The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about settings, because this chapter is DRENCHED in atmosphere. The author doesn't just describe places—they make you FEEL them. Start with the hot spring scene. It's not a spa treatment. It's a coming-home ritual. Nine people, different lives now, but the moment they soak together, the water becomes a metaphor. Warmth. Cleansing. Memory. Wang Shuo yells about scrubbing backs and knowing about moles—ridiculous, gross, perfect. It's the kind of intimacy that only exists between people who shared dorm rooms and stage life. Then the backyard. The gazebo. The sunshine and barbecue aroma. This isn't just a villa—it's a sanctuary. A place where time bends. The text says ‘They sat in the gazebo in the backyard, enjoying the sunshine and the aroma of barbecue.' Notice how specific that is. Sun. Smoke. Food. Friends. It's sensory overload in the best way. You can smell the grill. You can feel the warmth. You can hear Wang Shuo's loud laughter. But here's where it gets haunting: the shift to evening. ‘By evening, the starry lights in the backyard were lit.' Those lights aren't just decoration. They're memory triggers. They lead to the robot competition—which is cute, sure, but it's also a mirror. Dougao is calm, methodical. Wang Shuo is chaotic, loud. It's the same dynamic as the group. Some build. Some break. Some watch. And then—the bedroom. Lu Xi alone. Shower. Bed. Pulls up covers. And his mind goes to the concert. ‘Confetti was everywhere, the screams of fans, the adrenaline from finishing the dance, and the alcohol.' That's not a memory. That's a vision. The author paints it in vivid, almost cinematic detail. You're there. The noise. The lights. The high. And then—Xie Zhuhan's face. Not described further. Just THERE. Like a photograph developing in your mind. What I love is how the author uses space to show emotion. The hot spring = closeness. The gazebo = nostalgia. The bedroom = isolation. Even though Lu Xi is surrounded by people, he's alone in that room. Doubao and Dougao sleep nearby, but he's miles away in his head. The setting shifts from communal to private, from day to night, from laughter to silence—and so does the emotional tone. Brilliant use of environment to mirror internal states.
... Read More
The way this chapter handles its timeline is genuinely impressive, and I don't say that lightly because most novels in this space treat flashbacks like they're filling space. We start in medias res with a memory — five years ago, Lu Xi just signed with Starlight, he's been with Xie Zhuhan for a month, nothing's happened physically. Then we cut to the make-up-kiss scene which establishes their dynamic. Then Pete's intervention which establishes the external perception of their relationship. Then a devastating single-sentence paragraph: “Then he took a devastating fall.” DASH. Just like that, five years of his life are gone. The author doesn't waste a single word on explaining what happened during those five years. We don't get the breakdown, we don't get the recovery, we just get that period and then we're back in the present with Lu Xi watching a porn adaptation of his own trauma. And THEN the author drops the meta-context about the novel-within-a-novel — Kiss Me, Little Fox Spirit — and describes its structure: sweet first half, brutal second half where the empress skins the fox alive. Because of COURSE that's the parallel. Because of COURSE Lu Xi is watching a story about betrayal and transformation and realizing it mirrors his own life. The pacing here is ruthless and it works. Every section earns its place. No filler. No unnecessary exposition. The author trusts the reader to connect the dots between the fox spirit story and whatever catastrophic thing happened to Lu Xi five years ago. That trust is rare and I appreciate it deeply.
... Read More
The external stakes in this batch are actually pretty substantial and I want to make sure they don't get lost under all the comedy. Rhettsey. Four years of silence. The broken engagement with the watch guy (Xie Zhuhan, who Lu Xi won't even name at the dinner table). The fact that Jian Huai felt inadequate — truly inadequate — comparing himself to Rhettsey's family power. These aren't background details. They're a loaded gun sitting on the mantelpiece and every charming breakfast scene is happening in its shadow. Jian Huai's arc here is especially tense because he's positioned as the protective figure but admits he's too weak. He knows about the scandal. He knows Director Wang is sensitive to rumors. He knows Rhettsey's family could destroy Lu Xi. And he can only offer compliments about Director Yuan's praise. The helplessness of someone who wants to protect but physically cannot — that's genuine stakes. Meanwhile the internal conflict is equally sharp. Lu Xi is caught between wanting to run (he left before, four years ago) and being unable to leave now because of the twins and because… Dahl? The succubus servant who somehow turned into the person holding this broken family together? The guy who makes breakfast and bathes children and then climbs into bed claiming it's his duty? "We're bros. Friends. Whatever. Just not master and servant." — That last line is the most honest thing Lu Xi has said in the entire passage. He doesn't know what they are. He's terrified of what they are. And the story is building toward that collision between the domestic joy and the external threat in a way that's going to hurt SO good.
... Read More
"A skilled general is nothing without soldiers." Zhu Li says this line and it hit me like a truck because it's true on every level. Lu Xi is trapped in this brutal position where his past self — the confident eighteen-year-old dancer who could play instruments and light up a stage — is being used as evidence against his present self. The netizens are weaponizing his own history, his own genuine affection, his own generosity. Every comment is a small violence: "Just an eighteen-year-old who hasn't read much, got famous with a pretty face, probably kept by some rich old man." "Shameless, not even fit to shine zy's shoes." "Just get lost already, you're too dirty." The stakes here aren't just about reputation — they're about whether Lu Xi can survive having his most private, vulnerable moments turned into public currency. And Zhu Li knows it. She's furious but powerless. She remembers who he USED to be, the kid who was bursting with optimism and warmth, and the gap between that memory and the current narrative is so wide it's almost dizzying. What makes this conflict especially tense is that Rhettsey is now entering the picture as a variable nobody can predict. If he finds out who really bought that watch — if he understands the context that the internet has deliberately ignored — everything changes. But if he comes in angry, or disappointed, or if he's already formed his own version of events... that's a different kind of danger entirely.
... Read More
Let me just say—Lu Xi is genuinely one of the most compelling father figures I've read in recent web fiction. The opening scene with Doubao and Dougao is so casually perfect that it almost slips by unnoticed, but then you sit with it. Here's this guy who's been through whatever the hell happened over four years, who comes back to two toddler sons who already know him, and instead of making a big emotional speech, he just... crouches down and tells them he'll pick them up in the afternoon. That's it. That's the whole thing. And yet it lands so hard. Doubao clutching that whale plush and declaring "I'm the gege, I'll take care of didi" made me actually exhale sharply. The kid is terrorized but putting on a brave face, and Dougao's deadpan correction—"I'll keep an eye on gege"—is pure comic relief but also so tender. These kids are already a unit. They don't need their dad to explain anything; they've already figured out how to be each other's people. And then the same man walks into a room full of people who think he's finished, who've already written him off, and says he's not signing with Starlight. He doesn't raise his voice. He doesn't argue. He just... states it. The fact that Pete can see something in Lu Xi's eyes that makes him stop trying to smooth things over—that's character revelation through behavior, not description. Lu Xi isn't performing strength; he simply IS strong in a way that doesn't need an audience. I'm genuinely invested in how this man rebuilds himself on his own terms while raising two kids who clearly adore him.
... Read More
"You've offended an honored guest of the Rhettsey family. You'd better take your punishment quietly." This line from Rhettsey's grandfather is doing SO MUCH WORK thematically, and I need to unpack it because it connects to everything this story is really about beneath the surface. Who is the honored guest? Obviously Lu Xi. But the tragedy is that he spent his entire childhood in America being treated like garbage by people who should have protected him, while simultaneously being rejected by the culture he identifies with. The university changing his degree without consent — that's the ultimate symbol of someone deciding who you are without your input. The girl's name, the isolation, the bathroom locking. All of it is about erasing his identity. And now here he is in China, and some ancient vampire lord is fighting an entire powerful family to keep him safe. The Rhettsey family, who once would have been untouchable, are brought to heel by someone whose power they can't even comprehend. It's this beautiful reversal of the colonial power dynamic that runs through the whole narrative. The surveillance cameras recording everything is also symbolic — in a story where people have been hiding, lying, and manipulating since Lu Xi was a child, there's finally something that CAPTURES the truth. What actually happened vs. what Rhettsey's family wanted people to believe. The officers seeing the footage and finding Lu Xi's account consistent — justice, however imperfect, being served through institutional process rather than magical intervention alone. And that final image of Lu Xi sitting on a couch, drinking hot water from a paper cup while his protector watches from behind glass? It's the visual representation of someone who has finally found a place where he's not just tolerated but cherished. The honored guest isn't just a status — it's a home.
... Read More
Can we talk about how good the dialogue is in this book? The twins sound like ACTUAL three-year-olds, not mini-adults in child bodies like so many authors do. Doubao's 'Why? Doubao is cuter!' and Dougao immediately catching onto 'Because Uncle Jian is a big celebrity'—this is real kid logic. They're processing the world in the simplest, most honest way possible and it's hilarious. Lu Xi's dialogue is perfectly calibrated too. He's sharp but guarded. When he deflects the restaurant staring with 'It's because of Pretty Jian, right?' instead of addressing his own discomfort—that's a man who's learned to redirect attention away from himself. Every line feels like it's revealing something underneath. And Zhao Yu—OH MY GOD. 'Lu Xi, do you think adding lines here would work?' while eating melons like he's the director? The green tea energy radiating off the page is insane. He's performing innocence while secretly manipulating everyone. The author gives him lines that sound polite on the surface but feel deeply wrong once you read between them. 'Just so we're clear, I'm not doing this for myself' is the kind of line that makes you want to throw the book across the room. Jian Huai barely speaks and yet his voice is the most distinct of all. 'Water is fine.' Three words and you understand everything about this man—restrained, practical, trying not to impose. His silence speaks louder than Zhao Yu's polished words ever could.
... Read More
You know what really gets me about this reunion scene? It's not the hot springs or the barbecue or even the drunk-kissing incident (though that's hilarious). It's the way everyone still gravitates toward Lu Xi like gravity hasn't changed in four years. They're all adults now—Wang Shuo with his competitions, Zhang Zihan running cake shops, Xu Nuoyan pregnant with a kid—but the second they gather, it's like no time passed at all. And Lu Xi? He's still the captain. Still the one everyone looks at when things get quiet. But here's what I can't stop thinking about: the unspoken stuff. They all avoid mentioning Doubao, Dougao, and the fact that Lu Xi left four years ago with some ‘male friend.' That elephant in the room is HUGE. You can feel it in every glance, every loaded joke. Wang Shuo teases about pregnancy rumors to fill the silence, but it's clearly a distraction. And Lu Xi? He smiles through it, plays along, but the text says ‘his mind was a bit slow' after drinking. Is he running from something? Or is he just tired of carrying everyone's expectations? Then there's Jian Huai. Quiet. Observant. Watching Lu Xi more than anything else. The narration literally says ‘To be precise, watching Lu Xi.” That's not nothing. And when Lu Xi heads upstairs alone, Jian Huai follows but ‘the words on the tip of his tongue somehow failed to come out.' What words? What's he holding back? This guy has the best reputation, the most stable status, yet everyone ignores him for Lu Xi. That's a quiet heartbreak right there. And Dahl—the succubus reserve, the childhood friend, the ‘official wife' according to the group's joke. He smirks like he's won something, but look closer. He's warm to Xu Nuoyan because “these two are the cute type.” He's protective. He's present. But does Lu Xi really see him? Or is Dahl just comfortable in the role of ‘always there' while someone else gets the spotlight? The group fell apart because Lu Xi left. Not because they grew apart—because he walked away. And now they're pretending it didn't matter. But the text says “Once he left, everything fell apart, and the group faded quickly.” That's not forgiveness. That's dependency. And Lu Xi knows it. That's why he drinks so little and still gets wasted. He's numbing something. I just wonder what he's running from—and whether Jian Huai finally says those unsaid words before the night ends.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing about Xie Zhuhan that the author keeps letting slip — this guy is SO protective but refuses to admit it in any normal way. Remember earlier when he claimed his whole mindset was just "checking how he's doing" with a little sarcastic aside about secretly stalking all of Lu Xi's updates? Well yeah, no shit. When he sees those vulgar insults and photoshopped black-and-white photos of Lu Xi, his reaction is immediate and cold: "Erase everything." Not a word of comfort to Lu Xi, not a public defense. Just silence and execution. The butler nods and is about to move when Xie Zhuhan spots ONE comment — "They're such a perfect family of four" — and suddenly his eyes do something interesting. He doesn't just order the insults taken down. He takes down the ENTIRE SUPER TOPIC. The narration itself calls it out: "Isn't that a bit childish?" And that's the whole joke, isn't it? The overbearing CEO trope says he should dramatically sweep in and destroy Jian Huai's career. Instead, Xie Zhuhan's version of revenge is basically a playground move — you called my guy's name in a positive way, so I'm burning down your whole online space. It's petty, it's absurd, and honestly? It's kind of the most intimate thing he's done in this entire scene. He's not doing it for justice. He's doing it because someone called Lu Xi part of a PERFECT FAMILY OF FOUR without his permission. Then there's Zhu Li, who's been sitting on the fence this whole time, telling herself she doesn't care, she won't get involved, she's just gonna enjoy the melon. She even has this great internal monologue about how if she ever becomes a fan of Lu Xi again, it'll only be as an ANTI-fan. And then Jian Huai's fans cross the line — doxxing, funeral wreaths, trashing Stage 100 — and Zhu Li loses her damn mind: "I'VE HAD ENOUGH! Are you bullying my baby just because he has no one backing him?!" Four years of pretending not to care, and one threat of physical harm and she's RIGHT THERE. The contrast between the two protectors is beautiful — Xie Zhuhan strikes from the shadows with corporate power, and Zhu Li explodes in raw maternal fury. One is calculated cruelty disguised as indifference, the other is a mother bear with nothing left to lose. Both love Lu Xi in their own way. Both refuse to say it out loud to HIM.
... Read More
I need to talk about this paragraph because it made me physically laugh out loud. The book summary of Youth Isn't Sad: "high school girl cheats on a test, gets caught, cue: rooftop scenes, shouting, and flirting. After the college entrance exam, the girl's friends visit the school at night, then they had sex, and finally had an abortion. They broke up, and each of them gets on the train to the university." And Lu Xi's response? "total nonsense." That's it. That's the review. Two words and I'm dead. The humor in this text is genuinely sharp—not forced, not trying too hard, just observational comedy that comes from a character who clearly has taste and isn't afraid to say so. And the way the crowd is going wild over Zhao Ziyang while Lu Xi is just sitting there internally roasting everyone's life choices? "So young and already cursed with bad taste. Tragic." This man is a vibe. Also the A-tier contestant sucking up to Zhao Ziyang and Lu Xi's judgmental side-eye at them—perfect comic relief between the tense competition scenes.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or