Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in this chapter is absolutely masterful and I need to unpack why it works so well. It starts SLOW. Meandering. Two guys walking, small talk about holiday plans, casual questions about childhood. It feels like a breath of fresh air—comfortable, unhurried, almost slice-of-life. You settle in. You get comfortable. You think this is just a chill chapter about friendship. Then LU WEI SHOWS UP OFFSCREEN and the tempo changes INSTANTLY. The prose gets tighter. Lin Wangye's panic accelerates. We feel the ground shifting. The domestic scene suddenly feels precarious, like a house of cards waiting for wind. And then—the author pulls a COMPLETE U-TURN. Instead of dealing with the Lu Wei threat, we go BACK to childhood. Back to marbles and cartoon references and recess. It's a soft landing after the panic, but it's also a SETUP for something bigger. Because we know what's coming. We know eighth grade is the turning point. Every sweet moment between Lu Chengxuan and Lin Shen now carries the weight of impending loss. And then the chapter ENDS mid-sentence. 'He stopped comin'—' CUT TO BLACK. No resolution. No warning. Just raw abruptness that mirrors how grief actually arrives—not with a farewell tour, but with a door closing. The author is playing with temperature. Hot, cold, warm, cold, HOT. And I'm left freezing and sweating at the same time.
... Read More
I have to say — the Yingtian Mountain sections are genuinely beautiful writing. Like, the author takes their time here and it shows. "At over 1,500 meters above sea level, hiking all the way up on foot was a serious physical challenge. Best-case scenario: three days of being bedridden. Worst-case? You'd need someone to carry you back down." This is such a fun way to describe a setting. It's not just "the mountain is high" — it's "you're going to suffer and here's exactly how much." I could feel the altitude in my lungs reading that. And the whole setup of the sightseeing shuttle going to a "small town-like area halfway up the peak" with hotels, restaurants, shops — it felt so lived-in. Like this place has its own ecosystem. Tourists trickle in, some brave enough to hike to Yingfu Temple, most content to stay in the mid-mountain village. The snow-covered scenery, the brutal winter temperatures, the fact that people still come anyway despite it all — there's a romanticism to that I really appreciated. The hotel suite moment was also great worldbuilding in a smaller scale. Four-star hotel, chain options versus affordable guesthouses, the four friends splitting costs evenly. It painted this picture of a group trip that felt real — not some lavish fantasy getaway, just regular people trying to have fun together, arguing over beds and money like actual friends would. The contrast between the sterile hospital corridor with Dr. Bai and the snowy mountain village is also kind of brilliant. Two completely different atmospheres in one chapter, and both worlds feel equally tangible.
... Read More
The structural choice to split this chapter into two distinctly different scenes is something I have strong opinions about. The first part — the classroom announcement, the gossip, the corridor revelation — it moves at this breathless pace. The author gives us wave after wave of reactions: the class explode, Fu Xuexue explains, Lin Wangye pieces it together, Shi Yuan confesses, Lin Wangye loses his mind. By the time Lin Shen is dragging someone for a "serious talk," I was completely caught up in the momentum. And then — cut to — an internet cafe. Two people dying in a video game. The tonal whiplash is intentional and effective. After the emotional intensity of the corridor scene, we need air. The gaming scene provides that release valve while also doing important character work for Lin Shen. It shows us another side of him — frustrated, competitive, slightly reckless — that we don't see in the classroom setting. The transition between these two scenes is handled through Lin Shen's dialogue with no explanation, no bridge paragraph. Just straight cut. It works because the reader is already invested enough to follow along without hand-holding. The pacing here trusts the audience. One thing I will say — the chapter ends somewhat abruptly on Lu Chengxuan's gaming incompetence. It feels like there could be more resolution to the Lin Wangye/Shi Yuan storyline before we pivot, but maybe that's deliberate. Maybe the author wants us to sit with the excitement of the corridor scene and then reset with something lighter. Either way, it keeps me turning pages.
... Read More
The pacing here is a masterclass in relief and tension. After the high-octane rescue and the bureaucratic hangover of the police station, the author doesn't keep us on a knife's edge. They give us the ‘green tea' meme moment with Lin Shen. They give us the wholesome, slightly cringey mother-son bonding between Lin Wangye and Lu Wei. It's a breath. A comfortable, warm breath. We get to see Lin Wangye succeed in his social maneuvering, get the cool GPS watch, feel the glow of being accepted. Then—BAM. Cut to the bedroom. The pacing slows down drastically. It becomes internal, quiet, digital. The text conversation stretches out, mimicking the insomnia. The phone call lingers. It's almost too slow, and that's the point. It forces us to sit with the characters in their vulnerability. But then, right at the end, when Lin Shen calls Lu Chengxuan in the dead of night asking about the busy phone? The pace snaps back. The peace is broken. We're back in the game. The transition from the syncing breaths to the vibrating phone in the dark is seamless storytelling.
... Read More
This chapter does something really interesting with pacing. It starts so slow and quiet—the melting snow, the gentle sunlight, this soft moment between two people—and then Lin Shen knocks on the door and everything explodes into comedy. The tonal whiplash is intentional. You're sitting with this intimate scene where Shi Yuan's heart is trembling and Lin Wangye is offering kisses, and then suddenly it's about composite logarithmic functions and love spells. But the structure here isn't just comedy relief. Every time Lin Shen enters, the tension between Shi Yuan and Lin Wangye gets pushed further to the edge without either of them actually crossing it. The author uses the dad as both comic relief and obstruction. The chapter ends with Lin Wangye muttering about paying for sins and Lin Shen declaring he needs to go to a temple to exorcise a demon—that's not just a funny ending, it's the author deliberately keeping everything unresolved. Nothing gets answered. What sins? Is there a demon? Are they cursed? All of these questions are left hanging while the comedic energy carries us forward. The pacing between scenes also deserves mention—the shift from the quiet windowsill moment to the hospital room comedy to the author's note explaining the previous life timeline. That meta-break in the narrative is a bold structural choice that reminds you this is a story about cycles and second chances. The chapter flows from tenderness to humor to metaphysical weight and back again, never letting you settle into one emotional register for too long.
... Read More
Okay so this entire chapter is basically one massive plot bomb dropping and I am NOT okay. Lin Wangye walks into that classroom expecting maybe a normal high school setting and instead finds out Shi Shi—the movie queen from twenty years in the future, basically the most decorated actress in the entertainment industry—was sitting in this exact same class as his dad? Twenty years ago? The timeline just collapsed on itself and honestly I love it. What really got me was the way the narrative handled this reveal. It didn't just dump exposition. First Lin Wangye sees her and his reaction is pure shock—his jaw almost hitting the floor, all these internal questions racing. Then the teacher explains she'd been abroad for nearsightedness treatment and just returned. And then the real gut punch: that perfect middle seat in the third row wasn't placed for academic reasons at all. It belonged to THE school belle. The seat he's sitting in right now? It was literally her seat. Which makes the whole situation with Jiang Bowen volunteering even more layered. The subplot about his mom is also quietly building and I'm already obsessed. Lin Wangye has been searching for her this whole time and now suddenly everything clicks into place—why he doesn't look like his dad, why there's never been any overlap between the Lin Group and Shi Shi in the original timeline. Could she be hiding her past as a mother? With his dad's habit of keeping everything secret, it suddenly all makes sense. But the author isn't confirming anything yet. That uncertainty is killing me.
... Read More
So Lin Wangye just sits there, processing the fact that his dad likes men. Not a cliffhanger-twist, not a gradual reveal—just Lin Qianqian casually dropping this like it's gossip about a celebrity. The plot doesn't tiptoe around the big reveal; it shoves you into the protagonist's head and makes you feel that absolute blankness where thought goes to die. What's brilliant about the structure here is that everything that happened before—the cold shoulder from Lin Shen, the family tension, the weird distance—suddenly recontextualizes itself. Lin Wangye starts connecting dots he never noticed: those moments between Lin Shen and Yang Qingsen that seemed innocent now glow with a completely different meaning. The author doesn't spell it out for us; we get it through Wangye's own painful realizations. And then the question hangs there, thick and unresolved: if Lin Shen is gay, how did Wangye come to be? Was he adopted? Is there another woman involved? The plot doesn't answer this immediately—it just leaves Wangye spiraling, which is exactly the right move. A mystery wrapped inside a family drama wrapped inside an identity crisis. The narrative keeps peeling layers without giving us the comfort of resolution. I also loved how the shopping scene follows immediately after. It's a tonal shift that could've felt jarring, but instead it grounds the story. The plot isn't just about big revelations—it's about what happens next, about people trying to pretend everything is normal while standing on a fault line. When Lin Shen tousles Wangye's hair and asks what they're talking about, that mundane gesture suddenly carries enormous weight. The plot knows when to breathe and when to press harder.
... Read More
Let's be real—the police station scene was tense AF and I didn't expect it to hit this hard. You've got Lin Wangye, a kid with literally zero survival instincts, being dragged away by actual officers. The author does this thing where they DON'T immediately explain who he is or why he's in trouble. You're just thrown into the chaos with Lin Shen, screaming for help, and you have no idea what's happening. That's good pacing of information, honestly. What made the stakes feel so high wasn't just the arrest itself—it was the implication that this kid has been in this LOOP his whole life. Run away, get caught, brought back. The officers aren't even the villains here, which makes it worse. They're literally trying to help him, giving him that thermos cup lecture about dressing warmly in winter, and he still can't escape this cycle. The cop saying "stay safe" as they walk out felt like the calm before something much bigger happens. And then—"Alright, we need to discuss something now." —chapter ends on that note and I had to immediately open the next one. Whatever they're discussing, it's clear Lin Wangye's situation is about to get more complicated, not less.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is *insane* and I have thoughts. Let's start with Lin Shen because his voice is absolutely iconic. The man opens with 'Come at me! I'm going one against three today!' — said like a general going to war, while holding a Coke and sitting in front of a board game. This is peak Lin Shen energy. He's performing aggression as a shield, and we know it, and Lu Chengxuan knows it, and somehow everyone at the table knows it except... well, honestly, maybe not even Lu Chengxuan. The man plays neutral like it's a personality trait. And Lu Chengxuan's dialogue? Near silence. 'Show me some sincerity.' That's it. Two words that carry the weight of their entire history. He doesn't need to say more because Lin Shen already knows what that means. Then there's Lin Wangye's exchange with Dr. Bai, and this is where the author really flexes. Watch this: "No, no—I'm not Lin Shen. My name's Lin Wangye." followed immediately by "They're real siblings. I've got nothing to do with it!" The over-explaining! The panic! The way his words pile up like he's trying to convince himself as much as the doctor? This is such a human, authentic reaction. People don't stay calm when their identity is questioned — they ramble. They add unnecessary details. They say things like 'I grew up in a welfare home' like that's relevant context when really it's just noise from a nervous system going haywire. Dr. Bai's calm, professional responses create this perfect foil. His 'So Lin Qianqian's your sister? That makes you Lin Shen?' is delivered with genuine curiosity, not accusation, which makes Lin Wangye's spiraling explanation even funnier and more painful. The author's narrative voice throughout is sharp, observant, and quietly humorous. Phrases like 'who the hell plays a board game like this' and 'it sounded way too much like I swear I'm not lying' show a narrator who's in on the joke and wants us to laugh even when characters are suffering.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are deceptively low on the surface—nobody's in physical danger, nobody's fighting, it's just two people in a bedroom—but the emotional stakes are THROUGH THE ROOF. Let me break down why this works so well. Lin Wangye's central conflict: he knows tragedies are coming for the people he loves, and he can't warn them without sounding insane. He's carrying the weight of eighteen years of loss alone, and every moment of happiness with Shi Yuan is simultaneously a gift and a torture because he knows—KNOWS—how it ends. The necklace is the physical manifestation of this conflict. It's a piece of his past that shouldn't exist in this timeline, and every time Shi Yuan looks at it, Lin Wangye feels like he's one question away from everything collapsing. But here's what makes it even more tense: Shi Yuan is smart enough to notice something is wrong but patient enough to wait. That's the real suspense—not will he get caught, but WHEN will the gap between what they know and what they can say become too wide to bridge? The author has built this ticking clock out of love and silence and I am completely hooked.
... Read More
This batch opens with such a deceptively light, breezy tone. Four friends deciding where to hang out, joking around, complaining about hiking. It reads almost like a youth comedy. And that's the trap, honestly. The author lulls you into this comfortable vibe and then—whoosh—dropped us straight into a hospital ICU with a middle-aged man barely conscious after passing out. The transition between the two storylines works surprisingly well though. The hospital visit for Suihe naturally segues into the supermarket stop, which then pivots to Lin Shen's dad appearing in another hospital room. It's like the author is using hospitals as an anchor point—first Suihe's ward, then the ICU—and the hiking trip serves as the contrast, this outdoor adventure standing in opposition to everything that's happening indoors. What I appreciate is that the author doesn't rush the Suihe stuff. We get proper scenes—the toy shopping, the banter between Lin Wangye and Shi Yuan, the quiet moment with the lamb. These aren't throwaway scenes. They build character and relationship dynamics while simultaneously letting the underlying tension of the illness simmer underneath. Then the Lin Pengcheng section hits with clinical precision: doctor's orders, vital signs, diet restrictions. The prose itself becomes more measured, more sterile, matching the hospital environment. Good structural awareness from the writer.
... Read More
"Shi Yuan gently rubbed the clay on Lin Wangye's chin that he'd accidentally smeared there." I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay right now. This is the most intimate gesture in the entire chapter and it happens over dirty pottery clay and costs approximately zero words of explicit romance. Lin Wangye can't even make a cup — he's been struggling this whole time, flipping through instructions like a man who definitely said "I can do this alone" five minutes ago — and instead of finishing, the scene ends on someone wiping something off his face with a wet wipe. And the fact that Shi Yuan noticed the clay on his chin but didn't make a big deal out of it, just... pulled out a wet wipe from his pocket and handled it. Prepared. For this exact scenario. Or at least prepared enough to have wet wipes on hand while teaching pottery to clueless strangers on a Saturday. Meanwhile Lin Shen is out here getting into heated arguments with random players about whether his marksman sucks and nobody is wiping anything off anyone's face. The contrast is making me emotionally unstable. "Actually, making a cup is quite simple too. I've been watching you." — SHI YUAN HAS BEEN WATCHING. He's been watching Lin Wangye struggle with clay this entire time and only now decides to intervene. Like he was enjoying the show.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or