The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the moment Jian Huai says nothing. Not silence—the wordless pause before he speaks, the way his gaze lingers on Lu Xi in the elevator, the way he forces himself to look away. That sequence is approximately eight lines of prose and it contains more emotional content than half the romance novels I've read this year. But the line that actually wrecked me was: "…He wouldn't have kids with someone else." Read it again. Think about what that means. Jian Huai has been watching Lu Xi fall from grace for four years. He's the award-winning actor, the successful one, the one everyone respects. And his first thought upon hearing a rumor about Lu Xi's personal life isn't jealousy or schadenfreude—it's a protective certainty that this other person cannot possibly be real. That Lu Xi loves someone too much to have moved on. That the emotional territory between them remains unchanged despite everything. And Lu Xi's version of emotional vulnerability? He says "we shared a bed once" like it's nothing. Like it's casual history. Like mentioning that four years ago they slept in the same space doesn't carry the weight of a thousand unsaid things. Pete's horrified "wait, shared a bed or shared a dorm???" is the audience surrogate reacting to what the reader already understood. The most tender moment in this entire chapter though? The twins walking out of kindergarten. Doubao puffing his chest saying "Dougao's my didi" and Dougao's cool face softening just for his brother, saying "Gege." Two children who chose this life, who call their father their mommy, who exist in a world that will eventually ask questions they don't deserve to answer. Lu Xi scooping them up and swiping his card—this is love without an audience. This is the emotional core the entire story orbits around. I'm not okay.
... Read More
"Our past relationship was a joke." Lu Xi says this line with a sneer and I am NOT OK. Like, I understand why he's saying it—he has every reason to be bitter, he has two kids, he moved on, Xie Zhuhan showed up out of nowhere asking about the mother like he has any right—but the way it HITS. He's basically closing the door in Xie Zhuhan's face and honestly? I get it. But then Xie Zhuhan's internal monologue about picturing 'the actress nestled in the young man's arms' and 'how he had fathered children with another woman while they were together' and feeling that surge of anger in his chest... that's not just jealousy, that's GRIEF. He's grieving a life he wasn't part of. And the cruelest part is Lu Xi probably knows exactly what he's doing. He says 'Or maybe you just fell in love with me as a substitute?'—throwing that right back at him. It's like he's dissecting their entire history in one sentence. I came for the romance and I'm leaving with emotional damage.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about Jian Huai for a second because this character is quietly the most interesting person in the entire novel and I need everyone to recognize it. He hears three people badmouthing Lu Xi and his response is immediate and cold. No hesitation. No checking if he should intervene. Just walks in and shuts them down with a single sentence. But here's what got me—the internal narration right after: "…He wouldn't have kids with someone else." That is NOT the thought of someone who has moving on. That is the thought of someone who is deeply, thoroughly tangled up in feelings he has never addressed out loud. And the flashback to their debut days? Four years ago, everyone wanted to attach themselves to Lu Xi. Being near him meant buzz, meant CP fans, meant popularity. Jian Huai barely scraped through. He was ninth. They were in the same batch, same starting line, and now—award-winning actor versus a guy getting a rookie contract. The narrative keeps coming back to this imbalance, but I don't think the author is framing it as simple jealousy. I think Jian Huai's entire arc is about watching the person he cared about most become someone he can't reach, while the world celebrates Jian Huai for qualities Lu Xi used to have. Lu Xi's reaction to Pete's questions is also telling. When Pete asks about Jian Huai's body—yes, actually his body, Lu Xi is that exasperated—he deflects with the sharpest line in the chapter: "If you're so curious about Jian Huai's body, go ask him yourself." Is that defensive? Is that genuine irritation? Or is it a joke that contains a grain of truth Lu Xi isn't ready to admit to himself? Their dynamic is a loaded gun pointed at the reader's chest and nobody's pulling the trigger yet.
... Read More
There are two images in this passage that I can't stop thinking about, and I think they're doing more thematic work than most novels dedicate entire chapters to. The first is Doubao's whale plush backpack. A whale. The largest creature in the ocean, carried on the back of a three-year-old who is already worried about protecting his brother. There's something about that image that feels almost symbolic—an enormous, gentle creature reduced to a child's accessory, the way Lu Xi himself might feel: a once-dominant force in the entertainment industry now being measured against metrics that seem to shrink him. The second is Pete's internal warning about the snowball effect: "Take one bad role, and the rest would only get worse." This is the central anxiety of the passage made explicit. The entertainment industry operates on momentum, and Lu Xi has lost his. Four years of absence means he's not just behind—he's actively falling. Every wrong decision compounds. Every compromise makes the next compromise easier. But here's what I think the passage is really saying: Lu Xi has already refused the easy path. He walked out of that conference room with a D-tier offer on the table and chose nothing instead. That's not recklessness—that's the opposite. It's someone who understands the snowball and has decided to step off the hill entirely. The theme that keeps echoing through these chapters is about what we owe ourselves versus what we owe other people's expectations. Lu Xi is a father. He's an idol returning to work. He's a man who disappeared for four years and now has to answer for it. But mostly, he seems to be someone who has learned—perhaps painfully—that the only contract worth signing is the one you write yourself.
... Read More
"Xie Zhuhan, I love you so much." "Lu Xi will always love Xie Zhuhan." I am NOT okay. I repeated these lines five times. Five. The birthday scene hits different because we KNOW what comes next. We've already seen him in that peach blossom forest, leaning over another woman, those same starry eyes full of tender affection directed at someone else. And then Xie Zhuhan—yes, THE Demon King, yes, the one who just toppled a fake tree with magic out of jealousy—stands behind him and hears EVERY SINGLE WORD. This is the kind of betrayal that doesn't need dramatic confrontation. It's quiet. It's Xie Zhuhan hearing his own name spoken with absolute devotion, knowing that devotion no longer belongs to him. The fireworks are roaring, the young man is wrapped up in his moment, completely unaware that the person he's declaring his love to is standing right there in the shadows. And then we cut to the present—the peach blossom forest scene where the little male fox is playing the part of the pampered consort, all flushed cheeks and sultry whispers, while Xie Zhuhan watches from somewhere beyond the frame. That gaze that grows more intense? That's not a actor losing focus. That's someone watching the person who chose someone else, performing love for another woman, and having absolutely no power to stop it except by breaking a fake tree. The butler's sigh says it all. "The Master has used his magic again. Just to topple a fake tree." What a devastatingly petty act of grief.
... Read More
I need to talk about the author's interjection because this is peak comedic timing and I am not okay. After Xie Zhuhan orders the supertopic taken down, the narration pauses and gives us this little dramatic beat where even the butler thinks, "Isn't that a bit childish?" And then the author just—leans into it. Full commit. We get this format that looks like a script comparison: Other overbearing CEOs: If you touch my Xixi, I'll eliminate you completely and make sure you have no fans left in the entertainment industry! 逼King: Take down the super topic. What perfect family of four?! The 逼King reference is doing so much work here. It's self-aware meta humor that basically winks at the reader and says: yes we know this is petty, yes we know this isn't what a domineering CEO would normally do, and yes that's exactly why it's perfect. And then immediately after, the author drops the narrator's voice again with Xie Zhuhan's internal monologue presented as a status update: Current mindset of our gong: I'm not in love with Lu Xi. I'm just checking how he's doing. [Secretly stalking all of Xixi's updates] The bracketed text is the kill shot. The denial followed immediately by the admitting everything is so cartoonish and so accurate to the genre's romantic lead archetype that I laughed out loud. But then Zhu Li's dialogue shifts everything. After pages of internet commentary and sarcastic authorial asides, she finally SPEAKS and it's: "I'VE HAD ENOUGH! Are you bullying my baby just because he has no one backing him?!" Fuck t The sentence cuts off mid-curse. Not even the author finishes her line. She's so furious she can't even type it properly. That's not a stylistic choice — that's the character breaking through the narration entirely. Her voice is so raw, so immediate, that it disrupts the formatted structure of the scene itself. Every character here has a completely distinct vocal register. Xie Zhuhan speaks in commands. Zhu Li speaks in explosions. The fans speak in fragmented social media posts. The author narrates with sarcastic footnotes. It's chaotic and messy and absolutely perfect.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the ghost subplot because honestly the way this chapter handles the supernatural element is kind of brilliant. Lu Xi genuinely believes there's a lecherous ghost watching him in the hot spring. He's scared, he texts his brother in panic, and he pulls the kids under the covers like it's some horror movie. Meanwhile, readers are sitting there like... bestie, that's literally Jian Huai looking at him. The cold feeling returning when Lu Xi is in his bathrobe, the gaze following his neck and collarbone, the dry throat needing water, the deliberate excuse to leave the room when Dahl mentioned needing help. Every single "ghostly" symptom is just Jian Huai trying really hard to play it cool and failing spectacularly. The structure here is doing double duty — on the surface it's a fluffy slice-of-life visit with birthday preparations and barbecues, but underneath there's this whole layer of unspoken tension and comedic misdirection. The author keeps the ghost suspense alive for Lu Xi while letting readers in on the joke. And then the chapter ends on this amazing cliffhanger where Lu Xi messages his brother about being targeted by a lecherous ghost, and his brother calls about someone named Cecil, and Lu Xi accidentally interrupts something personal. The chapter doesn't resolve anything — it just layers one awkward situation on top of another. That's good pacing, honestly. It keeps you wanting to turn the page without giving away the romantic payoff.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about Jian Huai for a second because WOW. This man has been silently pining for Lu Xi since Stage 100 five years ago and he just casually drops that he contacted CatTV BEHIND HIS AGENT'S BACK just to get Lu Xi on the same show. Wang Qing's reaction is literally EVERYONE. She went from furious to immediately recalibrating her entire understanding of reality in about three seconds flat. "You took this show for Lu Xi?" and Jian Huai doesn't even deny it! He just sits there like a man who has absolutely nothing left to lose because he already figured out what matters. And the agent conversation is so good because Wang Qing is not a stereotypical dramatic woman — the text specifically says she looks down on woman's intuition, and yet SHE'S the one who nails it first. "Jian Huai likes Lu Xi? Since when—" "Since Stage 100 started?" Five years, Wang Qing. FIVE YEARS of this man holding onto feelings while being the most professional actor on the circuit. The fact that he'd turn down Director Zhang's film over this just shows how serious he is, but also how quietly he's been operating. He doesn't want Lu Xi to know, doesn't want to bother him about it — he's building something behind the scenes and trusting the timing will work out. The ending thought though... "Lu Xi barely knew him. But with the thought that they'd be on the same show soon, those precious memories buried deep in his heart began to shimmer with light." That line broke me. It's so vulnerable for a character who projects this cool, composed exterior. What memories exactly? What happened between them five years ago that he's been carrying around? I need to know SO bad right now.
... Read More
Okay so this opening just absolutely wrecked me in the funniest way possible. Let me set the scene: Lu Xi comes back to China after four years abroad, and honestly? The moment when he spots fans waiting for him and his entire energy shifts is EVERYTHING. He transitions from 'playful dad mode' to 'dignified celebrity mode' so fast. Raises his hand like a lucky cat, does a little wave, feels the warmth of being seen again — and then the camera pans to the banner behind him: 'Only Love Zhao Yu.' The fans weren't cheering for HIM. Four years and love had already faded. This single beat does SO much work. It establishes that Lu Xi was once at the top, that he left for a reason, that there's a successor taking his place, and it immediately makes me want to know what happened. Plus the twin boys riding on luggage — cute subplot material right out of the gate. And Zhu Li dropping 'Lu Xi is back' in her gossip group like a landmine? Yeah, the narrative is setting up a whole mystery about his past. I'm already invested.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage does such careful work of character revelation through what's left unsaid. Doubao's whine about the mean person who won't show up carries the weight of adult disappointments compressed into toddler syntax. When he says the person is mad at them, we understand the entire emotional landscape of childhood rejection. Lu Xi's rapid-fire responses—offering chocolate, proposing online orders, suggesting Belgian sourcing—reveal a father who speaks through solutions because he fears silence might amplify his powerlessness. The director's instructions to the actor create another register of voice entirely. Phrases like treat him like you love him to death carry theatrical precision that contrasts with the domestic simplicity of the father-son exchanges. Yet both registers serve the same function: revealing how characters navigate emotional proximity through speech. Even the narration adopts multiple tones—sometimes observational, sometimes ironic, occasionally tender—which prevents the voices from becoming monotonous. The author understands that dialogue isn't just about what people say; it's about the rhythm of their thought processes made audible.
... Read More
Let me just say this outright: the scene where Rhettsey cuts off Lu Xi's car and rolls down his window is one of the most tension-packed three paragraphs I've read in recent memory. On paper, it's a simple confrontation—a wealthy antagonist blocking the protagonist's path and making a demand. But the author stacks every element to make you feel trapped alongside Lu Xi. Rhettsey's smile hasn't changed. He's still wearing those sunglasses. He's still calling him 'baby' and 'sweetheart' like this is some bizarre romantic gesture rather than economic coercion. 'You're having dinner with me tonight. Free of charge.' That shift from transactional to mandatory is chilling precisely because it happens so casually. There's no villain monologue, no dramatic music—just a man who realizes politeness isn't working and switches tactics. What makes the stakes feel genuinely high is that Lu Xi isn't alone in this moment. He has his kids to drop off, Dahl beside him, and we've just spent time understanding that Rhettsey's endgame is to dismantle Huating 'flesh sucked dry.' This isn't a personal feud; it's corporate predation dressed in charm. And then there's the deeper layer—the tension between Lu Xi and his own nature. He's a succubus in a world that doesn't recognize one, raising twins, trying to maintain some semblance of normalcy, and everywhere he turns, people are trying to use him or control him. TheRhettsey standoff, Dahl's presence, the unresolved mystery of his origins—all of these threads are converging toward something, and the author is brilliant at making you feel the pressure building without ever showing the clock ticking. The suspense isn't in knowing what happens next; it's in watching Lu Xi navigate an environment where every relationship is laced with hidden power plays.
... Read More
I have to appreciate how natural the dialogue sounds here. So many web novels treat conversation like a vehicle for exposition, but this author lets characters actually sound like humans who have history with each other. Pete's voice is distinct and consistent throughout—he's the comic relief but he's also the emotional barometer. Watch how he goes from teasing to genuinely worried in the same paragraph: "You're still the same Lu Xi. The way you talked back to Executive Xu earlier scared me speechless. That wasn't like you." That's not filler dialogue. That's a friend who knows his boy and is quietly concerned. And Lu Xi's response is perfect—cocky, self-aware, slightly deflected: "Does my face give you confidence that I'll make a comeback? Just say what you want. I'm handsome, I know." He doesn't directly answer the concern. He covers it with humor. That's how people actually talk when they're uncomfortable. The contrast between Lu Xi's loud confidence and Jian Huai's near-silence is remarkable. Jian Huai has maybe five lines in this entire chapter and each one lands. "Nothing." "No." "…He wouldn't have kids with someone else." The author trusts the reader to fill in the blanks, which is a bold choice. Even the gossipers have a distinct collective voice—they're not just plot devices, they're a Greek chorus of workplace toxicity. "Worlds apart; one up, one down." "What does he think, that he's Jian Huai now?" Their dialogue does double duty: it advances the social stakes while also reinforcing the central theme of fortune reversals. Pete's obsession with Jian Huai's abs also made me laugh out loud. It's the kind of random, specific humor that only emerges when you've written characters who've known each other for years. "His first drama as a movie star was a costume series, right? There's a bath scene, wet and shirtless, wow." This is genuine friend energy.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or