Should We Continue This Marriage? - Reviews

Should We Continue This Marriage?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how good the dialogue restraint is here? Nearly every conversation between Etia and Derek follows the same pattern: someone says something, the other person deflects, and then they both pretend everything is fine. "That's not true." "It may not be much to your liking." "Never mind." "Let's go back. It's cold." These aren't just lines, they're dance steps. They're two people who want to say so much more but have built this habit of circling around the real topic like it's landmine territory. And Derek's lines in particular are crafted to sound protective but read as dismissive - "It's nothing serious," "It's nothing for you to worry about," "Please rest comfortably." Every single one of these phrases is technically kind but emotionally hollow, and Etia knows it. She calls it out internally: "another formulaic answer returned, Etia just turned her head away." The narrative voice itself is worth discussing because it splits between Etia's sharp, frustrated internal monologue and Derek's quieter, more confused one. When he thinks "Why did I suggest she come along?" that's not arrogance, that's genuine bewilderment. He doesn't understand her either and the dialogue never lets us forget that. The few lines that DO break through the pattern hit like physical blows.
... Read More
'It was the border, no less. A place where if you climbed the fortress wall, you could see the red land so bright it hurt your eyes.' This image of the red land — visible from the border, glowing like a wound — keeps appearing in my head. It's not just setting; it's the novel's central metaphor made landscape. Let me think about what this passage is really about beneath the surface. The title of this territory is Sylvester, but the real subject seems to be boundaries — physical, emotional, social. The border between safe land and demon beast territory mirrors the border between Derek and Etia's hearts. Both are supposed to be protective, but both keep failing. Derek's philosophy about punishment is deeply tied to this theme. He executed a knight for carelessness because 'one person's carelessness would spread without a trace to others, and that would soon have to be paid for with lives.' This is the logic of a border guardian — you enforce strict boundaries because crossing them has consequences. But then Etia crosses his emotional border, and he can't enforce the boundary at all. His own carelessness — letting her come to the frontier — threatens everything he's built. The coachman's death is another boundary violation. He died because Etia, a noblewoman who'd only ever read about adventure in novels, treated the border like fiction. 'Novels are just novels' — she says this to herself, and it's the moment she loses her innocence. The boundary between fantasy and reality, between entertainment and consequence, collapses. The Land of Fire is mentioned multiple times as a source of the demon beast problem, but its secrets are guarded — 'maybe only the lord and knights know?' This hidden knowledge mirrors how Derek hides his true feelings. Both the political threat and the emotional threat are partially invisible, partially understood, and both require sacrifice to contain. And the divorce itself — is it really about ending the marriage, or is it Derek trying to redraw a boundary he feels he's already failed to maintain? He pushed too close, something terrible happened, so he pushes back harder. It's the same logic he applies to punishing careless knights, applied to his own heart. The recurring imagery of light and shadow is everywhere — moonlight on Etia's pale face, firewood casting shifting shadows on Derek's features, the red land that 'hurts your eyes.' Light reveals truth but also causes pain. You can't have one without the other. What is this novel actually saying? I think it's about the violence of caring too much in a world where boundaries are the only thing keeping you alive.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the internal conflict in this book is WHERE IT'S AT. Etia wants a divorce. She needs a divorce. But every step toward getting it requires her to perform the role of a devoted wife, and each performance chips away at something she can't quite name. That tension between what she needs to do and what she's starting to feel — that's the engine of this story. And Derek? Oh, Derek is a walking contradiction. He says he'll grant her divorce because 'that would surely be a better life for her,' but his internal monologue keeps circling back to her. He remembers her silhouette. He feels guilt about being too harsh. He thinks about what she must have felt coming home to that bedroom after two years of neglect. And yet he STILL shows up in her room at night. The external stakes are also not to be messed with. The Crown Prince's inspection isn't just a cute subplot — it's a political minefield. If things go wrong, if the Northern lords look weak or divided, everyone loses. Etia's jewelry and status depend on appearances. The lawyer's advice about proving she's fulfilled her 'duties' adds a ticking clock. If she doesn't produce evidence of being a proper duchess, she walks away with NOTHING. But the real conflict is the wine scene. She dressed up like she was trying to seduce him. She spent all day anxious. And he couldn't care less — or rather, he's so tense and stiff that he can't show it. They're both desperate for something to shift between them and neither knows how to make it happen. That's not just conflict, that's a whole damn tragedy waiting to happen.
... Read More
There are SO many symbols stacked in this batch and I'm not sure the author even realizes how rich they are. The North itself is the biggest one. Etia initially found it barren and unwelcoming — just like her marriage. But over time, she grew to love it. The parallel is clear: both the land and the relationship were something she was forced into, both seemed cold and uninviting, and both have secretly become sources of strength and belonging. When she realizes she'll miss the North if she leaves, that's not just location attachment — that's her subconscious telling her she's attached to THIS LIFE, however complicated it is. Then there's the clothing motif. Etia's thin nightgown, her fear of being seen, the elaborate outfit the maids prepare for the wine evening that she immediately regrets — clothing is armor and vulnerability in equal measure. She's always performing some version of herself for an audience she can't escape. The fact that Derek doesn't even notice her dressed up? That's its own kind of symbol — she's performing for an audience of one, and that one person is looking right through her. And the wine. An imported luxury in a harsh, distant land. Something meant to be shared between two people who can't seem to find common ground. Derek doesn't even like alcohol. The wine is literally wasted — a perfect metaphor for their entire situation. The deepest theme here, though, is the idea of marriage as transaction versus marriage as trust. The Crown Prince says it best: "I need people I can trust." Derek treats his marriage as a political arrangement he's willing to release her from. But Etia, despite wanting out, is the one who initiates the wine evening. Who wants to bridge the gap. Who's already feeling regret about leaving. The transaction was supposed to be clean and simple. It was never going to stay that way.
... Read More
I love how sparse the dialogue is in this section and how much weight each line carries. Derek's lines are almost always short, clipped, practical — 'You haven't returned for several days, so I was worried and came.' 'I'm not finished yet.' 'Go back now.' He's not being cruel on purpose; he's just a man who doesn't know how to say anything softer, and that's what makes it hurt more. Etia's internal monologue is where the real voice lives though. The contrast between what she says out loud (calm, polite, yielding) and what she's actually feeling (heart pounding, trembling, desperate to stay) creates this ache that the dialogue alone couldn't achieve. Her strategy of evasion — the one she learned as a child sneaking into her father's political discussions — is such a vivid character detail. It tells me everything about her upbringing and her nature in one sentence. There's also the narrative voice itself, which has this quiet, almost restrained quality. It doesn't melodramatize. When Etia falls from the carriage, the prose is blunt and physical — 'Her body hit various parts of the carriage, making it impossible to distinguish what was happening to her.' No purple prose, just the raw sensation. And then the wolf howl. 'Awooooo—' and then blackness. The author trusts the reader to feel the terror without explaining it.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is masterful in a way that's almost frustrating. Chapters 40-43 are all slow interiority — Derek thinking about divorce, Etia wondering where he is, the red landscape, the history of demon beast threats. It's deliberate. It's quiet. You could skip ahead and miss the point entirely because the point IS the quiet. The author is making you feel the suffocation of this land the way Derek feels it, the way Etia feels the emptiness of her days. Then the confrontation at the barracks happens, and it's still slow — two people eating lunch in awkward silence, both wanting something the other won't give. And you think, okay, this is a relationship drama, that's the arc. And then the ground shakes. Everything after that hits in real time. No reflection, no interiority — just action, sound, impact, darkness. The shift from three pages of internal monologue to a few paragraphs of visceral chaos is jarring in the best way. It mirrors exactly what happens to Etia: one moment she's standing safely in a barracks, the next the world has rearranged itself without her consent. The silence that follows — the castle going dark, servants too terrified to speak, Derek abandoning all his duties — is the quiet returning, but it's a different kind of quiet. Not emptiness. Dread. And I am NOT ready for what comes next.
... Read More
This book made me feel something weird and I can't quite name it. It's not heartbreak exactly. It's more like... the ache of watching two people who are somehow meant to be close orbiting each other at maximum distance. The wedding night scene haunts me. Not because it's dramatic, but because it's so painfully mundane in its pain. She's sitting there in a thin chemise, nervous and wine-bruised, and he's standing there in this sharp tailored suit like a statue. She touches his chest and he flinches. FLINCHES. Can you imagine that? The body remembers rejection even when the mind tries to perform duty. And then the two-year time skip hits like a physical blow. All that loneliness compressed into paragraphs. Etia in the North, surrounded by cold and unfamiliar servants, unable to remember her husband's face. The line about men supposedly valuing the bedroom—and her wondering if he'll come demanding that again—chilled me. That's not fear of intimacy. That's fear of being reduced to a function. Of being the wife who exists only for heirs. But what wrecked me was her final realization about her own anxiety. She says something like: you don't worry about someone whose life or death you don't even know. But now that he's back, all these worries naturally attached themselves to her. I read that and sat there frozen. She's afraid OF caring. Afraid that maybe, just maybe, she's starting to need this man she barely knows. And that terrifies her more than anything else. The CP tension here isn't in grand romantic gestures—it's in the terrifying smallness of almost-caring.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters are layered in the best way. On the surface, you've got Derek stuck between his duty to the Sylvester territory — people literally depend on him to keep demon beasts at bay — and his crumbling marriage. He can't abandon the land because the residents can't leave, and he can't abandon his wife because... well, he won't admit why. Then Etia shows up, and suddenly there's a third variable: her safety. Every time Derek thinks he has one problem solved, the world throws another one at him. The demon beast attack changes everything. Up until that point, the danger had been abstract — something that happens 'sometimes' in a land everyone looks down on. Etia realizes this mid-chapter and feels ashamed of her own ignorance. But then it stops being abstract. The ground shakes. Swords clash. Black smoke rises. She's thrown from a carriage and loses consciousness. The stakes went from 'maybe my marriage will end' to 'I might actually die and nobody knows where I am.' What makes this work is that the author doesn't soft-pedal the consequence. Etia doesn't just get a scratch and wake up dramatically. She's unconscious. The castle is in full panic. Derek drops everything. The note about the priest saying she's 'merely sleeping' and Derek's rage at that understatement tells me this isn't over yet. The tension is doing its job.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the weather in this book. It's not just decoration — it's doing actual emotional labor. Let me paint what I'm seeing here. You've got this northern territory, Sylvester, where winter isn't some pretty backdrop but an active force. The servants are clearing snow that won't stop falling. Knights are mobilized. Storehouses are opened for residents. It's a community moving with military precision — and Etia watches it all from behind a window, fascinated but disconnected, like she's observing a species she no longer belongs to. "Etia found it fascinating how all the territory residents moved like a well-organized army, but she only watched. There was nothing more she could help with here anyway." This single paragraph contains more loneliness than I think any single line could. She's surrounded by people, in a functioning society, and she is completely outside it. Not because they're excluding her — because she has no role anymore. The divorce hasn't happened yet, but in her mind it already has, and with it, her purpose in this place evaporates. Then there's the library and bedroom — her refuge, her prison. She bounces between them. The castle itself feels like it's holding its breath along with her. Derek can't leave because of the snow. She can't leave either. They're trapped in this white silence together, running into each other like ghosts in a house that's already mourning its own end. And the snow delays the priest. OF COURSE it does. The narrative is practically whispering: *not yet, not yet, give them one more day.* It's almost comedic how nature is obstructing the very thing both characters seem simultaneously desperate for and terrified of. The setting here is so specifically rendered — the white-locked doors, the blocked roads, the storehouses, the southern priest stranded — that this world feels like it exists independently of the characters. It has its own rhythms, its own logic. The snow isn't a mood. It's an entity. And it's the only thing in this story that doesn't judge anyone.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about this whole dinner scene because honestly it's one of those moments where everything that could go wrong goes wrong, and yet somehow it's also the most honest conversation they've ever had, right? Etia shows up to this wine dinner with a plan: she's going to subtly probe Derek about divorce. Get a read on his intentions. See if HE'S looking for a way out. But here's the thing about dealing with a man who's literally too sharp to be played—the second Derek senses she's fishing for something, he just... deflects. He blocks every question like a wall. When she pushes, he answers with another question. It's like she's trying to pick a lock and he's the locksmith watching her fumble. The escalation is brilliant, by the way. At first it's restrained—civilized conversation about whether she needs anything, about finances, about making good memories. Then Etia starts drinking faster, more desperate with each glass. She goes from polite wife to "Do you want children?" and at that point the entire scene flips from a subtle political maneuver into something raw and almost tragic. She doesn't even know why she's saying these things anymore, and that's when we realize she's not操纵ing anything—she's genuinely unraveling. The night ends with her passed out on his shoulder and him finding tear stains on her face. Classic narrator move, by the way, dropping that single detail like a bomb and then cutting away. We don't get resolution at all, which is exactly what makes it work. The real question hanging over everything isn't whether they'll divorce—it's whether they'll ever actually TALK to each other without wine and panic and social duty standing in the way.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this line where Etia realizes she can't even recall Derek's appearance anymore. Two years of marriage and she knows nothing about him except his name. That's such a devastating detail, right there. She remembers the wedding night—that 'unpleasant' experience—but not his face, his voice, how he walks. It's horrifying when you think about it. These people are technically husband and wife but they might as well be strangers who share a roof. What's fascinating is Derek's character. The coldness isn't just a personality quirk—it's armor. He's the Conqueror of the North, a war hero drowning in monster battles and territory management. When he returns, he immediately throws himself into backlogged work, bouncing between the study and training grounds. Not once does he seek her out. Is he avoiding her? Or is he so consumed by duty that marriage simply doesn't register as a priority? The ambiguity is delicious. But Etia—oh man, Etia. She's researching divorce laws and alimony like a spy. While pretending to be the indifferent noble wife, she's secretly preparing for abandonment. That takes real steel. Most people in her position would either crumble or become clingy. She chose strategy. And the fact that she's genuinely worried about being cast out because her family treated her as payment in a political deal? That's a character study in quiet desperation. Neither of them is evil here. They're just two people trapped in a system that valued their families' interests over their happiness.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely *ruthless* and I need a minute. Let me walk through the structure because the author is doing something clever here. We open with exposition about Sylvester Territory — demon beasts, strict punishments, the philosophy of a lord who values every life. This reads almost like a history document at first. But it's not filler — it's the thematic foundation. Derek's treatment of his people (strict but merciful) mirrors his treatment of Etia (harsh words but absolutely devoted action). The parallel isn't stated, it's felt. Then the chapter pivots sharply into the personal. Etia has been collapsed for a week. Derek hasn't left her side. We get this incredible time compression — seven days of waiting, of fear, of Derek internally unraveling, all rendered in maybe two pages of prose. The author doesn't show us the days passing one by one; they dump the accumulated weight of all seven days onto us at once. It hits like a physical blow. The middle section shifts to Etia's POV during her recovery. This is where the pacing breathes — we get slower, more reflective moments. Servants chatting, Hannah being loud, Etia hearing about the demon beast situation. It's a deliberate deceleration after the intensity of Derek's vigil, and it serves two purposes: (1) it gives us worldbuilding exposition through natural dialogue, and (2) it builds Etia's guilt slowly, layer by layer, until it becomes crushing. Then the structure does something I didn't expect. Derek appears after THREE DAYS of absence — not continuous presence like before — and the pacing SNAPS taut again. Every line of their dialogue is short, clipped, loaded. 'Let's divorce.' 'I said let's divorce.' Silence. Doors opening and closing. The final image of Etia alone on the bed, unable to process what just happened. The chapter ends on the word 'si' — cut off mid-sentence. 'She'd thought about almost daily si...' I literally had to stop reading and stare at my phone. This cliffhanger is brutal because we know from earlier hints that divorce was always on the table, but the delivery — coming FROM Derek, at THIS moment, when she's still recovering — makes it feel like a knife twist. The structure throughout this batch moves from external (territory politics, demon beast threats) to internal (guilt, fear, love) and back out again (divorce as both personal and political). It's a spiral, not a line. Each layer gets tighter than the last.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or