The Best Scam - Reviews

The Best Scam
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this dynamic between Xu Miao and Xie Ge because it is NOT healthy and I love it. Xie Ge is literally performing vulnerability like he was trained for it. He sends photos of his red wrist, types 'I'm about to cry,' uses stickers of a puppy wiping tears. But here's the thing that got me—Xu Miao KNOWS. He thinks he knows. He even internally mocks Xie Ge: 'Always pretending to be pitiful, Xu Miao thought.' And yet he STILL transfers money. STILL coaxes him. STILL smiles when Xie Ge sends that photo of the taped wrist. There's this moment at the pharmacy where the REAL Xie Ge grabs Xu Miao's arm and asks to transfer him the money for the muscle tape. Xu Miao's reaction is so telling—he shakes off the touch immediately, says something brutally practical like 'You don't need to pay me,' and then hides in an inconspicuous spot to WATCH Xie Ge wrap the tape and send a selfie. That's not just curiosity, that's obsession disguised as detachment. And Xu Miao's own internal monologue about being deceived? 'Cause and effect, karma coming full circle.' He's a liar himself, so being lied to feels like poetic justice. But he can't stop. The fact that he keeps going back to Gangji, keeps scrolling through their chat history, keeps finding excuses to send money—it's this exhausting push-pull where he pretends he's in control but he's clearly the one being strung along. Who's really performing here?
... Read More
The pacing in this section is actually really clever because it moves at three different speeds simultaneously. You've got the immediate action—the fight at the beginning, Xie Ge getting into a conflict with customers, winning with his fingernails of all things. That's fast, punchy, almost comedic. Then you transition into Xu Miao's slow walk, scrolling through chat history, ending up at Gangji almost by accident. The tempo drops. It becomes meditative, drifting. And then—the overheard conversation. This is where the pacing snaps tight again. Every line of dialogue from Xie Ge's sibling and coworker hits like a beat dropping. 'Didn't you already eat this yesterday?' 'Why are you wearing this shirt again?' Each question is a tiny hammer strike, and by the time Xie Ge says 'I'm gonna wear it till it falls apart,' you're already reaching for your phone to check if Xu Miao replied. Then the pharmacy scene—slow again, almost mundane. Two people reaching for the same box of muscle tape. An awkward exchange. And then Xu Miao waiting in the shadows like a stalker (which he basically is, emotionally if not literally) watching Xie Ge wrap his wrist. The final beat is the voice message, and that trailing 'I just… want to keep you compa'—the message cuts off. Whatever he was going to say, we don't know. The chapter doesn't resolve anything. It just… stops. And that's perfect because neither of these guys knows where they stand.
... Read More
I need to address the opening dialogue because WOW. The banter between Xie Ge and Liang Dong is genuinely funny and feels completely natural. Like, this is how actual friends talk — the petty jabs, the deflections, the way they circle around uncomfortable truths without actually addressing them. Liang Dong's line "You wouldn't understand" while clearly hiding something is such perfect character work. And then Xie Ge immediately weaponizes his girlfriend by flashing the phone screen? That's not just humor, that's characterization. We learn SO much about their dynamic in like three exchanges. The "rat poison" joke was the cherry on top. It's dark, it's casual, it's the kind of threat that only exists between people who know they're safe with each other. I love how Xie Ge can be this deeply vulnerable with Xu Miao about his feelings, but with Liang Dong it's all armor and sarcasm. The contrast is brilliant. With Xu Miao, Xie Ge types and deletes messages, his words trembling with insecurity. With Liang Dong, he's sharp, quick, unbothered. Two completely different versions of the same person. Even the text message formatting in the narrative works well — the [ATM] and [XM] labels give immediate visual distinction, and the rhythm of rapid-fire rejected messages followed by the cold, delayed reply from Xu Miao creates this unbearable tension. You CAN feel Xie Ge's anxiety in how the messages are structured. The author understands that HOW people communicate is EVERYTHING.
... Read More
There's something really interesting about how the author uses the milk tea shop as a kind of threshold — a place where things happen, where decisions get made, where Xie Ge ends up protecting someone and getting hurt. The shop isn't just background, it's almost a character itself. The opening scene at the shop entrance where Xie Ge compares the location to a photo is loaded with meaning. He's literally measuring reality against expectation, searching for someone he's only imagined. The phrase "near home, the heart grows timid" captures this perfectly — he's been coming here for a year, but when the moment actually arrives, he hesitates. He wants it to be "more formal." The osmanthus trees are another beautiful environmental detail. They're in full bloom, fragrant and sweet — nature continuing its cycle while these two humans struggle with communication and commitment. The contrast between the natural world (which operates on certainty and seasons) and their relationship (which operates on uncertainty and endless waiting) is striking. I also appreciate how the school setting frames everything. University life, off-campus housing, the proximity that makes it all both possible and impossibly complicated. The fact that Liang Dong lives five minutes from campus but chooses the dorm anyway — that small detail says so much about avoidance, about the spaces we create between ourselves and intimacy.
... Read More
I have to say, Xie Ge is such a contradictory mess and I love him for it. On one hand, he's being genuinely cruel to Xu Miao—calling him disgusting, telling him to get a psychologist, basically treating him like trash. And yet... somewhere in the middle of all that, he's also the one crying on the phone, begging to know why Xu Miao is ignoring him. The man literally asks 'Would he agree to anything? Even breaking up?' when Xu Miao won't talk to him. That right there tells you everything about Xie Ge's emotional maturity level. But here's what's interesting—his cruelty isn't random. It's defensive. He's clearly been hurt before, and every time Xu Miao shows up being sweet and persistent, it cracks that armor and Xie Ge panics. The scene where he offers to introduce Xu Miao to a psychologist? That's not just being mean—that's Xie Ge projecting his own need for therapy onto someone else because he can't face his own feelings. Classic deflection. And then the dinner scene at the restaurant—he picks a seat facing the entrance, waiting for someone, and the person he doesn't want to see walks in first. Fate has a sense of humor, doesn't it?
... Read More
There's a water motif running through this entire section and I'm starting to think it's not accidental. Tears become lakes. Droughts get measured in square meters. The ground is wet while the sun shines. There's this persistent imagery of emotional overflow—feelings so big they literally reshape the landscape. Xie Ge's 'artificial lake' is the perfect symbol for this whole relationship. It's water without rain, moisture without storm. Something that LOOKS natural but was manufactured. Is that what their connection is? Something fabricated, or something real that just doesn't follow natural patterns? The name coincidence—two men with the same name—is another layer. In literature, duplicate names usually signal fate, duality, or the idea that people are mirrors of each other. Xie Ge and Xu Miao aren't just connected by circumstance; they're fundamentally mirrored. Both desperate. Both pretending they don't care. Both waiting by the door for someone who might not come. And the restaurant seating arrangement—Xie Ge facing the entrance, watching every person who enters—that's a powerful visual metaphor for anticipation and its inevitable disappointment. He's performing the role of someone waiting, but the script keeps changing on him.
... Read More
The wrist scene. Let me just sit with this for a moment. Xie Ge sends a photo of his reddened wrist to Xu Miao, playing the victim, asking for comfort. Xu Miao, despite suspecting something is off, buys the muscle tape himself and sends Xie Ge a picture of it from a pharmacy near Gangji. Then—plot twist—he runs into the REAL Xie Ge in that same pharmacy, and the real Xie Ge is there buying the exact same tape because his 'girlfriend' sent him a photo of it. So which wrist is actually hurt? We don't know. Xu Miao sees Xie Ge rub his wrist hard a few times in a corner right before sending the photo. Is he faking it? Is he genuinely injured and just bad at asking for help? The ambiguity is what keeps the tension alive. The stakes here aren't life-or-death, but they feel enormous because they're emotional. Xu Miao stands to lose something he didn't even admit he had. When he watches Xie Ge from afar, wrapping the tape clumsily and sending another photo, he's not just observing a stranger—he's watching the person he's been emotionally investing in, possibly being manipulated, possibly being genuine, and he can't tell the difference anymore. That uncertainty is the real conflict. Not whether Xie Ge is lying, but whether Xu Miao will keep caring even if he is.
... Read More
I need to talk about ATM's dialogue because WOW. This character speaks in full paragraphs through text messages and I am HERE for it. The way he writes—"It's already been five hours, forty-six minutes, and thirty-nine seconds. Fifty-eight seconds."—that's not just clingy, that's specific. That's someone who is counting every second apart. And Xu Miao notices the time too. They're both doing it. Both of them are obsessed with the same invisible clock. And the humor! The author lets ATM be genuinely funny without making him a caricature. The puppy holding its heart emoji. The dramatic "What would I do without you?" followed by the self-aware zoom-in on his own hand injury. He knows Xu Miao will see it. He's performing, but he's also genuinely affected. That duality makes his voice so real—people don't usually separate the performance from the feeling, they just layer them. Xu Miao's voice is the perfect counterweight. Shorter messages. Dry. Sarcastic. "Don't pretend to be pitiful." "So who's the boyfriend here, you or me?" He says less but every line lands because we know what he's thinking underneath. The gap between what he texts and what he feels IS his character. And the scene where ATM sends that scarf photo—zoomed in so tight it's basically just his chin—with the caption about loving it so much he wishes winter would last longer. That's not just good dialogue, that's character revealed through the specificity of what someone chooses to show. The author didn't need a single narration beat to tell us ATM is the type of person who notices small kindnesses and treats them like miracles. One image did it. Also side note: the voice changer detail. That's such a weirdly specific prop and the author just drops it in like it's nothing. Three days from idea to execution. Half a day's wage on a voice changer. This man didn't hesitate.
... Read More
I am not okay. I thought I knew what to expect when Xu Miao sent that hotel location—something dramatic, sure, but I didn't think it would hurt this much. The fact that Xie Ge was so desperate to hear Xu Miao's voice on the phone, sniffing and crying, begging 'Is it just because I wanted to see you?'—and Xu Miao's answer was essentially 'I'll make sure you give up completely'? That is not how you treat someone who loves you. That is not how you treat anyone. But here's what wrecked me even more: the scene where Xu Miao deletes Xie Ge's contact, calling him 'ATM,' then adds him to the blacklist. The narrative says Xu Miao felt 'strange relief' afterward. Relief! As if he'd been carrying something unbearable and finally set it down. And I had to go back and reread that part because I couldn't believe it. But then the last line—Xie Ge sitting on the hallway floor, arms wrapped around Xu Miao's leg, still wearing the mask—totally undid all of that neat resolution. He waited. He showed up. He came anyway. Even after everything. And Xu Miao didn't even know it was him, did he? This book does not let you off the hook. The emotional whiplash between these two is something else entirely.
... Read More
Let me just talk about the scene where Xu Miao accidentally overhears Xie Ge at Gangji. This is cinematic as hell. Xu Miao literally ends up outside the shop because he was scrolling through chat history and walking in a daze. The loudspeaker is blaring about a new product, the shop is crowded with customers chatting, and somehow this whole conversation just falls into his ears like fate decided to serve him drama on a silver platter. The conversation itself is so casual—someone teasing Xie Ge about eating the same dessert two days in a row, complaining about his threadbare shirt. But then Xie Ge drops this line that hits like a truck: 'Not everyone gets a shirt hand-sewn by their girlfriend. I'm gonna wear it till it falls apart.' And Xu Miao is standing there, ten feet away, processing this. The detail about the shirt is what ruined me. Xie Ge points to the initials 'X.G.' on his chest, saying every stitch is his girlfriend's love. And Xu Miao gave him that shirt. With that ugly little dog he clumsily stitched himself. The shirt is right there on Xie Ge's body, and Xu Miao has to watch him wear it and claim it came from someone else. The setting does so much work here. It's not some dramatic confrontation in a dark alley—it's a bright, noisy, mundane dessert shop. That's what makes it hurt more. Life goes on around them, people are chatting about nothing, and Xu Miao's entire world tilts on its axis. The author doesn't need rain or thunderclaps; a crowded shop with a loudspeaker announcing new products is enough to make you feel like the ground just opened up.
... Read More
The scene with Xu Miao on the convenience store steps really stuck with me. Not because it's visually spectacular—well, OK, it has that quality—but because of what the setting does emotionally. A 24-hour convenience store, fluorescent lights, two men who shouldn't be running into each other again, and the entire world compressed into those narrow exterior steps. It feels so grounded and ordinary, which makes everything that happens inside it hit harder. And the hotel room scene? The author doesn't describe much of the room at all. Just footsteps approaching, a door clicking open, a voice from earphones being a girl's and a voice from the doorway being a man's. That contrast—two rooms, two realities, one doorway—was so cleanly filmed in my head. I could see it like a movie cut. The mask detail too, stuffing it into his pocket before leaving, then putting it on right before knocking. It's such a small prop but it becomes this whole metaphor for hiding, for performing, for not being allowed to show your face. The hallway at the end, empty and dim, Xu Miao walking toward the elevator—then suddenly stopped by someone on the floor. No description of the floor itself, no lighting details, just that physical interruption. Minimalism used perfectly. Sometimes less description means the scene lives in your head longer because you have to fill it in yourself.
... Read More
I need to process what happened with the special-number transfers. 520. In Chinese culture that literally means 'I love you' numerically, and Xu Miao has been sending these without even thinking about it anymore. 'Sending special-number transfers to Xie Ge had been Xu Miao's habit for a long time.' A habit. Like brushing his teeth. Like checking his phone first thing in the morning. When Xie Ge complains about muscle tape costing 520 being 'daylight robbery,' Xu Miao replies: 'The rest is a reward for being brave.' Brave. He's rewarding performative suffering. He's paying someone to pretend to be hurt so he can feel like a provider, a caretaker, someone needed. And then there's the voice message at the end. Xie Ge's 'sticky, soft voice' saying 'I miss you. Can we talk on the phone tonight? I feel like… we can call for a bit.' That hesitation. That 'I feel like' before he even states what he feels like. He's testing the waters, gauging how much access he can get. And Xu Miao, who just found out he might have been deceived the entire time, replies 'Work is really busy today. I might not have time.' He's pulling back. Just a little. But we both know he'll cave. He always caves. The way Xu Miao couldn't stop smiling when Xie Ge sent that photo of the wrapped wrist—that's the tragedy. He's addicted to this person and he knows it. He knows the foundation is fake and he's still building on top of it anyway.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or