Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just talk about the Thumbs-Up scene for a second? Lin Shen gives Lin Wangye a thumbs-up after the teacher praises him, starts to say 'Nice job!' and then gets called out by the teacher before he can finish. That gesture — that stupid, perfect little thumbs-up — and then it's interrupted. It could have been anything. But it was genuine. Lin Shen, who has everything, who has been carrying Lin Wangye on his back through life, is genuinely proud of him. And the narrator tells us Lin Shen 'felt a lump in his throat' when Zhao Youyou praised Lin Wangye's awareness. This guy has built his entire identity around being the protector, the provider, the one who makes sure Xiao Lin never knows hardship — and seeing his brother actually stand on his own two feet and succeed? That hits different. Meanwhile Lin Qianqian shows up and is cold to Lin Shen but charmed by Lin Wangye's 'Hello, sister~' With his soft voice and innocent smile. The kid has survived eighteen years of poverty and secrecy by reading rooms like a hawk, and he's still got that warmth toward the people who matter. When the teacher calls Lin Shen out for 'not studying' while praising Lin Wangye for it? Brutal. And Lin Shen just agrees with a nod. He doesn't defend himself. He knows the truth — he didn't need to study because someone else had already paved the road.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about how this chapter controls time because it's genuinely clever. You start with what should be a quick emergency—Lin Wangye realizes Shi Yuan is gone, he's frantic, he needs to call him. But the phone call itself takes up an enormous amount of narrative space for what amounts to five minutes of real time. And within those five minutes, you get: the initial panic, the relief when it connects, the explanation of why he was discharged, that devastating “can I come see you” followed by the gentle no, the long mutual silence that the narration specifically calls out, the small talk about dinner, the promise to meet next week, the weather warning, the hang-up. That silence is the pivot point. The text says: “As those words fell, both ends of the call fell into a long, mutual silence.” Both of them are feeling it. Both of them are processing. And the pacing slows down even more after that—the small talk that follows feels strained and hollow precisely because the important moment already happened. Then the aftermath: Lin Wangye standing there listening to the dial tone, slumping like a deflated balloon. The author doesn't rush this. They let you sit in the disappointment. And then they immediately undercut it with Lin Shen's comedy relief about the property management office, which is such a smart structural choice—it gives the reader permission to breathe while also making the contrast sharper. You laugh at Lin Shen and then immediately remember Lin Wangye is still hollowed out two inches from your screen. The chapter ends with them walking to a hotpot stall and Lin Wangye's stomach growling while his heart is breaking. That's pacing as emotional manipulation, and I am here for it.
... Read More
There's a recurring symbol I can't shake: the tricycle. It carries Xu Suinian's grandparents through bitter winter cold, selling skewers to survive. It's humble, fragile, mechanical—a piece of transportation that barely qualifies as transportation. And Xu Suinian himself rides in it, or at least has ridden in it, connecting him to a world of struggle that Lin Wangye and Lin Shen have never truly understood. But the deeper symbol here is Lin Wangye's knowledge itself. Twenty years of future memories—this is supposed to be his cheat code, his path to godhood. Yet it's useless against a sick child. The novel keeps asking: what is the value of knowing the future if you can't change the present? Money, which Lin Wangye has never needed because his father had it, becomes the ultimate barrier. Three hundred thousand isn't even that much to the Lin family, but it might as well be three million to Lin Wangye, who's been living off his brother's scraps. The unpaid bill moment is symbolic too—Lu Chengxuan insisting on paying, the old lady accepting exactly fifty and waving off the change. These small transactions carry enormous meaning about dignity, helplessness, and the thin line between giving and charity. The whole scene is about how little control any of them actually have.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is so naturally messy and real, I keep coming back to certain exchanges. Let me start with the Lin Shen and Lin Wangye banter after the breakdown: "Help me out here. I said I'm borrowing it. I'll pay it back." "Alright, alright, I promise I'll think of something." "Do you have a plan?" "Hmm…" Lin Shen leaned back on the sofa, thinking as he looked up at the ceiling. This conversation is SO Lin Wangye—immediately pivoting from emotional vulnerability to practical problem-solving, like he needs to prove he's useful even when he's falling apart. And Lin Shen's response, the casual 'I have a way' that acts like 'a stabilizing anchor'? That's the voice of someone who's learned to be reliable despite having no actual resources. The contrast between their personalities shines through every line. Then there's the grandmother's dialogue—honest, warm, practical. 'There's still a lot of people after evening self-study. If I pack up early, I'll lose out.' No melodrama, just the quiet economics of survival. And Lin Wangye's improvised excuse about Xu Suinian helping him with math? The grandmother's hesitation before accepting it? You can practically hear the unspoken conversation happening beneath the words. The author's dialogue never feels written. Every character has a distinct rhythm. Lu Chengxuan barely speaks and yet his presence is felt in every scene. That's exceptional voice work.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Lin Shen and how this scene completely flips his character. Up until now, he's been the classic selfish playboy dad—scamming his own son for hotpot money, living off his 'omnipotent' brother Chairman Lin. But when Lin Wangye starts crying, something in him shifts. He says 'I'll figure something out' like it's nothing. That man who couldn't even find a tissue in his pocket for his own son—suddenly he's a father. The transformation happens in two seconds flat, and it's beautiful because it feels earned, not forced. Then there's Lin Wangye, who breaks down in his father's arms like he's eight years old again. Not because he's weak, but because this is the first time in his two lifetimes he's genuinely felt helpless. In his past life, money solved everything. Now even with future memories, he's staring at a sum that might as well be infinite. The power dynamic between father and son has never been more inverted. And Lu Chengxuan—silent, watching, always three steps ahead. He paid the bill without being asked, he cut off Lin Shen's questioning smoothly, and now he's just sitting there watching the whole thing unfold from across the room. That final eye contact with Lin Wangye? Charged with something I can't quite name. Is it understanding? Warning? Pity? The man never speaks but he sees everything.
... Read More
The setting in these chapters is doing so much heavy lifting without even trying. We're in an internet cafe—this is China in the early 2000s probably, pre-smartphone era when LAN cafes were basically social hubs—and the atmosphere is thick with cigarette smoke and the glow of CRT monitors. Lin Wangye notices the cigarette burning close to his fingers, and honestly that detail tells you everything about the era and the environment. No fancy RGB lighting here, just flickering screens and secondhand smoke. Then there's the private room scene. The manager comes in with membership cards, Lin Shen swipes his card with the casual authority of someone who owns the place through connections, and the room itself is described as cramped but cozy—two machines, a small sofa, a few potted plants adding greenery. It's such a specific, lived-in space. You can picture it. The curtain separating it from the main hall, the clutter piled behind the counter, the narrow maze of paths Lin Shen guides his son through. It feels like stepping into a memory that belongs to both of them but neither fully knows yet. "From the garbled characters in the ID number section on the screen, Lin Wangye guessed this must be an internal member card for the internet cafe—one that allowed unlimited access with no time limit." This is the kind of worldbuilding detail that makes the setting feel real without slowing things down. The technology, the social hierarchy of who gets special treatment, the casual authority of a father who clearly has status in his community—all of that comes through in objects and actions rather than exposition.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Lin Wangye because THIS MAN is a comedic goldmine and honestly he carried half the chapter for me. The author set up this whole situation where Lin Wangye is eavesdropping outside a door, pressing his ear against it, and what does he hear? A few sounds, a bed creaking, maybe an argument that he can't quite make out. And what does his brain do? It goes FULL SPEED ahead into the most wildly incorrect conclusion possible. "The safest place really was the most dangerous." That line hit me so hard. Lin Wangye spent all this time suspecting random people—his dad's associates, even Shi Yuan at one point—and meanwhile the actual answer was RIGHT UNDER HIS NOSE the entire time. Lu Chengxuan, who has been helpful, patient, and around all along. Of COURSE he's the one. The author uses Lin Wangye's misdirection brilliantly here. Instead of giving us a straightforward reveal about Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan's relationship, we get it filtered through a completely unreliable, wildly imaginative narrator whose conclusions are simultaneously hilarious and weirdly accurate. No wonder everything clicked into place for Lin Wangye once he started connecting dots from his previous life. The plot twist isn't just "they're dating"—it's that Lin Wangye arrived at the right conclusion through the stupidest possible reasoning. And then Shi Yuan just... accepts it? "All right," he says, and changes the subject. What does that mean? What does Shi Yuan know? That's the kind of layered plotting I live for. The surface is comedy gold, but underneath there's actual relationship history being hinted at, and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the pacing in these chapters because holy crap. First you've got the rescue — Lin Wangye literally lunging in to grab Shi Yuan and Fu Xuexue and bolt. That was SO fast, like half a second of reaction and then they're gone. I loved that chaos. Then they think they're safe, walking Fu Xuexue home, chatting like nothing happened… and BAM. Phones snatched, backs against the wall, armed this time. Classic bait-and-switch structure. The author lulls you into thinking the danger passed, then slams it back down twice as hard. And Lin Shen taking on like five grown men with a baseball bat swinging at his face? That's not just action for action's sake — it also reveals who he is without any exposition. "If I didn't know how to fight, I'd be dead by now." Chills. Absolute chills. But that ending though. It just cuts off mid-sentence like "he started str—" Are you KIDDING me. I immediately opened the next chapter. No mercy, this author has zero respect for my sleep schedule.
... Read More
The way this text builds its world without stopping to give you a info-dump is genuinely impressive. We learn through a single shop dispute that roughly half the major shopping malls in Ningchang City are Lu family property, and the other half has Lu investments. That's not a brochure — that's a detail dropped casually into a confrontational scene that simultaneously establishes power dynamics and makes the geography feel real. The barbecue restaurant scene is where the atmosphere really comes alive. You've got the contrast between the first restaurant — formal, numbered tickets, dedicated waiters, corporate polish — and this new place which is cheaper, higher-traffic, servers juggling multiple tables, the clatter and smoke and noise of a proper casual dining experience. The author doesn't describe it with adjectives; they describe it through what happens to the characters. When Lin Shen is comfortable eating without table service, you know exactly what kind of place this is. There's also the visual of Lu Chengxuan holding the tongs, carefully turning each piece of meat, knowing exactly when each cut is done. That's such a specific sensory detail that transforms a generic restaurant scene into something tactile. You can smell the charcoal, hear the sizzle, see the oil glistening. The text trusts you to imagine the rest. And the mall interior itself — name tags, logos, the general manager's entrance, the way employees instantly recognize authority. The author has built a world where corporate hierarchy is visible and immediate, where a single logo on a chest piece can change the entire power structure of a room. That's economical worldbuilding at its finest.
... Read More
The setting in this chapter is remarkably sparse—basically one room, one bed, one fruit basket—but the author makes every detail earn its place. Let me walk through what I noticed because the environmental storytelling here is quietly brilliant. The hospital room is described through absence as much as presence. An empty room. Parents who aren't there. A father who's 'not home much.' The physical space mirrors the emotional one—Shi Yuan is alone not because nobody cares, but because caring people are elsewhere, worrying elsewhere, living elsewhere. The reddest apple in the basket becomes the most vivid object in the scene, and that's not accidental. In a sterile white environment, that red is life, warmth, something chosen with intention. Then there's the worldbuilding woven through casual observation. Ningchang Seventh High School—a top-tier institution where Class A is basically the honor roll made manifest. Fu Xuexue, an 'undeniable academic genius,' couldn't get in. This single detail tells us about the competitive pressure-cooker environment these characters move through, and it makes Shi Yuan's choice to take a part-time job at a pottery shop feel even more significant. He's operating in a world where excellence is expected and optional, and he's choosing to do something that has nothing to do with rankings. The pottery shop itself is a fascinating worldbuilding choice. Clay. Wheels. Something shaped by hands, slowed down, requiring patience. It contrasts with the esports world Lin Wangye comes from—reflexes, speed, milliseconds. Two different philosophies of craft existing in the same story, and I have a feeling they're going to intersect in ways I haven't predicted yet.
... Read More
There's this one passage that I keep coming back to. Late at night, when everything was quiet, Lin Wangye looks at the uncertain path his life has taken and feels wronged. No grand setting description, no elaborate scene — just a boy alone with his thoughts at 2 AM, and somehow it paints the entire picture. The author trusts us to fill in what that room looks like, what kind of night it is, what kind of poverty he's living in. Then contrast that with the school scene: fifty-two students, papers being shuffled, the homeroom teacher leaning on the podium with his arms folded. The classroom has texture — you can hear the rustle of papers, the applause, the teacher's voice shifting from stern to soft when he praises Fu Xuexue. And then the sidewalk outside the school gate. A car honks twice. The window rolls down. Lin Qianqian's face — 'delicate and beautiful, a face Lin Wangye knew all too well.' Known all too well from what angle? Photos? Memory? He's seen her but never met her. The author paints her with specific details: two years older, music academy sophomore, natural makeup instead of the bold lipstick Lin Wangye is used to. Every visual choice here reinforces the contrast between the world she belongs to and the world Lin Wangye has been hiding in.
... Read More
Let's unpack this because the plot threads are getting deliciously complicated. You've got Dr. Bai piecing together that Lin Wangye's last name is Lin but he's not actually related — the DNA test used a peer's hair sample, which is honestly kind of wild when you think about it. Who does that? But here's what really got me: the moment Dr. Bai connects the dots about the tea-colored hair from the photo matching the two samples. His eyes darken. He's thinking about under what circumstances someone would pull hair from a friend instead of family. That's the kind of detail that makes me sit up and pay attention — it's not exposition, it's deduction happening in real time, and we're watching a competent adult figure out the mystery alongside the reader. Then there's the parallel plot with Lin Wangye grinding on this e-sports hotel project. Lu Chengxuan's testing him by barely helping at all, making him do market research himself. The university district pitch gets absolutely destroyed by Lin Shen for reasons that seem petty at first — oh it's just because students leave for summer and winter breaks? — but it's such a sharp business insight that recontextualizes everything Lin Wangye thought he knew. Two separate mysteries cooking: the family secret and the location problem. The author is threading them through different settings (hospital vs internet cafe) but they're both about Lin Wangye trying to figure out where he belongs. Literally and figuratively.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or