The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball - Reviews

The Substitute Succubus Returns with a Ball
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this scene because it is absolutely masterclass-level plotting disguised as a wholesome little shopping trip. On the surface, it's just Uncle Xie taking the twins to pick out watches — cute, right? Wrong. The author builds this entire power reveal through something so mundane. Twenty-three thousand yuan, right? Seems expensive to any normal person. Then Doubao pulls out a piggy bank, Dougao does the same, and we think — oh this is just cute rich kid behavior, probably thousands of dollars in cash. And then — crack — the black card falls out. THE BLACK CARD. A globally limited card with no spending limit in the hands of KINDERGARTENERS. The entire counter staff went silent. Even the previously boastful associate with big clients shut up. The way the author uses the sales staff's reactions as a measuring stick for just how extraordinary this wealth is... genius. But here's what really gets me — this isn't just showing off money. This plot move serves triple duty. It establishes Xie Zhuhan's power and status in the living world (which matters when you consider what he IS now), it shows the twins are genuinely cared for and well-provided for by "Uncle" (the father figure they have), and it creates this heartbreaking contrast — all this power, all this wealth, and Xie Zhuhan is already transitioning to a ghost who can only watch from the sidelines. The chapter ends with him becoming invisible to the person he's been circling around this whole arc. The structural pivot from material power to supernatural powerlessness in those last few pages is chef's kiss.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Xie Zhuhan because THIS MAN is something else. Let me rewind a bit — we see him first through the butler's confused eyes, right? Young Master Lu vanishes into thin air right before those four bodyguards corner him, and the butler is just standing there like "what the hell." Then later we get this gorgeous line: "Master. Another day without a tail or a butt." This guy is clearly obsessed with Lu Xi in the most devoted, almost comically loyal way possible, and I love it. But the real reveal of his character comes at the police station scene. He listens through the glass wall and hears Lu Xi say "gave me a girl's name, isolated me..." and the narration literally says his expression was indifferent, almost disinterested — BUT the butler knows better. He was angry. That gap between how Xie Zhuhan appears and what he's actually feeling? Chef's kiss. Then he just disappears and comes back with Rhettsey DEPORTED. Seven days. Full sentence. The Rhettsey family didn't even pay bail because apparently they realized they had made a severe miscalculation about who Lu Xi actually is. The line "Charlie Rhettsey – have him deported. He is never to set foot in China again. If he dares approach Lu Xi again, I'll handle it personally." — I literally gasped. This man doesn't play around when someone threatens his person. And what does Lu Xi get from all this? A soft "Mm" after a long silence when the butler asks if they should still look after Young Master Lu. After everything Xie Zhuhan just did for him? That one word says so much. It's not gratitude — it's something more complicated, more intimate.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author handles dialogue because it is genuinely one of the best things about this book. Let me start with Cecil's message to Lu Xi—'You're my only didi. It's nothing.' Just two sentences and the entire emotional architecture of their relationship crystallizes. No melodrama, no over-explaining, just this quiet, devastating acknowledgment that they are family by choice and that whatever Cecil does (including sending Dahl as a surprise houseguest), it comes from that place of protection. The voice here is so distinct from everything else in the text. Then cut to Dahl, who speaks in this completely different register—formal, reverent, almost archaic in his devotion. 'Master, I'll take care of it.' 'Master, please don't send me away.' Every sentence from Dahl carries the weight of a lifetime of conditioning, of being raised to believe his entire existence depends on his master's acceptance. And Lu Xi's internal monologue is this wildly different voice again—colloquial, sarcastic, deeply human. 'Ahhhhhhh, just kill me already!' This layering of voices isn't just stylistic flair; it's the book's primary tool for characterizing without exposition. You know exactly who these people are based on how they speak. And the comedy goldmine that is Lu Xi's reaction to Dahl calling him 'Master' while dressed in what I can only assume is an aggressively formal uniform—it's funny but there's also this undercurrent of genuine tenderness. Lu Xi could fire him. He could send him away. Instead he sighs and says 'Fine.' That's character development disguised as comedic relief, and I'm not okay with how good it is.
... Read More
This section is structured in this really satisfying three-act rhythm that made me want to read straight through. First beat: the domestic opening, slow and quiet, kids asleep, just Lu Xi and Old Daddy Lu decompressing. It's almost meditative. Then second beat: the phone notification explodes the scene wide open — missed calls, texts, the producer's invitation, and the quick research montage where Lu Xi discovers the full mentor lineup. The pacing here accelerates like someone's scrolling frantically through a search engine. Third beat: the chat group conversation, which expands the scope from Lu Xi's personal life into the wider fandom and industry ecosystem. Each section ends on a note that propels you forward — the Zhao Ziyang reveal, the producer's assumption that he'll be upset, the chat group's reaction to the casting news. The chapter transitions are smooth too. There's no awkward stopping point where you'd want to put the book down — each scene hands off to the next like a relay race. The author clearly understands that variety show narratives have a natural episodic rhythm, and they're using that structure to their advantage. By the time we hit the producer meeting at the end, the story has built enough momentum that the reader is already imagining what happens next.
... Read More
The dialogue in this piece operates on at least three frequency bands simultaneously, and I'm here for it. Let's start with the brainwashing scene: Pete's pitch about the role being 'thrilling' while Lu Xi is internally screaming? The contrast between external persuasion and internal resistance creates this hilarious dissonance that feels so true to how we talk to ourselves when others won't take no for an answer. But the real masterclass is in the Jian Huai scenes. Watch how the dialogue shifts register: formal politeness ('Congratulations. What's the project?') sliding into something that could be professional concern or something far more complicated ('I could visit the set'). Then the leap to 'Is your crew still hiring? I could play the second male lead' hits like a punchline that's also a love letter. The timing is impeccable. And Lu Xi's response—joking about pursuit, then immediately worrying about fan reaction and image? That's character revelation through deflection. He doesn't address the emotional subtext; he addresses the practical consequences. Classic Lu Xi. The line 'Captain Lu, Contestant 65 was your first teammate' though—how much just landed there? It's delivered as fact, but the weight of it carries years of history. Jian Huai remembering this detail while Lu Xi doesn't remember the rankings? That's dialogue doing the work of a hundred pages of exposition. And the follow-up, where Lu Xi pivots to 'I just remember that you practiced dancing very hard'? He doesn't have to say 'I noticed you when I should have been paying attention to my competition.' The subtext does the heavy lifting. Even the author's note at the end has voice—it's deadpan, listicle-format, absurdly clinical about romantic entanglements. It doesn't break tone; it extends it. The humor isn't separate from the romantic tension; it's the pressure valve keeping the whole thing from becoming unbearably precious.
... Read More
Okay so let me just — the Xie Zhuhan section had me SHOOK. Like, this man is physically PAINING. Heart palpitations, severe headaches, nearly losing control of his magical power. And it's all because Lu Xi left for Beijing. He says one word: "Where is he?" and his lips trace that name silently. Even uttering it causes faint thread-like pain. BRO. You're a literal demon king and you're reduced to a lovesick wreck over your husband's career trip?? And then the butler scene — "the old Demon King and the new Demon King. When the young Demon King defeated the old Demon King, he drove him out of his territory." This entire power dynamic is just layered ON TOP of the romance and I am HERE FOR IT. Xie Zhuhan detests his father, won't let anyone suggest involving him, and yet when he hears Lu Xi is auditioning, he immediately asks if Lu Xi likes it. Same pattern from four years ago — whatever the boy glances at, the master buys it. It's pathological at this point. Meanwhile Jian Huai is over there being the most wholesome neighbor ever. Building robots with Dougao, cooking extra food, sending portions upstairs, NEVER mentioning his feelings for Lu Xi again. He respects boundaries so hard it actually hurts. The contrast between these two men orbiting the same person — one who would destroy the world for them, one who wouldn't want to burden them — is absolutely delicious. And Doubao telling the class "I don't have a mommy, but I have two daddies!" That kid has more emotional maturity than half the adults in this novel. Xie Zhuhan appearing on the playground right after that line though — chef's kiss.
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about the piggy banks in this chapter that I can't stop thinking about. These two kindergarten kids — literally the age where you still drink milk and count your coins — are carrying enough cash AND a black card to buy luxury watches. What does that say? First layer: wealth as inheritance, as destiny. The twins didn't earn this; it was given to them by "Uncle." They're heirs before they can even read properly. Second layer, and this is what got me: the contrast between the physical piggy banks and the invisible card. The pig is tangible, breakable, childish. You smash it open to get to what's inside. The card is sleek, black, limitlessly powerful — but it came FROM the pig. All that hidden power was always stored inside something small and ordinary. Isn't that exactly what Xie Zhuhan's situation is? He's the black card — immense power, influence, resources — but it's trapped inside a form (a ghost's form) that the people he cares about can't even perceive. And Lu Xi... he's the one smashing open piggy banks with his words, accidentally breaking open truths he can't possibly understand. The ice cream treat is another symbol that stuck with me. Doubao insists on treating Xie Zhuhan to ice cream as thanks — a child's gesture of reciprocity, simple and pure. But Xie Zhuhan doesn't want ice cream. He wants something else entirely. The scene where he realizes "it wasn't about wanting ice cream. It was about wanting to see him" — that's the thematic core. Everything in this chapter is about the gap between what is offered and what is actually desired, between the visible and the invisible, between the living world's currency and the emotional economy that actually matters.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter is basically the calm before the storm and I CANNOT wait for what happens next. Let me break it down because the structure here is SO smart. On the surface it looks like a fluffy parent-child day scene at a kindergarten. Cute frogs, adorable twins, wholesome vibes. BUT — and this is where the author is GENUIS — we cut to Xie Zhuhan watching from the SECOND FLOOR. That juxtaposition is everything. We're laughing at the frog costume moment and then *bam*, 1.9 meters of pure ice and jealousy standing above it all. The plot thread I find most interesting is the butler's line: "Young Master Lu." This implies Lu Xi isn't just some regular person — he's got status, he's got FAMILY, and Xie Zhuhan clearly feels threatened by Jian Huai's presence in that family unit. The principal even says "Mr. Lu said Mr. Jian Huai is Doubao and Dougao's uncle" — so there's an official narrative being maintained here, and Xie Zhuhan is hearing it and SEETHING. The pacing of the reveal is masterful. We don't see Xie Zhuhan until halfway through the chapter. The author lets us feel the warmth of the scene first — the cheering kids, the social butterfly Doubao, the frog dance — and THEN drops the cold reality that someone is watching this with pure venom. That flicker of warmth in his eyes that gets extinguished when Lu Xi smiles at Jian Huai? Chilling. Actually chilling. And the cliffhanger element — Xie Zhuhan saying "Tomorrow. We're going to Fenglin Kindergarten" — means this isn't just a passing jealous moment. He's planning to CONFRONT something. The tension between his icy composure and the internal rage is what makes this subplot so gripping. Who is he really angry at? Jian Huai? Lu Xi? Or himself for not being there?
... Read More
Let me just say — the pacing in this batch is absolutely ruthless and I am here for it. The author takes you on a rollercoaster that goes from slapstick comedy to corporate scheming to domestic fluff to existential yearning, all in roughly ten thousand characters, and somehow NONE of it feels rushed or draggy. The opening scene with Lu Xi fleeing the Apple Class teacher is pure comedic relief — fast, punchy, ends on a joke. Then the ice cream shop stretches things out beautifully with sensory details (strawberry, sea salt, the generous mini cones, the adult joy of eating in front of your kids). The scene at the shop where the staff wonders if he's a celebrity is a nice touch — it adds a tiny layer of "this man is important" without being heavy-handed. Then WHOOSH — we cut to Jian Huai and Wang Qing and the entire tone shifts. The conversation is tighter, more contained, sitting on a couch with tea instead of running around a shop. The pacing slows down to let the emotional weight land. Five years. Stage 100. Turning down a film. These are big reveals that need breathing room, and the author gives them space by keeping the scene physically small and still. But then — BAM — we're back to domestic chaos with the bath scene. The tonal whiplash from Jian Huai's quiet yearning to three men splashing in bubble bath is jarring in the best way. It's like the author is saying "here's the romantic tension, now here's why Lu Xi is worth all of this." The bath scene is long and unhurried, letting us linger on each moment — the mirror posing, the water fight, the sleepy milk bottles. The structure essentially gives us three acts: comedy (ice cream), drama (Jian Huai's confession to his agent), and warmth (bath time). And the chapter ends on that fragment — "It smelled like" — which is either a transcription error or the most aggressive cliffhanger in recent memory. I need to know what it smelled like RIGHT NOW.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are layered in a way I really appreciate. On the surface, it's a celebrity comeback story—Lu Xi returns after four years and needs to rebuild his career. But the author immediately complicates that by making his return PUBLIC and SCANDALOUS. He didn't slip back in quietly; he arrived with twin children and the entire internet is losing its collective mind over it. What makes the conflict tense is that everyone already has opinions about him. Zhao Yu's manager sees Lu Xi as a threat and wants to deploy 'water armies' to control the narrative. The fans are split between curiosity and judgment. Pete literally tells him to change careers because the industry won't forgive him. None of these people are neutral. But the real stakes feeling come from the quiet moments. When Lu Xi calls Pete and gets rejected, then immediately gets called back because the trending numbers changed the calculation—that's a brutal commentary on how the entertainment machine works. People don't care about Lu Xi the human; they care about Lu Xi the product. And right now, the product is explosive news. There's also the internal conflict simmering underneath. He's a single father who disappeared for four years, came back with kids but no apparent plan, living off his brother's generosity while insisting he's here to work. That's a lot of pressure to absorb in one chapter, and the author handles it with light touches rather than heavy drama. The tension comes from anticipation—what happens when the public finds out more? Who is the mother? What exactly happened during those four years?
... Read More
Okay so this whole peach blossom forest scene is such a vibe and I need to talk about it. On paper it's supposed to be this cheesy on-set rom-com moment—fake trees, prop master spraying water, plastic petals everywhere—but the author somehow makes it feel alive, like you're actually there squinting under those counterfeit blossoms. The contrast between the gaudy, budget-conscious production and the way Lu Xi looks in that moon-white robe? Chef's kiss. "His beautiful lips were getting closer and closer to her." Like, the scene is building this tension, right? The camera is rolling, the female lead is blushing uncontrollably, everyone on set is holding their breath—and then BANG. The fake tree just collapses like it had a personal vendetta against romance. And the best part? It wasn't an accident. We get this little cutaway to the butler and the icy figure outside, and it's revealed that the master used magic just to topple a prop tree. A PROP TREE. The petulance of it! The wind stops, the petals freeze mid-air, and suddenly this whole sappy set piece turns into something way more ominous. The fake peach blossoms become this metaphor for the entire situation—surface-level beauty masking something far darker underneath. I also love the costume detail about the little male fox having the most outfit changes despite the empress and enemy emperor not even getting dragon robes. "Do you know how much it costs to hire all the civil and military officials?" This is such a grounded, funny touch that makes the whole production feel real. The author really commits to the bit of low-budget filmmaking colliding with supernatural drama.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc with Jian Huai wanting to confess but being TERRIFIED of messing up the friendship is giving me whiplash. Four YEARS. Four years of just... hovering? And he's over there like 'if I don't take this step, we'll forever remain good friends' which honestly is the most dramatic thing I've ever read. Meanwhile the birthday party subplot is doing SO MUCH heavy lifting. The twins sneaking off to find Uncle Xie? The secret shopping trip? It's like the author is threading three separate plotlines and I'm just sitting here trying to catch my breath. The pacing here is actually insane when you think about it — you've got the romantic tension simmering, the domestic bliss of party planning, and then BAM, Xie Zhuhan appears like a supervillain in a children's book. I love how the birthday becomes this focal point where all the major plot threads are converging. Also: same-sex marriage law was passed FIVE years ago?? The worldbuilding detail about legal recognition dropped casually in the middle of a shopping scene is chef's kiss.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or