The Best Scam - Reviews

The Best Scam
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just start by saying the pacing here is masterclass level restraint. The author could have dumped all the backstory in chapter one—Xu Miao's family, the scam operation, how many people he's conned, everything—and honestly that would have been the easier choice. But instead we get the ATM messages FIRST. We get the romance first. We get the warmth first. And THEN the author slowly peels back the layers like an onion made of knives. The structure does something really clever with time. Chapter 1 is basically one afternoon in real time—Xu Miao at work, checking his phone, scrolling through hours of messages. It feels immediate, present tense almost, even though it's written in past tense. Then the backstory hits and suddenly we're pulled back months, maybe a year, to when this all started. The flashback doesn't feel like an interruption; it feels like the ground giving way beneath everything we just read. And the transition points are so well-timed. The kitten photo. The hand injury. The scarf. Each one is a small moment that opens a bigger door. The scarf especially—Xu Miao buys it after his first real paycheck from the internship, and that's when the tone shifts. Up until then he was just a guy doing what he had to do to survive. After the scarf, he's someone who's starting to care, and that's when the conflict becomes personal instead of financial. I also want to mention how the author controls the information drip. We know Xu Miao is a scammer from early on. We don't know ATM's background until later. We don't know if ATM suspects anything. We don't know if ATM even knows Xu Miao is male. The author is playing 4D chess with what each character knows versus what the reader knows, and that creates this constant low-grade panic that makes you want to keep turning pages even though nothing 'big' is happening yet.
... Read More
The restaurant scene is absolutely cinematic. Let me paint it for you: Xie Ge, sitting alone at a table facing the entrance, surrounded by beautifully presented dishes that have somehow become nauseating. Every time the door opens, he looks up hoping. The food arrives cold. And then—there he is. Xu Miao. Walking toward him like a ghost neither of them asked for. The way the author frames this is chef's kiss. Same name, two people—one he'd run into even while hiding, the other he couldn't meet no matter how much he begged. What a cruel twist of fate that both men share the same name. The irony is almost too much. And Xu Miao standing at the table, asking to share, and Xie Ge's razor-sharp response about psychologists... the tension in that single exchange is so thick you could cut it with a knife. Then Xu Miao leaves quietly, and Xie Ge sits there surrounded by food he can't eat, staring at messages that won't come. The spatial arrangement matters so much here. Xie Ge chose a seat facing the door—wanting to be found, wanting to see who comes in. But the person he wants doesn't come. The person he doesn't want does. The restaurant becomes this liminal space where desire and disappointment occupy the same square footage.
... Read More
This chapter is structured like a tension spring. It starts coiled—hallway encounter, confused questions, the fake hotel revelation—and each exchange pulls it tighter until something has to give. The author doesn't rush any of it. Xu Miao tries to leave. Xie Ge stops him. They talk. They argue. They almost kiss. They don't. They talk more. Xie Ge explains the misunderstanding. Xu Miao tests him with a kiss. Xie Ge turns away. Xu Miao offers to break up. Xie Ge explodes. And then—the room. The door closing. The question: "So… are you still nervous now?" The pause before the answer. The shove. The kiss. The pacing here is masterful because the author lets the argument breathe. In lesser writing, this scene would be twenty lines of shouting and done. Here it's pages of back-and-forth where each character gets real estate to be wrong, to be hurt, to be defensively stupid. The hallway fight especially—notice how the author lets Xie Ge monologue a bit, lets him get loud, lets everyone hear, lets Xu Miao just… absorb it. That's deliberate. The author is making us feel the weight of Xie Ge's desperation. And then the room scene shifts entirely. The energy changes from defensive to aggressive to tender to hilarious in the span of a paragraph. "Are you a puppy or something? You bit my tongue." From the loudest argument to the softest tease. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works because we've earned the relief. The chapter ends on that ambiguous note—"Was it what he thought it was? If it was, wasn't this developing a…"—and just stops mid-thought. No resolution. No period. We're left hanging and I am NOT okay with this. Five more hours and then what?
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Xu Miao because this guy is so complicated and honestly kind of tragic. Here's someone who claims he wants to let things fade naturally, tells himself it's easier since they've never met in person — but then the SECOND Xie Ge threatens to break up, his whole facade cracks. He's the one who couldn't let go, not Xie Ge. That realization hit me like a truck. His internal monologue about the relationship is so revealing. He literally plans to just drift apart, convinces himself money can fix the emotional distance, sends a transfer the moment those angry messages come through. And then he takes a photo of osmanthus flowers and promises a bouquet "if they have a chance to meet in the future" — as if the future is guaranteed, as if he isn't already preparing for an ending. Xie Ge on the other hand is so painfully earnest. All those messages he types and deletes, pacing around his room, desperate for any sign of connection. But here's the thing that kills me — he forgives Xu Miao SO easily. One picture of flowers and all his frustration melts away. That's not love, that's attachment. That's someone who's been waiting so long for any reply at all that even crumbs feel like a feast. And then there's the whole Xie Min situation. His little brother dragging him to that milk tea shop, Xie Ge getting scratched protecting some girl — and his FIRST thought is to send a photo to Xu Miao. Even when he's physically hurt, his emotional center of gravity is still Xu Miao. That's devotion, but is it healthy devotion? I kept wondering how much of Xie Ge's identity is tied up in waiting for someone who may never show up.
... Read More
Let's talk about that coffee. One cup. That's all it takes to shatter weeks of careful boundary-setting between these two men. Xu Miao brings coffee because he noticed Xie Ge looked tired—that's genuine care. And Xie Ge's response? Throws it in the trash. In FRONT of him. This is such a loaded moment. It's not just about caffeine. Xie Ge is rejecting the gesture, the attention, the implication that anyone should care about whether he's resting or not. The physical act of throwing the coffee away is violence disguised as inconvenience. And Xu Miao's reaction—forcing a smile, apologizing for being presumptuous—shows exactly how powerless he feels in this dynamic. But here's what I keep coming back to: Xu Miao knows Xie Ge isn't actually allergic to caffeine. He remembers the photo from last week. He KNOWS this is a lie. And he says nothing. He just absorbs it. That's not weakness—that's a different kind of strength. The kind that waits.
... Read More
That shirt. I can't stop thinking about that shirt. It's this cheap, loose-thread disaster that Xie Ge's mom apparently doesn't want to be seen in, that his sibling calls him out on constantly—and he refuses to take it off. 'Every stitch is her love, got it?' he tells them proudly, pointing to the X.G. initials. But the shirt came from Xu Miao. With that ugly little dog he hand-sewed. Xu Miao, who is presumably wealthy and powerful given how casually he transfers money, made something with his own hands for someone he cares about. And that someone is wearing it and telling other people it came from a girlfriend who clearly isn't Xu Miao. The dog is such a specific detail too. 'Clumsily stitched an ugly little dog.' It's not elegant. It's not refined. It's the opposite of everything Xu Miao projects in his public life. It's vulnerable and awkward and real—and Xie Ge is walking around in it like it's nothing, letting other people admire it while claiming a different origin story. There's also the repetition motif—Xie Ge eats the same dessert two days running, wears the same shirt, receives the same kind of care from two different 'girlfriends' (one real, one online). The whole thing feels like a hall of mirrors where nothing is quite what it seems, and the only thing holding it together is Xu Miao's willingness to believe whatever brings him comfort in the moment.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this opening is such a sneaky little narrative trap. On the surface it looks like a fluffy modern romance—two guys texting, one is obsessively clingy, the other is cold but secretly soft—and then BOOM you get hit with the whole backstory dump about Xu Miao running an online girlfriend scam to pay for his family's medical bills and his dad's construction accident. And I love how the author sets it up. We spend all this time reading the ATM messages thinking it's just cute couple energy, then we find out the person on the other end isn't just any mark—he's the one mark Xu Miao couldn't bring himself to scam. That reversal is everything. The structure here is brilliant because it mirrors how relationships actually work in real life. You think you know someone through their messages, through curated photos and carefully timed emotional confessions, and then the truth hits you and everything shifts. Xu Miao told himself this new ATM was poorer than him, worse background, bad choice—but then he kept him around anyway. The plot isn't moving forward with big events; it's moving sideways, deeper into this moral fog where Xu Miao is the villain of his own story and he knows it. One thing that really got me: the scarf moment. He buys ATM a cheap scarf after his internship finally pays off, and ATM's reaction—the over-the-top gratitude, the fake product photo zoomed in on just his chin—that's not just cute, it's devastating. Because Xu Miao gave him something and ATM genuinely treasured it, and that's the moment the scammer becomes the one being scammed by his own conscience. I'm not even gonna pretend I wasn't crying a little. The author really said "let's make the reader fall for the lie before pulling the rug."
... Read More
I'm still thinking about the osmanthus flowers scene. Xu Miao sends a picture and says "The flowers are blooming. If we have a chance to meet in the future, I will give you a bouquet of osmanthus." On paper this is sweet, right? A romantic promise, a future plan. But the subtext is devastating. He's NOT saying "I can't wait to see you." He's saying "IF." He's leaving the door cracked instead of throwing it open. And Xie Ge — poor, hopeful Xie Ge — receives this and ALL his anger dissolves. One image of flowers and he's floating on happiness again. That emotional whiplash must be exhausting to live. What struck me most is how the physical distance mirrors the emotional distance. Xie Ge has been coming to this area repeatedly, hoping to catch a glimpse, wondering if someone he passed on the street was Xu Miao. He's building a fantasy of coincidence while Xu Miao is somewhere else, carefully constructing an exit strategy that he's simultaneously sabotaging by trying to be better. The scratch on Xie Ge's arm at the end — he sends it to Xu Miao with "It hurts so much sob sob sob" — and I couldn't help but feel this mix of tenderness and heartbreak. He's sharing his pain, seeking comfort, but also maintaining that connection. Every interaction is both a thread pulling them closer and a reminder of how far apart they actually are.
... Read More
'I like you. I really, really like you.' That's it. That's the tweet. Xie Ge says this during a voice call and somehow it hits harder than any grand declaration could. Here's the thing that absolutely destroyed me: Xie Ge doesn't know WHY he likes Xu Miao. 'We've never even met in person, and I don't fully understand you. But I still like you so much.' This is raw, unfiltered emotional honesty from someone who spends the rest of the chapter masking vulnerability behind demands and playful anger. The moment he lets it slip is almost accidental—he's nervous, he stumbles, and then it's out. And Xu Miao's reaction? 'He felt like a little deer had leapt into his chest, his heart thudding wildly.' For one impossible second, the deception cracks. Not because Xu Miao feels guilty—though maybe he should—but because genuine emotion, even received through a screen, does something to a person. The text says it plainly: 'Whether it was real or not, at that moment, he wanted to believe it was genuine.' But then the narrator drops the glass metaphor and I was absolutely not prepared for it: 'I already told you I'm made of glass—it's not a lie.' Xie Ge says this casually, almost jokingly, but it's the emotional thesis of the entire relationship. He's fragile. He shatters easily. And yet he keeps piecing himself back together, again and again, for someone who may not even be real. The irony is so thick you could cut it with a knife. The birthday gift conversation that follows is somehow both the sweetest and most pathetic thing in the text. Xie Ge demanding a gift like it's a test—like if Xu Miao remembers, maybe he's real. Maybe this is real. And Xu Miao's internal response: 'You'd get a gift even if you didn't ask.' Which is both true and devastating, because the gifts were never about the object. They were about proof.
... Read More
There's a scene—well, not really a scene, more of a frozen moment—that I cannot stop thinking about. The scarf arriving. ATM sending back a photo that's basically just fabric filling the frame with a sliver of chin at the top, like he couldn't even face showing his whole face to the camera but also couldn't NOT share this with Xu Miao. And Xu Miao's ears are red from the cold and he's smiling at his screen and the author just writes: "He thought, in such a cold world, at least one of us should be warm." That line is the entire thesis of this book dressed up as a thought. The cold here isn't just winter. It's the construction site where Xu Miao's dad lost his leg. It's the bar where ATM's mom drinks herself numb. It's the gambling dens that swallowed ATM's brother. It's the online space where Xu Miao performs intimacy he doesn't feel. Everything in this world is cold and everyone is trying to be warm for someone else. But the author does something really interesting with the physical setting. We barely see any of it. There are no detailed descriptions of campuses or cities or rooms. The world is built almost entirely through the phone screen—photos of kittens, close-ups of hands, zoomed-in scarves, emoji after emoji. And somehow that sparse environmental detail makes the world feel MORE real, not less, because that's literally how these two people experience each other. Their world IS the phone. The phone is the world. The only actual physical description we get outside the screen is that stray kitten—"shiny and healthy, chubby and round, curled up like a big mooncake, sunbathing." And even that gets ruined by the annoying human scratching its chin. The author is telling us something about warmth and contamination, about how the things we love in this world come with strings attached. I'm not overcomplicating this. Maybe I am.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this outright: I did NOT see this twist coming and I am still recovering. The entire setup of these four chapters is a house of cards built on one character's lies, and the author lets us enjoy that delicious dramatic irony for the majority of the text before quietly, almost gently, pulling the thread. Xu Miao is introduced to us basically as the narrator of his own romantic comedy—he's charming, he's giving, he sends money, he listens to Xie Ge's insecurities and soothes them. We're meant to root for them, right? The chat messages read like peak internet couple energy. And then boom: 'He forgot—that the moment you start trusting someone is the moment you begin being completely deceived.' Every one of his past partners had been fooled by him in exactly the same way. Now he had forgotten… so he, too, began to be deceived. This is such a clean, almost surgical narrative move. The author doesn't announce it with fanfare—they just slip it in right after the most tender moment of the voice call, like a cold splash of water. It reframes everything we've just read. Every sweet message, every gift, every patient listening session—was it real? Or was Xu Miao performing? And here's what's genuinely impressive about the plot construction: the story gives us Xie Ge's birthday looming in the background as if it's just another cute romantic detail, but it's actually setting up the big reveal. The money transfers that used to be 'just because' are now recontextualized as part of a long-con. The plot doesn't just have a twist—it has a structural deception that mirrors the emotional one. I'm also obsessed with how the Liang Dong subplot threads through all of this. His jealousy, his curiosity, his muttered 'heartless'—it's not just filler. It's creating a parallel storyline of genuine emotion against the fake one, which makes the eventual crash so much more painful. The author is playing 4D chess here and I am here for it.
... Read More
What I love about this passage is how the conflict operates on at least three levels simultaneously. There's the surface-level conflict—Xu Miao trying to break up with Xie Ge. Then there's the deeper conflict: Xie Ge discovering that Xu Miao is a man, which shatters the entire foundation of their relationship. And then there's the internal conflict that runs through both of them, which is the real story here. Xu Miao told himself he'd feel relief after deleting Xie Ge's contact. He did feel something. But then he spent all that time rehearsing what he'd say if Xie Ge knocked on his door again. If he wanted to hit him, he said, he could accept it. Accept it! That tells you everything about where Xu Miao actually is emotionally. The stakes here aren't just about whether they stay together or not. They're about identity, about whether Xie Ge can reconcile the person he thought Xu Miao was with the person Xu Miao actually is. And the cruelty Xu Miao shows—calling him 'disgusting,' the breakup fee transfer, the whole performance—what's at stake for Xu Miao is survival. He's trying to destroy the relationship fast enough that it won't destroy him. And then Xie Ge shows up at the door in a mask, and Xu Miao sees him and walks away, and Xie Ge ends up on the hallway floor with his arms around Xu Miao's leg. The ultimate escalation: not a breakup scene, but a scene where neither person can let go. Who wins when both people are losing?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or