Qin He freezes — not because he's offended, but because he's never been praised or treated gently like that. The text says it directly: "He seems to have forgotten that the person in front of him was an almost adult male, not a three-year-old child who could wipe things off himself." But Yu Cheng doesn't forget. He does it anyway. And that's the whole story right there. The symbolism of food and sweetness runs through this entire excerpt. The grapes are described as having a sour and sweet scent, and Qin He literally cannot taste sweetness in life — "Children love sweets, but he had never tasted the sweetness." His father was an alcoholic who spent money on drinks, not on a child's needs. The mother was afraid. Qin He learned early to be careful, to not make messes, to be the good quiet kid who didn't cry. Being called obedient was a sentence, not a compliment. Photography works as a symbol too — it's about capturing moments, freezing time, choosing what to focus on. Qin He says he wants to do photography, and Yu Cheng immediately sees it as a way to pull him out of his own head, to give him something that belongs to him alone. The invitation to the exhibition isn't just about an event — it's about Yu Cheng insisting that Qin He deserves experiences that aren't tied to survival or performance. The house visit at the end ties all of this together. Qin He's embarrassed by his living situation, the suburb, the smells, the disorder. It's everything his childhood represented — chaotic, uncontrolled, unguarded. And Yu Cheng is walking into it willingly, bringing gifts, making his mother happy, never once treating it as less than. That's the theme: someone who has never been allowed to be imperfect is being loved anyway.
... Read More
The pacing in these four chapters is genuinely sneaky. The author spends the first half establishing Yu Cheng as sort of a nuisance—showing up with his friends, acting entitled, making snide remarks—and then slowly peels back layers until you realize the kid is actually putting in emotional labor he doesn't know how to name. The transition from the shopping scene to the classroom handoff works because there's a full day gap that lets tension simmer. You're left wondering 'what happens when he actually gives the clothes?' and the payoff is both satisfying and frustrating because Qin He's so... flat about it. And then Gao You's warning lands right after, which reframes everything. Is Yu Cheng actually dangerous? Or is he just emotionally clumsy and poor kids everywhere are taught to assume the worst? The chapter ends with that teacher's voice rising—'They're a bunch of useless people'—and it cuts off mid-complaint, which is such a classic hook. We're about to find out who this teacher is yelling about, and honestly the fact that the teacher immediately labels Yu Cheng 'useless' while the narrator clearly cares about him tells me everything I need to know about who's actually valuable in this story. The structure trusts me to connect dots. Good author.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the candy scene because my heart actually stopped for a second. Yu Cheng puts a candy in his palm and just... offers it to Qin He? With that grin? And Qin He who is literally so uncomfortable with closeness that his breathing quickens and he leans back — but he doesn't refuse the candy, right? He just sits there awkward and the whole thing is so tender it hurts. And then there's the sunlight scene where Yu Cheng is watching Qin He read and just tracing his face with his eyes. His eyelashes are so long. Thin lips, people with thin lips are cold-hearted. But then Yu Cheng licks his own lips uneasily and I was SCREAMING. He's noticing these things about Qin He's face and he's blushing and trying to hide it by rubbing his face. Meanwhile Qin He has no idea and just tells him to behave because his look is ugly. "My face is the kind that people would stop on the street and ask if I'm a celebrity." Bro you don't even realize what you're doing to him. The three-point smile Qin He has around Yu Cheng now compared to before — that detail killed me. This is someone who has never been so comfortable, never felt so at ease, and he's blaming it on money when really it's the person who gives it to him. And Yu Cheng asking "are we friends now" with that awkwardness — this boy who is usually so bold and aggressive is genuinely nervous about this. I'm not okay. This slow burn is killing me.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the bus as a symbol and I think it's the central metaphor of these chapters. The bus is a shared space where class differences become violently apparent. Yucheng, who has never had to squeeze onto a bus in his life, is physically overwhelmed by ordinary commuters — the very people his family probably ignores. Meanwhile Qin He moves through that same space effortlessly, boardings smoothly while Yucheng is left panting on the sidewalk. It's a perfect visual representation of their entire dynamic: Qin He navigates the real world with practiced ease; Yucheng is a tourist in it. Then there's the imagery of Qin He's mother's hands. "Worn out beyond recognition, with scars all over and no intact skin left." Hands are such a loaded symbol — they create, they nurture, they labor. Her hands tell the story of everything she's sacrificed without her saying a word. And Qin He reading that story, understanding it instantly, choosing to absorb the burden himself rather than complain... that's the theme right there. Survival isn't glamorous. It's scars and white hair and pretending you're fine while your child watches you cry. But the deepest symbol might be the tutoring arrangement itself. Money buying attention. Time commodified. Yucheng literally paying for proximity to someone who barely acknowledges him. Isn't that what capitalism does to human relationships? Everything becomes transactional, even care. Even connection. And Qin He, the most honest character in this story, is the one who forces every interaction into a commercial framework because it's the only language he trusts. I'm not saying the author is making a political statement. But the symbolism is so woven into the fabric of the narrative that you can't unsee it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or