The Best Scam - Reviews

The Best Scam
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about how incredible Xie Ge's text messages are. This man is clearly the type who says one mean thing in person but then spends hours crafting the perfect paragraph to send via WeChat. The contrast is hilarious and revealing. In person: 'I don't need it. I'm allergic to caffeine. Take it away.' Cold. Brutal. Done. On text: 'Wife, can't you grant me this tiny request out of pity for how unlucky I've been today? [Yearning][Yearning][Yearning]' Bro, you just told him he looks disgusting five minutes ago. Now you're sending puppy emojis and asking him to switch to vibrate mode. The whiplash is something else. And Xu Miao's responses are perfectly calibrated. Short. Measured. Not giving Xie Ge the satisfaction of knowing he's affected. 'I'll think about it.' That's it. That's the whole response. Meanwhile Xie Ge is over here emotionally exploding into seventeen messages. The narrative voice itself is really strong too—third person limited, mostly following Xie Ge but dipping into Xu Miao's perspective when it matters. The tone shifts seamlessly between comedic (the artificial lake metaphor) and genuinely heartbreaking (Xie Ge rolling around on his bed like an ant on a hot pan). The author knows exactly when to make you laugh and when to make you feel like you've swallowed a handful of thumbtacks.
... Read More
I need to talk about Liang Dong because honestly he deserves more screen time and I'm genuinely worried about him. This guy walks into the dorm, sees that everyone got a scarf from his mom, and immediately takes charge of the photo situation. He's practical, he's efficient, he wraps the scarf around Xu Miao's neck in 'a few swift motions.' But then—and this is the detail that wrecked me—he presses further. 'What kind of friend? Can't I even hear what you're saying? You're guarding against me that hard?' And when Xu Miao teases him back, Liang Dong is 'so annoyed he could grind his teeth.' He calls him 'heartless' under his breath and walks off. I keep coming back to this moment because it's so quietly devastating. Liang Dong is the only person in this dorm who seems to want something REAL from Xu Miao. Not money, not performances, not curated chat messages at 2 AM—but actual presence. And Xu Miao, for all his charm, literally cannot give it to him without breaking character. Meanwhile, Xie Ge is over there saying 'I already told you I'm made of glass' and 'I'll piece myself back together soon' while simultaneously asking for gifts and demanding priority status. The asymmetry is painful. One person is visibly fragile and performative in their vulnerability. The other is genuinely hurt and doesn't even have the vocabulary to name it. And Xu Miao—dear, manipulative Xu Miao—he notices ALL of it. He reads Liang Dong's shift in expression 'in the not very bright lighting.' He knows exactly what he's doing. The tragedy isn't just that Xie Ge is lying; it's that Xu Miao is surrounded by people who love him genuinely and he has no idea how to receive it.
... Read More
The stakes in this opening are so quiet but they're everywhere. Like, on paper nothing huge is happening—guys texting, one guy has a sick mom, another guy has a violent dad—but the tension is literally in every single message bubble. Because every time ATM says something affectionate, something vulnerable, something that sounds like real love... Xu Miao knows he's built it on a foundation of lies. That's not background conflict, that's the entire engine of this story. And what's crazy is that both guys are already bleeding. Xu Miao's family is drowning financially, his dad's leg is crushed, there's a new baby in the house eating up whatever income they have. He took up scamming because he genuinely had no other way to survive. But ATM—ATM's father hits him, mother drinks, brother gambles, younger brother's rebelling. This kid is living in a warzone at home and the only place he feels warm is in a conversation with someone he thinks is a girl. The internal conflict is where it really kills me though. Xu Miao thinks he's the predator here. He's the one with the voice changer and the strategy. But every message ATM sends chips away at that certainty. When ATM says "I'm made of glass" and "You should be taking care of me"—is he being dramatic? Or is he actually fragile? Does Xu Miao even know at this point? And that last line about winter: "in such a cold world, at least one of us should be warm." I chills. Actual chills. Because Xu Miao is the one who's supposed to be cold—the scammer, the liar—and yet he's the one trying to provide warmth. How long can this hold before someone finds out? How long before the guilt becomes unbearable? I need to know.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the author uses TWO completely different dialogue registers and makes them feel like entirely separate worlds? The chat messages are SHORT. Fragmented. Repetitive in a way that feels authentically anxious: 'Are you mad?' 'Don't be mad, okay?' 'I was just joking.' 'It's been thirty-five minutes. Are you really busy, or just ignoring me?' 'I'm gonna hold my breath until you reply.' 'Murderer.' This is not how a confident person texts. This is someone spiraling in real time, firing off messages, revising their tone with each attempt. The self-correction—from 'are you mad' to 'don't be mad' to 'I was just joking'—shows a person trying to walk back their own vulnerability. And the [holding_breath.jpg] is such a perfect Gen-Z move: packaging emotional distress into a meme format so it's palatable. Then the voice call hits and the language completely transforms. Xie Ge speaks in longer, more complex sentences. His vulnerability is still there but it's dressed differently—more performative, more dramatic. 'You don't treat me like you used to when we first met. Aren't we dating? Shouldn't I be your number one priority?' The shift from text to voice isn't just a change in medium—it's a change in Xie Ge's performance of himself. On text, he's raw. On voice, he's curated. And Xu Miao, the connoisseur of performances, notices every nuance. Liang Dong's dialogue is even more distinct—short, clipped, loaded with unsaid meaning. 'Heartless.' Two syllables that carry an entire emotional arc. The author gives each character a voice so distinct you could identify them blind.
... Read More
I need to process the symbolism in these chapters because the author is stacking metaphors like it's going out of style. Let's start with the scarf. Liang Dong's mom sends scarves for ALL four dormmates. But watch what Xu Miao does with HIS scarf: he takes the photo, crops out his face and most of his body, and sends it to Xie Ge. The scarf becomes a prop in the performance—a tangible object that proves 'I have a life, I have friends, I'm wearing something you sent me.' But the cropped photo? That's the edit. That's the curation. That's the version of himself he's selling. Meanwhile, the black-and-white checkered pattern—'a safe, classic choice'—mirrors how Xu Miao presents himself: neutral, undeniably stylish, impossible to fault. Nothing controversial. Nothing that might trigger rejection. Then there's the glass. Xie Ge says 'I'm made of glass' and means it as self-deprecating humor. But glass is also transparent—which is the opposite of everything Xu Miao is. Glass breaks when struck—which is exactly what happens to Xie Ge's carefully constructed reality. And glass can be melted and重新formed—which is what Xie Ge keeps doing, piecing himself back together after each disappointment. The deer metaphor is my favorite though: 'a little deer had leapt into Xu Miao's chest, his heart thudding wildly.' A deer—a prey animal, skittish, wild,untamable—trapped inside the chest of a man who has spent his life controlling every interaction. The imagery suggests something untamed stirring in someone who has built his entire existence on control and calculation. It's hope. It's fear. It's the moment the performative breaks through. And the cold wind at the beginning? It's not just weather. It's the emotional temperature of Xu Miao's real life—biting, isolating, making him yearn for the false warmth of the screen.
... Read More
Okay, this one message from Xie Ge destroyed me and I need to talk about it. 'The sun's shining up in the sky, but the ground is wet. At first, I didn't know why, but then I realized it's because I missed you so much I couldn't help crying. My tears fell and turned into the world's smallest existing artificial lake.' What is this level of pathetic and beautiful? This is a man who writes poetry about his loneliness and calls it 'a drought in one square meter' and I am OBSESSED. The fact that he tracks his emotional damage in terms of wet ground area is simultaneously the funniest and saddest thing I've ever read. And Xu Miao! Sweet, patient, coffee-buying Xu Miao who gets rejected repeatedly and still manages to be gentle. He notices everything about Xie Ge—even when Xie Ge lies about being allergic to caffeine, Xu Miao remembers the picture Xie Ge sent him last week. The man pays attention. That's the thing about real devotion, isn't it? It shows up in the details. The dinner date that never happens is killing me. Xie Ge sets up the perfect scene—facing the entrance, waiting for Xu Miao—and instead gets the person he dreads. Meanwhile Xu Miao is deliberately avoiding the restaurant because... why? Because seeing Xie Ge is too painful? That's the kind of emotional push-and-pull that makes my heart ache in the best way.
... Read More
Let's talk about the mask. Xie Ge wears it throughout this entire chapter while claiming he hasn't slept well, worried about looking worse. But Xu Miao already saw his face. The mask is purely symbolic at this point—it represents Xie Ge's fear of being truly seen, not just physically but existentially. If Xu Miao sees the real him, the real circumstances, the fact that this whole relationship started with deception, will he still want him? The mask is armor, but it's also a barrier. And Xu Miao removes it himself, insistently, almost tenderness in the gesture. He's saying: I don't care what you look like. I already know you. But the deeper symbolism runs through the identity theme. Xie Ge fell for someone he thought was a stranger, then fell harder when he discovered the stranger was Xu Miao in disguise. Which version is the real connection? Does it matter? The novel keeps asking this and never gives a straight answer. "Physical intimacy was the sharpest tool to express affection"—this line about Xu Miao's philosophy is really about authenticity vs performance. Words can be faked. Disguises can be worn. But the body, the kiss, the touch—that's unmediated truth. Xu Miao trusts the body more than language because language is what got them into this mess. The mask is language. The kiss is truth. And the five hours on the flight—that's liminal space. They're suspended between who they were and who they're becoming. The chapter doesn't resolve anything because the resolution isn't the point. The point is that they're finally in the same room, no masks, no lies (well, fewer lies), and the rest will figure itself out.
... Read More
I need a minute. I literally need to lie down. The image of Xie Ge pressing his forehead against Xu Miao's neck, refusing to let go, whispering that he was nervous—not disgusted, just nervous—and Xu Miao having every reason to believe him but not being able to, and then Xu Miao initiating the kiss himself and then calling him a puppy for biting his tongue—this is the most emotionally volatile thing I have ever read. And I mean that as the highest compliment. "Physical intimacy was the sharpest tool to express affection. Xu Miao didn't believe spiritual connection could replace it." This line though. This single line tells us everything about Xu Miao's love language. He doesn't trust words. Words failed him. Words are what got them here. So he goes for the body, because the body can't lie. And Xie Ge—oh god, Xie Ge. He spent the entire chapter defending himself, explaining, pleading, trying to make Xu Miao understand that none of those cruel things he said were real. And Xu Miao finally sees it. Finally actually SEE it. But by then he's already exhausted. The kiss scene in the room is either the sweetest or most chaotic thing in this entire novel. Xu Miao shoves him against the door and just kisses him like he's been starving. And Xie Ge? He's frozen, panicking, bites his tongue—this boy has never kissed anyone and here he is with a man he thought was someone else and now it's Xu Miao and his brain short-circuits. And Xu Miao LAUGHS at him. Softly. Teasing. "It's not bad. I was just scaring you." And then the five hours comment. I can't. I physically cannot. This is devastating and adorable in equal measure.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are so deeply internal it almost doesn't register until you're already crying. Externally? Nothing. No villains, no dramatic obstacles, no family disapproval shown yet. Just two people who want the same thing and keep missing each other. But internally—holy shit. Xu Miao's stake is survival. If he stays and Xie Ge still leaves after knowing the truth, then nothing mattered. Every message, every visit, every morning he woke up hoping to see him—that was all for nothing. Better to end it now on his own terms than be discarded later. Xie Ge's stake is different. He's terrified that if Xu Miao sees the real him—the face, the identity, the fact that he was fooled by a disguise—he'll realize this was all some weird trick and lose interest completely. So he wears the mask to protect himself, which paradoxically pushes Xu Miao further away. It's a self-fulfilling prophecy of rejection. And then there's the third layer, the one neither acknowledges: what happens when the outside world finds out? The Chen Lu incident already proved that people like to gossip, to assume, to categorize. Xie Ge mentioning his girlfriend—that's not just plot info, that's a ticking clock. How long can this secret last? The hallway argument raises the stakes to a breaking point. Xie Ge's scream—"Your love counts as love, but mine is just trash?"—that's not just anger, that's the sound of someone who feels invisible. And Xu Miao's guilt afterward, the way he deflates instantly when Xie Ge says sorry—that shows us the power dynamic. Xu Miao always comes back. No matter how much he tries to leave, he comes back. Which makes me worry for both of them. Because one day, Xie Ge might stop being the one who waits.
... Read More
The phone call scene is where everything detonates. Up until this point, Xie Ge has been maintaining this careful fortress of sarcasm and rejection. He's been the one in control—telling Xu Miao what to do, dismissing his gestures, shutting him down at every turn. But then Xu Miao goes silent, and the fortress crumbles. 'I don't want to keep crying, but I can't control it. I'm sorry.' This is the most vulnerable Xie Ge has been in the entire chapter. Not the text message vulnerability—the real-time, voice crack vulnerability. When you hear someone's voice breaking, you can't pretend it's performance. The stakes here are massive. We're talking about the difference between walking away clean or diving headfirst into something neither of them wants to admit they need. Xie Ge offers the cleanest exit: 'Right now, bringing up a breakup would be the cleanest solution.' But he doesn't do it. He can't. Instead, he keeps digging, asking questions he doesn't want answers to. 'Is it a good friend?' ... 'I'm drinking. Can you stop asking?' The tension between wanting to know and dreading the answer—that's where the real drama lives. And the chapter ends on a cliffhanger that I AM NOT READY FOR. 'I won't'—won't what? Won't stop asking? Won't let go? Won't—
... Read More
Let me just take a moment to appreciate how cinematic some of these scenes are because the author really understands visual storytelling. The opening image: Xu Miao walking through freezing cold wind, blowing warm breath into his palms, shoving his phone into his coat pocket. We immediately know two things—this person is cold, and this person is busy enough to ignore a message mid-conversation. The environment does double duty as mood and character information. Then we cut to the dorm—'heating on full blast'—and Xu Miao strips off his coat like shedding armor. The temperature contrast between outside and inside mirrors the emotional temperature contrast between his real life and his online life. Brilliant, quiet worldbuilding. But the balcony scene? That's the one I'm still thinking about. Xu Miao steps out to make a call—literally stepping away from the warmth, from Liang Dong, from the physical world—into the cold to have an intimate conversation with someone who may not exist. The lighting is 'not very bright,' which is why he misses Liang Dong's expression shift. This is such a small detail but it's doing SO much work. The darkness becomes literal dramatic irony—we, the readers, see what Xu Miao doesn't. The voice call itself is almost unbearable in its simplicity. No grand setting, no dramatic location. Just two people breathing into phones, one pretending, one desperately hoping. The intimacy of that soundscape—the quiet earpiece, the occasional breath—creates a soundscape that's more vivid than any described landscape. And then Liang Dong pushes the balcony door open and shatters the moment entirely. The intrusion of the mundane into the intimate. It's such a perfect visual metaphor for how real life keeps interrupting performed life.
... Read More
This entire passage is drenched in the symbolism of waiting. Xie Ge waiting at the shop, waiting for replies, waiting for a meeting that may never happen. The osmanthus flowers that exist "if" they meet. The year-long pattern of hoping and imagining possibilities. But what's really compelling is how waiting functions on multiple levels. It's romantic devotion — Xie Ge genuinely cares, genuinely hopes. It's also self-torture. Those deleted messages, the pacing, the constant checking of the phone — waiting has become a form of punishment he inflicts on himself. Xu Miao represents a different kind of waiting. He's waiting for the right moment to end things, waiting for Xie Ge to lose interest first, waiting for his own feelings to align with his plans. But the universe keeps thwarting him — he keeps falling harder, keeps trying to make amends, keeps sending flowers. The scratch on Xie Ge's arm is also deeply symbolic. A physical wound from an act of courage — defending someone weaker — transmitted digitally to the person he loves most. Pain becomes connection. Violence becomes romance. It's almost grotesque how efficiently suffering gets converted into intimacy in online relationships. And the ATM label for Xie Ge's messages? Whether intentional or not, it underscores how transactional this relationship has become. Money transfers, emotional investments, the currency of attention. Xu Miao tries to buy his way out of guilt, and Xie Ge accepts the payment because he's starving for any form of contact.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or