The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say — this chapter sequence is a masterclass in how to build tension and then RELIEVE it. We start with immediate action: four bodyguards vs. Dahl, car pulled over, danger imminent. Boom, fight happens. Then we cut to the police station, and instead of resolving everything quickly, the author makes us WAIT. Rhettsey is smug, untouchable, demanding coffee like a spoiled brat. The police are already getting pressure to let him go. For a solid chunk of these chapters, the reader is sitting there thinking "is he really just going to walk away?" And then — cut to Xie Zhuhan appearing like a ghost, making one phone call, and WHAM. Rhettsey's world collapses. Seven days detention. Family cuts him loose. Grandfather himself tells him to take the punishment quietly. The deportation happens off-page and we just see the aftermath through the internet article, which is honestly the perfect choice because it mirrors how real these things play out — you find out about someone's downfall through gossip, not from personal experience. The structure here is so clever too. We get multiple POV shifts: Zhu Li researching, the police station scenes, Xie Zhuhan's magic teleportation, and then the Weibo article as an epilogue-style ending. Each section gives us new information at just the right moment. The Rhettsey family not sending lawyers or paying bail? That detail lands perfectly because it shows the scale of what just happened — this isn't just punishment, this is social death for someone whose entire identity is built on family name. The only thing I'd critique is that the transition from the police station to Xie Zhuhan's phone call feels slightly abrupt, but honestly, the pacing is tight enough that I didn't even care while reading.
... Read More
The Chinese idiom used in this chapter—三年河东三年河西—is doing so much thematic work that I almost want to pause and appreciate it. It literally means fortune is unpredictable; what goes up must come down and vice versa. And the author applies it to TWO different relationships simultaneously. First, the obvious application: Lu Xi was the rising star, Jian Huai was the nobody. Now it's reversed. Jian Huai is the Best Actor, Lu Xi is struggling for a rookie deal. The idiom describes their career trajectories perfectly. But there's a second, quieter application running underneath. Jian Huai has everything professionally but is emotionally stuck. Lu Xi has lost everything publicly but is building something private at home with his twins. Fortune doesn't just reverse—it splits into different currencies. Fame for one, fatherhood for the other. The kindergarten scene is pure symbolism. The parent card that only works with the matching photo—this is a system that demands proof of identity, proof of belonging. Lu Xi swipes his card and becomes Doubao and Dougao's daddy. The stage king, the fallen idol, the guy who talked back to executives—all of that dissolves into a single parental identity at the school gate. The author is asking: who are you when no one is watching? When the cameras are off? When you're just picking up your kids? The twins calling Lu Xi "mommy" while he's clearly their father is another delicious piece of symbolism. Family is whatever holds it together. Identity is whatever you choose to claim. And the entire industry—gossipers, executives, management—keeps trying to define these men by external metrics while the story keeps showing us what actually matters.
... Read More
The pacing here is genuinely masterful and I want to break down why. It opens with a slow burn — fans waiting, the tension of a flight landing, the mundane professionalism of Zhu Li scrolling her phone. Then BAM, chaos: wrong person spotted, fake fans exposed, the handsome stranger appears. The pace accelerates with the twin boys' ridiculous airport antics, then hits a comedic peak with the fan misunderstanding beat, and RIGHT AFTER that emotional punch (the banner reveal), the narrative shifts again into the gossip group chat. This last section is where the real mystery seeds get planted — the four years ago, the xyxf drama, the vague references to a scandal that ruined someone. The transition from comedic airport scene to intrigue-filled chat group is seamless. It's like the author is saying: laugh now, but we're building something bigger. The chapter structure moves from external observation (Zhu Li watching) to intimate character moments (the twins with Daddy) to world-building lore (the gossip group), and each section hands off to the next without a single drag.
... Read More
Let me just say—this chapter structure is genuinely clever and I wish more authors would commit to this kind of parallel storytelling. We have Lu Xi's thread and Jian Huai's thread running side by side, and the author keeps cutting between them like a director cross-cutting in a film. Lu Xi walks out of that elevator like a man who still thinks he's the king of the stage. Jian Huai walks out of the same elevator like a man who's already won everything but can't stop glancing back. The parallel structure hits hardest when Pete rambles about how Lao Jian was ninth back in the day while Lu Xi was champion, and Lu Xi just… doesn't care. He says they shared a bed once. THAT is such a casual throwaway line that does so much narrative heavy lifting. These two have a history that predates the rivalry, the fame gap, the kids, the falling out. The author never tells us what happened between them, and that silence is doing more work than any exposition dump could. Then you have the kindergarten scene at the end, which is such a tonal pivot from everything that came before. One minute we're watching office gossip and career stakes, and the next we're seeing Lu Xi as Doubao and Dougao's dad, standing at a school gate in sweatpants basically. It recontextualizes his entire existence. He's not just a fallen idol trying to claw his way back—he's a father. That changes the stakes of everything. And Jian Huai's confrontation with the gossipers? I love that the author chose to reveal his motivation through an internal thought—"…He wouldn't have kids with someone else." Not a speech. Not a dramatic declaration. Just a quiet, almost pained internal certainty. The plot doesn't need fireworks here; it needs restraint. This chapter understands that perfectly.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in slow-burn pacing. The author could have had Jian Huai confess immediately or have Dahl cause some dramatic confrontation, but instead we get this carefully layered progression: arrival and tension → gifts and domestic setup → afternoon flowers and bathrobe incident → hot spring ghost misunderstanding → panic text to brother → accidental interruption. Each beat builds on the last without rushing. What's impressive is how the author uses downtime — the kids napping, the flower arrangement, the casual chat — to let tension simmer rather than explode. The plot doesn't advance through big events but through tiny charged moments: a gaze held too long, a button popping, a cold breeze that isn't actually a breeze. By the time we reach the cliffhanger with the brother's phone call, you're already anticipating the next chapter because the story has positioned multiple unresolved threads perfectly. The transition from the warm birthday preparation scenes to the spooky hot spring moment to the comedic panic under the covers creates a rhythm that keeps you engaged without ever feeling dragged out. Every scene serves the overall tension, and the chapter structure mirrors the emotional arc — starting light and playful, building to something slightly unsettling, and ending on a note that's equal parts funny and anticipatory.
... Read More
Okay so this one scene. This ONE SCENE. Lu Xi throws himself into Xie Zhuhan's arms after their fight, demands a make-up kiss, and Xie Zhuhan literally just... takes him into his arms and kisses him properly for the first time. And Lu Xi is breathless and trembling and his legs give out and Xie Zhuhan's hands brush his waist and he STIFFENS. Stiffens. Like his brain went: WHOA okay cool now I need to go stand in the bathroom for twenty minutes and process. And Lu Xi, being the absolute gremlin that he is, leans in and whispers in his ear “What should I do, Xie Zhuhan? My waist is weak. Touch it.” And Xie Zhuhan says “You're still young” in this voice that's described as “deep and bottomless, as if he was suppressing something, or perhaps nothing at all.” THE UNDECIDED SUPPRESSION. The author did NOT come to play. I literally screamed at my phone because of course Xie Zhuhan is a virgin. Of COURSE he is. This man who dresses like a stoic CEO and speaks in two-word sentences has never had sex in his LIFE and his 18-year-old boyfriend is weaponizing cuteness against him every single morning. The energy swap in this relationship is everything. Lu Xi seems smaller and younger but he's the one driving, and Xie Zhuhan is just... desperately trying to maintain dignity while losing every single battle. And then the dream sequence? Where Xie Zhuhan wakes up alone and mourns the memory of Lu Xi calling him “Uncle Xie” while whimpering? I am not okay. This man is so deeply in love and he doesn't even know how to SHOW it.
... Read More
I need to address the absolute comedic genius of Dahl's dialogue because it is unmatched. "I'm warming your bed, master." Said with what the text calls honest conviction. HONEST. CONVICTION. This man genuinely believes he is being helpful and the reader is supposed to find this both hilarious and slightly terrifying. And then the naked reveal. Eight-pack abs, golden skin, V-line—and the narration just goes full sales brochure: "He is 23cm/9inches long, could go seven rounds a night, and last over an hour." BRO. This is the most deadpan specification of physical attributes I have ever encountered in a novel and I am deceased. "Master, if you ever need me, I'm always ready to serve." Bent at the waist, mimicking Lord Cecil's respectful posture. He's treating seduction like a customer service protocol. His logic is so internally consistent it's impressive—he studied the manuals, he met the standards, he's confident he can still grow. This is a man who has read the fine print on his own body and filed it under strengths. Meanwhile Lu Xi is just screaming internally: "Bro, what are you even thinking?! We can only ever have a pure master-servant relationship!" And then immediately contradicting himself three paragraphs later. The voice contrast between Dahl's earnest absurdity and Lu Xi's flustered internal monologue is chef's kiss. Also the author's own note — "The film emperor appears gentle and refined on the surface, but in reality, he's starting to embrace the silly, absurd mindset too" — that is the entire tonal thesis of this book right there.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about the atmospherics because the author is NOT playing around. The scene with the twins in the bathtub is one of those moments that just transports you. Temperature-controlled tub, foamy bubbles, swirling mist, Doubao's yellow rubber duck and whale and toy train floating across the surface. Dougao's side—'not a single toy. Just a cold, blank expression.' I could literally SEE this. The contrast between the two boys isn't just described through dialogue; it's painted visually. And then there's Xie Zhuhan's manor. The rules are established so subtly: 'the master disliked anyone entering the third-floor bedroom or study. Even he could only enter upon request.' But then immediately undercut with 'Except for one person.' Five years ago, when Lu Xi was 18 with mint green hair, he didn't even let the butler finish his sentence before darting upstairs. The manor feels vast, imposing, cold—but the memory of Lu Xi running through its halls gives it warmth, history, weight. The contrast between these two worlds—the luxurious isolation of Xie Zhuhan's estate and the warm, messy, bubbly domesticity of Lu Xi's apartment with his children—is stunning. One is all silence and study desks and cold authority. The other is 'choo-choo!' and pink soaked arms reaching for a father to carry them. Even the online world feels vividly rendered. The forum posts from Rabbit Zone3 and Douban's Group 8, the marketing accounts setting up polls, the water armies spreading dirt—this isn't just background, it's a fully realized digital ecosystem that exists alongside the physical world. The author treats social media not as an afterthought but as a legitimate force that shapes the characters' lives. The writing has this cinematic quality to it. I found myself literally pausing between scenes to let the images settle in my mind. This is the kind of worldbuilding that doesn't need exposition dumps—it just SHOWS you everything through careful, deliberate sensory detail.
... Read More
I just finished these chapters and wow—what a rollercoaster. The plot moves in this really interesting way where we get these flashes of information one piece at a time, and I literally had to re-read parts because my brain couldn't keep up with all the reveals. So the premise itself is already a hook: a former top idol who disappeared at his absolute peak is coming back five years later... with TWINS. That alone is a massive revelation. But the plot doesn't stop there. We also find out about Xie Zhuhan, this extremely wealthy and powerful figure who seems to have been Lu Xi's only connection all along—the butler's memory of Lu Xi casually barging into the study five years ago shows us their history in just a few lines, and it tells us SO much. The subplot about the 'anti-hype' campaign is what really got me though. Someone is deliberately digging up Lu Xi's old scandals to prevent him from rising again. This adds this layer of corporate intrigue that feels very real to me—I've seen this kind of sabotage in the entertainment industry. The fact that Lu Xi himself is almost arrogant about it, telling his brother 'they're trying to stop me from blowing up again,' makes me laugh AND makes me believe he has the confidence of someone who actually knows his worth. What I love is that the narrative doesn't give us the full picture immediately. We're getting these glimpses through social media posts, through the butler's memories, through phone calls—it's fragmented in a way that feels very modern and very real. And I'm already theorizing about what happened five years ago. Why did he leave? What's his relationship with Xie Zhuhan really about? Those twin boys... whose kids are they? The plot is setting all these questions up beautifully. The chapter ends with Lu Xi being offered a deal by his brother's company, but Peter (his manager?) completely roasting him right after. That comedic beat came out of nowhere and made me snort. The plot pacing here is excellent—serious drama, tender family moments, then suddenly comedy. It never lets me settle into just one mood.
... Read More
This whole chapter is sitting on top of a pressure cooker and the ring is the pin. Lu Xi has given all his personal belongings to Pete except this one object that matters. Why? Because it's tied to his succession to the throne - literally and metaphorically. He's a prince who can't find his crown jewel while being watched by something that wants him. The "lingering gaze" keeps coming back like an unresolved note in a song. Is it a ghost? Is it Xie Zhuhan? The author won't tell us, and that's the whole point - the fear comes from not knowing what's watching. But the coldest symbol might be the room. North-facing, gloomy, no sun. While the rest of the hotel basks in warmth, Lu Xi gets stuck in the dark. Pete handles it behind his back, and Lu Xi doesn't even know. He walks in exhausted, eyes barely open, and just accepts the cold because he has no energy to fight it. The ring represents what he's fighting for; the room represents what he's losing. And that chill behind Director Yuan's neck? That's the story itself watching us watch it.
... Read More
Jian Huai. Jian Huai did ONE scene in this entire batch and I'm already completely invested in whatever history he has with Lu Xi. The line that got me was: "He used to get shy when I taught him this stuff." Just that one sentence, tucked in almost casually after Lu Xi notices Jian Huai being all smooth and flirty with the camera. It implies a whole backstory—Lu Xi taught Jian Huai how to charm a camera? When? How long ago? What was their relationship then? The fact that it's delivered with this quiet, almost wistful observation instead of some big dramatic reveal is what makes it hit so hard. And then there's Lu Xi himself as a character—this guy retired from the entertainment industry because of bad rumors, now he's a single dad to twin toddlers, and he's back on a competition show of all things. The Zhao Ziyang confrontation on stage was also peak character moment. Zhao throwing shade about Lu Xi's rumors and then Zhou Xin just... dismantling him in two sentences? Chef's kiss. "We're here to judge actors." Simple. Final.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pacing because this chapter is a masterful escalation and I was NOT prepared for it. It opens at maximum wholesome — two short kids trying to see into a glass counter, a helpful sales associate, Xie Zhuhan lifting them up. This is picture-perfect fluffy content. You're smiling. You're relaxed. Then the twin negotiation sequence kicks in — mutual yielding, finding common ground, the piggy bank payment scene. Still wholesome, still warm, but now there's this undercurrent of financial power that makes you sit up a little straighter. The black card reveal is the first real gear shift — everything changes in that moment. The store goes silent. Status shifts. We understand just HOW powerful Xie Zhuhan is in the living world. Then — the ice cream scene. Back to warmth. Back to tenderness. Doubao offering to treat Uncle Xie. And that's when the author PIVOTS. "It wasn't about wanting ice cream. It was about wanting to see him." Single paragraph. That's all it takes to completely reframe everything that came before. We thought this was a slice-of-life chapter. It was actually a tragedy in disguise. The return to the bedroom is the final descent — Xie Zhuhan becomes ghost, the gaze exchanges happen, Lu Xi's entire ghost-monologue plays out, and the chapter ends on a temperature drop that reads like a door closing. The pacing is deliberate: warmth → power → warmth → devastation. Each cycle pulls the rug out from under the reader, and by the third cycle you're just... sitting there. Processing. The author trusts us to feel the weight without spelling it out. One temperature drop. That's the whole punchline.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or