The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Jian Huai and Dahl's dialogue in the finale is absolutely iconic and I cannot recover from it. After Jian Huai delivers the most sincere, vulnerable confession of his life on that balcony, what does he do when faced with the antagonist? He goes full comedic relief mode: “Of course. I'd like to apply to be a candidate for Doubao and Dougao's other father. If possible, tomorrow—no, even now—we can get the certificate. Lu Xi, I'm serious.” Bro. You just confessed your undying love and now you're treating marriage like you're ordering takeout? And then Dahl waltzes in with: “Master, there's also me. I was betrothed to you since childhood. I'm the rightful main partner… either, as long as I'm the head wife.” HEAD WIFE. I'm dead. The contrast between Jian Huai's raw honesty on the balcony and this unhinged competitive energy in the courtyard is comedy gold. It's also character-revealing: Jian Huai can be deeply tender AND absolutely chaotic. He's not playing it cool—he's using humor as a shield AND a weapon simultaneously. And Lu Xi's response? “What kind of nonsense are you spouting! Is this the old society? Do I need to marry several concubines?” The exasperation is so specific, so perfectly voiced. He's genuinely offended by the anachronistic harem framing, which tells you everything about where his head is at. The dialogue here does triple duty: it advances the plot, it reveals character, and it keeps the tone from becoming so heavy it cracks. Even in the most dramatic moment, these people sound like themselves.
... Read More
I need to sit down. I actually need to sit down right now because this scene with the midnight snack and the skewers and crayfish — it was so casually devastating. Let me paint it for you. It's late. Lu Xi just performed on stage, gave it everything he had, got three As and a D. He's exhausted. His twin boys are asleep in the backseat after staying up all night to watch their daddy. And Jian Huai shows up with food and says, casually, like it's nothing: "Midnight snack? I had my assistant buy some skewers and crayfish. They'll be delivered to the hotel room later. We won't have to go out to eat. How about it?" How about it. Not "let me take care of you." Not "can I spend time with you and your kids?" Just... how about it? Like they're already domestic. Like this is normal. Like Jian Huai has been imagining this exact scenario a thousand times and finally found the courage to suggest it without sounding like a creep. And then Lu Xi agrees because he doesn't want to leave the twins alone. Small gesture. Tiny moment. And Jian Huai helps carry Doubao into the garage. And a reporter snaps a photo. And the entire narrative arc of this story just shifted on its axis. What struck me most was the quiet intimacy of it all. No grand declarations. No dramatic music. Just two people sharing cheap street food at midnight while one of them secretly starts falling for the other's kid. And Jian Huai asking to come to the kindergarten performance like it's the most natural thing in the world — "I've never participated in such an activity before. It sounds interesting." Sounds interesting. Sure, Lao Jian. Sure.
... Read More
Everything in this story is building toward an explosion and I am HERE for it. Let me break down the stakes because they're multiplying by the page. Xie Zhuhan just found out Lu Xi has twin children. TWINS. He's trying to convince himself it's a misunderstanding because the alternative—that Lu Xi moved on, had a family, maybe even loved someone else—is too painful to process. But the damage is done. He knows now. And he's icy but firm about it, which means he's already formulating some plan. Meanwhile, Lu Xi is living this quiet life with his twins, trying to rebuild his career, navigating the entertainment industry as a single parent. He doesn't know Xie Zhuhan is looking into him. He doesn't know his past is coming back to haunt him. Every scene he's living in peace is framed by dramatic irony that makes me want to scream at the page. Jian Huai has his own conflict—he waited five years, feels inadequate compared to whatever Xie Zhuhan is to Lu Xi, and is trying to protect his friend without overstepping. But he's also falling for him, and that's dangerous territory when the person you're protecting is this complicated and wounded. Zhao Yu on the variety show is creating workplace conflict, trying to steal screen time and undermine Lu Xi under the guise of collaboration. But the REAL stakes aren't about a TV show—they're about who gets to define Lu Xi's narrative. Is he the betrayed partner? The single father? The fallen idol? Or is he just Lu Xi, trying to raise his kids and do his job?
... Read More
I can't stop thinking about the watches in this story. They're not just accessories—they're the entire emotional architecture of the narrative compressed into two wristbands. Five years ago, Lu Xi gifted Xie Zhuhan a fashion watch. Xie Zhuhan, who never wore fashion watches, set aside his favorite for Lu Xi and posed for countless photos of their clasped hands. He posted them online. He kept the watch even after Lu Xi left. And now—years later—he's still keeping it in a box, touching it when no one's watching. The watch represents everything unspoken between them. Love that was shown through objects rather than words. A relationship that was documented but somehow still fell apart. The fact that it's described as 'beautiful, flashy, and vibrant' like the young Lu Xi himself—that parallel is intentional and it kills me. Meanwhile, Lu Xi is wearing a DIFFERENT watch now, or maybe not even wearing one at all. He's living a completely different life with twin children and a new identity. The old watch is trapped in a box while its gifter is out here surviving. There's also the group chat dynamic with Calico Cat and Zhu Li—online spaces where fans perform loyalty and love from a distance. Zhu Li's rage about 'that watch bastard' shows how deeply personal these symbols become when you're invested in someone's happiness. The watch isn't just metal and glass. It's proof of love, proof of betrayal, proof of everything that was lost.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this chapter opening hit different because the author doesn't waste time. We drop right into the chaos of Lu Xi being spotted at the airport with TWO KIDS and the fan chat literally losing their minds. The plot is moving fast but in a good way—four years of unexplained absence, a mysterious return, twin toddlers calling him daddy, and he's already getting trended on Weibo the second he lands. That's efficient storytelling right there. What I love is how the subplots are layering simultaneously. On one level you've got the personal mystery of 'who is the mother, where was he for four years?' which is classic fanfic fuel. But then there's the career subplot with Pete—their conversation is gold because it tells us SO MUCH without exposition. Pete's 'postpartum depression' joke reveals that Lu Xi is the type to deflect serious topics with humor, and Pete's 'change careers' advice versus his immediate backtrack when he sees the trending numbers shows how the industry works. The Zhao Yu angle is setting up a proper rivalry. This guy idolized Lu Xi, studied him, but made the 'smart' choice to not vanish at his peak. That's such a clean character contrast and it's only page one of his arc. The marketing war between their agencies is basically a plot engine that's going to keep things spicy. One thing I'm genuinely curious about—the brother who bought the apartment. Lu Xi says 'money can solve everything' to his gorgeous older brother but also claims he's back to start a career. Is he independently wealthy? Is this family dynamic going to factor into the drama later? The plot is clearly building toward something bigger than just a workplace romance setup.
... Read More
Okay so this section is genuinely masterful in how it sets up an almost-missed reunion and I need to talk about it. Rhettsey shows up at the hotel, immediately dismisses the whole business inspection as secondary, and demands they find Lucy — his former classmate who supposedly ran off to China to become a celebrity. And then the manager's female employee literally has the moment where she connects the dots: Lu Xi. She types it into the iPad, hands it over, and the manager storms up to the 23rd floor to report it. But then — and this is the part that had me gripping my phone — the text just CUTS OFF mid-sentence with "the female employee snapped" and we never find out if the manager actually delivered that information or if Rhettsey already left the floor, or what happened next. The author dropped a literal cliffhanger in the middle of a sentence and I am FURIOUS in the best way possible. This is also tying together two separate narrative threads — the present-day scandal aftermath and the past relationship — into one converging point. The watch photo that became ammunition against Lu Xi five years ago? That same timeline is what brought Rhettsey into this city. Everything is connecting. I literally cannot wait for the next chapter.
... Read More
The audition waiting room that the author constructs here is perhaps the richest environmental portrait I have encountered in this novel. Morning auditions for male actors, afternoon for actresses - this simple scheduling detail immediately establishes the mechanical reality of the entertainment industry's caste system. And then watch how the author paints the emotional landscape of that room: some actors come out dejected, some with darkened faces sulking, some pale and reflective, some red-faced with shame and tears threatening. This vignette of rejected performers operates as a chilling preview of what failure looks like before either protagonist even enters Director Yuan's office. The atmosphere is thick with anxiety and fragile ego. When Zhao Yu worries that 'Director Yuan is very strict when filming,' we feel his fear reverberate through every person who has ever sat in that waiting area. But the real worldbuilding magic happens when we enter Yuan Tang's audition space. The screenwriter who 'didn't know who this person was but was quite arrogant' immediately establishes the power dynamics. Everyone else who came in before Lu Xi had been cautious, bowing their heads and greeting first. Lu Xi's refusal to 'stand on ceremony' becomes a quiet act of defiance that transforms the entire energy of the scene. I must mention how the author uses the fictional Phoenix Seeking Phoenix production as mirror and contrast. Set against the Tang Dynasty golden age, featuring the great poet Li Bai, this drama-within-a-drama creates layers of historical resonance. When Lu Xi reads about Li Bai writing his masterpiece at nineteen in Chang'an City, the imagery becomes almost cinematic - sword in one hand, wine jug in the other, bold and uninhibited yet vibrant with youth. The Tang Dynasty setting isn't backdrop; it becomes emotional context for understanding what Lu Xi must embody. The final image of Director Yuan's tired eyes suddenly lighting up creates a visual transformation that mirrors Lu Xi's own internal shift. In twelve minutes, everything changes.
... Read More
Let's talk about Lu Xi's line delivery because this guy is a METHOD ACTOR and I am HERE for it. "How could I let Your Majesty do it personally? Let your little fox serve you instead." The voice is described as "clear yet sultry" and honestly the way this line lands is devastating because it's scripted fiction becoming indistinguishable from something real. The female lead is blushing uncontrollably. Her heart is racing. Who can resist this male beauty? EXACTLY. That's the point. Lu Xi knows exactly what he's doing, even if the script only calls for a light kiss. But then there's the contrast with everyone else's dialogue. The female lead is basically just screaming internally—"I'm excited, let's hurry!" "Boss Xi was too damn charming"—while the director is just trying to manage a budget production. "Do you know how much it costs to hire all the civil and military officials?" This grounded, almost documentary-style commentary about the economics of filmmaking against the operatic romance being performed on screen creates this hilarious tonal whiplash that somehow works perfectly. And Xie Zhuhan doesn't say a single word in any of these scenes. He just watches. He just topples trees. The butler does more emotional exposition than the Demon King himself. "Sigh." Two characters, one breath, and we understand everything about his state of mind. That's skilled writing. Letting silence do the heavy lifting while everyone else is busy negotiating call sheets and loose powder.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this author controls tension like a god. The chapter opens with Xie Zhuhan in that room, holding an old watch, and the butler drops the bomb about Lu Xi having children. The silence after 'Three years and two months old' is so heavy I could feel it. The author doesn't rush it. They make us sit in that cold realization alongside Xie Zhuhan—either Lu Xi was cheating OR he moved on immediately. Both options are devastating. Then—BOOM—cut to 'Daddy!' and we're suddenly in a sunlit kindergarten with twin toddlers calling out to their father. The contrast is brutal. One moment you're suffocating in Xie Zhuhan's grief, the next you're watching a handsome man juggle two kids and a suitcase like a circus act. This pacing choice is Genius. It prevents the book from becoming one-note angst and keeps you bouncing between emotional extremes. The variety show rehearsal scenes with Zhao Yu playing green tea are almost comedic in their absurdity. 'I'm not doing this for myself. Just want to hear your opinion.' Please. The man is clearly orchestrating everything. But this lighter moment serves a purpose—it gives the reader breath before the next emotional gut punch. The author knows exactly when to pace fast and when to slow down. The hot coffee going cold in Jian Huai's car is one of those slow, quiet beats that makes everything else feel more urgent by comparison.
... Read More
I need to talk about these twin boys because WOW. Doubao and Dougao are identical in looks but COMPLETELY different in personality, and the author handles this distinction so cleanly it's impressive. Doubao is the sweet, clingy one — 'Daddy, faster!' with those grape-like eyes and puffed cheeks, covering his eyes because he's scared but also excited. Meanwhile Dougao is the ice-cold counterpart who just says 'Hold on tight' with zero emotion. And Lu Xi's reaction? 'Kid, your voice is shaking. How is that not scared?!' The man is DONE with these two but clearly adores them. Their dynamic — one driving the other everywhere, the quiet one always grounding the chaotic one — feels very intentional. And then there's Lu Xi himself. On the surface he seems like a polished idol who can switch between 'cool celebrity' and 'exhausted single dad' in seconds. But that moment when the fans realize their mistake and he silently lowers his arm? There's a vulnerability there. He's not just a star — he's a father raising two kids alone, and the text doesn't overexplain it, which makes it feel more real.
... Read More
The fox's eyes changing color is honestly one of the most elegant symbolic choices in this whole story. Pink when he's the empress's adorable pet—soft, harmless, decorative. Scarlet when he becomes overwhelmingly powerful—blood-red, dangerous, literally weaponized. The author doesn't need to explain what this means. We just KNOW. And then there's the costume. The little male fox gets every flashy outfit while the actual EM perors can't afford dragon robes. This isn't just production comedy—it's commentary on who holds power in this story. The empress may sit on the throne, but the fox commands every gaze in the room. His clothing is armor, is performance, is a language all its own. The fake peach blossoms another layer of meaning here. They're sprayed with water to look vibrant on camera, just like Lu Xi's performance—constructed, artificial, designed to fool the lens. But beneath the plastic petals and painted stems, something real and ancient and jealous is watching. The artificiality of the set mirrors the artificiality of the role Lu Xi is playing, while Xie Zhuhan's magic represents the raw, unfiltered truth cutting through the fabrication. "Born with it." Succubus genes. Lu Xi says this so casually about his flawless porcelain skin, as if his very existence isn't some kind of supernatural performance already. Everything in this story is layered—costume over skin, performance over feeling, fake trees over real magic. The question is: when the camera stops rolling, what's actually left?
... Read More
I keep coming back to the airport scene. The author describes Rhettsey stepping off that plane and suddenly the whole environment shifts — the autumn air is still hot, the hotel manager is sweating through his shirt despite the season, there's this tension in the terminal between the mundane business of travel and the sudden entrance of someone who operates on an entirely different frequency. 'A group of tall Caucasian men in formal suits walked through the terminal, led by a playboy-looking figure with golden hair, blue eyes, and a muscular build, drawing stares from everyone around them.' This is such a cinematic moment. You can SEE this. The contrast between the desperate, scrambling hotel staff trying to make a good impression and Rhettsey barely registering any of it — he doesn't even accept the flowers. His bodyguard blocks the bouquet like it's a threat. And his first words in this entire country aren't about business. They're about finding someone. 'So this is the country Lucy ran back to.' The word 'ran' is doing so much work there. It implies escape, urgency, a story behind the story. And then the hotel manager's complete confusion — 'Who's Lucy? Some girl?' — adds this layer of dramatic irony where the reader is sitting there going YES IT'S LU XI WHILE EVERYONE ELSE IS SCRAMBLING THROUGH GOOGLE IMAGES OF D-LIST INFLUENCERS. The setting itself feels alive in a way that's not just decorative — the declining stock prices of Huating Hotel mirror Lu Xi's own decline in public standing. Two falling empires in different worlds, converging on the same floor of the same building.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or