Should We Continue This Marriage? - Reviews

Should We Continue This Marriage?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say — the pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I am HERE for it. We go from three weeks of nonstop castle preparation, whirlwind energy, Etia completely forgetting about divorce because she's too busy, to the Crown Prince arriving and EVERYTHING becomes performance. Every word measured. Every smile calculated. The dinner scene alone takes up half the chapter and it's exhausting just reading it because you CAN feel Etia's anxiety building with every guest, every compliment, every fake conversation. And then — silence. The inspection party leaves. The castle goes quiet. Etia returns to her room, settles by the window, and finally gets a moment of peace. The text literally says she'd missed this quietness. Three weeks of noise, three weeks of pretending, and then— "Having been constantly busy even before the Imperial people arrived, Etia had missed this quietness." But of course, no rest for Etia. Because Derek is already in her bedroom. The quiet moment is immediately shattered by the one thing she wasn't ready for: him. The pacing here is GENIUS because it mirrors Etia's emotional state. She's been running on adrenaline, and now that it's gone, she has to actually FEEL everything she's been avoiding. The chaos was her armor. The silence is where the vulnerability lives. And the chapter ends on this barely-there note — Etia about to examine Derek's face, then looking away. Not a cliffhanger, not a dramatic moment, just... almost. The author trusts us to sit with the almost. I respect that so much.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is immaculate. Let me just start with the opening image: desolate winter scenery, empty central square, cold wind. It's not just setting, it's a mood thermometer for the entire relationship. When Etia says "I hoped the cold wind would blow away all these worries," that's not decorative prose, that's her literally trying to externalize something she can't process internally. And then later there's this scene by the fireplace where she's watching the burning logs and the narration says "the crackling flames seemed particularly alien today." ALIEN. She's in her own castle and it feels foreign. That's how isolated she is. The contrast between the warm library (where she buries herself in books hoping for answers) and the freezing border where Derek actually is - it's brutal. And the Land of Fire as a concept is such a smart worldbuilding touch because it's this threat that's always present, always just beyond the walls, mirroring how their relationship is always on the verge of something explosive. The world itself feels alive and hostile in a way that makes their emotional distance even more suffocating.
... Read More
"What do you have to be nervous about? You're a proper Crown Prince, Your Highness." "That's exactly why I'm more nervous." I need to talk about how EVERY dialogue in this section operates on two levels simultaneously. Surface level: polite, proper, appropriate noble conversation. Actual level: everyone is desperately trying not to reveal everything. The Crown Prince's lines are always slightly too warm, slightly too personal. He's performing friendliness but there's real curiosity underneath. "You two seem to get along well. It's good to see." Is he sincere? Is he testing them? The text never quite says, and that ambiguity is deliberate. Derek's dialogue is the sharpest. Short. Precise. Every word chosen like a weapon laid down gently. "If a married couple uses different bedrooms, there will be talk." He doesn't say "I want to sleep in this room." He says it as FACT. As OBLIGATION. But we know it's not obligation — we SEE him watching Etia, noticing her blank expression, feeling awkward about her discomfort. And Etia's dialogue is the most painful because it's ALL evasion. "I'm still—" (can't say I'm uncomfortable). "No, no. I ate plenty." (lie). "I'm fine, so please use the bed, my lord." (offering herself as sacrifice without understanding why it hurts him). The author never lets a single conversation be just a conversation. Every line is a negotiation, a deflection, a tiny strike or block in a fight neither person admits is happening. I literally re-read the dinner scene four times because the subtext is SO dense.
... Read More
This chapter is basically a dissertation on the limits of money as emotional currency, and I'm here for it. Etia gives consolation money from her OWN pocket. Not the ducal funds, not castle resources—her personal discretionary money. Why does this matter? Because it symbolizes that she's paying a debt that belongs to someone else. Derek should have done this. As lord, the responsibility falls on him. But she does it anyway because she can't STAND the idea of someone dying without consequence, even if that consequence isn't hers to bear. "That's not solvable with money." She says this to Derek, and it echoes the entire theme of the story. What happened to the coachman can't be fixed with gold. What happened between Etia and Derek can't be fixed with apologies or grand gestures. Some debts simply cannot be paid. The greenhousethis is another powerful symbol. Derek remembers it perfectly—the flowers, the butterflies, the sunlight—but he can't remember Etia's face. It's like the beauty of that moment was real, but she wasn't present in it. He was so focused on the setting, the arrangement, the spectacle, that he missed the person. And the snow? It's not just weather. It's isolation. It's the silence between two people who want to communicate but don't know how. It's the blankness that covers everything—their mistakes, their pain, their unspoken feelings. Even more symbolic: Etia says she'll become complete strangers. She's resigned to the idea that this marriage will end in nothing. But Derek is asking different questions now. "Do you wish to stay here?" That's not the question of a man who wants divorce. That's the question of a man who's finally realizing he doesn't want her to leave. The theme is clear: love isn't about what you give. It's about seeing the person in front of you. And Derek is just beginning to see.
... Read More
'Everyone praises you so much you really think you're a hero. Pathetic bastard.' This is Derek talking to himself. In the mirror, after his wife nearly dies because of something HE allowed to happen. And this is the man who just asked for a divorce. I am NOT okay. Let me unpack the Derek-Etia dynamic because it is the most painful thing I have read in months and I keep going back to it. On the surface, this is a marriage of convenience — arranged, distant, headed for divorce. But the text keeps showing us the gap between what these two people SAY and what they ACTUALLY do, and that gap is where all the emotion lives. Derek's actions: He doesn't leave Etia's side for a week. He throws away border affairs to be with her. He personally moves her when she's injured despite worrying about straining her body. He calls in a priest. He stares at her sleeping face in moonlight until his hands shake. His internal monologue is pure self-flagellation — he calls himself stupid, pathetic, a bastard. He blames himself for endangering her. And yet when he finally speaks to her after three days of hiding, he says 'let's divorce.' Why? Because he can't bear to look at her like this and do nothing? Because he feels he failed as her husband and therefore has no right to be one? Because saying those words is the only way he knows how to push his pain outward without breaking down in front of her? Etia's side is equally rich. She's been called 'Duchess' and 'my lady' her whole life — titles that create distance. But when Derek says divorce, she does something extraordinary: she calls him 'Derek' for the FIRST TIME. Not 'my lord.' Just Derek. And the text literally says his heart wavered over something so trivial. THREE DAYS of silence, and she breaks it by using his name. The servant dynamics are also worth noting — Helva is genuinely happy for them ('perhaps I can look forward to the two of them having a child'), Mary is protective and sharp, Hannah is chaotic energy in a quiet room. They see what the protagonists can't see: that these two are obsessed with each other in the most painfully awkward way possible. And Etia's guilt over the coachman adds another layer — she's not just hurt physically, she's carrying the weight of a dead man because she was too careless. Derek's divorce proposal lands on top of an already crumbling emotional foundation. How does she even respond to that right now?
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Derek for a minute because this chapter completely flipped how I see him. Like we keep getting these glimpses into his head and he's NOT the cold bastard I initially thought. Remember when Etia cried and he just... couldn't handle it? He literally strode up to her, turned her around firmly but carefully, and asked if she was still in pain. Not checking if she wanted him there, not being pushy about it, just genuinely concerned. And then when he learned about the coachman's family? He didn't get mad about her spending her own money secretly. He actually felt BAD that he hadn't thought of doing it first. There's this moment where he's standing outside her bedroom door for what feels like forever. Can you imagine? A man who's clearly not emotionally articulate is literally rehearsing what to say before walking in. He said he needed to rub his face dry several times. That's not cold. That's someone who's trying really hard not to mess this up. And his reaction when he heard she was crying? His heart sank. Just immediately sank. No dramatic speech, no overreaction, but the physical response tells you everything. He's been carrying this weight of guilt about how he treated her since day one—using people as tools, leaving after the ceremony, thinking absence was kindness. "That's why Derek naturally didn't think his relationship with Etia would be good." This line hit me like a truck. He actually believed they were doomed before they even started. And now he's realizing he might have been wrong about everything. The way he looks at her when she's crying—it's like he's seeing her for the first time. Not as the wife he abandoned, but as a person who gave money from her own pocket to a commoner family without telling him. Who showed compassion when he expected none. Who's crying not from weakness but from overwhelming guilt she doesn't deserve. I'm genuinely curious what happens next because this man is waking up to his wife and it's too late for him to not care anymore.
... Read More
"Watch your step." He just says it and lifts her hand and suddenly EVERYTHING changes. I literally gasped. Not because it's some grand romantic gesture but because it's SO small and SO accidental and Derek clearly didn't even plan it - he just saw ice and reached out and now Etia's standing there completely flustered because apparently physical touch still short-circuits them both after two years of marriage and zero real intimacy. And the narration says 'though they'd held hands several times while being escorted, it felt truly strange.' STRANGE. Not uncomfortable, not cold, STRANGE. Like their bodies remember each other but their minds haven't caught up. Then they don't say anything on the carriage ride back and Etia thinks 'taking his offered hand felt more torturous.' Torturous is the wrong word, it's electric, it's terrifying, it's the first honest thing that's happened between them in chapters. Also - his internal monologue about her climbing onto him drunk two years ago??? The man has been carrying THAT memory around and I am deceased.
... Read More
"Does she know too?" — three words from the Crown Prince and the entire scene pivots. That's the kind of dialogue that does SO much work with so few words. No exposition, no explanation, just a casual question that opens up an entire universe of tension. But honestly, the dialogue that got me most was the silence. The entire wine scene is basically a masterclass in what characters DON'T say. Etia asks "Do you like wine?" — a pathetic, clumsy opener. Derek replies flatly that he doesn't drink much. The conversation dies. She's internally berating herself while he's sitting there with this STIFF face. No grand confession, no dramatic outburst — just two people who want something from each other and can't figure out how to ask. The maids' dialogue is also surprisingly effective. Mary offering the wine suggestion is such a small moment but it tells us everything about the household dynamics — everyone KNOWS something is wrong, everyone is tiptoeing around it, and the servants are the only ones brave enough to voice the unspoken. "I thought it would be nice if you and the lord enjoyed it together too" — said with such casual warmth that it almost hurts. And Derek's conversation with the Crown Prince? Chef's kiss. "I want you to be happy. Only then can I trust you, right?" This man who has spent his life with a sword in his hand is articulating something so achingly simple and so politically dangerous at the same time. His voice is distinct — measured, direct, occasionally softening in ways he clearly didn't intend. Etia's internal voice is equally strong: flustered, practical, sharp-witted even in her moments of vulnerability. Their narrative voices never blend into each other, which is rare and really appreciated.
... Read More
This dinner. Oh my god this dinner. I actually gasped out loud at the table. So the Crown Prince drops the, like, most inappropriate question possible — "You should have a second generation soon, shouldn't you?" — and Etia CHOKES on her wine. Not a cute choke. A full-on panic, face-red, gasping, Derek-handing-her-a-handkerchief choke. And Derek?? He doesn't laugh. He doesn't smirk. He SHIELDS her. Uses his arm to hide her from view while she recovers. Like a cave. She looked like she was hiding in a cave, the text literally says so. And I just — the tension in that room was SO thick you could cut it. Everyone thinks they're a cute couple. The Crown Prince is being all warm and misunderstanding everything. Etia is internally screaming because she's literally planning her divorce and here this man is asking about babies. And Derek? Derek is sitting right next to her, watching her choke, watching her suffer, and he still protects her without thinking. But here's what destroyed me: after the dinner, when it's just the two of them in the bedroom again, Etia's internal monologue. She's analyzing his expression, wondering why he got angry, trying to solve him like a math problem. She says "What did such things matter between people getting divorced?" But she's already noticed his sharp features. She's already looking at his face. She's already FLUSTERED when he enters the room. These two are swimming in feelings they refuse to name. And the author just sits there watching them drown while being super polite about it. Masterful.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how this whole arc is structured because honestly the author is playing 4D chess with us. We have this surface-level plot about monster attacks and territory management at the border, but the REAL plot is just two people who can't communicate around each other like it's a sport. Derek goes off to handle the crisis, tries to protect Etia by keeping her in the dark, and Etia interprets every single one of his decisions as rejection or a step toward divorce. Meanwhile Derek is over here thinking 'I've neglected her too much' and also 'she only wants to come because she doesn't understand danger.' Both of them are wrong about each other and neither will say why. The whole monster incident is basically a MacGuffin that exists solely to force them into parallel loneliness. I love it. The way the chapter ends with him catching the scent of blood and immediately thinking about her? That's not foreshadowing, that's just Derek being Derek.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or