Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me be real for a second — the stakes in this book are low-key devastating and I don't think people talk about it enough. Qin He is a tutor making twice his old salary because he has no choice. He's studying for his own exams on the side. He's desperate for time and money simultaneously, which is basically the worst combination possible. Everything he does is calculated: 'with time, he could repay this difference by working hard.' He feels guilty for earning more, which means he's operating under constant financial pressure. If Yu Cheng's family decides to stop paying — which could happen at any moment — Qin He loses everything he's built in these chapters. Meanwhile Yu Cheng's stakes are different but equally real. His dad's requirement is top 800. He's aiming for top 600 on his own. This isn't just about grades — it's about proving himself to a father who clearly measures worth in rankings. And his mother? She's there, smiling, young-looking, holding the house together. What does she want from him? The conflict isn't dramatic explosions. It's the quiet terror of a scholarship-dependent student sharing a car ride with the richest kid in town, knowing this comfort is conditional. It's Yu Cheng blocking sunlight for Qin He without realizing he's doing it — an accidental intimacy that could just as easily be rejected. Every scene between them has an underlying current of 'what happens when this arrangement ends.' Qin He tells himself it's about reputation, about professional pride. But we know better. We know he's already invested emotionally and he's terrified of it. The author doesn't hammer this home. It just sits there, pulsing, under every cheerful exchange. That's skilled writing.
... Read More
'He wasn't overly friendly with people, partly due to his personality and partly because he knew that he couldn't afford to mess with most of the people in the school or because they were simply not from the same world as him.' I keep coming back to this passage because it's the thesis statement for the entire novel's exploration of class. 'Not from the same world'—what a devastatingly clinical way to describe social division. The clothes Yu Cheng buys are deliberately unbranded, affordable, durable. They're antithetical to everything the wealthy students wear, and yet Yu Cheng himself is one of them. He's caught between worlds—close enough to the rich kids to belong, but distant enough that even his own brother doesn't register him. The embroidered patterns on the jeans edges are interesting too: decorative but subtle, like the kindness Yu Cheng is trying to offer. It's there if you look closely, but easy to miss if you're not paying attention. And Qin He—the top student, the student representative who speaks every week, the one who 'always had good academic performance'—is invisible to people like Yu Cheng until this moment. The novel seems to be asking: who gets seen, and on what terms? Yu Cheng sees Qin He but misunderstands him. Qin He sees Yu Cheng but files him under 'unimportant things to forget.' They're both right and both wrong, and that's where the tragedy lives.
... Read More
Okay can we talk about how this story just opens with random gossip about someone hitting the principal's son and I was like wait who are we even following here and then it hits me it's a setup for Yu Cheng, but no, we get yanked into Qin He's entire life instead. That was such a deliberate misdirection. The author drops us into a classroom where girls are whispering about 'the legend' Yu Cheng, builds this whole mythos around a delinquent rich kid, and then pivots so hard into Qin He's backstory that I had to re-read to make sure I wasn't confused. And honestly? It worked. Because now I understand why this collision at the wall matters — it's not just some random bully encounter, it's two people who are both carrying invisible weight crashing into each other. The plot is laying groundwork for a clash between two fundamentally different worlds: the scholarship kid who survived abuse and the rich kid who survives on entitlement and rage. And that final line — 'Otherwise I'll report to you tomorrow' — left me genuinely intrigued. What happens next? The conflict hasn't erupted yet but it's clearly coming.
... Read More
There is a moment in these chapters that hit me like a punch to the stomach. Qin He goes from stumbling, cautious, watching Yu Cheng's every expression like a cat measuring territory — to standing on a platform, speaking flawless English to overseas visitors, radiating confidence. It was breathtaking. Then the second he senses Yu Cheng actually watching him, all that light dims. He becomes restrained again. The exhibition itself is the perfect narrative device here: it's his dream, his world, the place where he normally belongs — except the moment another person enters his frame of reference, he retreats. That pattern, repeated silently, tells us everything about who this boy is and what he's built around himself. And then Li Zhuang appears. One paragraph, barely described properly before the narrative slams into childhood trauma. "Shut up. He's Qin He. Why are you trying to take advantage of him by calling him your son?" The way Yu Cheng deflects the abuse, stepping on the man harder — it's fierce. Protective. But the ending, that half-finished sentence "He was no longer a child" hanging there, it broke something open in me. The grandfather is still there, still lurking, still breathing down their necks. This isn't resolved. None of it is.
... Read More
"They had become like reset smartphones, tampered with by others and filled with implanted thoughts." That line. That ONE line tells you everything about this world. No exposition dump, no info-dump about the facility, just that single devastating metaphor and I immediately understand the entire horror. The world-building here is so efficient it hurts. You get the sense of a place where people are systematically dehumanized—the guards controlling sleep with noise, the doctors with their cold glasses and smiles, the banners in the empty treatment room displaying the suffering of patients and the ignorance of their families (which is honestly the most biting detail—these people's own families didn't even know). The sensory details are sharp too: the faint morning light that GLARES now because his body has gone sensitive, the tinkling bell on his wrist as the only marker of time passing, the red rashes spreading across his skin. This isn't just a prison—it's a factory for breaking people, and the author makes you feel every inch of it without ever raising its voice.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is doing some serious heavy lifting and I want to applaud whoever wrote it. Lu Ran's voice is immediately recognizable—she clings, she whines, she pivots from vulnerable to gossip-mode in one breath. 'I can't live without you. You have to help me this winter break. My grades are already terrible. If this continues, I'm afraid my mom will beat me with a broom.' That's a full paragraph of panic and manipulation and it reads like someone who has spent a lifetime knowing exactly which buttons to press on Qin He. And she's self-aware enough to lead with the gift: 'Aren't I thoughtful?' Like she knows she's being excessive and is banking on charm to get away with it. Qin He's quieter, more measured. 'You wrinkled them all.' That's his entire response to a dramatic performance. Dry, practical, unfazed. It tells us everything about their dynamic—he's seen this version of her a hundred times and he's not impressed. But Yu Cheng—his dialogue is where it gets interesting. Every sentence is either an accusation or a deflection. 'What are you doing?' 'Did I disturb your peace?' 'Can't you understand human language?' He's performing rage but underneath it is this raw, almost childish need to be prioritized. And then the aftermath: 'Your birthday gift.' Two words. No explanation, no softening. Just the gift and his hands behind his back and his eyes everywhere but on Qin He. That silence between the lines is where the real dialogue lives.
... Read More
The symbolism in this ending is so layered I could write a thesis. Paper lanterns — 'I have lit some paper lanterns for you. Remember to take them, you're afraid of the dark.' This is everything. Light as protection, light as guidance home, light as an offering to someone who 'is afraid of the dark' — both literally and metaphorically. The narrator has been carrying these lanterns through an entire year of separation, and the fact that they still exist at the end suggests the light wasn't extinguished. The mole under the eyelash is another obsessed-with-detail symbol: 'There's a mole under your eyelashes, and when you smile, you look like a cunning fox.' This is someone who has memorized every inch of the beloved's face through years of looking at photographs. Memory as devotion. And then the recurring motif of the PROMISE — 'You promised me that you would accompany me, so you have to fulfil that promise.' Promises as the structural bones of the entire relationship. The elderly neighbor's section introduces another symbol: the wounded child who 'understood too much too early and endured too much.' This mirrors the central relationship — two damaged people who made promises to each other in darkness and are now trying to fulfill them in light. 'When the voices become too noisy, one can choose not to listen, and it's more important to follow one's heart.' The author's thesis statement disguised as grandmotherly wisdom. Everything connects. Everything loops back. This isn't just a love story — it's about how we carry people who aren't physically present and how promises become the architecture of survival.
... Read More
Gao You comes in all mysterious like 'Did you upset Yu Cheng? Stay away from him; he's not easy to deal with' and my chest actually tightened. Not because Yu Cheng is some danger to Qin He—I mean sure, the social power imbalance is real—but because I could already feel the slow-burn ache of this relationship forming. These two are going to keep missing each other in the most agonizing way. Yu Cheng puts in this enormous emotional effort, carefully selects clothes, asks his brother, worries about making Qin He comfortable, and then acts so casually when he gives them that Qin He's left thinking it was just a transaction. And Qin He is already planning how to pay him back like it's a debt to be settled, not a gesture to be received. The author drops this tiny detail that kills me every time: Qin He 'wasn't overly friendly with people, partly due to his personality and partly because he knew that he couldn't afford to mess with most of the people in the school or because they were simply not from the same world as him.' That sentence is a whole thesis on loneliness disguised as practicality. He's not cold because he doesn't care—he's cold because caring costs too much. And Yu Cheng, who is simultaneously the most powerful person in Qin He's world and the one person who might actually see him, is also the one Qin He instinctively keeps at arm's length. I need them to just talk to each other like normal human beings for five seconds but I also understand why neither can.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dialogue in this chapter because holy hell, the voice work is incredible. First, let's address the elephant in the room: the bathroom scene. I almost spit out my tea. Qin He looks at Yu Cheng — who has been following him everywhere since the kidnapping — and says, "Don't be shy about it. I won't make fun of you." And Yu Cheng's response, twisting his head almost breaking his neck, saying "Just go by yourself!" — this is some of the most natural teenage boy dialogue I've ever read. The indignation, the flustered deflection, the violence towards inanimate objects (that stool scraping must've sounded like nails on a chalkboard). You can HEAR this exchange. But it's the quieter dialogue that really sells the characters. When Qin He talks about his childhood, he says it in this flat, almost robotic tone — "Qin He, you're so pitiful" — mimicking other people's voices but never his own. The author writes: "There was no emotion in his words. It seemed more like telling a story that had nothing to do with oneself." That's not just good dialogue, that's psychological characterization in three sentences. And Yu Cheng? His lines are short, sharp, practically violent in their intensity: "Who did this?" "Are you okay? Did they do anything to you? Tell me." Each question is a separate sentence. No flourishes. Just raw panic disguised as interrogation. Then later, "You're going to turn into a grumpy old man" — and Qin He says it with laughter, which is the first time we see him really laugh since the kidnapping. That shift in tone, from deadpan to genuinely amused, tells us everything about how much Yu Cheng means to him. The school gossip section is narrated in this detached, almost documentary style — people speculating, assuming, misinterpreting. It contrasts beautifully with the intimate dialogue between the two leads and gives us outside perspective without breaking the narrative flow. One tiny critique: the kidnapper dialogue at the beginning is pretty generic. "Rich people have strange fetishes" — yep, that's a thing villains say in every story ever. But honestly, it doesn't matter because the author isn't interested in those characters. They're plot devices, and they serve their purpose.
... Read More
Yu Cheng is such a good person and it makes me so mad every time I read his scene. Think about it—he gets slapped by his own mother's friend at school, then goes home to kneel in the study while his father threatens to blacklist Qin He from every school in the country. And what does he do? He keeps his posture straight and says, "I did nothing wrong, and I have no intention of seeking revenge on anyone." Bro. You're kneeling on the floor being intimidated by your father and you still find the energy to defend someone else's character? But then there's Qin He and I just—I don't know how to process it. He took the beating from his mother. Didn't flinch. Just stood there like a wooden man while she slapped him and called him disgusting in front of the principal. And when she smashed his phone? He kept saying "I'm sorry" over and over like he was the one who caused this. Like he deserved it. The tragedy of his character right now is that he's internalized all of this shame before anyone even told him to be ashamed. The most devastating moment for me was when Yu Cheng realized his father's words about not being able to protect Qin He had become a permanent wound. "Traces of the beating still remained on his face, and Yu Cheng slightly bowed his body. He had learned to submit." He submitted. Not because he agreed, but because the alternative was destroying the person he loved. That's not weakness—that's the most painful kind of strength there is.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pacing in this section because it's genuinely masterful. The author knows exactly when to slow down and when to glide, and it's not predictable. Chapter opens with a quiet classroom scene — Yu Cheng asleep, maple leaves at the window. Very still, very atmospheric. Then it cuts to the dorm, the test papers, the remedial session. The pace accelerates naturally because Qin He is actively engaging with Yu Cheng's problems instead of just observing. By the time we get to the candy moment, the energy has shifted from observational to interactive. Then — and this is where I love it — the author drops us into a completely new environment. The car ride, the autumn breeze, the villa, the garden. This isn't just a scene change; it's a tonal expansion. The story was confined to school walls before, and now we're seeing Yu Cheng's entire world. The pacing deliberately slows here. We linger on the garden, the lighting, the photos. The author is giving us space to breathe and absorb what this means for their dynamic. The structure moves from public (classroom) to semi-private (dorm) to private (home). Each transition represents a deeper level of access Qin He has into Yu Cheng's life, and each transition is earned through their growing comfort with each other. What I found particularly smart is how the author handles the study progression. Instead of montaging through weeks of tutoring, we get one focused session and then jump forward to results. The top 600 reveal hits because we've been given just enough process to believe in the outcome without being bored by the mechanics. The chapter ends on an image — the mother appearing, youthful, smiling — which is both warm and slightly unsettling. Where do we go from here? The pacing demands we turn the page. And we do.
... Read More
cannot wait for the ending

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or