Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about how this whole situation explodes in my face every time I think about it. One minute they're fine, the next—crack—the phone screen shatters and everything is over. The author plays with timing so well here. The photo gets posted during lunchtime when traffic is highest, which means by the time anyone even thinks about deleting it, everyone has already seen it. That's not bad writing, that's deliberate. The principal says it takes a while because it was peak hours, and honestly? That detail makes it feel real, like something that could actually happen at a school. It's not some convenient misunderstanding where people just don't see the photo. No, everyone sees it. Everyone talks about it. What really hits me though is how fast things spiral. It goes from the photo appearing to Qin He being suspended and brought home to his mother physically abusing him. That escalation is brutal and it happens without any warning or breathing room. I wanted to scream at the page. And Yu Cheng's father? He doesn't even yell. He just sits there in his chair with those unnaturally cold eyes and says he can destroy Qin He's future with a few phone calls. The power imbalance here isn't just between the boys and their parents—it's between people who have everything to lose and people who have literally nothing. Also, I have to mention the transfer school compromise. Yu Cheng negotiates his way into transferring so he can stay close to Qin He without directly defying his father. But you can feel the author laying groundwork for more conflict because of course this isn't a real solution. It's a temporary ceasefire. What happens when they miss each other? What happens when one of them tries to reach out? I'm not convinced this story ends happily anytime soon.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Yu Cheng because this man is a complete mess and I love him for it. The way he grabs Qin He on the ice rink—yanking him away from Lu Ran like his hands move before his brain can catch up—is so revealing. This isn't just jealousy, right? It's something deeper and more desperate. He's been holding back all day, we see it in the text, and then ONE moment of Qin He being tender with someone else and he SNAPS. But here's the thing that got me—when he confronts Qin He, his actual argument is: you wouldn't let me find you, so how did you find HER? That's not really about Lu Ran. That's about feeling replaced. And then he STILL doesn't throw the gift he brought. He's furious and he's still carrying a present. That's the kind of contradiction that makes a character live on the page. The whole half-brother framing is interesting too. Lu Ran sees Qin He as family, completely platonic, and she says so outright. But Yu Cheng can't wrap his head around sharing attention, even platonically. The narration literally tells us he doesn't understand why he has these thoughts but he won't allow them—which is basically the textbook definition of someone denying their own feelings. I'm sitting here like... bro, maybe it's not about possession, maybe it's about something else entirely. But I'm not telling him that.
... Read More
Okay so this entire arc is about what happens when your past catches up to you in the most violent way possible. Let me start with this line because it sets the entire tone: "I gave birth to you for nothing, you ungrateful brat!" - that is Li Zhuang at his absolute worst, and it's horrifying because it's so casual. The guy is literally yelling at his own son like he's some kind of ATM that failed to dispense cash. But here's what absolutely floored me: Li Zhuang doesn't just threaten Qin He. He SELLs him. I had to stop reading for a second. The man who beat him as a kid, who showed up demanding money, then just... negotiates with creditors to hand his own child over as collateral. "He can pay you back. If he can't, I'll give him to you as compensation." GIVE HIM. Like he's a used bike, not a human being. And the structure of this is so clever. First you have the alley confrontation where Qin He punches his father and seems to have total control. Then the scene shifts to the creditor's meeting where the power dynamic FLIPS. Li Zhuang is now the one sweating and trembling, and the man with the scar across his forehead is in charge. Then BAM - you realize the consequences of that conversation because it cuts to Qin He being blindfolded and tied to a chair. The reader knows before Yu Cheng does, and that dramatic irony is exquisite. The pacing here is relentless. From the confrontation to the kidnapping to Yu Cheng's desperate search - it all happens in real-time almost. There's no breathing room. The chapter ends with Qin He making a calm phone call while surrounded by eight men, which I found both terrifying and incredibly impressive. This plot doesn't waste a single moment.
... Read More
So this whole chapter is basically Yu Cheng executing a masterplan, and honestly it kind of works? He hears Qin He say he likes photography, immediately pivots to "my friend gave me a ticket," and then spends the entire evening maneuvering to get real tickets from his brother. The whole sibling exchange is hilarious — Yu Cheng literally lying and saying "I promised someone else, don't make me lose face" to his brother who clearly indulges him completely. But the actual plot movement here is quieter than the surface action. The visit to Qin He's house with his mom is huge. We get Qin Wanqing's perspective for the first time, and she sees Yu Cheng as this good kid, the only friend her distant son has. Meanwhile Qin He is openly uncomfortable about Yu Cheng seeing where he lives — the remote suburb, the haphazard lanes, the garbage that sits too long. That gap between what Qin Wanqing thinks (her son has a great friend who brought gifts) and what Qin He feels (exposed, ashamed of his surroundings) is a plot detail I can't stop thinking about. Also the test paper threat at the beginning is both funny and telling — Yu Cheng saves Qin He from his own mom's awkward interrogation, and the reward is two more exam papers? These two are weird.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author controls tempo here because it's masterful manipulation of reader experience and I am BOTH impressed and furious. The chapter opens with that Shakespeare quote about daybreak, then immediately plunges us into darkness. That structural choice alone sets the rhythm for everything that follows. The author knows we'll be waiting for hope and deliberately withholds it, section by section. First we get the clinic scene—slow, almost bureaucratic in its cruelty. Then a month jump cut. Then the encounter, which unfolds in real-time with agonizing slowness. Every step Yu Cheng takes, every backward step Qin He makes, is given its own paragraph, its own beat. The author doesn't rush the reunion because rushing would betray the gravity of what's happening. They let us sit in the discomfort. We're supposed to feel trapped the way Qin He feels trapped. Then the information reveal comes in pieces. Not all at once. We get snippets—campus violence first, then the treatment clinic. Each revelation lands, then the narrative moves on, giving us space to breathe before the next blow. And that ending. The cut-off sentence. It's not just a cliffhanger; it's a pacing choice that mirrors Qin He's fragmentation. The story itself can't hold together past a certain point because the character CAN'T hold himself together. The structure IS the meaning. There's no neat resolution because there's no neat recovery. Some wounds don't close. They just become part of how you move through the world.
... Read More
These chapters move like water — calm on the surface, but there's undertow everywhere. The structure is interesting because the author cuts between two completely different emotional registers and somehow makes them complement each other instead of fighting. We start with Yucheng's bus humiliation, which is almost comedic in its specificity. Then we pivot to Qin He's phone call with his mother, which is devastating in its quietness. The switch is jarring but deliberate — it forces you to recalibrate your emotional expectations every few pages. What I find masterful is how the author handles the transition from public to private spaces. The bus stop is chaotic, loud, public — Yucheng's domain of performative frustration. Then we cut to Qin He's cramped living room, where the tension is domestic and suffocating. The contrast does so much work without any explanation. And the pacing within the tutoring scene! Yucheng drops his pen, taps his fingers, makes a peace sign — small, restless actions that mirror his mental state. Qin He barely moves. The author uses physical stillness versus physical fidgeting to communicate the power imbalance without stating it outright. When Qin He finally says yes, the chapter doesn't explode with celebration. It ends on a practical note about scheduling. This is how real life works — the big moments are understated because the characters don't have the luxury of dramatic reactions. Is there any part that drags? Honestly, barely. The Lin Ying scenes could've been tightened, but they serve as breathing room between the heavier moments. The author knows when to press and when to let the reader catch their breath. I stayed up way too late reading these four chapters and that's the only review I need to give.
... Read More
The rental apartment. Two rooms advertised, one delivered. A bedroom separated from the living room by a half-wall — just for the sake of renting it more easily. Let that sink in. Someone built a life inside a lie of space. Two almost-adult boys crammed into something that pretended to be bigger than it was. And yet Yu Cheng doesn't notice or care about the house at all — his mind is full of how to improve his impression, how to be worthy of this visit. The half-wall is everything. It's the barrier between who Qin He is publicly and privately. Between the confident exhibition-goer and the boy who gets leg numbness from crouching too long. Between the fluent English speaker and the child who still flinches at the sound of his grandfather's voice. "My leg is numb." Qin He says this deadpan, and Yu Cheng laughs until people look over. But it's a funny moment only on the surface. Qin He crouched down suddenly — not because he wanted to, but because his body remembered something older than the present moment. A posture of submission. Of shrinking. Years of abuse wired into his nerves so deeply that even sitting casually triggers a collapse. And the cat? Stray. Owned by someone else in the alley. Fed only a few times. Chubby from good care but clumsy, rolling on the ground, unable to catch what's right in front of it. Qin He playing with it in the autumn breeze — perhaps the only creature in this story that understands what it means to be half-owned, half-free, cared for but not claimed. Just like him.
... Read More
There are visual motifs in this text that I can't stop thinking about. The maple leaves at the beginning — bright red, spiralling into the classroom through the partially open window, caught in the gauze screen, contrasting with Yu Cheng's fair skin. This is such a deliberate image. Red against pale. Movement against stillness. Nature invading the structured space of a classroom. Yu Cheng asleep, transformed by this moment of beauty into something softer, more vulnerable. The maple leaves are doing thematic work here — they represent something transient and beautiful that arrives uninvited, just like Qin He arriving in Yu Cheng's life. Then there's the sunlight. Dim, filtering through trees, casting shadows on Qin He's face. Yu Cheng watching him through this dappled light — it's almost painterly. The light becomes a barrier and a bridge at the same time. Yu Cheng is physically close but emotionally hidden behind his own thoughts. And the photos on the wall at Yu Cheng's house. Yu Cheng and his brother, childhood to adulthood, always scowling, arms crossed, clearly unhappy about being photographed. But his mother is there too — young-looking, smiling. These photos are a timeline of a family that exists without its father. The absence of the father in those photos (and in the narrative so far) is loud. Yu Cheng's rebellion, his aggression, his test scores — are any of these just noise to fill a house that feels incomplete? The well-maintained garden in winter — 'a green paradise, like a thriving spring' — is probably the most symbolically loaded image. Someone is caring for this space obsessively. Who? And why maintain perfection in a season of decay? I think about that every time I turn the page.
... Read More
"You're like a sheep that fell into a wolf's den." That line from Yu Cheng is everything. He's being playful, teasing, but there's also something protective in it disguised as banter. And then Qin He immediately counters with the exam paper threat — classic deflection through authority. These two have a rhythm that feels lived-in, like they've been saying these exact things to each other for months. What I love is how Yu Cheng's dialogue shifts depending on who's listening. With Qin He's mom, he's fluent in sweet talk — "this is Qin He, right? A good kid" — basically performing the perfect student role. With his own brother, he drops the act entirely: "I don't care; you have to get it for me." That's not someone who normally asks nicely. He's used to getting what he wants, except with Qin He, where the stakes are different. Qin He's voice is quieter, more measured. When he says "Photography" — just one word, no elaboration — it's significant because the text itself tells us this is the first time he's talked about his own ideas with Yu Cheng. The dialogue here does the heavy lifting. The moment with the grape juice is told through action more than words, but the subtext in Qin He's silence speaks louder than anything he could say out loud. Their dialogue isn't trying to be clever for its own sake. It serves the relationship. Every exchange reveals something about power dynamics, vulnerability, and who holds the cards in any given moment.
... Read More
'Broken glass scattered everywhere' — that's literally the opening image of Qin He's childhood memory and I can't stop thinking about it. Glass shatters. It cuts. It reflects light in fractured ways. And the author puts it right there in the first paragraph of that flashback like it's the foundation stone of everything. Then the dim light becomes a 'spotlight shining on this fragmented family, as if it were a farcical play being acted out.' A farce. That word does so much work. The father kneeling, crying, promising to change — it's theater.表演.表演.表演.表演表演.表演表演.表演表演.表演表演.表演.表演.表演.表演.表演表演表演表演. I keep going back to that hospital scene — the winter wind howling outside, the child on tiptoe reaching up to touch his mother's head, saying 'I'm not afraid; I have my mother.' The repetition of 'mother' as anchor, as fortress, as everything. And later, the keypad phone — a phone that can only call and text, bought by a mother who had no education herself but understood that connection matters. Every object in this story feels loaded. The smartphone Qin He is working toward buying isn't just convenience — it's access, independence, a lifeline to the world he's trying to climb out of. Meanwhile Yu Cheng's iron chain that 'clangs' with every movement — what does that symbolize? Noise. Performance. Making yourself impossible to ignore because maybe if you're quiet, nobody sees you at all.
... Read More
Let me tell you about the most devastating thing in this entire text: 'I heard you have an older brother, right? You're not giving up on yourself and letting yourself go?' That line from Yang Man? That's not just an insult. That's a surgical strike aimed at whatever insecurities Yu Cheng already carries. Because we learn later—through his own internal monologue—that EVERYONE compares him to his brother. He's the 'stain on the Yu family.' His brother is 'better than him.' And he HATES it. The scene where he grabs Yang Man's collar and his veins bulge, eyes bloodshot? That's not just anger. That's years of being told you're the lesser Yu child, the disappointment, the one who got everything handed to you but couldn't even succeed at that. It's the pressure of expectations crushing down on him in that exact moment. And Qin He's response when Yu Cheng asks him 'Do you also think I'm a manic monster? Not as good as my brother?' is so perfectly gentle. 'Whether or not you're a monster is not for others to say; it's up to you to decide for yourself. Also, I really don't know your brother; I only know you, Yu Cheng.' Think about what THAT means. In a story where everyone defines Yu Cheng by comparison to someone else, Qin He is the FIRST person who says 'I don't know your brother. I only know YOU.' That is a profound character moment. That's the kind of line that changes everything between two people. Also notable: Yu Cheng hitting Qin He when he's trying to calm him down. That tells you something about his state of mind—he's so overwhelmed that even the person trying to help him becomes someone he lashes out at. And then Qin He taking that, getting a red mark from his nails, and still staying? That's loyalty. That's genuine care. That's the foundation of something real between these two characters. And Yang Man? She's not just a 'mean teacher.' She's someone who uses her position to vent her own frustrations—like how she's obsessed with Yu Cheng dragging down her salary. She's not concerned about his education at all. She's concerned about her bonus. That's the kind of character detail that makes antagonists feel real rather than cartoonish.
... Read More
The visual language in this section is strikingly consistent and I think that's intentional. There's this recurring palette of white that shows up everywhere—hospital walls, the colorless replacement of Yu Cheng's wardrobe, the blank page of a future Qin He supposedly wanted for him. It's a very specific kind of emotional desaturation. But then you have the cemetery scenes, which are rendered with actual sensory detail. 'The last leaf fell from the tree, and the young man in a dark coat stood up.' I keep coming back to this image. A dark coat against what I assume is a gray winter sky, one last leaf falling, and this man who has become a ghost while still breathing. The cinematic quality of it is unreal. The graveside opening is another scene that lingers. 'Tears drop onto the gravestone'—you can almost hear the sound of that impact. 'His throat is unable to make a sound, only turning into a low sob.' The progression from desperate pleading to wordless grief to dry-eyed hollow silence maps perfectly onto the anatomy of prolonged mourning. It's not dramatic in a theatrical way; it's dramatic in the way real silence is dramatic. And Qin He's apartment—the space he leaves behind—is almost a character itself. The photos, the annotations, the candy wrapper, the withered petals in a bag, the broken phone. These objects create a private museum of a relationship that existed outside the main narrative. The worldbuilding here isn't about magic systems or political structures; it's about the archaeology of love. What someone keeps when they're gone tells you more about them than anything they said while alive.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or