Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's something really special about how this novel handles its setting, and I want to talk about the contrast between the ancient town outside and the intimate hotel room inside. The author describes the town with this one perfect line: "To match the scenery, the entire town was filled with old-style architecture, like something straight out of ancient times. Walking through it felt like being transported hundreds of years into the past." That's it. That's all we get for the outside world, and it works because it's deliberately spare. The ancient feel of the town creates this timeless, almost dreamlike backdrop—like the story could be happening in any era, which adds to the romantic atmosphere. But then we move inside, and the world shrinks to something incredibly intimate: a warm hotel room, a lazy chair, a blanket being dropped over someone's shoulders, the creak of a bed, soundproof walls that both protect and betray. The author uses the hotel room as a kind of pressure cooker for all the emotional tension. It's cozy and comfortable on the surface, but underneath it's where secrets are overheard, where bodies get close, where conversations hint at things unsaid. The sensory details are what make it work. The lazy yawn, the stiff tour bus seats from earlier contrasting with the soft hotel bed, the warmth of the room making Lin Wangye careless enough to let his hoodie ride up. Even the author's note about the system fixing a bug feels like part of the worldbuilding—this timeline has rules, and they matter. The ancient town, the modern hotel, the system mechanics—they all coexist in a way that feels intentional rather than jarring. The setting never feels like wallpaper. It's alive, and it breathes with the characters.
... Read More
Okay so this hit me right in the feels. Lin Wangye keeps circling back to that funeral moment and just CAN'T figure out what Lu Chengxuan was actually thinking. Was he happy his rival's dad died? Was he genuinely sad? The text literally says no one can predict what someone will be like twenty years later, and honestly? That's kind of beautiful and terrifying at the same time. What gets me is how Lin Wangye's hatred of Lu Chengxuan was never even his own — it was inherited. He grew up surrounded by people who treated the Lu family as enemies, and the resentment was just... quietly planted in him. He never had a real conversation with this person, never asked questions, just absorbed everyone else's opinions. Now he's regretting not asking Shi Yuan about the past. Ugh, why do we always realize we should've asked questions AFTER everything falls apart? Also the whole "we grew up together" reveal when Lu Chengxuan casually drops that he and Lin Shen were childhood friends? Chef's kiss. The rivalry between their families was supposed to be generational enemy energy, but these two were literally going to the same school since elementary? That adds SO much weight to everything. No wonder Lin Shen fought for every inch when competing with Lu Chengxuan — this wasn't just business, this was personal history.
... Read More
OK so let me just start by saying that one moment where Lin Wangye literally throws himself at Lin Shen's leg shouting "Dad" had me absolutely losing it. The contrast is everything — Lin Shen is right in the middle of a crucial gaming moment, keyboard clicks still going, and he just casually waves him off like "get off, don't distract me." He doesn't even look away from the screen. That's their dynamic in one beat. It's affectionate but wrapped in this layer of everyday practicality that makes it feel so real. But then underneath all the humor, Lin Wangye is in genuine emotional turmoil here. His whole conflict about the adoption — he wants to go to school, he needs the household registration change, but if he becomes a Lu on paper, what happens when the future fractures? He already knows that the two men in front of him will eventually fall out. His hesitation isn't about ungratefulness, it's about loyalty dividing him in half. And Lin Shen sees that immediately. When Lin Shen says "we'll just go our separate ways when the time comes" — he's acknowledging it, isn't he? He already knows something bad is coming between them. That hit me hard.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this whole Lin Wangye mother storyline because it is genuinely gripping and I can't stop turning pages just to figure out what the hell is going on with his parents. The logic he's running through in his head is actually really solid—his dad told him his mother abandoned him, but that makes zero sense given his dad's status back then. If there was some kind of scandal or affair, there would be records, traces, something. But there's absolutely nothing. The only logical conclusion is either she died long ago, but then why fabricate the abandonment story? It's a genuine paradox that's got me invested. And then this sudden pivot where he asks Lin Shen about having a girlfriend—wait, that's not even the weird part. The weird part is how it connects. He's clearly looking for leads, trying to find any thread he can pull, and when he asks about a girlfriend, Lin Shen shuts it down immediately. Which of course drives Lin Wangye even more nuts because it closes another potential avenue. The structure here is doing something really clever—I love how the author bounces between the internal mystery and these grounded character interactions. You're never just sitting with exposition; it's always paired with something human. That line about his father standing under the streetlamp smoking? That's not random atmospheric filler. That's the plot breathing in the background, waiting for the next beat. I'm genuinely curious now whether his father knows more than he's letting on, or if there's something Lin Wangye hasn't considered yet.
... Read More
There's a moment—well, a cascade of moments—where Lin Wangye has to sit with the fact that everything he thought he knew about his father is wrong. The emotional whiplash is brutal. He goes from 'my dad is giving our family the cold shoulder' to 'what if I was adopted? What if my entire identity is built on a lie?' All in one afternoon. The most heartbreaking part isn't even the big revelation—it's the quiet aftermath. Lin Wangye pretending to sleep against Lin Shen's shoulder in that taxi, while his mind races through suspects and scenarios. He can't even look his father in the eye anymore. That physical closeness (head on shoulder, fake sleep) paired with emotional distance is devastating to read. The author doesn't need dramatic dialogue or tearful confessions; they just show us two people sharing body heat while one of them is mentally reconstructing his entire life. And Lin Qianqian! Her protective fury—'I'll kill him!'—that's genuine sibling energy, raw and unfiltered. She's not being malicious; she's terrified for her new brother. The emotional truth in that scene is perfect: she wants to smash someone's face in because someone might hurt the person she's just started caring about. But then there's the quieter emotional thread—Wangye's confusion about his own sexuality, his memory of that 'thump in his chest' when he saw Shi Yuan. Is he like his dad? Does it run in families? The emotional landscape here is messy and unresolved, and that's what makes it feel real. We don't get clean answers; we get a boy sitting in a taxi, trying not to fall apart while his father sleeps beside him.
... Read More
Lin Wangye's internal voice is the anchor of this entire piece. When he says 'R-Really... is that true?' the stammer isn't just punctuation—it's characterization. We hear a boy whose vocabulary has failed him, whose usual articulation has deserted him in the face of something too large to process with complete sentences. But it's the contrast between internal monologue and external dialogue that makes this chapter sing. Internally, Wangye is a torrent: 'Where did I come from? Where am I from!? Was I just some random kid tossed into his pocket?' That's stream-of-consciousness, raw and unfiltered. Externally, he manages only 'N-Nothing. Nothing at all.' The gap between what he thinks and what he says is where the voice lives. The author understands that adolescent male speech patterns often involve minimizing, deflecting, disappearing into silence when overwhelmed. Lin Qianqian's dialogue is all gesture and impulse—'I'll kill him!' delivered while rolling up sleeves. She speaks in action verbs. Lin Shen's voice, when it appears, is deceptively casual: 'What are you two talking about?' That ordinary question gains enormous weight because we know what the listener just heard. The dialogue doesn't need to be dramatic; it needs to be true to the moment, and the author nails that. The most striking use of voice is the interrupted whisper at the end. Someone says something to Wangye in the taxi—lowered voice, gentle pinch on the cheek—but we never hear the full words. That deliberate withholding of dialogue is itself a form of voice: the author refusing to give us the comfort of completion, forcing us to sit in the same uncertainty as the protagonist.
... Read More
The visual storytelling in this chapter is absolutely cinematic, and I need to talk about how the author uses light and shadow to mirror emotional states. Let's start with the opening image: Lin Wangye crying, cheeks red from wiping, Shi Yuan soaking a towel to gently clean his face. The contrast between the cold water on the towel and the heat of Lin Wangye's tears immediately establishes this tension between comfort and helplessness. Shi Yuan can perform acts of care—wiping tears, offering to search again—but he cannot fix the actual loss. That's a quiet but powerful visual metaphor. Then we transition into the dream sequence, and the imagery shifts dramatically. We're at Yingfu Temple now, or rather, in Lin Wangye's memory of it. The mountain descent, the spring clasp snapping—these details ground the emotional moment in physical reality. The temple setting itself carries weight; it's a place of prayer, of wishing, of seeking blessings. And the necklace he's mourning was a gift from Shi Yuan himself, designed and crafted by his own hands. The symbolism is almost heavy-handed in the best way. But the scene that genuinely gave me chills is the one in the dim nightlight. The platinum pendant, tossed aside near the pillow, catching that cold metallic cross-shaped gleam. The author writes: "It made the world in Shi Yuan's eyes look strange and surreal—like none of it was actually real." This is masterful. The cross shape of the pendant, the cold light, the dreamlike quality—all of it creates a sacred yet unsettling atmosphere. It's as if the sacredness of the moment (the kiss) is filtered through something almost religious or transcendent. And then there's the physical sensation: "The cold sting of snow and wind slipped through the fabric of Shi Yuan's clothes and into Lin Wangye's nose, making his heart race faster and faster without him even realizing it." This detail is everything. The external cold versus internal heat, the body reacting before the mind catches up—it's visceral, it's embodied, it's real. The nightlight scene with the dim glow illuminating only a small corner, shadows and light mixing, creates an intimate bubble where anything becomes possible. It's a space suspended from reality, and within it, Lin Wangye finally acts on what he's felt for years.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually at stake here, because on the surface this looks like a fluffy romance but underneath it's a pressure cooker. Lin Shen's external conflict is straightforward: his best friend (or whatever they are) is romantically involved with someone else and didn't tell him. The betrayal isn't even the main event—the secrecy is. He's been 'holding back to save face' for days. Days! That's not a small amount of suppressed emotion. And Lu Chengxuan, who knew and chose silence, is now both the source of the information and the obstacle to Lin Shen confronting it. But the internal conflict is where it gets dangerous. When Lin Shen ends up on top of Lu Chengxuan, his body reacts before his brain catches up—scalp going numb, whole body going limp, then panic and twisting. The physical intimacy is terrifying him because it's happening with the wrong person (or maybe, God help us, the right person). And then he covers it with aggression, which is the most Lin Shen thing ever but also the most self-sabotaging. What they're gambling here is enormous. If Lin Shen confronts Lin Wangye and Xu Suinian, he risks losing his friend. If he pursues whatever this is with Lu Chengxuan, he risks losing his friend AND compounding the betrayal. There's no safe outcome. The stakes keep climbing with every scene because the author keeps removing escape hatches—first the door that Lin Shen can't walk through, then the bed he can't get off of, then the apology that doesn't actually fix anything. And that last line—'You su' cut off mid-word—? That's not just a chapter ending. That's the author holding a knife to the reader's throat and smiling.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dialogue in this because it's doing things to me. Fu Xuexue's whole transfer pitch is fascinating — she's sitting across from her homeroom teacher and she's like, I know I like Class 7, I really do, but my grades aren't stable and Class A has people who can help me stabilize. Smooth. Calculated. Every word perfectly placed to sound humble while being a complete power move. And then you have Xu Suinian who literally doesn't say a single line of dialogue in this entire batch but somehow the author makes his absence LOUDER than any monologue could. The teacher tells Fu Xuexue 'Our Xiao Xu came to me right after school asking to transfer' and I nearly fell out of my chair. He didn't tell his FRIEND. He didn't tell anyone. He just quietly arranged his own exile and let it happen in a teacher's office while Lin Wangye was typing messages into the void. The Lin Wangye text messages are genuinely funny too — 'Xiao Lin Bullied by Math: Where are you?' — this kid is absolutely panicking and we get it in three short bursts of text. The voice distinction between characters is razor sharp and I appreciate that so much.
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene for a minute because I am absolutely shaking. Lin Wangye says something so offhand like 'if I died for ten days my dad wouldn't even notice' and I thought it was just a joke. A guy being sarcastic. And then the narrative pivots to his PAST LIFE where his father was ALWAYS busy, ALWAYS delegating to assistants, and when Chairman Lin died they kept it from him because of stock prices. HE ONLY FOUND OUT ONE DAY BEFORE THE FUNERAL. Oh my god. He's not crying because of the fight. He's crying because his own father's death was basically handled like a corporate PR decision and now hearing Lin Shen casually mention parental neglect just opened a wound that apparently never healed. And Shi Yuan doesn't even know the full story — he just sees his friend crying and pulls him into a hug. 'It's okay, it's over now.' That line. THAT LINE. Because to Shi Yuan, it IS over. The fight is done, they're safe. But for Lin Wangye, it's NOT over. The trauma of being emotionally abandoned by his own family has been sitting there all this time and this random comment in a van unlocked it. The fact that Shi Yuan didn't push for details, didn't ask 'what's wrong,' just held him — that's the kind of friendship that doesn't need words. I literally had to pause and breathe after reading that. These two are so good together and I'm not even mad about it.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about how Lin Wangye has basically achieved enlightenment? He started out suspicious ('Doubted the green tea'), then he saw through it ('understood the green tea'), and now? He has fully ascended. He is the green tea. And the craziest part is that he weaponizes it perfectly. Watching him pivot from crying into Shi Yuan's neck like a heartbroken Victorian poet to immediately putting on the sweet face for Lu Wei is both terrifying and impressive. There's this moment where he's wiping away tears and snot with a tissue, looking like a mess, and then suddenly he's cooing at Lu Wei's mom energy. It's a survival mechanism, sure, but it's also a power move. And then Lu Chengxuan observing all of this—his internal monologue about envying Xu Suian being the first person he's ever envied? Chilling. It shows how isolated he is despite being surrounded by people who care. He's the one watching the show, not participating. Meanwhile, Lin Shen is just the exasperated bro在旁边 shaking his head. The dynamic is so deliciously messy.
... Read More
I need to talk about the layering in this scene because it's absolutely insane. You've got Lin Shen, a man who seems emotionally constipated even by his own standards, forcibly sharing his coat with his son while their eyes keep darting toward this third point in the triangle—Lu Chengxuan. And Lin Wangye? He's standing right in the middle, hyper-aware of every shift in gravity between them. The most devastating moment isn't any dramatic confrontation. It's when Lin Shen wraps his arm around Lin Wangye's shoulders deliberately in front of Lu Chengxuan and laughs lightly, saying, “See? We're warm now, it's fine.” That line is so casual, but it's loaded with territorial energy, paternal possessiveness, and maybe even a hint of insecurity. Meanwhile, Lu Chengxuan just stands there in his wool sweater, refusing the jacket, watching them like a ghost at his own dinner table. He doesn't interrupt. He doesn't look jealous. But his silence is louder than anything. It's the kind of scene that doesn't tell you how the characters feel—it makes you feel it by showing you what they're choosing NOT to do. And that's when I realized: the real relationship drama here isn't romance or rivalry. It's about proximity. Who gets to stand close to whom, who has the right to share warmth, and who's left standing in the wind.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or