The Best Scam - Reviews

The Best Scam
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to process the sheer emotional range packed into these pages. We go from comedic absurdity (a man tracking his loneliness in expanding wet patches) to gut-punch devastation (rolling on a bed like an ant on a hot pan) in the span of three scenes. The text message exchanges are where the comedy lives. Xie Ge sending photos of his meal to prove he kept his promise, complaining about being abandoned after dinner, the puppy emoji face-holding. These are the messages of someone who has completely lost the plot and is having the time of his life. But then the dinner scene hits differently. The food that looked delicate and appetizing now looks nauseating. Every detail Xie Ge精心 arranged becomes an indictment of his own hope. He went through all that trouble for a visit that never came, and the only person who showed up was the one he wanted to avoid. And Xu Miao? Choosing not to go to the restaurant, choosing to walk past him instead—that's not rejection. That's protection. Both of them are trying to protect each other by pushing away, and it's the most destructive form of love I've ever read.
... Read More
"I'm not hungry anymore!" — Xie Ge interrupting himself mid-explanation like a kid caught doing something wrong. This boy cannot change the subject to save his life and he knows it. "Do you think I'm going to believe what I hear, or what I see?" — Xu Miao's devastating one-liner. Seven words and he dismantles three days of conversation. The man has a weaponized calm. "Can't I be nervous? The person I like suddenly appears in front of me, leans in to kiss me—what, I'm not a corpse." — Xie Ge at his most raw and unfiltered. This is the line that made me laugh and cry at the same time. WHO writes like this? Who makes a grown man sound this genuinely flustered? "I didn't want to fight with you. I was just explaining." → "But your voice was really loud." → "Sorry." The entire emotional arc of their relationship compressed into three lines of dialogue. Xu Miao diffusing tension with a casual observation, and Xie Ge immediately folding. It's ridiculous. It's adorable. It's exactly how people who actually care about each other talk when they're hurt. The mask dialogue though—"What if you think I'm not pretty anymore? You already want to break up with me. If you see me like this, you'll be even more determined to leave me." Xie Ge saying this WITH A MASK ON while Xu Miao had literally already seen his face. The dramatic irony in their conversation is insane. Every line carries double meaning and neither of them is fully hearing the other. Xu Miao's voice is measured, clipped, always holding something back. Xie Ge's voice is loose, sprawling, emotional, prone to tangents. They literally cannot have a normal conversation. And that's why it works.
... Read More
'Whether you want it is your business. Giving it to you is mine.' That line. That is the most Xu Miao line I have ever read in my life. It's cruel, it's controlled, it's so cold and clean and final, and yet I swear if you read it out loud you can hear the strain underneath it. Because this isn't someone who's actually moved on—that's someone who's trying really hard to sound like they've moved on. And Xie Ge's voice? Completely different register. More chaotic, more desperate, more raw. 'Why are you still caring about me?' and 'Do you want me to keep misunderstanding that you still like me?' Those aren't just questions—they're the sound of someone's emotional defenses cracking in real time. The author writes their dialogue so distinctly that even without tags I could tell who was speaking. That's the kind of skill that makes a relationship feel actual, like two real people who actually know how each other talk. The phone call where Xu Miao says 'Let's still meet. I'll make sure you give up completely'—I literally had to stop reading for a second. How do you say something like that and also mean 'I am still thinking about this'? The subtext here is doing overtime. Xu Miao keeps saying one thing while every other word screams the opposite. That's not bad writing, that's really good writing about a person who doesn't know how to be honest.
... Read More
Okay so the fake hotel reveal—when Xie Ge calls him out—is actually such a clean plot move. Everything that led to it has been building: the eavesdropping incident, the cold shoulder, the "no more meeting" rule Xu Miao kept enforcing. But here's the thing, and I need to say this because it bugged me—Xu Miao's reason for lying still feels kind of thin. He gave Xie Ge a fake hotel address to force a breakup? As if distance was ever going to solve a misunderstanding rooted in identity? It's the kind of dramatic choice that works in fiction but drives me absolutely crazy because it almost costs them everything. And then the hallway confrontation—Xie Ge demanding answers, the whole "why are you doing this to me" breakdown—it's messy and ugly and PERFECT. Real people don't negotiate clean breakups. And the part where Xu Miao tries to test Xie Ge by leaning in for a kiss, and Xie Ge turns away, and Xu Miao immediately retreats into "let's just break up" mode—that's not a plot twist, that's character logic. Xu Miao can't wait. He's too anxious, too insecure, too used to being the one who runs first. The chapter circles back to the same wound every time: neither of them trusts the other to tell the truth, so they keep hurting each other. Classic. But the payoff in the room—the shove, the aggressive kiss, the "we still have five hours" line—is earned because we watched both of them spiral for long enough. I'm still not over the mask reveal moment. Just… the dramatic irony of Xie Ge hiding his face while Xu Miao had already seen it. That hit different.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or