Funeral - Reviews

Funeral
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's a thematic current running through these chapters that I can't shake, and it all circles back to that closing quote about snow. 'If we can experience snow together in the morning, we can consider ourselves old together in this life.' It's a line that carries the weight of everything unsaid between these characters. Snow is temporary—it melts, it refreezes, it's fragile and beautiful precisely because it won't last. The makeshift ice rink itself is a symbol: something created from aftermath, from what was lost (melting snow) becoming a new surface to move across. Lu Ran represents safety—childhood friendship, no complications, the kind of bond that has no romantic threat because it was never allowed to exist outside platonicty. She's the half-sister framing, the warm memory, the person who protected a weak boy and now clings to him like family. But she's also the obstacle, whether she intends to be or not. Yu Cheng represents something far more dangerous: the thing that can't be named. The text refuses to call it what it is, even in narration. 'He didn't understand why he had these thoughts but he didn't allow them.' Denial as a character trait. The camera gift—something permanent, something to capture moments, something to hold onto. Irony noted. And that trembling tree? The only thing displaying anger because the snow has already melted? That's the whole relationship in one image. Everything that's been swallowed by silence, visible only in what shakes afterward.
... Read More
I keep thinking about that cracked phone screen. It's the first image in this chapter. A kiss photo, shattered glass, and then Yu Cheng picking up the pieces. What a metaphor. Their relationship gets exposed in the most violent way possible—cracked open for everyone to see—and then they're left trying to gather whatever's left. The phone itself represents connection. Qin He's mother smashes it, and in that moment she's not just destroying an object. She's cutting off his ability to reach out, to communicate, to maintain any link to the person he loves. And Yu Cheng's father doesn't even need to smash anything. His threat alone does the damage. The irony is that both parents think they're protecting their sons, but they're really just enforcing shame. There's also this recurring idea of surfaces versus reality. The photo on the forum shows one moment—a kiss—but it becomes the entire definition of who these boys are to everyone else. Qin He becomes "the pervert" in his classmates' eyes. Yu Cheng becomes a disappointment to his father. Their whole identities get flattened into that single image. The story seems to be asking: what happens when a private moment becomes public property? And more importantly, who decides what counts as a scandal? I also noticed how the word "monster" gets used. Yu Yao calls Yu Cheng a monster, a pervert. But the real monsters in this chapter are the adults—the ones hitting, threatening, and breaking children for loving the wrong person. The story flips the language of shame and makes you question who actually deserves it.
... Read More
'Whether it's the last falling leaf, the fleeting fireworks, or the flying snow in the sky, Qin He loves them all.' I had to stop reading this part because it hit me in a way I wasn't expecting. This boy's entire world is home, school, and his part-time job. He's never been anywhere. His whole desire is to one day explore the vast world after getting a stable job. And his way of coping with that longing is photography — trying to capture beautiful moments before they disappear. That's not just a hobby, that's a philosophy. He knows things are fleeting so he wants to preserve them. Meanwhile Yu Cheng is this walking explosion of emotion — his whole personality is described like 'a stick of dynamite.' If something doesn't go his way, he makes everyone unhappy. But even he has these moments of awkward vulnerability, like when he's on the phone with his brother trying to find cheap clothes and can't even explain why he's doing it. The contrast between these two boys — one quiet and yearning, the other loud and confused — it creates this emotional tension that's really compelling. I keep thinking about that moment where Qin He washes up and goes to bed 'not thinking much about what had happened today.' Does he really not think about it? Or is he just good at burying things?
... Read More
Let me lay out what's actually at stake here because people are underestimating this story. On one side: Qin He's family is drowning. His grandmother's health is declining, his mother is working herself into early old age, and Qin He is a student who needs to figure out how to bring in more money without sacrificing his education. That's not a subplot — that's the main plot wearing a disguise. Every decision he makes is filtered through this pressure cooker. On the other side: Yucheng has been transferred to a class where his father has set a hard requirement — top 800 in the grade, no reckless behavior, no disturbing classroom discipline. His father doesn't believe his promises. The chains are tightening layer by layer, and the text literally says: "Layer by layer, the chains and demands fall on Yu Cheng, but he doesn't feel uncomfortable at all." Wait. What? That line hit me like a truck. Yucheng doesn't feel uncomfortable because for once, someone is taking him seriously. His father's demands are real, his consequences are real, and having Qin He as a tutor makes it all feel legitimized. But here's the conflict: Yucheng wants Qin He's attention, but the arrangement requires Qin He to treat him like a paying customer. Every hour they spend together is framed as work, not friendship. The more Yucheng invests, the more he risks being reduced to just another transaction in Qin He's life. And the suspense? Absolutely gripping. We don't know if Qin He will actually stick with the tutoring. We don't know if Yucheng's father will back down or dig in deeper. We don't know about the grandmother's condition. The author is stacking variables like a gambler and I am sweating.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the pacing in this section is ruthless and I respect it enormously. It starts at maximum emotional intensity—a man breaking down at a grave on his birthday—and then instead of releasing that tension, it compounds it. Qin Wanqing dies. Yu Cheng isolates. Time jumps four years. He changes his entire identity. Finds a box of memorabilia. Burns the last photo. Takes a pill. That's a lot of narrative ground covered, and the author doesn't slow down to breathe between any of it. There's no reprieve chapter, no comedic relief, no 'meanwhile' cutaway. The momentum is relentless, which mirrors exactly what grief feels like—it doesn't give you breaks, it just keeps accumulating. The transition from the immediate aftermath of Qin He's death to the four-years-later endpoint is handled through summary rather than scene, which is a risk. Some of that summary is gorgeous ('He became another Qin He'), but I will admit there are moments where I wanted more raw scene and less told timeline. The hospital episode with Lin Ying, for instance—'she actually likes Qin He' gets dropped in as a single sentence and I was left wanting SO MUCH MORE. A full scene there would have added enormous texture. But the biggest pacing choice is the ending itself. The final paragraph trails off mid-sentence: 'Perhaps he knew he was about to meet the person he had'—and then we're done. No period. No resolution. Just a cliffhanger that's actually an embrace. That structural gamble is either brilliant or careless depending on whether you believe in an afterlife, which I guess is exactly the point.
... Read More
I'm still not over this line. 'Fuck it, what future? You didn't even return my birthday gift to Qin He! You forgot; even if I have to go to the underworld, I will find you; you owe me!' This is the entire emotional thesis of the book compressed into one unhinged, broken sentence. It's not about the gift. It's about commitment. It's about 'you left me and I'm not accepting that as the final answer.' The absurdity of it—a grown man screaming at a gravestone about an unreturned birthday present—is exactly what makes it so devastating. Real grief isn't dignified. It's petty and huge and contradictory all at once. And then earlier, the image of Yu Cheng crawling in front of the tombstone, hoping his beloved will appear and comfort him 'just like countless times before.' The word 'just' does so much work there. This isn't the first time he's imagined Qin He showing up. He's been rehearsing this delusion. He knows it won't work and he does it anyway. That's not weakness—that's love as a reflex. The dream sequences are where the emotional writing really peaks though. He's enjoying warmth in dreams and then watching it get destroyed. The contrast between dream comfort and waking horror creates this brutal rhythm. 'All that meets the eye is white; dreams are shattered; everything is just illusion.' White like hospital walls. White like nothing left. White like a page you can't write on anymore. And the ending—'Perhaps he knew he was about to meet the person he had'—the sentence literally cuts off. We're not told he dies. We're not told he lives. We just get the trailing thought of someone who has made peace with an outcome. That ambiguity is the most emotional choice the author could have made.
... Read More
Can we talk about how natural some of this dialogue is? Because I just re-read the opening exchange between Yucheng and Qin He at the bus stop and it is *chef's kiss*. Yucheng: "What a coincidence. No thanks; I have to catch the bus. I don't know if Yucheng has ever squeezed onto a bus before. Do you know how to ride it?" He's being sarcastic and passive-aggressive, but it sounds like an actual rich kid who's trying to sound witty and failing slightly. Then Qin He just... smiles faintly and gets on the bus. No response needed. The silence IS the response. That's elite-level dialogue writing right there. And Yucheng's meltdown afterward: "Come pick me up right now!" — the driver's confused response, Yucheng snapping "Mind your own business and just drive" — it's hilarious and desperate at the same time. You can hear the humiliation in his voice. He's been publicly outmaneuvered by someone who wouldn't even dignify him with a proper reply. Then there's Lin Ying, who has a completely different vocal register. She's sharp but softening: "You went to play ball; hurry up and take a shower later. How come there's still the smell of car exhaust on you?" She's mothering him while simultaneously investigating. The shift from scolding to sniffing is so naturally maternal. Qin He's dialogue is sparse but loaded. "Tutoring? Double the amount?" That's it. That's all he says. And it tells you everything about how he operates — efficient, guarded, always calculating. The contrast between his clipped sentences and Yucheng's rambling emotional output is basically the whole relationship in miniature.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how the pacing works in these chapters because honestly it's doing something really clever. You've got this whole sequence where Yu Cheng keeps appearing in Qin He's life like a bad penny—first at school, then at his store, then literally at the bus stop on the way home. Each encounter escalates just slightly, and every time Qin He's more done with it. But the author isn't rushing. They let each scene breathe, let you sit in Qin He's annoyance, let you feel that frustration building. And then—boom—suddenly you're in Yu Cheng's head and everything flips. All this time you've been seeing Yu Cheng as the annoying stalker guy, and then we get this whole backstory about why he acts this way. The comparison to his perfect older brother, the loneliness underneath all that arrogance, the fact that he genuinely can't remember the last time someone looked at him without disdain. It recontextualizes everything that came before, and I literally had to reread the earlier scenes because now they mean something completely different. The chapter ending with Yu Cheng sitting at the bus stop muttering about fate?chef's kiss. The tension between wanting connection and not knowing how to ask for it—it's perfectly paced. Not rushed, not dragged. Just right.
... Read More
I've been thinking about the scars on Qin He's body ever since reading these chapters, and honestly it's become this whole metaphor that won't leave my head. Yu Cheng caused physical bruises, yes, but then there's Yu Cheng's own invisible scars—the ones from growing up in the shadow of a perfect older brother, the ones from everyone only wanting to be his friend because of his family name. Both characters are marked, just in different ways. There's this one line that keeps running through my mind: "I only know you, Yu Cheng." Said by that English teacher, Xian Nan Zhi. For the first time, someone addresses him without insults or belittlement. It's such a small moment but it cracks something open. It makes you realize how starved Yu Cheng is for basic human decency, which explains so much of his behavior. And the red cross on Qin He's paper—drawn with a red pen among all the checkmarks, looking discordant. It's such a quiet symbol of how his peaceful routine was disrupted, how something wrong entered his carefully ordered world. But also how he's trying to stay composed despite it. The whole theme of what people see versus what's actually there runs through these chapters like a thread. Yu Cheng projects arrogance but is lonely. Qin He projects indifference but is willing to help someone who hurt him. The world keeps making assumptions, and the story keeps undoing them one scene at a time.
... Read More
The opening of this passage just drops us into a room with Qin Wanqing shoving her brother toward the living room while muttering 'you are always so troublesome' and I immediately felt like I was in a Korean drama or something. The familial energy is so warm and lived-in. Then we cut to the ice rink and the author somehow makes a makeshift skating area feel cinematic. The details are doing a lot of work here. 'A few days ago, the snow melted and accumulated a lot of water, which froze over and became a makeshift ice rink.' That's such a specific, grounded detail—it tells us this is a place where nature does its own improvisation, where people adapt rather than wait for perfection. And then Lu Ran tripping and Qin He catching her, and the whole moment suspended in that frozen space, is just... god, the visual of Yu Cheng appearing like a storm cloud and yanking Qin He away, Lu Ran falling to the ground in the background watching the drama unfold like she's at a theater. She literally goes to 'watch the show' instead of helping. That's such a funny character beat. The snow imagery keeps coming back too. 'The snow melted silently on the ground, and only the trembling tree displayed the anger of Yu Cheng.' The environment mirrors his internal state without the narrator having to say 'he was angry.' That's craft. And the final image of them alone in silence after the argument, the world reduced to just two people and a forgotten magic trick—that's a scene I'm going to remember.
... Read More
The atmospheric writing in this section is genuinely stunning. Let me paint you the first image: a dirty, messy alley at night. Flickering lights that can't quite penetrate the darkness. And then - "Only a round moon on the horizon illuminated this dramatic scene." That single moon is the only clean, beautiful thing in an otherwise grotesque moment. It's like the author is saying: even in the worst scenes, there's still a sliver of something aesthetic, something almost poetic. The contrast between the moon and the bloodied ground below is almost unbearable. Then there's the autumn setting. "It was already dark outside, and autumn is a season with frequent rain. The gloomy sky seemed like it was about to rain, and leaves were falling rustlingly." Every element conspires to create this oppressive, melancholy atmosphere. The falling leaves mirror the falling apart of Qin He's world. The impending rain - and later, we never actually see it pour, but the threat of it lingers throughout. It's subtle environmental storytelling. The creditor's scene is equally vivid. "The man in front of Li Zhuang had eyes like a snake or a scorpion, as if he wanted to tear something from him. The person in front of him had a permanent frown, causing a '川' character to form between his eyebrows, and a horrifying scar ran across his forehead." This description is visceral. You can SEE this man. The scar, the eyes, the way he kicks Li Zhuang "like he was kicking a lifeless object" - it's cinematic in a way that makes me want to watch this as a film adaptation immediately. And Yu Cheng's search through the empty streets, the security guard trying to stop him, the few people who remember Qin He and rush to the store only to find he's already gone - these are all small moments that build a world that feels lived-in and real. The rain-soaked autumn night isn't just backdrop; it's a character in itself.
... Read More
Let me just say this first—these two have the sharpest tongues I've ever read in my life and I am HERE for it. Yu Cheng: "Don't be angry; our Yu family doesn't have this hobby. I saw that you ignored me two days ago and thought you were blind, so I kindly came to try and see if you could see me." I fell out of my chair. The audacity. The absolute lack of self-awareness wrapped in such a polite sentence. This guy is ridiculous and I love him. And Qin He's response is just cold, deadpan destruction: "I don't need friends either." Triple negative. Three ways to say no in one breath. The man doesn't even have the energy to be mean, he's just... done. But here's what's actually brilliant—the dialogue reveals their entire dynamics. Yu Cheng has to prick people before he can speak honestly. It's his defense mechanism wearing a haughty mask. And Qin He? He sees right through it every single time. Their conversations aren't just witty banter for entertainment—they're two people who are completely mismatched in how they approach the world, constantly colliding. The line "If the mountain doesn't come to me, then I will go to the old mountain" is giving me life. Yu Cheng just fully admitted he's being persistent in the most poetic way possible and then immediately followed it with asking if they could be friends. This boy is a disaster and I respect it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or