Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
So the whole 'you live at his house every day' moment? That's not just exposition — that's a landmine. The author keeps this ticking throughout the whole arc: readers know Lin Wangye is secretly Lin Shen's half-brother, everyone else thinks he's just a rich kid scholarship student, and every interaction between them is layered with dramatic irony. What I love is how the reveal about Lu Chengxuan's mother knowing Lin Wangye's mother comes completely out of nowhere in casual conversation. It's the narrative equivalent of someone mentioning the weather and then dropping a grenade. Meanwhile, the subplot with Lin Qianqian pulling up at the school gate at the end — she's Lin Shen's full-sister, Lin Wangye has never met her, and the author frames it so perfectly with that description of 'blood ties being magical.' She's everything he isn't: accepted, celebrated, naturally close to his brother. This chapter is basically three acts compressed into one. And that ending? A car honking, a window rolling down, and suddenly his entire family's world is about to collide. Masterclass in parallel storytelling.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this about Lin Shen because I am OBSESSED with his character. The author paints this kid who CANNOT stop talking—literally 'couldn't stop talking if his life depended on it'—and yet the most interesting thing is what he does when someone ELSE needs him. Remember the marble scene? Lin Shen loses at his own game, acts all tough like 'meh I don't care,' and then casually wanders over to talk to the quiet kid watching from the sidelines. That's not boredom, folks. That's LIN SHEN BEING A GOOD FRIEND and he doesn't even realize it. And Lu Chengxuan—oh my god, Lu Chengxuan. The guy who can't string three sentences together in the present timeline but opens up like a flower when talking about his childhood? The text literally says 'Lu Chengxuan, who usually didn't talk much, actually said more than usual this time.' MORE THAN USUAL for this guy means an entire monologue. And what does he share? Not anything dramatic. Just... he talks about marbles. About spinning tops. About how Lin Shen was basically his compass through elementary school. That's the relationship I'm here for. Two boys who balance each other—Lin Shen brings chaos and warmth, Lu Chengxuan brings silence and depth. And then BAM, eighth grade hits and Lin Shen's mom dies and the whole dynamic probably shatters. No wonder the chapter cuts off right there. The author is playing 4D chess with these two.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the WeChat conversation reads? Because this is how you write digital intimacy without it feeling cringe. [Xiao Lin Bullied by Math]: (little dog holding a rose in its mouth leaning against a wall.jpg) [A]: Same here. Goodnight ^^ That's it. That's the whole exchange. And it's perfect. The emoji choice tells us everything about Lin Wangye — he's enthusiastic, a little goofy, putting himself out there even though he's overthinking every word. And Shi Yuan's response? "Same here. Goodnight ^^" — short, sweet, but that double caret at the end is doing so much work. It's warm without being overbearing. It leaves Lin Wangye exactly enough hope to keep him spiraling beautifully. Then there's Lin Wangye's internal monologue analyzing that chat: "I mean—this is flirting, right? Totally counts as flirting, yeah?" The dashes, the self-interruptions, the desperate need for validation from his own brain — this is such an authentic voice. You can hear him lying cross-legged on his bed, phone in hand, replaying every message like it's evidence in a court case where he's both prosecutor and judge. Meanwhile, Lu Chengxuan and Lin Shen's dialogue is all subtext. "Got any plans for college?" "Ningchang University. Where else?" On paper, it's a boring conversation. In context, it's a collision. The author lets the dialogue do the heavy lifting without ever explaining what's actually happening between them. That's skillful writing.
... Read More
I literally stopped reading for a full minute after this chapter. Not exaggerating. The buildup is already devastating in the best way. Lin Wangye has been carrying this crush like it's this huge secret burden — and here's the thing, the text never even explicitly says 'he has a crush on Shi Yuan.' You just KNOW. You can feel it in every description, every glance, every way the narrator frames these moments. And then he's standing at the door of room 520, trying to calm his racing heart, and he walks in and it's SHI YUAN. Not the polished, elegant Uncle Shi he remembers from family gatherings. But younger. Vulnerable. Wearing a hospital gown with messy hair. The version of him that exists OUTSIDE of whatever world Lin Wangye has built up in his head. The line about how Shi Yuan smiles softly and says 'Lin Wangye?' and Lin Wangye's whole world rearranges itself in that moment — I'm not okay. The fact that Shi Yuan remembers him? That he's 'pretty well-known at school'? That they went to the same school and never officially met? The missed connections are PAINFUL and I love it. This isn't just romance buildup. This is two people orbiting each other and finally colliding. The emotional weight of it is enormous and the author handles it with such restraint. No grand declarations, no dramatic confessions. Just a boy in a hospital bed saying someone's name like it means something, and another boy who can barely breathe.
... Read More
The tension in this chapter is absolutely suffocating in the best way. On the surface, it's a classroom scene—new student arrives, seating arrangement problem, kids chat after class. But underneath? Every single character is operating on at least two levels, and Lin Wangye is the only one who sees the whole board. Let's break this down because the layers are insane. Lin Wangye is trying to remain invisible in his father's past, but he's also piecing together a mystery about his mother that could rewrite everything he knows. That's stakes. Real stakes. If he gets discovered, his entire mission is compromised. If he uncovers the truth about his mom too fast, he might not be ready for what he finds. Meanwhile, Lin Shen is sitting right there in front of him, and the narrator tells us his 'thin lips were pressed together, his face expressionless, but the look in his eyes was heavy and complicated.' What is he hiding? What does he see when he looks at Shi Shi? The fact that he leaves after class without saying a word and doesn't come back for a while—that's not nothing. That's a man running from something. And Lu Chengxuan—oh god, Lu Chengxuan. He stops Lin Wangye from giving up his seat with three words. He watches Shi Shi pass by and doesn't react at all, but he clearly knows exactly what's happening. He's playing a game that none of us fully understand yet, and his calm, almost bored demeanor is more intimidating than any explosion could be. The classroom itself becomes a pressure cooker. The teacher is stressed about seating. Students are whispering. Shi Shi is surrounded by admirers but emotionally untouchable. Jiang Bowen volunteers to move—not because he's selfless, but because his athletic scholarship gives him an out. Everyone has their motives. Everyone is calculating. And Lin Wangye is stuck in the middle, pretending to study math while his entire world is shifting beneath him.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes because this situation is genuinely tense and I want to unpack why. Lin Wangye's father has been CUT OFF by his own grandfather. Bank accounts frozen, relationship threatened, literally told to get as far away as possible. That's not just drama — that's existential threat. A teenager suddenly homeless, dependent on someone his family considers an enemy, walking into the lion's den (the Lu family mansion, no less). The power imbalance is staggering. And Lin Wangye KNOWS this. The text explicitly says "no matter how young or rebellious he had been, he couldn't be reckless now. Deep down, he was completely resistant to the idea." But there's no other option. His father has no home, and Lu Chengxuan is the only path forward. That resignation — that moment where he gives in and asks "Brother, can you take me in?" — that's a defining character moment. He's swallowing his pride, his inherited prejudices, and his genuine discomfort because survival comes first. The irony? The person he's most afraid of trusting is literally the only person who can help him. And Lu Chengxuan? He doesn't agree, doesn't refuse — his indecision itself is its own kind of power play. The tension between these two isn't just interpersonal, it's structural. Family feud, class difference, dependency, unresolved history — the author is stacking the deck and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
"According to our family tradition, if you're still in school and not married, you're considered a kid. That means you get red envelopes. And since it's your first time showing up... you're basically part of the Lu family." I keep coming back to this passage. The word "basically" does so much heavy lifting here. Lu Chengxuan is telling Wangye that paperwork and residence equal family—that his household registration being with the uncle, his sleeping in the Lu family bed, his presence at the dinner table, these are all the rituals of belonging. In a story where Wangye has spent so much of his life as an outsider looking in, this bureaucratic inclusion is almost sacred. The red envelopes themselves are rich symbolism. They're money, yes—but they're also recognition. An elder giving a red envelope is literally saying: you belong to this lineage, you are worth investing in, you are mine to protect. Wangye hears the financial value and gets excited, but the author is asking us to hear something deeper. This is a boy who has never been claimed by anyone, being formally adopted into a family through the oldest Chinese ritual there is. And then there's the contrast with the empty Lu villa versus the warm, cramped world of the Lin household and the hospital. Two families, two definitions of home. One is grand and blood-bound but currently absent; the other is modest and chosen, present and tangible. The story seems to be asking: which one counts as real family? And maybe the answer is both, at different stages of the journey.
... Read More
The shift in this chapter is brutal and I mean that in the best possible way. One minute you're in this cozy little dessert shop with six guys passing around a bank card like it's a hot potato, eating ice jelly, talking about zodiac signs—November 11th for Singles' Day, Lin Wangye's actual birthday, which he claims from his past life. It's warm and silly and feels like a slice-of-life anime episode. The author lets you breathe here. Lets you feel safe. And then: "That girl—isn't she in your class?" One sentence. That's all it takes to pivot the entire scene. The camera literally moves from inside the shop to the street outside, and suddenly we're looking at a girl walking with her head down, surrounded by five or six young guys whose vibe "screamed wannabe gangsters." Clean clothes, styled hair—but something off. The imagery is sharp: the bleached yellow hair, the cigarette, the thick gold chain swinging around the neck like some parody of wealth. This is Chen Shao, and he's already introduced as predatory before he even opens his mouth. What struck me most was how the author describes Fu Xuexue: "a helpless lamb surrounded by a pack of wolves." It's almost cliché, yes, but it works because it's followed by concrete details—the brother blocking her path, her biting her lip, the speed-up of her steps. You can SEE this. The transition from warm interior to hostile exterior mirrors what these characters constantly navigate: moments of peace shattered by the real world outside. The world of this novel doesn't let you forget that danger is always one block away.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how Lin Wangye operates? This kid climbs a mountain at dawn, gets to the one-third marker and his entire worldview fractures. He looks at Shi Yuan with those watery eyes and goes 'Help... I wanna go back...' and I literally clutched my chest. The way he cries instead of throws a tantrum is so uniquely *him* — he's not weak, he's just emotionally honest in a way that completely disarms everyone around him. Lin Shen understood this perfectly when he said he couldn't handle Lin Wangye crying, so he just... obeys. That's not fear, that's devotion wrapped in frustration. And the whole 'watch over Lin Shen' thing between Lu Chengxuan and Lin Wangye? Chef's kiss. Lu Chengxuan doesn't even flinch when Lin Shen explodes at him — just calmly offers the binary choice: 'Either it's just me, or it's all three of us.' He reads the room instantly. He knows Lin Wangye won't leave Lin Shen alone, so he sacrifices himself. Classic Lu Chengxuan move: say nothing, do everything. But the real gem is Shi Yuan. He doesn't sit. He pulls out a thermos. He studies the trail map. He offers the out without judgment. 'We can turn back if you want.' That's it. That's the whole character. He's the calm in every storm, and I need more of him in my life.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Wangye because this chapter completely made me fall harder for him. Like, the way he goes from discovering Shi Yuan's secret identity to immediately becoming his biggest defender in ONE SCENE? That's commitment right there. First, the glasses moment. OH MY GOD. When Shi Yuan puts on those thick black frames and Lin Wangye's internal monologue is basically 'WHO DESIGNED THESE AND WHY DO THEY EXIST' - I literally laughed out loud. But then it hit me how much Lin Wangye had already processed about Shi Yuan's appearance before that. He noticed the mole on his earlobe, the eyes, the lips - he was really LOOKING at him. And then the glasses 'sealed away at least 80%' of his looks? That's not shallow, that's Lin Wangye being honest about his visual preferences while still caring about the person underneath. But what really shows his character is what happens AFTER the initial shock. He doesn't just gawk and leave. He notices the empty kettle, the lack of anyone taking care of Shi Yuan, and immediately starts doing things - fetching water, unpacking fruit, planning to make Lin Shen apologize. This kid has been hurt (he implied earlier) and instead of moping, he's making sure someone else gets the care they need. And his relationship with Lin Shen? Classic best friends energy. Lin Shen is relaxed, eating an apple, barely taking the situation seriously. Lin Wangye is already formulating strategies for accountability. Their dynamic is so natural - Lin Qianqian scolding Lin Shen like a mom, Lu Chengxuan silently watching TV in the corner, and Lin Wangye being the one who actually gets things done. The most telling moment for me: when Lin Shen asks where he's going and Lin Wangye just says 'Paying your debt' and walks out. No drama, no speech. He's already decided to handle this. That's the kind of friend who shows up, not just talks about showing up.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lin Wangye's reaction to finding out Shi Yuan transferred specifically for him. Because this boy did NOT hesitate. One second he's processing the information, the next he's jumping into Shi Yuan's arms like a demented squirrel. This is a character who has been holding back emotion for what feels like hundreds of chapters, and the moment he thinks he understands what Shi Yuan did — that Shi Yuan chose him, chose their class — he just implodes with joy. And not in a subtle way. He literally wraps his legs around Shi Yuan's waist and sings a children's cartoon theme song. This is the most Lin Wangye thing ever. But here's what makes it work: the author doesn't make it purely comedic. There's this beat where Lin Wangye freezes, stammers, asks if Shi Yuan intentionally failed the exam — and that vulnerability underneath the chaos is real. He's afraid that someone like Shi Yuan would sacrifice himself for him. When Shi Yuan explains he didn't actually fail and was just giving Fu Xuexue space, that relief is palpable. And then the hug — it's physical, uninhibited, the kind of affection Lin Wangye has never been able to express directly before. Meanwhile Lin Shen watching from the window with that mix of confusion and disbelief is the perfect Greek chorus. And Zhao Youyou with her hands on her face? Iconic. This scene establishes that the core relationship dynamic has shifted fundamentally.
... Read More
There's this one sentence that sums up exactly why this story works so well for me: 'The pain that was bound to come would still arrive once the protective mechanism faded.' That's not just a beautiful line about grief—that's the entire narrative engine of this book right there. The author structures these chapters like a rollercoaster that never stops. You get hit with shock, then relief, then hunger, then grief, then hope, then the Lu Chengxuan encounter, then the internet cafe scene. Each beat lands and immediately pushes to the next. There's no breathing room, but that's THE POINT because Lin Wangye doesn't have breathing room. The pacing mirrors his desperation perfectly. What I appreciate most is how the author handles transitions. Moving from the school search to the cafeteria felt natural—not forced, not rushed. We follow Lin Wangye's physical journey (wandering → cafeteria → seeing Lu Chengxuan) and the emotional journey runs parallel (confusion → hope → recognition → desperation → small victory). The pacing between these beats is controlled so well. The internet cafe description is a fascinating structural choice too. After the intense cafeteria scene, the author drops us into another environment with sensory details—smoke, instant noodles, heaters making everything smell worse. It's a texture shift that gives us a momentary pause while still pushing the plot forward. The contrast between old internet cafes and the high-end versions from twenty years later also reinforces the time-travel element without needing exposition. If I had one tiny complaint, it's that I wanted even MORE of Lu Chengxuan's internal perspective in that cafeteria scene. Just a few lines from his side would have elevated an already incredible moment. But honestly? The restraint works too. Sometimes not knowing what someone thinks is more powerful.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or