Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay let's talk about Yu Cheng for a second because THIS MAN. He chose a school NEAR Yao'an City, didn't even go home on weekends, and was sending messages from DIFFERENT PHONE NUMBERS because he knew Qin Wanqing was checking his phone. That is the level of desperate, hopeful, quietly devoted energy I am HERE FOR. The photo at the corner of his desk — that's not just a bookmark, that's his entire emotional anchor. He's sitting there in this cramped dorm, grinding through schoolwork like his life depends on it, all for a future with someone who might never know. And then the chapter cuts to Qin He, alone in that dark room, THINKING ABOUT YU CHENG'S KISS IN THE HAUNTED HOUSE. Both of them are suffering in completely different ways, orbiting each other, and the author just—just lays it out like that. No grand confessions, no dramatic reunions. Just a guy who won't stop hoping and a guy who can barely survive. The asymmetry of it is absolutely killing me.
... Read More
I need to talk about voice because this book has MULTIPLE distinct narrative voices and the author switches between them seamlessly. The main character's letters have this intimate, slightly unhinged quality — 'Little Fox, I have lit some paper lanterns for you. Remember to take them, you're afraid of the dark.' The nicknames, the domestic details, the way they negotiate their own clinginess ('Don't complain that I'm clingy') — it all reads like actual letters someone would write at 2am. Then there's the final dialogue: 'Qin He, you know, I won't let go of what I have set my heart on. You promised me that you would accompany me, so you have to fulfil that promise.' This single exchange carries the weight of the entire novel. No exposition, no explanation — just two people speaking in the shorthand of a relationship that has survived impossible odds. And the elderly neighbor's voice is completely different: 'I don't understand the preferences of these young people.' Bemused, slightly detached, warmly observant. The contrast between her measured, slightly formal tone and the raw desperation of the letters is jarring in the best way. Even the author's brief sign-off — 'Bowling and tossing flowers' (I think this is a translation of a Chinese gesture of gratitude) — has its own personality. Three distinct voices, none of them interchangeable.
... Read More
"I said, Qin He, how much money did Yu Cheng give you to maintain him? Yu Cheng listens to you so much now, do you two have any improper relationship?" I came for the dialogue and stayed for the imagery. Let me explain. The洗手 room scene is so viscerally described. Qin He washing his hands — and I mean REALLLY washing them, knuckles raw, water dripping, that almost violent scrubbing motion that signals his rising anger before he even moves. The author keeps coming back to his hands. First they're red from washing, then later Yu Cheng notices them again. Red hands = clenched fists he didn't throw. That's subtle AF symbolism. And the setting itself! The upstairs restroom during break time, crowded and noisy, versus the downstairs one that's quiet because nobody goes there. Qin He deliberately chose the empty space. You can feel the acoustics — muffled sounds of impact against the door panel, the echo of insults bouncing off tiles. These boys are wearing white clothes that get splashed with dirty water, buttons broken, glasses crooked. The visual degradation is so specific. I could PICTURE them sitting on the floor after, pure white shirts now grey with toilet water, collars askew, no visible bruises but probably internal soreness everywhere. Then CUT to the classroom. Bright fluorescent lights probably, textbooks being shuffled, the teacher's performatively cheerful voice from the front. The contrast between the violent darkness of the restroom and the sterile brightness of the classroom is chef's kiss. Qin He walks back in on tiptoe, greets the teacher normally, sits down like nothing happened. The sheer AUDACITY of maintaining normalcy after that. The world of this story feels real because the spaces between violence and everyday life are so sharply drawn.
... Read More
I'm gonna be honest with you — this chapter had me reading at like 11pm and I told myself just one more chapter and then it spiraled. Here's WHY the pacing works so well. It starts with what feels like a casual conversation between Yu Cheng and Qin He. Yu Cheng explaining why he has a reputation, joking around, that whole playful dynamic where Yu Cheng is basically acting like a kid wanting validation. Super low stakes. You're relaxing. Feeling good about these two. Then — BAM — Qin He overhears the gossip. The temperature drops instantly. "his expression turned cold, and he washed his hands harder and harder, almost rubbing them red." That's your pivot point. The author doesn't announce the shift, they just SHOW it through action. From there the tension compounds FAST. The boys don't even realize they've crossed a line until Qin He is literally pressing one of them against the door. The dialogue during the confrontation is razor-sharp — short, vicious, escalating. No filler. Each line either advances the conflict or reveals character. When they bring up the homosexuality angle, that's when Qin He snaps and things get physical. The fight scene is surprisingly quick (thank god) — two paragraphs max — because the author knows you don't linger here. What matters isn't the fight, it's what the fight MEANS. Then the classroom return. Sudden whiplash back to mundane. Class starting, teacher pretending nothing happened, Yu Cheng being awkward. This calm-after-storm section is where the real emotional weight settles in. If the author had ended on the fight, it would've felt like an action setpiece. By bringing us back to the quiet tension of the classroom, it becomes something deeper. My only minor complaint: the very end feels slightly rushed. That last line about "the teacher began teaching with a fake smile" loops back to an earlier detail but doesn't fully land. Still, overall this chapter is a masterclass in tension escalation and release. I stayed up way too late because of it and I'm not even mad about it.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that struck me about the plot structure — both Qin He and Yu Cheng literally climb over the school wall at night. That's not a coincidence in storytelling, right? The author is setting up a parallel that's supposed to mean something. One boy does it because he's poor and working late and just needs to get home. The other does it because he's rebellious and reckless and probably causing trouble. They end up in the same situation, dealing with the same kind of person, getting the same kind of wounds. And then there's this whole disciplinary review plot thread hanging over Yu Cheng's head that feels like it's going to blow up later. Also the Yang Man subplot is clearly building toward something — she insults the entire class calling them useless and then personally targets Yu Cheng's family. That line about 'the son of a fallen king' is not something you just walk back. The plot has two threads running: the wall incident connecting the two boys, and the classroom conflict with the teacher. I have a feeling they're going to collide in a way neither of them expects.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one moment after dinner. Yu Cheng drags Qin He aside, shoves a camera into his hands, and then stands there with his hands behind his back looking at literally anything except Qin He. The text says 'this person is like a landmine, exploding with every sentence' and honestly that is the most accurate character description I have ever read. He's terrified of vulnerability so he armor-plates it with aggression. And then Qin He—bless him—just starts coaxing him like a child. 'When is your birthday?' That question, asked so casually, completely dismantles Yu Cheng. The narration says he was 'quite happy that Qin He could care about his birthday' and 'happy to see someone making an effort for him.' This man had been picking trees out of anger five minutes ago and now he's just... soft. Scratching his head. Forgot he even learned a magic trick to show Qin He. What wrecked me though was the ending. The quote they drop—'If we can experience snow together in the morning, we can consider ourselves old together in this life.' Who says that? To whom? Why does it feel like it was meant for exactly this moment but neither of them is brave enough to say it out loud? The text says 'the air was silent, and it seemed like there were only the two of them left in the world. But because of this small matter, they were at odds with each other.' That small matter being a birthday gift exchange that somehow became the most intimate thing in the entire chapter. I can't breathe.
... Read More
I need to appreciate how these two actually talk to each other because the dialogue here is genuinely good. Qin He's voice is so distinct — dry, slightly sarcastic, impossible to mistake for anyone else's. When he says "People who can't find common ground usually can't be friends, so you need to study hard" that is SO him. He's not being mean, he's being practical, and the fact that he frames friendship as conditional on academic improvement is both hilarious and kind of sweet in a very Qin He way. Yu Cheng's voice is completely different — more playful, a little unhinged, but with these moments where he drops the act and sounds genuinely earnest. "So, are we friends now?" coming from the same guy who was just teasing about luxury watches moments earlier? That contrast is everything. And the back-and-forth about the face: "Don't look at me like that. It's ugly. Behave." / "My face is the kind that people would stop on the street..." This is natural! This is how people actually talk when they're comfortable with each other. There's no stiffness, no 'as you know Bob' exposition disguised as conversation. The teacher-student power dynamic in their speech is also interesting. Qin He uses imperatives naturally — "be quiet," "follow my list," "behave" — but he also softens. He calls him "Young Master Yu" teasingly. Yu Cheng calls him "dear teacher Qin" with that playful glint. The title itself becomes a form of flirtation. Qin He's line about luxury watches though — "Not unless you want me to talk to you about luxury watches" — this revealed so much about him in one sentence. This is a person who genuinely doesn't have anything in common with this wealthy kid except tutoring, and he's painfully aware of it. That's not just dialogue, that's character.
... Read More
This one passage keeps running through my head: "It's a good thing you still come to school from time to time; otherwise, you might have turned into a monster with three heads and six arms." And then later, one of the bullies says: "This kind of person is a scum, causing trouble wherever they go. Maybe his parents don't even like him, which is why he acts like a monster with such a bad temper." Monster. Monster. Monster. The word gets thrown around like it's nothing, but I can't stop thinking about what it means here. On the surface, Yu Cheng is labeled a monster — the wild kid, the fighter, the one who doesn't fit. But then Qin He reveals something crucial: he was ALSO bullied as a child. "Qin He also grew up being bullied since he was a child." The story quietly positions both of them as survivors of the same system that labels them monsters. The boys in the restroom call Yu Cheng a waste of space, a jinx, suggest he's not even his mother's biological son — that's dehumanization at its most vicious, wrapped up in homophobic undertones. What fascinates me is the mirror between Qin He and Yu Cheng. Both have been called monsters. Both have learned to fight. Both wear labels that don't fit. But they respond differently — Yu Cheng lashes out physically (the fight with the male teacher), while Qin He channels his pain into cold precision and protection. The author seems to be asking: who really becomes the monster? The kid who fights back, or the ones who hide behind gossip and numbers? The red hands motif reinforces this too. Qin He scrubs until they're raw — not just from anger, I think, but from the weight of having to defend someone else's innocence in a world that refuses to see it. When Yu Cheng later asks about his hands, he's touching the physical evidence of protection. The image lingers long after the chapter ends, doesn't it?
... Read More
This text is layered with so many thematic currents that I barely knew where to start. But the most overwhelming one is debt - not just financial debt, but emotional debt, familial debt, the invisible obligations we carry from people who never deserved them. Li Zhuang embodies the perversion of fatherhood. In traditional terms, a father gives life and a son repays through loyalty and care. But here, Li Zhuang has taken this transactional framework to its darkest conclusion: he gave birth to Qin He, therefore Qin He owes him everything, and when Qin He refuses to pay, Li Zhuang tries to SELL him to settle the account. The metaphor is almost too on the nose, and yet it works because it's so devastatingly realistic. The name change itself is symbolic. Qin He shedding his father's surname is an act of self-reclamation, of breaking the cycle. "That bitch changed your last name, huh?" Li Zhuang's rage at this tells us that the name was never just a label - it was ownership. Taking a new name was taking back his own identity. And Yu Cheng's protective instinct represents a different kind of debt - the kind you choose to incur. He didn't have to care about Qin He. He didn't have to run into the storm searching for him. But he does, willingly, completely. The wolf guarding his treasure isn't bound by blood obligation; he's bound by love. That contrast between forced debt and chosen loyalty is the heart of this entire passage. The scar on the creditor's forehead forming a 川 character is also worth sitting with - it's almost like a map, a mark of someone who has survived and continues to survive through violence. It's a permanent reminder carved into flesh.
... Read More
You thought the conflict was just 'rich boy gives poor boy clothes awkwardly'? The author just pulled the rug out. That teacher's voice cutting through the office scene—'I teach them, and they still give me attitude! Especially Yu Cheng, he even hit me last time'—and suddenly everything shifts. Yu Cheng isn't just some oblivious rich kid, he's apparently in conflict with authority figures. He's got a reputation. The homeroom teacher tries to deflect and give Qin He candies like nothing happened, but you can feel the room changing temperature. Now every interaction between Yu Cheng and everyone else has stakes: what does this teacher do to him? Why did he hit her? How does this affect his standing at school? And for Qin He—sandwiched between a complaining teacher and a powerful student whose behavior he can't quite read—the conflict isn't external, it's internal. He already knows not to get involved with people like Yu Cheng, but Yu Cheng keeps appearing in his periphery like a ghost he can't shake. The stakes just went from 'will these two bond over hand-me-down jeans' to something much more volatile. I'm not even sure I want them to have a smooth relationship anymore. Give me the friction.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about THIS scene. Yu Cheng finding Qin He after a month apart. He goes to see him, sneaking out from under Yu Yao's surveillance like some romantic hero, right? And what does he find? Qin He sitting on the ground, scars visible, trembling, recoiling like Yu Cheng is some kind of monster. The irony absolutely DESTROYED me. "I won't touch you. If you don't want to see me, I'll leave first." Yu Cheng says this while watching the person he loves physically panic at his approach. And Qin He—he doesn't even dislike Yu Cheng anymore. He wants to go after him. He wants to reach out. But the demons carved into his bones won't let him. What kills me most is that final paragraph where it cuts off mid-sentence: "If... if he had been more caref—" More careful? More present? More something? I am NOT okay. I sat here staring at my phone like the text itself owed me an explanation. The whole dynamic of Yu Cheng becoming this silent guardian—watching from afar like a knight protecting a prince instead of a princess—is so beautifully written in its simplicity. He never stops caring, even when he can't reach Qin He. And Qin He crying on that hot pavement like a child with no one to help him... I genuinely felt like I was suffocating reading it.
... Read More
The letters. THE LETTERS. I need a minute. January 6th — 'I saw someone who looked very much like you. But don't worry, I didn't mistake them for you. How could I possibly mistake you?' — this is the kind of line that makes you put the book down and stare at the ceiling for twenty minutes. The obsession here isn't romanticized or glossed over; it's presented with this raw honesty that's both beautiful and deeply unsettling. And then the February entry hits differently: 'The weather in Yao'an City is getting worse... It's gloomy and dreadful without you, as if the weather is always bad.' The emotional logic of grief dressed up as meteorology — I'm ruined. But what absolutely destroyed me was the May entry. 'I wanted to leave my mark on you. I wanted everything on your body to have my traces.' This isn't just love, this is someone who has built their entire sense of purpose around another person and then realized they weren't strong enough to protect them. 'I haven't been involved in your past, but it sounds like a bitter life just by listening to it. My heart aches for you.' THE REGRET. The guilt wrapped in tenderness. And the ending — 'Qin He, you know, I won't let go of what I have set my heart on. You promised me that you would accompany me, so you have to fulfil that promise.' After everything, it's still about a PROMISE. A childhood promise that carried them through separation and suffering. I'm not crying, you're crying.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or