Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the bus scene is EVERYTHING. Yucheng trying to squeeze onto that bus and getting absolutely obliterated by regular commuters while Qin He just calmly boards and leaves him there? I laughed out loud. But here's the thing that actually gets me: Yucheng's entire arc in these chapters is him desperately trying to be seen by Qin He, and it's painful to watch. He transfers classes, takes up the seat next to him, drops his pen dramatically — all of this from a kid who literally has a driver and a mansion and still feels completely invisible to the one person whose opinion matters. Meanwhile Qin He? He doesn't even have the energy to engage. His head is somewhere else entirely — worried about his grandma, his mom's exhaustion, how to earn money. The contrast is brutal. Yucheng's problems are emotional and immediate; Qin He's are survival-level. And yet, when Qin He finally agrees to tutor him, there's this tiny crack in the armor. He could've said no. He could've ignored him completely. Instead he negotiates: double the market rate, weekends only, two hours at a time. That's not kindness — that's a transaction. But it's also the closest thing to connection either of them is going to get right now. And Lin Ying! Poor woman walking on eggshells with her own son, sensing he's up to something but not knowing what. She sniffs him for car exhaust — that detail killed me. The physical comedy of it masks something real: she's afraid he's spiraling again, and she's right to be. Yucheng promises to study hard, but we all know he's doing it for Qin He, not for his grades. The power dynamic here is so deliciously messed up.
... Read More
Okay so this whole confrontation in the office? Chef kiss. Absolute masterpiece of escalation. Let me walk you through why. Yang Man comes in with that fake 'concerned teacher' energy, and honestly I was already rolling my eyes before she even opened her mouth. But then she crosses line after line after line, and Yu Cheng is just... taking it. For a while. You could see the tension building in the text—the way he stays quiet, the way everyone thinks he's just going to swallow it again. But here's where the plot gets interesting: she keeps going. She hits his family. She calls him a 'manic monster.' And then the explosion happens. Kicking over the chair. Grabbing her collar. Bloodshot eyes. The whole thing reads like a pressure cooker finally blowing its lid. And Qin He? Oh man, Qin He is the MVP here. He didn't want to get involved. He just wanted his stuff and to leave. But something in him snapped and he pulled out his phone and STARTED RECORDING. That detail about him remembering the homeroom teacher said Yu Cheng doesn't hit people? That's not just foreshadowing—that's the author setting up the one piece of evidence that flips the entire narrative. Without that recording, Yu Cheng is completely screwed in this school system. The recording reveal when the principal shows up? That was the plot twist I wasn't ready for. Yang Man's face turning worse and worse as Qin He plays it back—chef's kiss again. And then Yu Cheng drops that threat about the Yu family's contributions to the school? Now the power dynamics have completely shifted. What started as a teacher scolding a student became a standoff where the student holds all the cards. I kept waiting for Yu Cheng to lose it completely, and for a second I thought he actually might. But the scene where he calms down and Yang Man escapes? That moment of silence with just panting sounds? That was the emotional low point of the whole chapter. And then Qin He kicking him lightly asking if he's okay? That's the kind of detail that makes you realize this character cares more than he lets on.
... Read More
Let's talk about narrative voice because this section is dominated by two distinct registers: the raw, unfiltered interiority of Yu Cheng and the carefully composed written voice of Qin He (through his letters). The contrast between them is where the writing truly sings. Yu Cheng's dialogue—even his monologue, even the stuff he says to no one—is pure id. 'Fuck it, what future?' 'Who do you think you are to be so relieved, leaving me alone?' This isn't a character performing for an audience. This is someone whose internal vocabulary has been reduced to fragments and expletives because language itself can't contain what he's feeling. When he whispers 'Do you want me or not? I'm so dumb; no one wants me' to a hallucination of Qin He, the dialogue sounds exactly like what it is: a person talking to empty air because the alternative is admitting the air is empty. Then Qin He's letters are completely different—measured, almost clinical in their tenderness. 'You should be proud of yourself, and you will have remarkable achievements in the future.' 'Remember to be gentle and smile more.' This is a man composing his own obituary, choosing every word with surgical precision. The nickname 'little hedgehog' is the crack in the armor—the one moment where the composed writer breaks character and speaks as a lover instead of an executor. The hallucination dialogue is the wildest choice though. '"Why are you so dumb, Yu Cheng? No one would want someone like you."' Is this Qin He mocking him? Or is this the voice Yu Cheng has internalized from the world—his father's disappointment, society's judgment, his own self-loathing projected onto the ghost of the man he loved most? The ambiguity is deliberate and it haunts me.
... Read More
Let's talk about stakes for a second because this chapter redefined what I think "stakes" even means in fiction. Usually stakes are about what might happen. Here, the horror is that everything has ALREADY happened. Qin He has already been broken. The question isn't whether he'll be hurt again—it's whether anything left inside him can survive what's coming next. The external conflict is clear: Qin Wanqing's abuse disguised as treatment, the society that enables it, the school system that failed to protect him. But the INTERNAL conflict is where this chapter truly grips you by the throat. Qin He doesn't want to push Yu Cheng away. He explicitly thinks—maybe not in those words, but in that ache—"He didn't dislike Yu Cheng anymore." He's aware of his own feelings. He wants connection. He wants to be loved. And yet his body betrays him every single time. The trauma response is automatic, involuntary, deeper than thought. Yu Cheng's conflict mirrors this from the other side. He CAN'T reach him. Every step forward is met with retreat. He ends up becoming a ghost in his own love story—present but invisible, watching from distances where he can't be seen. The helplessness here is suffocating and I mean that as the highest praise. What scares me most is that the person Yu Cheng begs for information—a vague figure on the other end who sighs and says alright—this suggests there's a whole network of people who know what happened and stayed silent. The stakes just expanded to an entire complicit system.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the dialogue in this chapter is devastating and I don't know how the author does it. Every line feels like it was written with the specific purpose of making you want to throw the book across the room. Let me give you the best one: "You want us to cut ties completely? Fine, I'll transfer schools. But you better not touch him. I want him to have a clean record with no punishments." Yu Cheng just negotiated his entire life away in that sentence. He offered to disappear, to transfer, to make himself irrelevant—and all he asked for in return was that Qin He be left alone. That's not a demand. That's a plea wrapped in a bargain. And his father? He just says fine and leaves. No debate. No consideration. Because he already won. Qin Wanqing's lines are equally brutal, and that's the point. "Why are you treating me like this? I raised you so that you could fall in love with a man!" Wait, what? She raised him to fall in love with a man? No, she raised him to be the son she wanted, and when he became someone else, she felt betrayed. But the way she says it—like it's some logical cause and effect—is absurd and that's what makes it hurt so much. The author's voice throughout this chapter never lets up. Even the narration carries weight. When it says Qin He 'kept his head down the whole time,' you can feel the silence. When it describes Yu Cheng's father's eyes as 'unnaturally cold,' you believe it completely. This writer knows exactly how to make every word count.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely relentless, and I need to talk about how the author builds tension like a master craftsman. It starts SO slow. Yang Man comes in with that passive-aggressive 'How did you do on the exam this time? Your score was zero' line. It's almost casual. Almost boring, if you're not paying attention. And that's the trap—the author lets you get comfortable before they yank the rug out from under you. Then the insults escalate. One after another. Each paragraph adds a new layer of venom: 'skipping classes,' 'getting into fights,' 'manic monster,' 'what kind of parents,' 'older brother,' 'not giving up on yourself.' Each barb is delivered with increasing speed and intensity, and by the time she says 'if I were your father, I wouldn't choose you as my successor,' you're holding your breath. And then—WHAM. The chair kick. The collar grab. 'What, don't you think I won't really hurt you?' The sentence structure itself changes. Shorter sentences. More fragments. The prose becomes fragmented, mirroring Yu Cheng's loss of control. But here's what I loved: the author doesn't let the tension stay at maximum forever. There's this moment after Qin He pulls Yu Cheng off where 'everything was silent, and only the sound of panting could be heard in the office.' That pause—that deliberate silence—is so powerful. It's the calm after the storm, and it makes the following scenes feel even more charged. The arrival of the 'leaders' and the principal creates a new wave of tension, but the recording reveal deflates it completely. And then the final exchange between Yu Cheng and Qin He—'Do you also think I'm a manic monster?'—that's the quiet ending that lingers. The story doesn't close with a bang; it closes with a question that haunts you. Also worth noting: the chapter ends mid-sentence with 'That…you…don't you need to take car'—cutting off abruptly. That's either a cliffhanger or a deliberate fragmentation, and either way it leaves you wanting MORE.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Yu Cheng because this chapter completely rewired how I see him. On the surface he's the classic toxic rich boy—shows up at Qin He's classroom door surrounded by his entourage like he's worshipping at a shrine, makes a sarcastic remark about bad memory, shoves the bag into Qin He's arms, and walks off. Classic "I'm giving you a gift but also I'm above you" move, right? But then you go back and reread the earlier stuff and... wait. This dude went to his brother for help finding clothes. His brother didn't even remember. Yu Cheng literally thought about it for days before swallowing his pride. And when he was shopping he was sweating through a hot day, worried about the price, muttering about whether the store was going bankrupt. He picked light-colored denim with embroidered edges—not flashy, not a big brand name. Something durable. He knew Qin He wouldn't wear something obviously expensive. So Yu Cheng went through all this effort to give a gift that wouldn't make Qin He uncomfortable, and Qin He basically treats him like a delivery person. That line hits different on reread: "It's not that Yu Cheng has a bad memory, but Qin He is just used to forgetting unimportant things." Ouch. The power dynamic here is so uneven it almost hurts, and Yu Cheng doesn't even seem to fully realize it yet. He got mad that his brother forgot him, wondered "when did he become so forgettable?"—and then he's the one being forgotten by Qin He and he can't figure out why. Classic. He justifiably feels hurt but has no framework for understanding that his entire existence in Qin He's world is background noise.
... Read More
Okay so Lin Ying opens the door and literally ignores both her own son AND her son's boyfriend to fawn over Qin He. And I need to talk about what the author is doing here because on the surface it reads like a throwaway comedic moment — mom loves the nice tutor, whatever — but it's actually doing SO much structural work. Think about it: we just spent two chapters watching Yu Cheng be the competent, caring one. He's handling funerals, doctor appointments, emotional support, homework — he's basically the main character's anchor. And then he gets home and his own mother treats him like background noise while Qin He gets the watermelon treatment. It's funny, yeah, but it's also quietly devastating and it changes how we see EVERYTHING that came before. Then Yu Cheng locks the door because "it would be strange to be intimate with his boyfriend in a private space" — and that single sentence just opened a whole new layer. The outside world sees one thing (Qin He as the golden tutor, Yu Cheng as the rebellious kid), but behind closed doors it's completely different. The pacing here is masterful because the author doesn't dwell on it. Doesn't explain it. Just drops the door lock and moves on like it's nothing. But it's everything. And then we cut to the ear-pulling tutoring scene and suddenly the whole emotional weight of the previous moment gets released through comedy. It's like the author knows we're sitting with something heavy and gives us permission to breathe. That's not accidental pacing — that's craft.
... Read More
I came into this expecting a fluffy slice-of-life chapter and instead got handed an emotional car crash and I'm not mad about it. The pacing here is surprisingly calculated. We start with domestic warmth—Qin Wanqing fussing over her brother, the casual family banter—and then Lu Ran arrives and everything gets lighter, almost comedic. She's clinging to his clothes, begging for tutoring, showing off a ticket she worked hard to get. The reader relaxes. Good. We're supposed to relax. Then Yu Cheng appears and the entire temperature drops. The transition from Lu Ran's bright, chatty energy to Yu Cheng's cold sneer is almost jarring, and that's the point. The author doesn't ease us into it—they just yank the rug out, much like how Qin He got yanked on the ice. 'He had been holding back, but this question ignited his anger.' That line alone tells us everything about the buildup. Days of unreturned messages, unanswered calls, simmering resentment, and it all detonates over something as mundane as whose hand Qin He is holding. After the explosion, the author lets us breathe again. Dinner. Then the private moment with the gift. Then the quote. Then silence. The structure mirrors an actual emotional arc—tension, release, false calm, deeper revelation. It doesn't rush. It doesn't drag. And that ending with the snow quote? That's a cliffhanger that doesn't feel like one but absolutely is. What happens next? I need to know.
... Read More
That umbrella. I need to sit with that umbrella for a moment. A transparent umbrella with little yellow ducks on it. Borrowed from a girl. Worn by Yu Cheng — this angry, violent, untouchable young master — while walking home in the rain with Qin He. The author specifically notes it looked "out of place with Yu Cheng's gloomy expression." Of course it did. This symbol of childish warmth, of something soft and slightly ridiculous, placed in the hands of someone who has spent his entire life armored in anger. And the rain. It's been drizzling the whole chapter. Not a storm, not dramatic weather — just this constant, annoying moisture that makes everything sticky and uncomfortable. The narrator says: "The humid air and sticky sweat made him uncomfortable." Even at the police station. Even in safety. Trauma doesn't care about location. But the umbrella scene is where the symbolism peaks. Half of Yu Cheng's clothes get wet protecting Qin He. He doesn't seem to notice. The narrator compares it to his heartache — "Just like that feeling of heartache, it submerged his entire heart without a word." This boy who has never felt empathy for anyone now stands in a downpour, soaked and silent, because someone else matters more than his own comfort. The father-son theme runs underneath everything too. Qin He's father sold him for 30,000 yuan. Yu Cheng's father is presumably absent or distant (given Yu Cheng's wealth and the fact that he seems to operate entirely independently). Both boys have fathers who failed them, and neither has anyone who chose them. Until now. The line "For the first time, someone cared for him so much, and he felt like he was surrounded by warmth, as if he had someone to support him" — this is the thesis of the entire novel compressed into one sentence. Qin He has never had support. Yu Cheng has never chosen anyone. They are each other's first. And then the next chapter immediately undercuts all of this profundity with a bathroom joke. Which is honestly the most realistic thing ever. Growth isn't linear. Vulnerability doesn't last forever. Sometimes you open your soul to someone and then ten minutes later you're making fart jokes because that's what humans actually do.
... Read More
Oh my god, the perfume scene. Yu Cheng spent extra effort on this outing — changed his usual flashy clothes, dressed simply, maybe even tried to match Qin He's aesthetic, put on fragrance that he hoped would impress. And what does Qin He do? His face literally changes. "Quite good" — said through gritted teeth, chin tucked into his collar, trying to breathe. The fragrance was too strong, suffocating even. Just like Yu Cheng himself sometimes: exuberant, flamboyant, impossible to ignore. But here's what destroyed me — Yu Cheng pouted. He waited. He wanted validation and got nothing. And yet he still dared to be angry but didn't say anything, only grumbled silently. This boy gives everything and receives crumbs, and he keeps coming back. Then the ladybird lands on Qin He, transforms to powder in Yu Cheng's hand, and — boom — that oppressive atmosphere vanishes but the scent lingers. Symbolism so clean it hurts. The ladybird was beauty, fragility, something alive landing on Qin He's guarded world. And then it died. Yu Cheng held it in his palm and it turned to dust. The cat scene though — that's the warm one. Qin He smiling, playing with toilet paper, wearing a camel coat, bangs swaying in the autumn breeze. For a moment, the real Qin He shows through. Playful. Soft. The kind of boy who would be happy just watching an orange cat fail to catch a paper ball. And Yu Cheng notices all of it.
... Read More
This chapter completely redefined what's at stake for these characters and I am NOT okay. On the surface, the external conflict is straightforward — Qin He gets kidnapped because of his father's debt. Simple, clear, dangerous. But the real conflict, the one that knocked me sideways, is what happens AFTER the rescue. Because even though the kidnappers are caught, even though Qin He is physically safe, he's still carrying all of that — the violence, the fear, the humiliation of being touched, the fact that his own father sold him. Yu Cheng's transformation in this chapter is the most violent thing that happens, and no one gets hurt. Watch him: he's pacing, fists clenched, eyes red, looking at Qin He's swollen cheek and bleeding forehead and almost losing his mind at the police station. He KICKS Li Zhuang. He shakes off people restraining him. This boy who previously would've cried when ignored now looks like he could burn the world down. And the line that shattered me: "If you do something, you have to pay the price. It won't work this time no matter what you say." That's not a threat. That's a vow. And it terrifies me because I know exactly what kind of person Yu Cheng is about to become. The internal stakes for Qin He are equally brutal. He spent the whole kidnapping trying to negotiate, trying to stay calm, trying not to show fear. But when he's actually safe, when he's walking home under that ridiculous umbrella, THAT'S when he breaks open and tells Yu Cheng about his childhood. Why then? Why not during the kidnapping when he needed someone most? Maybe because in the moment, survival came first. But in the quiet afterward, when he's safe and the adrenaline fades, all that pain comes rushing back. And he chooses Yu Cheng to carry it. That's a huge risk for someone who's never had anyone. The school gossip reveals another layer of stakes: Yu Cheng actually STARTED studying. Not because of pressure, not because of his father, but because of Qin He. What happens if Qin He leaves? What happens if their dynamic shifts? The reader knows this bond is fragile and extraordinary at the same time, and every scene after this feels charged with the question of whether either of them will survive this closeness intact.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or