The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Zhu Li's outburst hit me harder than it probably should have. Not because it's dramatic — though it absolutely is — but because of the exact words she chooses. "Are you bullying my baby just because he has no one backing him?!" No one backing him. Those words carry so much weight when you consider everything we know about Lu Xi's situation. He's an actor trying to rebuild his career, navigating a show called Actor, and somehow the entire online ecosystem has turned against him based on rumors, old scandals, and the guilt of association with Jian Huai. He didn't do anything. He didn't start this. He's just... there. Existing. And the world decided he's expendable. What makes this scene so emotionally devastating is the contrast between how protected Lu Xi IS versus how unprotected he appears to be. Xie Zhuhan is literally erasing comments and dismantling supertopics with a single word. But Lu Xi doesn't know that. Or maybe he knows but it doesn't matter, because this kind of protection is invisible, transactional, anonymous. The harassment happens on a platform where Lu Xi has no shield, no voice, no community fighting for him in the same way. And Zhu Li — she's been his mother-figure, his defender, his secret admirer who refuses to admit she cares — and even SHE was holding back. She told herself she wouldn't intervene. She was going to watch and eat melons and pretend this wasn't happening to her boy. It took funeral wreaths and doxxing threats to push her over the edge. And when she finally moves, she doesn't use corporate power or silent erasure. She uses pure, unfiltered maternal rage. Four years of suppressed loyalty explode in one moment. The emotional core of this entire passage isn't the romance between Xie Zhuhan and Lu Xi. It's the question of who gets to protect whom, and what happens when the person being protected has no idea they're being defended. Lu Xi is out there getting attacked by thousands of people while Xie Zhuhan watches from his iPad, deleting comments like they're flies, and Zhu Li screams at her phone. Three different kinds of love, three different levels of visibility, all orbiting one young man who just wants to act.
... Read More
This batch is absolutely wild in terms of pacing and I don't even know where to start. Let me just... process this. Chapter 40 opens with the critique session and within the first few paragraphs we get the full grading reveal — Zhou Xin's brutal honesty, Jian Huai's softer approach, Lu Xi's 3A1D score. It's efficient. Fast. But then Zhu Li starts unpacking her backstory as a former mom fan and suddenly we're in completely different emotional territory. The show-within-a-show gives way to personal history in about two paragraphs and it works because the author never lets us get comfortable. Then — BAM — we cut to after the stage. He Xiaoman staring at Lu Xi with terror. Zhao Yu being weirdly chill. The voting scores. Lu Xi refusing to continue. And then the twins are introduced properly for the first time in this section, already asleep in the backseat. My heart. My actual heart. The transition to the hotel garage scene is masterful. One moment they're on set, the next it's late night, food delivery, and Jian Huai carrying a sleeping child. And the photo gets taken. And then we cut to Sunday morning heading back to Jinjiang City with the twins chatting about kindergarten performances, and Jian Huai casually inserting himself into their lives, and then — marketing accounts EXPLODE with the rumor that Jian Huai is secretly married with kids. The pacing here is relentless. It moves from competition drama to personal revelation to romantic tension to scandal in under 10,000 characters and I have not breathed since page one. The author knows exactly when to slow down (the midnight snack conversation) and when to accelerate (the gossip bomb drop), and that contrast is what makes this read so addictive. I literally stayed up until 2 AM reading this and I have no regrets.
... Read More
I'm not even going to try to be subtle about this — the bathrobe scene is one of the most deliciously tense moments I've read in a while. Lu Xi unties his sash, mentions soaking in the water to warm up, and Jian Huai's gaze involuntarily follows his neck and collarbone. His face starts burning red, his throat goes dry. The author writes this with such perfect restraint. There's no confession, no touch, no dramatic moment — just two men in a house full of children and a jealous succubus, and Jian Huai is literally fighting himself just from watching Lu Xi get comfortable. And then there's the whole thing with Lu Xi feeling cold in the hot spring, goosebumps rising, thinking it's a ghost when it's actually just Jian Huai's longing gaze crossing the water. The romantic tension here is built entirely through misdirection and near-misses. Lu Xi is vulnerable and sweet with his kids, completely unaware of how he affects people. Jian Huai is trying desperately to be composed and failing. The chapter ends with this moment of domestic warmth — three little lumps under the covers — which makes the romantic undercurrents feel even more tender by contrast. What makes this work so well is that the emotional beats aren't forced. The attraction is there, the tension is palpable, but nobody's making grand declarations or dramatic moves. They're just... existing in the same space, feeling things, and the reader is dying waiting for them to figure it out.
... Read More
The opening of this section is one of those scenes that just lives in my head. Eight PM, kids asleep, the house suddenly goes quiet after all that bath-time energy, and Lu Xi closing the door like he's sneaking into his own secret life. Then Old Daddy Lu's dramatic sigh followed immediately by him LEAPING onto the sofa to check his phone — this contrast between domestic stillness and chaotic adult energy is SO well observed. You can just picture it. And the chat group scenes are equally vivid. The Salted Fish Retirement Group exploding with messages, the usernames, the yellow-picture emoji — this world feels extremely specific and alive. It's not just "they hang out on WeChat." It's a particular kind of Chinese internet culture, with inside jokes and group dynamics that feel authentic. The CatTV office meeting, the producer's internal monologue about how to handle a has-been idol — these scenes paint the entertainment industry as a place of calculation and reputation management. I love how the author balances the intimate domestic space (the 180-square-meter home, the buns sleeping) with the sprawling social world of group chats and industry politics. It grounds the story even while the stakes are very public.
... Read More
This book has such a weird and wonderful ability to make ordinary scenes feel cinematic. Let me walk you through the kindergarten pickup—because this one hit different. Old man Lu scooping up one kid in each arm, dodging the teacher like a fugitive, all while managing two backpacks and a suitcase? The image is so vivid I could see it as a film. And that smile from the teacher—the SAME smile she gave when she found out he was both mommy and daddy? Lu Xi internally questioning whether she suspects something? That tiny beat of anxiety says SO MUCH about his life. He's always looking over his shoulder, always slightly afraid of being found out. Then the restaurant scene! People staring, taking photos, the twins being adorably oblivious. Doubao genuinely asking if strangers are looking because he's pretty—three years old and already confident? ICONIC. And Lu Xi's response of 'I think they're looking at me 'cause I'm pretty' made me laugh out loud. This man is doing his best. The operating room set built for the show was described as 'cold and sterile' which perfectly mirrored the competitive energy between Zhao Yu and He Xiaoman. Zhao Yu playing little fresh meat green tea—'You be the judge' while eating melons like he's at a drama? The author's visual storytelling here is spot on. Every environment reflects the emotional temperature of the scene.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is absolutely electric. Each character has a VOICE so distinct you could identify them blindfolded. Wang Shuo? Loud, Northeastern, shameless. ‘Little Cake, going to sleep with Daddy again?' That's not just a joke—that's a personality. He's the chaos agent, the one who fills silence with noise, who uses humor as armor. His lines are long, rambling, full of physical comedy. Zhang Zihan? Short, sharp, reactive. ‘Ahhhh! Shut up!' ‘I'm going to kill you!' He's the foil to Wang Shuo's energy, the one who flusters easily but fights back. His dialogue is explosive, emotional, immediate. You hear his blush through the text. Xu Nuoyan? Calm, observational, dry. ‘Watch it, there are children present.' That's it. That's the line. But it says everything. He's the adult in the room, the one who watches and comments without participating. His voice is quiet but authoritative. Lu Xi? When he speaks, it's measured. ‘Alright, alright, I'll say it. Wang Shuo, what's going on with you? Watch your attitude!' He's the mediator, the disciplinarian, the one who reins everyone in. But notice—he's almost never the one initiating. He's reactive. Responsive. Holding space for others while staying hidden himself. And Dahl? His dialogue is minimal but loaded. ‘He's Dahl, my childhood friend, my friend.' Said with a smile like ‘official wife.' That's performative affection. That's claiming without committing. Dahl's voice is warm, teasing, but there's an edge—a desperation to be seen, to be chosen, that the reader feels even if the other characters don't. Jian Huai? Nearly silent. ‘Did that happen?' ‘Did you remember?' These are the only lines he gets in the entire chapter. And yet—his silence is LOUDEST. He's present but absent. Watching but not speaking. The author uses his lack of dialogue to make us lean in, to wonder what he's thinking, what he's hiding. The narrative voice itself is a character. It slips into Lu Xi's head, lingers on Xie Zhuhan, comments on the ‘ghostly interference' of lost photos. It's omniscient but biased—it favors Lu Xi's perspective, lets us hear his thoughts while others remain mysteries. That's a deliberate choice. The author wants us to empathize with Lu Xi's isolation, even in a room full of friends. Every line serves character. Every silence screams. This is dialogue as psychology.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are devastating because they operate on two levels simultaneously, and the author never lets you forget either one. Surface level: Lu Xi is an 18-year-old dancer who just had his first time with his boyfriend Xie Zhuhan, and then five years later he's watching a painfully accurate fictional retelling of whatever trauma destroyed him. The immediate tension is — what happened? Who did this to him? The single sentence “Then he took a devastating fall” is doing more anxiety-inducing work than entire chapters of lesser novels. Deeper level: Xie Zhuhan exists in this chapter as both protector and potential threat. He's the man who bought Lu Xi every luxury item in existence, who treats him with elder-uncle propriety, who gets flustered when Lu Xi touches him. He's clearly the SAFE option. The anti-abuser. But the novel is STRUCTURING itself around the possibility that safety is an illusion — that the person who loved you when you were vulnerable is the same person who could hurt you when you're broken. The Pete scene amplifies this brilliantly. Pete represents the outside world's assumption: young beautiful boy + wealthy older man = exploitation. The narrative initially validates this reading, making us wonder if Lu Xi's own perception of his relationship was naive. Then it undercuts that by showing Lu Xi's unshakeable confidence that “he got Xie Zhuhan wrapped around his finger.” But then — devastating fall — and suddenly that confidence looks like ignorance, and the question becomes: did Lu Xi misread Xie Zhuhan's devotion, or did someone else exploit his trust? I don't know what's coming and I will not sleep until I find out.
... Read More
Let me just say this pacing is either really confident or really cruel, probably both. The batch opens with fan forum chatter—quick, energetic, establishes the online hype around Lu Xi. Then we cut to a domestic scene that's warm and funny (the twins, the facial mask story), which gives us breathing room and emotional grounding. Then BAM—competition day, rankings, tension, the D-tier humiliation, the murder role reveal, and the text just... stops mid-sentence at "Chasing dr". No resolution, no aftermath, just a cliffhanger that's basically a physical attack. The transition from the soft, intimate father-kids moment to the cold, hierarchical competition floor is jarring in the best way. It mirrors Lu Xi's own experience—going from being a beloved dad at home to being the bottom-tier nobody in the industry. And that final image of him about to pick THE LAST ROLE, a murderer, with Zhao Yu watching from the A-tier platform? I need the next batch immediately. Also worth noting: the Zhao Ziyang vs Zhou Xin spat onstage happened OFFSCREEN from the contestants. The author didn't even let Lu Xi witness that conflict. He's so far removed from the power dynamics that he doesn't even get to be part of the drama happening around him—and yet that's exactly where the most interesting drama is. Brilliant structural choice.
... Read More
There's a moment in this chapter that I wasn't prepared for emotionally. Lu Xi watches his twin sons run toward a rocking horse in their new apartment—this brand-new home his brother somehow provided—and Doubao literally hugs his leg saying he's happy. Four years abroad, two kids who've never really had stability, and the first thing they find in this strange new place is a toy that goes back and forth, back and forth. The apartment itself is a symbol I can't stop thinking about. 180 square meters, four bedrooms, two living rooms, a sunroom, already cleaned, already stocked with new clothes in his size. This is luxury but it's also a gilded cage. His brother says 'money can solve everything' and yeah, the physical setup is taken care of. But money clearly can't solve the four-year absence, the public speculation, the career death he's walking back into. Then there's the twin dynamic as a mirror. Dougao is cold and controlled; Doubao is expressive and emotional. They bump heads together at the end—a small moment of sibling connection that feels significant. One shields with indifference, the other with enthusiasm. Both are protecting something. And the rocking horse—stuck in an endless loop of motion but going nowhere. Isn't that kind of what Lu Xi's life feels like right now? Moving, busy, trending, but is he actually getting anywhere? The author plants these images without announcing them as symbols, which is why they land so hard.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is deceptively sparse and that's what makes it hit so hard. Lu Xi asking "Where's my ring?" three separate times - each time with decreasing energy, increasing desperation. First it's curious, then it's annoyed, then it's bone-tired begging. And Pete's responses get progressively more elaborate, like he's trying to fill the silence with competence. But the real gem is Xie Zhuhan's exchange with Doubao. "Can we watch Daddy tomorrow too?" "Yes." Two words. Not "of course," not "absolutely," just "yes." It's the most Xie Zhuhan answer possible. The author knows exactly what kind of person he is and doesn't waste a single unnecessary adjective. Then there's Director Yuan's venting - actual frustration, real heat, the kind of director who yells because he sees potential being wasted. "Do you even know how to act?" That line made me wince in sympathy for Lu Xi. The narrative voice itself is also doing a lot of work - it's observational, slightly ironic, never sentimental. When it says "If this is a ghost, it's a real lecher," I actually laughed out loud. Perfect tonal shift.
... Read More
I couldn't stop thinking about the emotional architecture of this passage, particularly how the twins' disappointment mirrors the broader theme of waiting and hope. Doubao's puffed cheeks and swinging legs aren't just cute details; they're physical manifestations of a three-and-a-half-year-old's heartbreak over someone breaking a promise. The fact that Dougao sits beside him, unreadable but clearly affected, adds another layer—each child processes the same emotion differently, yet neither suppresses it entirely. The scene where Lu Xi hangs up and mutters something about dad problems made my chest tighten. Here's a man who plays emperors and fox spirits for a living, yet when faced with his own children's emotional needs, he feels genuinely inadequate. The emotional high point comes when he imagines the chaos that awaits when these boys grow older—when romantic entanglements and adult disappointments will complicate what once seemed simple. His worry isn't just about the present moment; it's an anticipatory grief for futures he can't control. This passage captures something universal about parenthood: you love your children enough to fear for them even before they've lived.
... Read More
The way this author builds the entertainment industry world is quietly masterful because they never stop to explain it. You just absorb it through the chaos. Fenglin Residences is established in two sentences—school district property, three kindergartens, affiliated private international elementary and middle schools. That's it. But suddenly you understand exactly what kind of life Lu Xi has built for his family. This isn't humble beginnings; this is someone who either came from money or climbed high enough to secure the best for his kids. The detail does triple duty: worldbuilding, class signaling, and character establishment all in one breath. Then Starlight Entertainment. The author tells us it's a major company with great reputation, rich resources, no shady business—but rumor has it a powerful backer supports them. Already we're getting the sense that nothing in this industry is as clean as it appears. The corporate politics are introduced not through exposition but through overheard argument. Pete vs. Executive Xu. B-tier vs. D-tier. "The market's changed" vs. "he shot to the top of the hot searches." What I love is how the physical space mirrors the emotional landscape. Lu Xi walks into the conference room—Pete flushed with anger, the stranger astonished by his appearance, the door left open so we hear everything. He's literally walking into hostile territory while carrying the weight of four years of absence on his shoulders, and he strolls in like he owns the place. The environment is cold, transactional, dismissive—and yet Lu Xi's presence transforms it. The author knows how to make a corporate office feel like a battlefield without drawing a single sword.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or