Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just take a moment to appreciate the atmosphere in this chapter because the author is painting with light and shadow and I am HERE for it. The bedside lamp glow—soft, intimate, everything warm and close. Then the bathroom, the sound of running water, and suddenly we're transported to this image of Shi Yuan out on the mountain at night, flashlight in hand, navigating narrow wooden walkways along sheer drops into pitch-black abyss. The contrast between these two spaces is everything. Inside: warmth, safety, the smell of body wash, bare skin and soft sheets. Outside: cold, danger, darkness, the kind of place where someone could fall and no one would hear them. And Shi Yuan went out there anyway. For a necklace. For Lin Wangye. The Yingri Pond waterfall scene he reconstructs in his head—Lin Wangye squatting by the water, scarf wet, swinging it around like a kid—that's such a vivid, almost cinematic memory. You can see it. The author doesn't need fancy worldbuilding when they've got moments this alive. The mountain at night, the flashlight beam catching diamond on metal, the long walk back in the dark—it's all so sensory and so real. This book understands that atmosphere IS emotion.
... Read More
There's a line in this chapter that I can't stop thinking about: "Shi Yuan seemed to be the dam holding back his emotions." That description of Shi Yuan is everything. He's not just some sick guy in a hospital bed — he's this person who has survived something terrible, built a successful life, and now carries the weight of his sister's illness without crumbling. And when Lin Wangye shows up crying, the first thing Shi Yuan asks isn't about himself or his situation — it's "Who's bullying you?" That's such a Shi Yuan move. Even in his own moment of vulnerability, his instinct is to protect Lin Wangye. Their dynamic is so layered. Lin Wangye has clearly admired him for years — "never truly understood Shi Yuan's past" and seeing him now as this composed, perfect, mature person. But the reader gets this glimpse into what it actually cost him to become that person. Meanwhile Shi Yuan sees right through Lin Wangye. When Lin Wangye tries to hide his distress, Shi Yuan doesn't push aggressively but he doesn't let it go either. He reads him. He knows when not speaking means something worse is building up inside him. And then there's the little gesture where Shi Yuan reaches out and ruffles Lin Wangye's hair. After all this heavy emotional conversation, this small casual touch feels incredibly intimate and telling. It's not dramatic or performative — it's the kind of gesture that comes from genuine closeness. I also love how Lin Wangye's protective instincts are flipping roles here. He was the one who needed Shi Yuan all those years ago, the one making long-distance calls, and now he's the one declaring "I'll find a way." He's not waiting to be saved. The power dynamic has shifted in the most beautiful way.
... Read More
Let me just say this — the way this group of four orbits around each other is SO good. Zhao Youyou, Lin Shen, Lin Wangye, and Lu Chengxuan. They're not related by blood but they have this fierce loyalty to each other that feels earned. Zhao Youyou basically declares war on Shi Shi's reputation in this chapter and I am HERE FOR IT. Her story about cleaning duty is absolutely legendary. This girl never touched a broom for an entire year, made Zhao Youyou do all the work, AND had a fake medical certificate for dust allergies? Then — PLOT TWIST — she wiped the blackboard for Lu Chengxuan with zero allergy issues. Lin Shen's reaction is priceless: "Do you realize how miraculous this is? It's a modern medical marvel!" I literally laughed out loud. But the most interesting dynamic is how ALL of them treat Lu Chengxuan. He's this aloof, unapproachable figure who emits this weird vibe that makes people avoid his table. Yet these three are genuinely comfortable around him. They tease him, they bond over gossip, they high-five after trapping him with a funny question. And he doesn't shut them out — he just sits there eating, occasionally responding with his trademark deadpan "No." Then Shi Shi walks in and the whole energy shifts. She performs this delicate little pout as she leaves, making sure Lin Wangye witnesses her slight hurt. And Lin Wangye literally gets chills. He's seeing the performance in real time and it makes him uncomfortable. Meanwhile Zhao Youyou just gives her a cold hum. No performance, no game. I think that's the core of their conflict — Shi Shi plays the social game constantly, and Zhao Youyou refuses to play at all. The fact that Lu Chengxuan answered the love letter question so seriously — just a calm "No" — tells you everything about how he views these social performances. He's not interested in playing along.
... Read More
"Machines fix themselves over time. And the older he gets, the more he seems to reset back to factory settings." I need to sit with this sentence for a while. This is Lin Shen's internal narration about Lu Chengxuan, and it is SO accurate and SO heartbreaking. Because Lin Shen REMEMBERS. He remembers when Lu Chengxuan was fragile, sensitive, hungry for friends. He remembers touching that soft part of him. And now? Now Lu Chengxuan is completely unreadable — no joy, no anger, no fear. Just cool logic. But here's what killed me: Lin Shen KNOWS he was the one who saw the real Lu Chengxuan. And he also knows, deep down, that he probably helped lock that version away. Every time Lu Chengxuan pulled back, every time he built another wall, wasn't it because letting someone in was too dangerous? And Lin Shen is the living proof of what happens when you let someone close. Then there's Lu Chengxuan, who says "If I don't go abroad... maybe I can manage. But it'll be tough, and I'm not confident I can pull it off." This is the closest thing to a plea he's ever made. He's laying his vulnerability on the table and pretending it's a business calculation. "I'm not going abroad" would have been so much simpler to say out loud, but he can't. He never can. And Lin Shen — oh god, Lin Shen. He raises his hand to grab more fruit, stops mid-air, and then slams the whole plate down. His anger isn't really about going abroad. It's about being powerless. It's about knowing that no matter what he does, Lu Chengxuan will always calculate his way out of emotional honesty first.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this fight scene setup was chef's kiss perfection. Chen Shao brings a whole crew to the dark street, everyone's about to get their lives ruined, Fu Xuexue is literally being silenced with a hand over her mouth — I am NOT okay — and then WHOOSH the street lights up like daytime andJess appears out of nowhere. Like genuinely, it's always the best moment when the underdog group is cornered and then suddenly there are seven seats of trained fighters rolling in. It's a trope but it hits DIFFERENT when it's done right. But here's what actually blew my mind: Lu Chengxuan had a TRACKER on his watch. His mom set up this whole safety net and she wasn't even there in person — she just sent Jess. Think about that. A mother who doesn't need to physically chase after her kid to know he's in danger. Meanwhile Lin Shen makes this joke about his own dad not noticing if he disappeared for half a month and the entire emotional weight of that comment just... lands. The plot isn't just about fights and rescues, it's quietly building this parallel about who actually shows up for whom. The Chen Shao arrest sequence was also surprisingly tight. He tried to pull the 'no cameras' card and Jess literally just said 'dash cams exist' and that was that. No dramatic legal debate, no conveniently forgotten evidence. It resolved fast, which honestly made it feel MORE realistic. But I do wonder — did Fu Xuexue's offer to cooperate as an eyewitness change anything between her and the rest of the group? That moment felt like a tiny turning point I'm not sure the story fully acknowledges yet.
... Read More
Can we talk about how natural these conversations feel? Not scripted, not polished to a shine, but genuinely human in a way that most web novels completely miss. Take Lin Wangye's line: 'Ohhh, got it.' That's not dialogue—that's a person processing information in real time. The elongated 'oh' with the double h, the casual nod, the immediate pivot to the next thought. You hear the voice. Same with 'Well... that's good, then...'—the ellipsis isn't decorative, it's the sound of someone recalibrating their expectations mid-sentence. And Shi Yuan! His dialogue is sparse but each line carries weight. 'If there's something on your mind, just say it. It's okay.' Three sentences. One period after each. No flourish. Just... availability. He's offering an opening, not demanding anything in return. That's a character who knows what it means to have things unsaid, and that's why his silence speaks louder than most people's monologues. The 'happy puppy' exchange is where the dialogue really shines because it works on two timelines simultaneously. In the past, it's playful bargaining between a kid and an authority figure. In the present, it's Shi Yuan offering Lin Wangye the same permission he once received—permission to be imperfect, to mess up, to still be loved. The repetition isn't redundancy, it's resonance. Even the narrator's voice has personality. Lines like 'Don't take on a job you're not cut out for' and 'expecting him to peel an apple properly was asking too much' carry this warm, slightly amused tone that makes you feel like someone's telling you a story over coffee, not delivering a lecture. The narrative doesn't narrate—it converse
... Read More
I need to talk about how vivid this classroom scene feels because wow. The author manages to make a regular high school classroom come alive in a way that's rare in these types of novels. We have the homeroom teacher at the door, the math lesson draining Lin Wangye's soul, the twenty-minute break where everyone crowds around him like he's some kind of celebrity. This isn't just setting description—it's atmosphere. What really strikes me is the sensory detail in small moments. Like when Fu Xuexue offers her pink and white notebook. That tiny color detail makes the scene visual and specific. Or when Lin Wangye looks at Zhao Youyou and we get this flash of future knowledge—her being a CEO twenty years from now. The author weaves future information into present observations seamlessly, which makes the world feel layered and real. The classroom itself has this great energy. It's not just 'students sat at desks.' It's Jiang Bowen leaning back dramatically like he was struck by lightning. It's the whole class erupting in laughter. It's Lu Chengxuan completely unaffected in the center of all this chaos. These details make the setting feel populated and dynamic, like you could walk into this room and hear the conversations happening around you. I also love how the author uses the school environment to reveal character. The fact that Lin Wangye starts copying math notes during history class tells us everything we need to know about his priorities and confidence. The history teacher's frustration is palpable. And the multiple-choice question about Tang dynasty calligraphy—while it might seem like random academic content—is actually a smart way to show Lin Wangye's knowledge without just stating 'he's smart.' Show, don't tell, and the author nails it here.
... Read More
I literally cannot—the ceramic dog keychain. A yellow ceramic dog with a watermelon rind on its head and a pink tongue sticking out. Shi Yuan made it himself. Just... looked at it and my heart did that thing. "So cute!" Lin Wangye says, bouncing on his feet, and I'm right there with him because YES, that is the most specific, thoughtful, adorable gift possible. He didn't just buy something—he spent time making something, waited for it to fire, saved it, and then pulled it out while walking home in the cold. And then Lin Wangye gives him a lens cloth. A folded-up, smoky gray, soft material, neatly stitched lens cloth. After years of just using his shirt to wipe his glasses. This is love language stuff, man. These two don't do big speeches. They do objects. The author understands that intimate moments aren't always fireworks—they're sometimes just two guys walking home, exchanging small things that say more than words ever could. The scene where Lin Wangye runs into Shi Yuan's arms at the pottery shop? The coworkers' reaction, the "ohhhhhh," the way Lin Wangye shrank back blushing, and Shi Yuan just... kissed him. In front of everyone. Didn't even hesitate. That moment is everything. It's the kind of public affection that makes you want to scream because it's so rare to see characters just... be happy without irony or tragedy lurking around the corner. Also—"I missed you." "I missed you too." Buried in a neck, whispered in an ear, while four college girls watch and comment. The sheer warmth of it. I'm not crying, you're crying.
... Read More
This section does something really smart with pacing. It opens in total silence — two people in bed, quiet conversation, a gentle goodnight. Then it SLAMS into full comedic chaos the next morning. No buffer. No transition paragraph. Just cut. And it works because the emotional weight of the first scene earns the humor of the second. Wangye diving into Shi Yuan's bed like a koala, the simple line "Don't care. I'm sleeping with my boyfriend." — that's the emotional anchor. Once you've felt that tenderness, the morning panic hits you differently. You're laughing, but you also know what was lost in that night. The structure is essentially: intimate revelation → catastrophic discovery → parental meltdown. Three movements, like a mini symphony. Each one shorter than the last, accelerating toward the comedy peak with Lin Shen's king bed theory. What's interesting is how the author controls what we know versus what the characters know. We see everything — the mess, the sleeping couple, the tears. But Lin Shen is operating on fragmented information: he heard crying, he saw a wrecked room, he suspects the worst. The reader is always one step ahead, which turns every line of his panic into dramatic irony. The chapter ends mid-sentence with Lu Chengxuan basically saying "wait till they wake up and switch rooms" — which is the perfect comedic button. It leaves us hanging, wondering what happens next, while simultaneously promising that yes, there will be consequences for this hotel arrangement.
... Read More
Let me just say this chapter is a masterclass in controlled pacing. We start SO slow. Lin Shen is half-asleep in a lazy chair, kicking off his shoes, requesting beer because he can't be bothered. The prose itself feels lazy—short sentences, drifting observations, that beautiful moment where a blanket is simply dropped into someone's arms and everything just... settles. This is the calm before, and it makes everything that follows hit harder. Then—the cut. * * * —and suddenly we're with Lin Wangye pressing his ear against a door, heart racing, world collapsing. The shift from languid afternoon nap to full-blown existential crisis happens in a single asterisk break, and it's gorgeous. The author doesn't waste a single word on transition. One moment everyone's chill, the next Lin Wangye's brain has produced an entire fictional romance novel in his head and he's living inside it. And then—another pivot. Back to the hotel room, but this time it's Shi Yuan and Lin Wangye, and the energy shifts again from frantic suspicion to something quieter, more tender. The massage scene unfolds slowly, deliberately, each touch measured, each question drawn out. The pain at the Shenshu point becomes this tiny cliffhanger—Shi Yuan's smile, the dropped eyes, the unfinished explanation—and then the chapter just... trails off mid-thought. The author knows exactly when to speed up and when to slow down. The comedic set piece with Lin Wangye's overthinking moves fast and funny. The emotional beats between Shi Yuan and Lin Wangye unfold with deliberate slowness. And that author's note at the end? Perfect structural punctuation. It stops the momentum, makes you breathe, and then drops lore that recontextualizes everything you just read. Brilliant pacing.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the racing game because I am convinced this author put it there for a reason and that reason is EVERYTHING. Lin Shen is racing against Lu Chengxuan — someone he acknowledges is FLAWLESS. "Whatever he set his mind to, Lu Chengxuan would master it flawlessly with zero mistakes." Lin Shen KNOWS he can't win fair. So he takes risks. He floors the accelerator on dangerous turns, gambling his entire position on a slim chance of catching up. "If he crashed, he'd lose embarrassingly, but if he took the chance, there was a slim chance of victory." This is not just a video game. This is a philosophy. This is how Lin Shen approaches LIFE — every decision, every relationship, every bet. He doesn't play safe. He doesn't hedge. When there's even a SLIM chance of reaching his goal, he goes ALL IN. The racing game becomes this perfect metaphor for his character arc — someone who has learned that caution equals guaranteed loss, and that only extreme risk offers any path forward. But here's where it gets interesting: Lu Chengxuan CRASHES. He wobbles on the final turn and hits the barrier. The flawless player makes a mistake at the worst possible moment. And Lin Shen exploits it. Victory comes not from superior skill but from willingness to gamble when others play it safe. Now layer this on top of the hospital scene — Xu Suihe, a child facing chemotherapy, who still cooperates, still plays, still celebrates her friend's small victories. She's also gambling. Her gamble is simpler: trust the treatment, endure the pain, hope for tomorrow. Her odds are slim, but she's racing anyway. And Lin Wangye — he can't learn the advanced material no matter how hard he tries. He's hitting his ceiling. But he passes math with a 92 and celebrates like he's won the championship. His theme is ACCEPTANCE — knowing your limits doesn't mean giving up, it means finding joy in what you CAN do. Three kids. Three different approaches to life-threatening situations. One is gambling on speed, one on endurance, one on acceptance. And they're all still racing.
... Read More
So let me just say this upfront—the premise of this story is already firing on all cylinders, and I'm completely invested. We open with our protagonist waking up in a strange body, confused, hungry, and then BAM, grief hits him all at once because he remembers his dad died twenty years ago. Except now he's back in time when his dad is only seventeen! That realization alone is devastating and hopeful simultaneously. The author plays with this dual emotion so well—tragedy and joy colliding in Lin Wangye's head. What I love about the plot structure here is how efficiently everything moves. We go from disorientation → hunger → grief → realization → action in just a few paragraphs. There's no wasted space. He immediately identifies his target (Ningchang City's Seventh High School), finds it, and the story introduces us to the future backstory about the Lu-Lin Pond in a natural exposition dump that doesn't feel forced. The author embeds a whole rivalry and school history into what could have been a boring info-dump, and somehow makes it work. The construction teams quarreling over cement is almost comedic. Then we get the cafeteria scene, and the Lu Chengxuan reveal hits like a punch. This is clearly a setup for something big—we're being told this kid will eventually donate three buildings to the school, and our protagonist knows this because he lived through it. The irony of Lin Wangye, a homeless starved guy, encountering the future elite Lu Chengxuan is chef's kiss. I'm curious how this relationship develops and whether knowing the future gives Lin Wangye an edge or just makes things more complicated. Also—did anyone else notice that "Lin Shen isn't dead yet" moment? That was a gut punch wrapped in hope. What happens next?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or