Should We Continue This Marriage? - Reviews

Should We Continue This Marriage?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about what these two are actually risking, because it's way bigger than either of them seems to realize. On the surface: divorce. Simple. Clean. Etia has lawyers lined up. She's postponed meetings because she's busy, not because she's hesitating. She's mentally ready. Or so she tells herself. But the stakes have quietly expanded. The Crown Prince is HERE — an imperial inspection party visiting their castle. If the marriage looks broken, it reflects on Derek's loyalty, his judgment, his suitability for whatever political role he's positioning himself for. Divorce isn't just personal anymore; it's political. And Etia, bless her pragmatic heart, immediately calculates this: "Wouldn't they face more criticism if they divorced while appearing to get along?" So now there's a LIE they're maintaining together without agreeing to it. They're performing happiness for the Crown Prince. They're performing unity for the castle staff. They're performing marriage for everyone except themselves. And the internal stakes? Even higher. Etia keeps telling herself she doesn't care about Derek's moods, his silences, his sudden coldness. "What did such things matter between people getting divorced?" But her body doesn't believe her. She notices his sharp features. She flusters when he enters rooms. She wonders why he's angry. She's building an attachment she hasn't authorized and it's making her terrified. Derek's stakes are different but equally dangerous. He's a man who's been on campaign, who's used to solitude, who's arranged his life around emotional distance — and now he's caught shielding a woman who wants to leave him, angry at a woman who offered him kindness, confused by a woman he can't stop watching. The conflict isn't just whether they'll divorce. It's whether either of them will survive finding out they care too late.
... Read More
This chapter is FULL of atmosphere and I need to unpack it. First off—the snow. Derek's territory is literally submerged in quiet heavy snow while his mind is roaring. And Etia's territory? Also buried in snow, but she's the one making noise with her grief. The contrast between the silent landscape and the internal chaos is just chef's kiss. Then there's this flashback to the greenhouse—Derek remembering the first time he saw Etia. "A greenhouse so splendid it was dazzling, and Etia sitting across from him there was only blurry." Can you feel how much he's forgotten? The flowers, the butterflies, the sunlight—it's all so vivid except for HER face. He remembers the setting perfectly but she's just... out of focus. That's such a brutal metaphor for how he's treated their entire relationship. "The scenery surrounding him that day was full of flowers, grass, and butterflies, and he felt only floral fragrance instead of the smell of blood." This line. Just this line. He's a man who's spent his life covered in blood, and the only time he felt something other than violence was standing in that greenhouse. And now he realizes that moment was precious and he wasted it. The drawing room scene with the coachman's family—so uncomfortable! These people are so terrified of the nobles they can barely speak. "Helva must have been quite strict" is Derek's gentle way of acknowledging the class divide that makes human connection impossible. And Etia's smile trembling because she can't remember the coachman's face anymore. The money's gone, the gratitude's real, but the memory is already fading. And that ending—Derek standing outside her bedroom door, unable to enter, rubbing his face dry. The most intimate scene isn't physical. It's a man rehearsing vulnerability before he dares to show it.
... Read More
Okay so first of all, can we talk about how the North is basically a CHARACTER in this story? Like, it's not just some generic cold backdrop. The text literally says Etia found that the North and she 'shared similarities somehow' — and I think that's the whole point. This barren, harsh, unwelcoming land that everyone else complains about? It became HOME to her. That's such a beautiful thing to write. The winter preparation scenes are what really sold me on the worldbuilding. The way the castle transforms — from a quiet northern estate into a bustling hub of activity with the Crown Prince's inspection party — you can literally feel the temperature dropping and the urgency ramping up. And the detail about snow covering doors completely? That's not just atmosphere, that's practical worldbuilding. It tells you about the climate, the labor, the constant struggle, and it makes Derek's commitment to these people feel real. There's this one moment where Derek is touring the village and the Crown Prince seems almost giddy, like he's on a picnic, while Derek is internally processing the weight of responsibility. The contrast between the pristine capital mentality and the gritty reality of northern life hits different. The Castle doesn't feel like a decorative set piece — it feels lived in, cold, slightly drafty, with servants gossiping and maids worrying about wine. Every corner has texture.
... Read More
Okay so the whole thing kicks off with this moment where Derek literally hands Etia an out. He's standing there in his formal clothes while she's barely dressed and he's like 'you can refuse this.' Refuse? After they've already exchanged vows before God and everyone? The tension in that scene is insane because you can feel her panic about what happens if he actually storms out. Her father's voice echoing in her head about bridal training... yeah, that's a nightmare. And then she ends up clinging to him anyway, both of them knowing this is going to hurt them both. Classic setup. You spend the next two years with these people barely existing in the same orbit, and then BAM he comes back early. The plot moves in this really clever way—jumping forward two years instead of dragging out the misery, which keeps the pacing tight. When he finally summons her after two months of silence, I genuinely thought he was going to drop the divorce bomb right there. Instead he talks about an imperial inspection? What the hell, man. That twist completely subverted my expectations. I was so ready for the confrontation and he just... didn't give it to me. Now I'm even more invested. Who's coming from the palace, what are they inspecting, and how does this affect their already-fragile situation? The narrative is pulling in directions I didn't predict at all.
... Read More
I literally had to stop reading for a second after the scene with the coachman's family. Etia saying "I'm not someone who should receive thanks" while her lips were trembling? That's the kind of quiet devastation that stays with you. Here's this woman who's already drowning in regret about her marriage, about her mistakes, and somehow she still finds it in herself to comfort OTHER people. She's sitting there in her own misery, crying over her failed life, and when these commoners come to thank her, she's worried SHE'S the one who shouldn't be thanking them. "I'm not someone who should receive thanks"—she literally means it. But then Derek says something that wrecked me: "That was an accident. If anyone should be held responsible, it would be me as lord." And Etia's eyes welled up again, but not from sadness this time. From something else. Something she can't name. She tries to tell him the truth—that she went where she wasn't supposed to, that the man died because of her—and she can't even finish the sentence. Her breath gets blocked. And Derek's gaze becomes intense. Like he's watching her struggle with words he wishes he could take back. There's this scene where she's packing her bags, crying silently, and Derek shows up. Not because he wants to, but because he can't stop himself. "She even resented Derek a bit for barging in at this particular time"—even in her broken state, she's protecting him from seeing her weak. That's love. Messy, complicated, almost-destructive love. And the worst part? She says yes to staying. Even knowing she'll become strangers. Even knowing it's probably pointless. She still says yes. Why? Maybe because somewhere deep down, she believes she deserves this punishment. Or maybe because she can't imagine anywhere else. "I want to be here." Four words that contain an entire universe of resignation. God, I'm emotional just thinking about it.
... Read More
Let me just say—the atmosphere in this book is unmatched. You can feel the cold seeping through every scene. Winter approaching, morning dew lowering body temperature instantly, servants rushing in frantic preparations for a lord whose face no one can quite picture. The North isn't just a setting, it's an active force shaping everything about these people. The sensory details are precise without being overwrought. Knights training in the distance—swords clashing, running footsteps, booming voices. Same elements as always, but Etia notices something changed because HE came back. That's how the worldbuilding works here: everything filters through her perception, and the environment responds to her emotional state. When she's anxious, the castle feels larger and colder. When she's lost in thought about her precarious position, even the tea feels inadequate. And the political landscape! Sylvester Territory's proximity to the Land of Fire, monster battles more frequent than interior regions, the economy built on trading monster hides and bones (which cost more to transport than they're worth—brilliant economic worldbuilding). The Emperor's inspection looming on the horizon adds another layer of political pressure. This isn't a fantasy world with generic castles—it's a functioning place with trade routes, military logistics, and real economic incentives driving these marriages. The servant gossip scenes are also brilliantly used. Rather than exposition dumps, we learn about the political situation through whispers in corridors and Etia's deliberate choice to ignore them—a choice that's starting to fail her.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Derek because this man is a MASTERCLASS in showing rather than telling. Let me set up what I mean. In literally every scene he appears in, what DOESN'T happen is way more interesting than what does. He comes home after two years and immediately drops the divorce bomb like it's a mundane errand. 'I'm requesting divorce.' No buildup, no ceremony, just... done. But then here's the thing that gets me — Etia herself narrates that 'he wasn't someone who'd lie about such things.' She knows him well enough to trust his bluntness, which means he's genuinely, consistently this person. Not a villain. Just... a man who doesn't sugarcoat. And the office scene? Chef's kiss. He reads her entrance, asks practically if she's feeling unwell — not even remotely interested in her emotional spiral — and then delivers 'The priest will come tomorrow. You should prepare.' Like a corporate email. Not cruel, exactly. Just... immovable. But wait, let me pivot to something else entirely. What struck me way more is how Etia's perception of Derek SHIFTED across these chapters. At first she's convinced he wants a divorce, she prepared for it, she even went to him with lawyers, right? She thought SHE was the one ready. And then the moment he actually follows through, she unravels. Her own realization — 'I hadn't wanted the divorce' — is devastating because she didn't just misjudge HIM, she misjudged HERSELF. The tragedy is layered. She trusted Derek, yes, but she also projected onto him what she expected from her own father. 'She'd unknowingly trusted Derek and thought he might be different from her father.' Oh man. She was looking for safety in someone who was fundamentally incapable of giving her what she needed, because she confused consistency with warmth. And the novel makes us feel that slow, terrible dawning. And Derek? The text literally tells us 'a truly emotionless expression' every time we see him. Is he protecting himself? Is he genuinely indifferent? We're never quite sure, and THAT is brilliant character writing. The ambiguity IS the point.
... Read More
"I... misjudged you, my lord." Five words. Five fucking words and I was GONE. Let me back up though, because the build-up was brutal. Etia spends the entire first part of this section walking around like a ghost — pacing, biting her nails, replaying his exact phrase over and over in her head like it's some broken record. She thought she wanted this. She actually went to him with lawyers. She was ready. She had her speech prepared. And then he says the word and her entire interior world just... craters. What wrecked me was watching her face the reality of it. She's not just losing Derek. She's facing her FATHER. Oh god, the Count Neiden section gave me actual chills. "She squeezed her eyes shut in fear even though she'd only thought that far." Just one sentence, but I could SEE the scene — her in the dim room, bracing against an imaginary future where she's boxed away in the western annex like some kind of disgrace. Here's what nobody's talking about enough: the family dynamic. Dahlia and Levan, perfectly adjusted children of Count Neiden, would look at Etia with disgust. Her mother, the Countess — they'd see divorce as the ultimate failure. Etia imagines being remarried off to some old nobleman she doesn't know, just "disposing of" a tarnished daughter. And her father, who supposedly treated his children equally? He doesn't abuse them but he IS "merciless if his children fell short of his standards." This man runs on reputation. So Etia stood at this crossroads: stay in a marriage that might slowly suffocate her but keep her autonomy, or divorce and return to a family that would consume her completely. And she chose... neither? She chose to beg. After preparing to be brave, she goes to Derek and asks him to reconsider. Not because she loves him necessarily — though maybe she does, maybe that's the terrifying part — but because the alternative terrifies her more. "The tears she'd held back burst out" and she couldn't stop them. Not wailing this time, just silent, shaking, collapsing against the door after she'd walked out. And then the snow keeps falling. Of course it does.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage are NUCLEAR, and the author makes you feel it without ever raising their voice. Let me start from the outside and work inward, because that's how the conflict layers here. On the surface: a divorce is being processed. Two people in a marriage are separating. That's it. That's the plot event. But underneath? Etia is facing annihilation on every possible front. First layer — her autonomy. She wanted the divorce because she thought it meant freedom. She imagined living alone, forging her own life. But as she actually confronts the possibility, she realizes she's built nothing. No close friends. No relationship with her siblings. No skills or identity outside this marriage. The divorce was supposed to be her escape hatch, and now that it's opening, she can't find her legs. "She wasn't even close to her own siblings, her older brother and younger sister, so there couldn't be anyone closer than them to Etia." This line hit me like a physical blow. She has NOWHERE to go. The math is simple and devastating. Second layer — her family. This is where the author goes absolutely ruthless. Count Neiden isn't a cartoon villain. He's an 'ordinary nobleman who valued honor above all else.' He tries to be fair. He hosts parties to show off his wealth. He preaches to his children. And Etia hated all of it. She was the one who couldn't perform. Who found the dresses uncomfortable, the conversations draining, the constant evaluation suffocating. So if divorce happens, her family doesn't just disapprove — they're GENUINELY disgusted. Dahlia, the perfect sibling, couldn't understand Etia even before this. Now? Etia has become the living proof that their father's system can produce failures. "The eldest daughter who'd already tarnished the family name would be useless anyway, nothing more than a parasite wasting food." Etia isn't just predicting this. She's NARRATING it in her own head, in her own voice. That's the true horror — she's internalized their cruelty so completely that she articulates her own worthlessness before anyone else does. And the third layer, the one that ties it all together: she trusted Derek to be different from her father, and she was wrong. Not because he's cruel, but because he's just... indifferent. The indifference is what breaks her. Because indifference can't be negotiated with. You can't beg someone to care, and Derek doesn't care about the divorce. He's already moved past it. She's still standing in the wreckage. "I hadn't wanted the divorce." The realization comes too late. The stakes were always everything. She just didn't know it until she'd already lost.
... Read More
Okay so this whole sequence where Etia goes to see Derek at the border is such a classic setup — you know the one where the protagonist makes a spontaneous decision that seems harmless but basically walks into a disaster. She's just curious, she brings lunch, she tells a small lie about worrying — and then BOOM, demon beast attack, carriage crashes, she's knocked out cold. The author really didn't let her have that wholesome couple moment, did they. Derek spends the entire section pacing back and forth about divorce, convinced he's being noble by sending her away, only for fate to literally intervene and trap them both in the same crisis. Classic dramatic irony that makes me want to yell at the pages. What's interesting is how the plot pivots from a quiet emotional arc (Derek deliberating whether to end the marriage) into pure survival mode almost instantly. One moment he's sighing at a lunch table, the next he's riding off to fight demon beasts while his wife is thrown from a carriage. I didn't expect the chapter to escalate that hard.
... Read More
"Though it had definitely been someone else's home, it had somehow become a familiar place to Etia. That fact gave her a very strange feeling." This sentence. This SINGLE sentence contains the entire thematic weight of Etia's journey so far. The castle. The title. The marriage. All of it was never truly hers. She became a duchess through marriage, handled nothing, knew nothing, owned nothing. The castle's affairs were managed by Derek's aide, his steward, his maid. She was a figurehead in her own home. And yet — three weeks of preparation, of touching every corner, of discovering how large it is, how much needs doing — and suddenly it feels FAMILIAR. That's the terrifying part. That's the thematic core. She's building attachment to a place that isn't hers, to a title that's borrowed, to a man who's preparing to leave her. The castle symbolizes everything she's been accumulating in this life — status, responsibility, routine — none of which she chose and all of which she's now afraid to lose without even realizing why. The bedroom scene doubles this symbolism. The couple's bedroom was never hers. It was Derek's space, Derek's domain, Derek's castle. But when she offers to sleep on the sofa, she's trying to perform wifely devotion in a room that was designed for a different kind of marriage. The physical space refuses to accommodate the role she's forcing herself into. And the dining hall? An enormous space she didn't even know existed, filled with strangers, where she performs happiness while choking on wine. The grandeur of the castle mirrors the grandeur of the performance she must maintain. There is no room — literal or metaphorical — for the real Etia.
... Read More
I need to talk about Derek for a second because this passage really lays bare how tangled his head is. He keeps telling himself that letting Etia go is the kind thing to do — she's from the warm South, this red land is miserable for her, the contract is over — but then he can't actually bring himself to say it. He holds her hand. He watches her eat. He gets angry when she tries to leave early. And then the moment everything goes to hell, his first instinct isn't about his own safety or his divorce plans, it's grabbing her waist and lifting her into the carriage like he's shielding her. That's not a man who wants to leave his wife. That's a man who's scared of what he feels and is trying to rationalize it away. And Etia — oh my god, Etia. She tells a transparent lie about coming because she was worried when really she just couldn't stand not knowing what he was doing. She deliberately picks the best food from the kitchen. She eats slowly just to extend the time with him. And when he's cold and pushing her to leave, she still doesn't push back aggressively, she just... stays. The fact that she's thinking about whether they could have been closer if they'd been a truly affectionate couple tells me everything. She wants this. She wants him. The tragedy here is that both of them care but neither knows how to bridge the gap without the other person getting hurt.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or