The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"What the heck. Don't say weird things like that. Lao Jian and I have a pure, brotherly bond! I have kids now. Stop making wild assumptions!" This is Lu Xi's internal voice and I am OBSESSED. It's chaotic. It's defensive. It's the mental equivalent of someone waving their arms frantically while saying absolutely nothing useful. The way he pivots from "what is this trending topic" to "does Lao Jian like me?!" to "thank god he doesn't" to panic about rejection — it's a full emotional rollercoaster in four sentences and I lived for it. And then he credits it all to his "succubus constitution." Of course he does. The man's ego is his armor and I respect it. The external dialogue is equally sharp. Jian Huai's call is all clipped professionalism — "Handle what?" "Oh, okay. Got it." — but the subtext is screaming. He's terrified. He can't say it outright but every short sentence is someone holding their breath. The grandma's dialogue is perfectly calibrated — "Goodness! Don't be sad. Let's not talk about it." So warmly inadequate. She has no idea she's standing next to a man who just casually mentioned his partner's horrific death like it's weather. And the kids! "Wah!!! I love you, Daddy!" vs Dougao's complete silence. Two different personalities in two different lines. The author doesn't need paragraphs — one exclamation and one ellipsis and you know these children like real ones. The narration itself has this voice too — that first line, "his Zen bullshit, fuck this peaceful retirement crap!" — that's not a character speaking, that's the NARRATOR's attitude bleeding through. It sets the tone for everything: this story is not taking itself seriously, but it's also not afraid to get messy. My favorite exchange though has to be: "By the way, what are you performing today?" "Something super cute. I'm dancing." "Then I'll have to see it. Your daddy's an amazing dancer." Simple. Warm. No subtext (or so we think). But coming right after the Jian Huai video incident, that line lands differently. Is he just being a supportive friend? Or is there something else in the way he says "I'll have to see it?"
... Read More
On the surface, this is a scene about acting and judgment. But read between the lines and there's something richer going on — a critique of power, privilege, and who gets to decide what art is worth. Zhao Ziyang represents an entire class of people who entered the entertainment industry not through talent or craft but through wealth and connections. "He came from a wealthy family, a typical spoiled rich kid who entered the entertainment industry as a director for fun." The text makes this crystal clear. His criticism of Lu Xi isn't genuine artistic feedback — it's the entitlement of someone who has never had to prove himself, projecting his own insecurity onto a person who actually earned his place. Lu Xi, meanwhile, carries the history of being used. The flashback to when Zhao Ziyang said "he's too immature to carry the deeper themes" reveals that this isn't the first time he's been dismissed by someone who saw him as a tool rather than an artist. The scene becomes about reclamation — Lu Xi reclaiming his agency on a public stage, using the very platform Zhao Ziyang thought he controlled. There's also the symbolism of the acting itself. Ning Gan, the character Lu Xi portrays, maintains "a perfect facade" while hiding something monstrous underneath. This mirrors Lu Xi's own position — everyone sees the idol, the pretty face, and they don't see the intelligence and strategic thinking beneath. The performance within the story becomes a metaphor for the performance of identity in the entertainment industry. And the audience? Zhu Li watching and laughing? She represents the readers — people who see through the pretense and cheer when the truth comes out.
... Read More
On the surface this chapter is adorable father-child content and a minor career negotiation. But dig a little deeper and there are SO MANY layers of conflict and stakes that most readers might miss if they're just here for the cute kids. Jian Huai's external conflict is straightforward — his contract is almost up, he's about to part ways with his agent, and he's making a career-defining choice (turning down Director Zhang's film) based on personal feelings. But the INTERNAL conflict is where it gets interesting. He's a man who has spent five years hiding his feelings, who operates behind the scenes rather than confronting directly. He wants Lu Xi on the show but "doesn't want him to know" — he's orchestrating something intimate without Lu Xi's consent, which raises uncomfortable questions about control and honesty in relationships. Lu Xi's conflict is more subtle but equally real. He's navigating life as a single father (the text heavily implies this without stating it outright — "others don't understand that Daddy is also Mommy"). He's dealing with societal judgment, his children asking innocent questions that reveal he has to explain complex identity things to toddlers, and probably exhaustion from doing it all alone. The ice cream scene is him seizing small moments of joy because that's what survival looks like. The highest stakes moment is actually the simplest: Dougao saying "Love Daddy the most" while too tired to keep his cool persona up. In that moment, we see what Lu Xi is fighting for — not fame, not career success, but these children who love him fiercely. And for Jian Huai, that's presumably what makes Lu Xi worth waiting five years for. The children are both the stakes and the prize. And then there's the unspoken question hanging over everything: will Lu Xi ever find out? Jian Huai is building a bridge while Lu Xi is walking across it blind. That dramatic irony is going to hurt so good.
... Read More
So Rhettsey walks in looking like the most insufferable golden retriever of a playboy imaginable—flashing smiles, driving convertibles, shouting sweet nothings from a car window—and Lu Xi immediately clocks it. This is the part where I had to stop reading and just stare at my phone because the author just flipped the entire script under our feet. Remember how the manager literally told Lu Xi that the president's strategy was 'if you can't persuade him, just throw money at him'? That is not a subtle setup. That is the author winking at us while handing us a note that says 'something is off here.' And then Lu Xi drops this absolutely devastating line: 'He's playing you all for fools. Huating will be stripped to the bone, its flesh sucked dry by him.' Chills. Actual chills. Because everything about Rhettsey's presentation—the theatrics, the flirtation, the theatrical 'fifty million' bid—it's armor. He's weaponizing his own ridiculousness as a camouflage strategy, and the fact that Lu Xi sees through it immediately tells us something crucial about who this character actually is. He's not just a rich hot mess; he's operating three steps ahead while everyone else is busy being distracted by his outfit. Meanwhile, the subplot with the twins and the bubble bath scene is doing incredibly heavy lifting in the background—just domestic normalcy, wholesome dad energy—before the narrative slams back into corporate warfare territory. That whiplash is intentional. It makes the stakes feel real because we've seen what Rhettsey is threatening to destroy.
... Read More
The author really knows how to use vertical space in this scene. Think about it—you've got Jian Huai and Lu Xi on the second-floor balcony, right there in that evening breeze, all intimate and soft and private. Then you cut to Xie Zhuhan standing in the middle of the yard below, looking up. The architecture itself becomes emotional geography. The higher ground belongs to the present; the lower courtyard is where the past can only watch from a distance. “The evening breeze blew gently.” That's such a simple line but it sets the whole tone before anything heavy happens. The scene starts domestic—kids asleep upstairs, cake eaten, normal evening stuff—and then pivots into something charged. Even the hallway encounter feels right: Lu Xi “startled”, wondering if Jian Huai has something urgent to discuss. The mundane details make the emotional bomb land harder. And then the courtyard confrontation. “Lu Xi stood in the courtyard on the first floor, with Jian Huai and Dahl on his left and right. Opposite him stood Xie Zhuhan alone.” Do you see how the staging works here? Three versus one. The composition literally shows the power shift. Xie Zhuhan used to have Lu Xi cornered emotionally, but now there are witnesses, there's protection, there's community. Even Dahl's internal narration—“This person is very strong”—adds tension without slowing the scene down. The transition from warm domesticity (bedtime, cake, sleepy kids) to cold confrontation is jarring in the best way. You don't get a smooth fade; you get knocked sideways. And I love that the author lets silence do the work. “No one spoke.” Four words, and you can feel the weight pressing down on everyone.
... Read More
Let me just say—the scene with Dahl's unbuttoned shirt was not just funny, it was worldbuilding. In three sentences, we understand the entire domestic ecosystem of Lu Xi's life. There's a man who loves to dress as a butler at home, two children named Doubao and Dougao (milk money invested in a web drama!), and a space where Jian Huai can visit and immediately feel out of place because he's seeing an intimacy he wasn't invited to. The elevator moment when Jian Huai steps out and gets 'Welcome, guest' from Dahl's pecs? That's visual storytelling at its most economical. You don't need a paragraph explaining their relationship dynamic when you can just show us the exposed chest and the practiced smile. The hot pot setting itself is perfect too—communal, warm, steamy, the kind of meal where conversation flows and boundaries blur. Chinese web dramas love their hot pot scenes for a reason, and this one earns every bit of it. But here's what really gets me—the dormitory rooftop. 'On the rooftop of the dormitory building, right?' This one line builds an entire world. We're talking about a competition setting, a shared living space, a rooftop where someone practiced dancing in private. It's nostalgic, it's specific, and it transforms from simple set dressing into emotional architecture. The fact that Lu Xi remembers this but not the rankings or the elimination rounds? That tells us everything about what kind of moments stick with us versus what we perform for. The author's note describing the 'Building Chief Xi's harem' with numbered rankings feels almost like casting calls—dry, administrative, ridiculous. But it contrasts beautifully with the actual lived spaces: the hot pot restaurant, the apartment with the butler uniform, the rooftop practice space. We get both the formal and the intimate, the ranked and the random, and somehow they coexist. That's worldbuilding that trusts the reader to hold complexity.
... Read More
"The first time he liked someone was so simple, sincere and passionate. A young man offering his earnest heart. The watch had many tiny diamonds, sparkling like the Milky Way, like a sky full of brilliant stars. He just wanted to give it to someone he loved." This passage absolutely wrecked me. Think about it from Lu Xi's perspective — eighteen years old, just starting to figure out who he is, and the first person he gives his whole heart to, he spends everything he has on a single gift. Eighty thousand yuan, every last bit of savings after years of working endorsements and magazine shoots just to pay back his adoptive parents. He didn't buy this watch to show off. He bought it because diamonds sparkle like stars and the person he loved deserved something that beautiful. And what did the world do with that gesture? They turned it into proof that he was a kept man. That he was shallow. That he was trash. The cruelty of this isn't just in the external attacks — it's in how the narrative frames his vulnerability as something to be weaponized against him. "Loving openly, without reservation, without regret. Yet it became irrefutable proof to attack Lu Xi." That contrast is devastating. He did nothing wrong. He loved honestly. And the world punished him for it.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the facial mask scene. On the surface it's just a funny dad-story—twins as babies, one cried so hard his face left a mask-shaped print on the other's pajamas. Classic sibling chaos, Daddy Lu making jokes about it. But reading it again, it hits different. Lu Xi was in London studying film at night while his brother took care of the twins. He came home past 9 PM to find them asleep, and the only thing he did was... scroll on his phone. "Ever since that facial mask crying incident, Lu Xi's nightlife consisted of tucking in the kids and scrolling on his phone. He, the father, was great!" That sarcastic "was great!" is doing SO much work. It's self-aware guilt wrapped in humor. This is a man who chose his children over his career, who disappeared from the industry entirely, who's now trying to rebuild himself on a competition show while being a single dad. The facial mask isn't just a funny anecdote—it's the artifact of a moment where everything in his life shifted. Two little dumplings. One year and two months old. And now they're old enough to go to kindergarten. Time is the real villain in this story, not any rival or rumor.
... Read More
Okay can we just take a moment to appreciate the sheer emotional satisfaction of watching Zhao Ziyang get dismantled? Like, I went into this scene expecting it to be tense and it IS tense — but the emotional payoff is SO much more interesting. You have Lu Xi on stage, about to be crushed by a powerful director who used him before, and he just... smiles. Six pearly white teeth. And then he delivers that line: "Giving me a D makes sense. I totally understand." The AUDACITY. The CALM. My heart was RACING. What struck me most wasn't even the conflict itself — it was the complete absence of any visible fear from Lu Xi. He knew exactly what he was doing. This isn't some innocent idol getting bullied; this is a man who knows his worth and has been waiting for the right moment to flip the script. And that moment? It came wrapped in a polite smile and a reference to Zhao Ziyang's garbage film Sea Girl. I also loved the subplot with Zhu Li in the audience. She was literally "ready to roll up her sleeves" but then burst out laughing instead. Her perspective as a viewer gives the whole thing this extra layer — she's watching us watch him destroy someone. There's a warmth there, a sense of shared excitement between characters that makes the scene feel alive rather than just dramatic. The author really understands how to make readers feel like they're IN the room experiencing this alongside everyone else. And honestly? I was cackling the entire time.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about the emotional whiplash in this chapter. On the surface, it's all laughter and hot springs and kids playing robot competitions. But underneath? There's this aching longing that pulls at you every time the narrative lingers on Lu Xi. Four years. Four years since he left, and they're finally together again. But the text keeps circling back to what WASN'T said. The drunk-kissing flashback is pure gold and pure tragedy. Zhang Zihan tried to capture it on video. The phone crashed. All the photos gone. Was it fate? Or just bad luck? But here's what hurts: Lu Xi doesn't remember. He's asking ‘Who did I kiss?' And everyone's like ‘You hugged me and Jian Huai!' But he doesn't recall. That gap between memory and reality—it's devastating. Because what if he DID remember? What if he knew who he reached for in his drunken state and chose to forget? Then there's the Xie Zhuhan detail. ‘Didn't Xie Zhuhan not come?' The narration drops this like a stone in still water. Xie Zhuhan wasn't there for the victory celebration. But his face appeared in Lu Xi's deepest memory. Why? Is Xie Zhuhan the ghost haunting this reunion? The one who got away? The one Lu Xi left WITH? The emotional core of this scene isn't the BBQ or the kids. It's the way Lu Xi's mind drifts ‘back to the victory celebration after the group's very first concert.” Confetti. Screams. Adrenaline. Alcohol. And then—Xie Zhuhan's face. Not the others. Not Dahl. Not even Jian Huai. Xie Zhuhan. That's the emotional landmine buried under all this warmth. And the ending? Lu Xi can't sleep. He showers, gets in bed, smells like alcohol, and stares at Doubao and Dougao sleeping peacefully. Then his mind goes back to that first concert. He had ‘a terrible headache and drifted off to sleep in a daze.” That's not just tiredness. That's emotional exhaustion. He's been holding this together for four years—being the captain, the leader, the one everyone leans on—and now that they're reunited, he's crumbling. Just slightly. Just enough for the reader to notice. I love how the author layers joy over sorrow. Every laugh is tainted by what was lost. Every toast carries the weight of four years apart. And that drunken memory? It's not just a funny anecdote. It's a window into Lu Xi's subconscious—the one place where he can't hide who he really wants.
... Read More
This batch does something I honestly didn't expect — it weaponizes tonal whiplash and makes it work. Chapter opens with domestic warmth (uncle's friend backstory, polite behavior between good friends), drops into Jian Huai's jealous internal spiral, then pivots to the most absurd bedroom scene in recent literary history, then lands on the author's own meta confession that the serious story devolved into crack. That structural choice — including the author note WITHIN the chapter flow — is brave. Most authors would bury that in an afterword. Here it's part of the rhythm. The pacing within the Dahl-Lu Xi bedroom scene is also carefully calibrated. Setup (Dahl in bed) → escalation (naked reveal with full physical specifications) → false resolution (put on pajamas) → internal collapse (Lu Xi admitting he's already been dragged into the pit). Each beat lands because the previous one escalates just enough. The joke gets bigger but the emotional truth underneath gets clearer with each layer. The two-day breakfast montage following the intense Jian Huai departure is a masterclass in breath control. After that emotional peak, we needed space to exhale. Instead of another confrontation or plot development, we get wontons and milk buns. And somehow that's more moving than any dramatic scene could have been. My only complaint: the batch ends mid-sentence with "You're already doing a grea" — the truncation is either a formatting error or the most cruel cliffhanger I've ever encountered. Either way, I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how emotionally devastating (in the best way) this section was? 「I love you so much, Xie Zhuhan.」 That's it. That's the whole line. But coming right after that flashback where 18-year-old Lu Xi—with mint green hair and stage makeup still on—bars his way into Xie Zhuhan's study and essentially says 'I want to do it right here,' the weight of it hits differently. Five years later, that line echoes through everything. Xie Zhuhan's internal monologue when he hears about the twins: 'Lu Xi loved him too much, so there was no way he would've had children with anyone else.' BRO. That man is still hung up on his first love five years later and he won't even admit it out loud. The fact that he says this with 'absolute confidence' tells me everything I need to know about how deeply this relationship affected him. And then there's Lu Xi with his kids—this soft, domestic side I wasn't expecting. 'Daddy wants to carry Dougao.' His whole interaction with the twins is so tender and natural. Doubao is the chatty one, Dougao is quiet and observant, and the way they interact… Lu Xi's parenting style is just… chef's kiss. He's patient, affectionate, present. The bath scene with the rubber duck and toy train made me genuinely smile. But underneath all this warmth, there's this ache. Lu Xi vanished at his peak. He has these twins but we don't know who the father is. He's being attacked online. And Xie Zhuhan—who clearly still has feelings—is sitting in a manor five years later, remembering every word. These two men are orbiting each other and I am HERE for it. The CP chemistry between them is so thick I can taste it, even through text. It's not just physical—the memory of their intimacy is layered with genuine emotion, and now we're seeing the consequences of whatever drove them apart. My heart is breaking for both of them.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or